Amagansett is one of the many charming hamlets that are found within the Hamptons. It is located near the town of East Hampton, between Westhampton and Montauk. Like the rest of the Hamptons, Amagansett too attracts all those looking to enjoy a coastal break, including celebs. You will love strolling through the pretty Amagansett Square, which features several chic boutiques and restaurants. On weekends, the square often hosts a variety of fun events. Pencil in an evening at Stephen Talkhouse, which is famed for its live music scene. For beachside fun, head to Atlantic Avenue Beach, one of Amagansett’s popular beaches.
If you are in the thick of planning your coastal vacation, then you’ll find our list of the best Airbnb vacation rentals in Amagansett, New York, helpful. Scroll down to know more!
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on June 01, 2024.
1. Inviting property with pool (from USD 1424)
With amenities galore, you’ll enjoy a carefree vacation at this appealing rental. Have relaxing swims at its extra-long heated pool and then sit back on the expansive deck that surrounds the pool. You may also spend leisurely afternoons lounging in the hammock set up on the upper deck.
If you are in the mood for some indoor entertainment, the basement level provides a lounge area set up with a flat-screen TV and a PlayStation. There’s a gym here, too, that fitness enthusiasts will welcome. The property’s living room with its vaulted ceiling and many windows is a bright and airy space for unwinding. You’ll also enjoy cooking in the fully equipped kitchen that comes with all essentials, including a stove, an oven and a Keurig coffee machine.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
fantastic pool and deckpool layout and deck were great tooalso they had multi-zone ac so it made keeping the house comfortable much easierthe only minor issue was that the pool heater did not work for my partywe grilled out enjoyed the nice pool was nice with heater and relaxed in the living roomCleanliness:
there were nice touches like a bottle of wine left for our group and plenty of clean towelsthe house is clean had everything we needed and is in a great locationthe house is spacious and the pool is just amazingHost:
alex was a gracious host and excellent communicatoralex was a great host the management company he works with is very responsivealex and the managers were very communicative and helpfulhouse was wonderful and owner was very responsive to our questions would rent againalex was a kind and gracious host we had a lovely weekend at his beautiful homeRead more reviewsLocation:
good location close to town centergreat location and spacious housegreat spacious house in a perfect locationgreat location amazing pool loved itthe house was beautiful and great location
Superhost
2. Posh rental in great location (from USD 600)
This rental’s chic white-toned aesthetics, open, airy layout and prime location make it an attractive choice for your vacay.
It occupies the second level of a beach house on Amagansett Lanes, putting you close to the town centre and the beach. The property has its own entrance, so you are assured of privacy. Its large living area, flooded with natural light, is a wonderful spot to unwind after your excursions. For those looking to catch up on work, a separate working space is provided. You’ll have a full kitchen at your disposal, as well as a deck that showcases lush vistas around the house.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the beds were extremely comfortablei forgot my toothbrush and there was one ready for me in the bathroom when i arrivedCleanliness:
nick’s apartment is clean stylish and well-appointedHost:
nick was very accomodating and responsivehe was very helpful offering the best recommendations in the area and helping us have the perfect weekendnick was a considerate host (left snacks for us ) and was quick to respond to any questionRead more reviewsLocation:
best of all the beach and the town square are all within walking distancehas a wonderful stay at nick's place
3. Tranquil home near beach (from USD 1709)
A beach vacation is one of the best ways to rejuvenate yourself. A secluded property with direct access to a beach sounds great, doesn’t it?
Upscale in its ambience, this huge house is located within a residential community on a dead-end road. Its brightly lit living room features ample windows and a fireplace creating a cosy ambience. The main level includes a large, well-equipped kitchen that’ll come in useful for serving up piping hot meals.
Step outside to its deck when you want to enjoy the pleasant outdoors. It comes with a grill and a patio lounge set. To reach the beach, just go down the path along the house, a walk of under 10 minutes.
Top guest reviews
Host:
noah was an outstanding host who consistently responded to questions quickly and also proactively offered local recommendationsnoah was a wonderful host and provided many great local suggestionsnoah was a great host the property and house were perfectRead more reviewsLocation:
fantastic house in an incredible locationhouse was amazing & just a short walk to one of the best beaches in the hamptonswe had a great thanksgiving at noah's house and loved the short walk to the beachthis was a perfect place for our family of 10 to spend the holidays
4. Appealing converted barn amid verdant fields (from USD 1000)
Nestled by a golf course, this snug barn-style home will feel like a haven away from the bustle of daily life. Soothing green landscapes surround the property. Inside, beamed wooden ceilings and plush furnishings give the rental a tasteful look. The abundance of windows lights up the interiors, making it cheery. The living area set up with a Roku box-enabled TV, is a great spot for chilling out. You will have a fully equipped kitchen available to rustle up your favourite meals, too.
