10 Best Hotels In Islamorada, Florida

Leonora
Leonora 
Updated

Islamorada is one of the most popular tourist destinations in the Florida Keys. It serves as a playground for anglers who flock to its rich fishing grounds. Regal palm trees line the beaches in Islamorada, providing shade to beachgoers. There are lots of fun things to do in the village. One can enjoy the sea and the sun at Anne’s Beach, or swim with dolphins, turtles, and other sea mammals at Theater of the Sea. Art lovers will enjoy strolling around Morada Way Arts & Cultural District to discover local galleries. Travelers can also have fun feeding the tarpon at Robbie’s Marina, engage in water sports, or feast on succulent seafood at Hungry Tarpon Restaurant. For a comfortable stay, book a room in one of the best hotels in Islamorada, Florida.

1. The Islands of Islamorada (from USD 2026)

The Islands of Islamorada is a 4-star hotel that offers comfort and convenience to all its guests. It features rooms with balconies where guests can enjoy sea views. You can also spend time at the private beach, on-site bar, or fitness center. Spa services are available, as well as yoga classes. Families will be glad to know that a playground is available.

History of Diving Museum and Anne’s Beach are both nearby.


The Islands of Islamorada

Wifi Available

Address: 82779 Old Highway
Accommodates: 8

Parking Bar Fitness centre Non-smoking rooms Fishing Babysitting/child services Facilities for disabled guests Free parking

2. La Jolla Resort (from USD 384)

La Jolla Resort offers clean, safe, and comfortable accommodations to visitors traveling to Islamorada. Guests on a business or pleasure trip find the location convenient. The property features well-equipped and spacious rooms, and some even have separate living areas.

If you love adventure, water sports, and cycling, you can enjoy them from this hotel. Each room provides wireless internet connection.


La Jolla Resort

8.7 User Rating

Address: 82216 OVERSEAS HIGHWAY, Upper Matecumbe Key, Islamorada (FL), United States, 33036

3. Fisher Inn Resort & Marina (from USD 209)

Fisher Inn Resort & Marina offers spacious rooms with modern amenities such as cable TV and a kitchenette. Wireless internet connection and laundry facilities are also available in the hotel.

Enjoy a relaxing swim in the heated outdoor swimming pool, which is open year-round. Have fun fishing, kayaking, windsurfing, and more during your stay. Guests can also go snorkeling or diving from here.


Fisher Inn Resort & Marina

Wifi Available

Address: 84951 Overseas Highway
Accommodates: 4

Parking Pets allowed Meeting/banquet facilities Non-smoking rooms Fishing Facilities for disabled guests Free parking Internet services

4. Caloosa Cove Resort & Marina (from USD 345)

Spend a grand time in Islamorada at Caloosa Cove Resort & Marina, which features a private beach. The view from the balcony of some rooms is stunning. Nearby are several restaurants, but those who prefer home-cooked meals can book a room with a full kitchen.

Have fun at the swimming pool or bask in the sun on the sun terrace. Other beaches are nearby, including Anne’s Beach and Sea Oats Beach. The hotel has facilities and amenities for your convenience, such as an on-site mini-market, vending machine, and ATM. Free wireless internet connection is available throughout the property.


Caloosa Cove Resort - With Full Kitchens

Wifi Available

Address: 73801 Overseas Highway
Accommodates: 6

Parking Restaurant Tennis court Terrace Non-smoking rooms Fishing Laundry Family rooms

5. Amara Cay Resort (from USD 379)

Amara Cay Resort is another great hotel option in Islamorada. Located near History of Diving Museum, diving enthusiasts can learn more about this sport. Travelers can also drive eight minutes to Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park and see ancient coral or learn about the history of the area.

While on vacation, you can continue your fitness routine at the on-site fitness center. The rooms are spacious and well-equipped for comfort. Sample some custom cocktails at the bar or savor burgers at Reel Burger. Guests have access to free wireless internet connection on the property.