The property offers two patios - sit back on any one of them under the shade of trees and savour the sight of rolling greens around you.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the listing is accurate - the house is very comfortable and well stockedthe house was great with three bedrooms (upstairs) and a very comfortable living room and dining roomCleanliness:
what a fantastic place it is clean clean cleaning products great location gaia is amazingHost:
gaia was very responsive and a great host would definitely stay here againgaia was super helpful and welcoming as wellgracious host in constant communicationgaia is very accessible communicative and helpful but never disruptiveRead more reviewsLocation:
great location and just a quick bike ride to the beachfantastic stay perfect location walking distance to town and the beachclose to beach and town for walks or biking also a huge plusperfectly located close both to the beach and local farmsher place has everything you need and more we just wish we had a bit more time
5. Upscale rental with heated pool (from USD 720)
The combination of generously sized rooms, high ceilings and an abundance of windows give the rental the feel of a country house. Take advantage of the massive living room with sofas scattered all around to spend quality time together. A TV is provided for those looking to relax.
Outside, the property’s woodsy setting creates a serene atmosphere. There’s a seasonally available heated pool surrounded by trees that is perfect for de-stressing swims. Enjoy spending time on the sprawling deck adjoining the house, relishing the refreshing outdoors and hosting cookouts for your group.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
all furniture is comfortable and practicalCleanliness:
beautiful home super clean amazing locationhouse is very spacious clean and have a lot of interesting interior details and objectsHost:
all around great host and propertythe host was responsive with any questions we had and made themself available if we neededjoe is an excellent host and a great guyjoe is a great host and makes everything so comfortable and easyjoe and chris are amazing hostsRead more reviewsLocation:
location is goodlocation is very good and close to east hamptons just 8 min drivethe house is stunning- perfectly secluded and a great locationlocation is ideally situated in amagansett only a 7 min drive to main streetthe location value and size of the house all exceeded our expectations
6. Gorgeous property with modern amenities (from USD 800)
Vacation in style in this sumptuous property. It is set on 2 acres (0.81 hectares) of verdant grounds abutting a large nature preserve, so you’ll feel like you are amidst forestlands.
The house’s interiors with expansive, open rooms and soaring ceilings create a sense of spaciousness. The property’s high-end amenities add to the experience. These include a smart HVAC system, remote-controlled blackout shades, high-speed mesh WiFi and a 65-inch Smart TV. You will find a recreation room in its basement featuring a TV, a small gym and games in addition to workspaces.
The property’s many outdoor amenities ensure ample opportunities for fun times. Make use of the heated pool and the adjoining deck featuring seating and a grill to relax and refresh yourself. For sports lovers, the grounds include a tennis court and a basketball court.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
what a place large open space all amenities and pristine kitchen highly highly recommendedthe pool deck was great and the tennis/basketball court was a hit for our familyisabelle’s home was beautiful matched the photos exactly and so comfortable for our week long staypool and tennis court were great too and we took advantage of these amenitiesthe beds are super comfortable and the pool area is fantasticCleanliness:
beautiful home very clean and spaciousthe pool was extremely clean and nice to usehouse was super clean and very well stockedthe stay was absolutely amazing and the house was perfectly clean and gorgeousthis place is very clean and is very well stocked with all the household items you would needHost:
our hosts were amazing and accommodated our every needgreat airbnb host very responsive polite and provided clear directionschris was an amazing host and answered our questions in secondsthe hosts were extremely responsive to our questions which was greatisabelle was a great host and made the experience seamlessRead more reviewsLocation:
great location and very quiet areai truly loved my stay here the location is breathtakingvery accommodating and great locationlocation very good close to east hampton amagansett and sag harborwe also really loved the location - quiet but easy access to amagansett and montauk
7. Sophisticated home near the sea (from USD 128500)
Located in a sought-after area near the ocean, this mansion-style property is set on 0.7 acres (0.28 hectares) of grounds. Enjoy cooling ocean breezes as you chill out with your favourite beverage on its front porch.
This historic property has been fully renovated to offer sleek, contemporary styling along with modern amenities. The elegant living room fitted with a fireplace is a light-filled space for relaxed lounging after your day’s outing. During your downtime, you’ll love curling up in the family room with your companions watching TV or just chatting.
The property’s outdoor features are surely its highlight. Spend leisurely days on its spacious back patio. Cooling dips in the pool found in the backyard will be welcome on hot days. Additional perks you’ll enjoy here include basic gym equipment and two dedicated workspaces.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
we appreciated all of the convenient amenities and fully stocked kitchen and dining roomthe upstairs rooms had beautiful ocean views and the downstairs was nice and privatebeautiful gated backyard with a heated pool spacious bedrooms and everything was clean with quality furniturea beautiful place with many comfortable sitting areasCleanliness:
the house itself is large clean and bright with lots of charm and characterit was sweaky clean and beautifully decoratedclean open many bedrooms bathrooms a peloton and more i would recommend this home to anyonethe property manager was so helpful and keeps the property spotlessthe house is beautiful spacious and very well kept and appears to be recently renovatedHost:
addie was a wonderful hostmanager was very attentive and responsivethe hosts were very responsive and incredibly gracious and kindandrew the property manager was so helpful and accommodatingthis is a lovely home and addie was very responsiveRead more reviewsLocation:
lovely location in the hamptonsthe location is superbthe house is gorgeous and the location is wonderful walkable to beachthe location was absolutely perfect with a short walk to the beach and to townthe location is great close to the beach shops and a playground for the kids
8. Stunning rental with private hot tub (from USD 1200)
Relish a vacation steeped in tranquillity and utmost comfort. After a day of exploring the charms of the Hamptons, you will look forward to settling in with a drink in the outdoor hot tub. If you’d rather enjoy a swim, the property provides an outdoor pool as well. Afterwards, kick back in one of the seating spots provided on the deck found alongside.
Inside, the property’s minimalist contemporary styling gives it a clean, uplifting vibe. The main living area will leave you impressed with its tall ceiling and window wall. Spend cosy evenings warmed by the fireplace here as you catch up on your favourite TV show.
The property is set within a private beach community, with the beach just a short walk away.
Top guest reviews
Cleanliness:
the house was beautiful and cleanbright and clean and lovely we had a wonderful staythe house was amazing beautiful house that is clean and well decorated with amazing amenitiesHost:
noa is a great hostnoa was really communicative and a great hostnoa was very accessible for any questions and extremely positive and communicativeRead more reviewsLocation:
amazing location that’s walking distance to beach and a short drive to townbeautiful home great locationthe private beach that is walking distance - a 2 minute walk - was amazingthe walk to the beach is a lovely 3 minutes passing gorgeous houses and greenerywe had a wonderful time incredible location clean & spacious home
9. Plush property with easy beach access
With the beach just a few houses away, this stylish property is ideal for a much-needed break from the daily grind. Enjoy fun-filled days on the shore, peacefully lazing under the shade of trees in the unit’s yard or just lounging indoors with your companions.
The rental’s inviting living room with full-length windows and a beamed ceiling is a fantastic spot to decompress and relive the highs of your day. Its well-stocked kitchen makes it easy to whip up meals if you are not keen on heading out. Al fresco meals on the patio that comes with a grill are a great alternative. A back deck, too, is available for open-air chilling.
Amagansett, New York, United States
7.56 km (4.7 mi) from East Hampton Main BeachAccommodates: 4
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
we had many breakfast and lunch on the beach and enjoyed beautiful sunrises and sunsetsCleanliness:
her home is very clean and comfortablethe house is spotless and serene and the perfect size for a few people to staythe beach was private clean and beautifulHost:
ann is a very thoughtful hostann is a great host and she makes check in and out super easy and stress freethe best part is how close it is to the beach the host was very professional and responsiveann was very responsive and we booked her lovely home right awaythe home location and amenities were all fantastic as was the hostRead more reviewsLocation:
cute beach bungalow 2 min walk to beachgreat location and hostgreat house great location beautiful beachgreat spot— close to the beachthe location is great has a secluded feeling and quiet
10. Casa Amagansett (from USD 533)
Warm and welcoming, this beautifully furnished property creates the perfect setting to forget the routines of daily life for a while. The sunroom is a bright and cheerful area where you can spend leisurely days with a book or watching a TV show. Inside, gather in the living room that features a baby grand piano and Sonos music system for a relaxed evening together.
The fully equipped kitchen provides all essentials that you may need to serve delicious and fresh meals to your group. If you are a fan of open-air meals, the backyard comes with an outdoor dining space. The hammock set up in the sideyard is an excellent spot to laze away on fine afternoons.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
we loved the large sitting room and the outdoor space seems ideal for the warmer monthswe enjoyed cooking in the big kitchen and enjoying them in the dinning room and backyardthe place was really comfortableCleanliness:
everything was very clean and organizedthe house was very clean and comfortablethe house was spotless and beautifully decoratedit was very clean and great locationthe house was very comfortable clean and well appointedHost:
he was responsive to our questions and extended our stay easilyvery nice and communicative hostthey were also both very communicative and responsiveluke was a great host and was very quick to respond to any questions we hadwe enjoyed our stay very much luke was a great hostRead more reviewsLocation:
the location was amazinggreat house close to the beachgreat location - walking distance to the beach and townwow what a gem the location is great just a short walk from the train station and the townthe house was amazing and in a great location close to beach and train station
A vacation to cherish
A vacation in the Hamptons is a favoured way for many to enjoy some much-deserved downtime. Take advantage of our list of best Airbnb vacation rentals in Amagansett, New York, to find the right option for a memorable stay here.
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data
Create an account to