Amara Cay Resort

Wifi Available

Address: 80001 Overseas Highway
Accommodates: 10

Parking Restaurant Pets allowed Meeting/banquet facilities Bar 24-hour front desk Fitness centre Golf course (within 3 km)

6. Pelican Cove Resort & Marina (from USD 461)

Pelican Cove Resort & Marina has 63 rooms with modern amenities. This beachfront hotel offers rooms with excellent ocean views, plenty of water sports facilities, and other activities. All rooms are efficiently cleaned and sanitized for the health and safety of guests. It has a restaurant, a poolside bar, a coffee shop, a swimming pool, and a souvenir shop.

A continental breakfast is available every morning. Bicycles can be rented by those who want to explore the area and enjoy the beautiful sceneries. Guests have access to a wireless internet connection throughout the property.


Pelican Cove Resort & Marina

Address: 84457 Overseas Hwy, Wildley Key, Islamorada (FL), United States, 33036

7. Sunset Inn (from USD 169)

Sunset Inn is another great hotel in Islamorada. It has outstanding facilities and excellent service. Located 1 kilometer (0.6 miles) from Anne’s Beach and 1.2 kilometers (0.8 miles) from History of Diving Museum, this property allows guests to explore nearby attractions with ease. There is a well-kept picnic area outdoors, as well as barbeque facilities and a swimming pool.

Bitton Bistro Cafe and Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar are both located nearby. Free wireless internet connection is available throughout the property for your convenience.


Sunset Inn

Wifi Available

Address: 82200 Overseas Highway
Accommodates: 4

Parking Garden Non-smoking rooms Facilities for disabled guests Free parking Internet services BBQ facilities WiFi Available

8. La Siesta Resort & Marina (from USD 349)

La Siesta Resort & Marina is a beachfront hotel that provides a marina with ocean-side slips. It’s also a place where guests can access bikes and watersports equipment. Children and adults alike can enjoy the on-site pool as it has a shallow end for kids. The heated pool provides an opportunity for a relaxing swim during the day.

Soak up the sun on the deck or at the beach, or have some drinks at the bar. One can access social media because free wireless internet connection is available throughout the property.


La Siesta Resort & Villas

Wifi Available

Address: 80241 Overseas Highway
Accommodates: 13

Parking Restaurant Pets allowed Bar Non-smoking rooms Facilities for disabled guests Family rooms Free parking

9. Breezy Palms Resort (from USD 152)

Breezy Palms Resort is perfect for a vacation in Islamadora. Book a double room with a pool view or a bungalow - either way, your room will feature modern amenities, comfy beds, and WiFi access.

Head out to go diving, snorkeling, sailing, or fishing. You can also just lounge on a beach chair or swim in the pool. Make use of the private beach area, since Anne’s Beach is 2.6 kilometers (1.6 miles) away.


Breezy Palms Resort

Wifi Available

Address: 80015 Overseas Highway
Accommodates: 5

Parking Terrace Non-smoking rooms Laundry Family rooms Free parking Internet services Safety deposit box

10. Coconut Grove Resort & Marina

Experience comfort and convenience at Coconut Grove Resort & Marina. The hotel has 20 guestrooms with air conditioning. A flat-screen TV provides entertainment to guests. Those who want to prepare simple meals can book rooms with kitchenettes. Bars, restaurants, and shops are nearby.

Must-visit attractions in the vicinity include History of Diving Museum and Stacie Krupa Studio Gallery of Art.


Coconut Cove Resort & Marina

6.2 User Rating

Address: 84801 Overseas Highway, Wildley Key, Islamorada (FL), United States, 33036

Enjoy the sun and the sea in Islamorada

Have a memorable holiday in Islamorada. Enjoy the lovely private beaches, water sports, and thrilling nightlife. For an unforgettable vacation, stay in one of these best hotels in Islamorada, Florida.

Disclosure: Trip101 selects the listings in our articles independently. Some of the listings in this article contain affiliate links.

Get Trip101 in your inbox

Unsubscribe in one click. See our privacy policy for more information on how we use your data

Leonora Puno loves to see places where nature abounds. She has traveled to several parts of the Philippines that glorify the beauty of nature. She loves reading about the beautiful places in other...Read more

 Want to contribute as a Local Expert?
Explore Islamorada
Good things are meant to be shared!