An Ohio village on South Bass Island, Put-in-Bay is a perfect destination for romantic getaways. It sits on the shores of Lake Erie and is often referred to as the “Key West of the North.” The 1812 Battle of Lake Erie, commemorated by Perry’s Victory & International Peace Memorial, is worth visiting. At the Lake Erie Islands Historical Museum, see ships built from the past and winemaking, too. Eat freshly caught seafood and experience the outdoors here! To get here, come by plane or by ferry.
Whether you book for a night or two, one of the best ways to experience Put-in-Bay is by staying in a cabin. Check out these top cabin rentals in Put-in-Bay, Ohio!
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on April 12, 2024.
1. Island Club Rentals - Put-in-Bay (from USD 525)
Step into a world of pure relaxation and adventure at this amazing cabin! You’ll have access to a pool, great fishing spots, and there’s even a state park nearby. And if you’re into golf, you’re in luck! There are plenty of places nearby where you can rent a golf cart and hit the greens. Inside the cabin, you’ll find a stylish design with a spacious kitchen and comfy bedrooms featuring Sealy King, queen, full, and twin beds.
Take a moment to unwind in the garden tub or chill out on the front and back decks with picnic tables. Plus, you’ll have modern amenities such as Wi-Fi, TV, and free parking. Just remember to bring your own bath towels, bed sheets, and pillowcases for a truly unforgettable vacation!
Top guest reviews
Cleanliness:
nice and clean we would stay againit was clean and cared forvery clean and well maintained definitely will returnclean great location and so funHost:
william was very friendly and kind would stay againRead more reviewsLocation:
fantastic location in the island club walking distance to the poolgood location and easy check-ingood place to stay in pib
2. Cedar Cabin (Put-in-Bay Cabins) (from USD 196)
Cedar Cabin, a part of Put-in-Bay Cabins, is also on a quiet lane with wooded trailhead steps that lead to the lake.
This vacation rental in Put-in-Bay is best for eight people with three well-fitted bedrooms. The living room is perfect for lounging comfortably while watching TV. The fully equipped kitchen has all you need to prepare a meal for the entire group. Alternatively, you can use the propane grill outside or sit around the fire pit and share some stories.
Top guest reviews
Cleanliness:
the cabin was very clean when we arrivedwe loved the massie nature preserve setting of the property the cabin was clean comfortable and well-equippedRead more reviewsLocation:
great location perfect distance from townquiet and convenient location clean accommodations and communicative owners
3. Massie Cabins (Put-in-Bay Cabins) (from USD 300)
Massie Cabins (located in Put-in-Bay Cabins) is a two-bedroom stay for six. It sits in a quiet lane near a lake accessible by wooded trailhead steps. You can sit on the benches here in the lakeside park and watch the island sunset or the boats sailing by. You can go kayaking or paddleboarding too. This lodging in Put-in-Bay is about 1.6 kilometers (1 mile) away from downtown Put-in-Bay, so you’re not far off from the village for dining and unwinding.
Back at the cabin, use the outdoor furniture to enjoy sitting on the decks and taking in the fresh air. You can also use the fire pit to roast marshmallows or use the propane grill for a barbecue brunch or dinner. Inside, you can cook yourself a meal in the well-equipped kitchen too.
Top guest reviews
Cleanliness:
very clean and spaciouscabin was clean and well organized with everything we neededthe property was clean and the neighborhood was very laid back and relaxingHost:
awesome owners communicated with us wellproperty manager was friendly and helpful with information regarding the islandowner was very helpful and pointed out some great spots on the island to check outRead more reviewsLocation:
good location very cozy little trailergreat place to stay we will definitely be coming back
4. Private cabin in the woods for eight (from USD 468)
This private two-story cabin for rent in Put-in-Bay, nestled in the woods, accommodates up to eight people and features three bedrooms. One of them has a loft with a futon and a screened-in porch where you can get some privacy. Located on each floor is a bathroom - so you won’t have to go up or down the stairs to use the toilet or take a bath! In the open kitchen living room area, opt to play video games, watch DVDs on the TV, or prepare breakfast.
As there’s no wifi and cable, take it as an opportunity to spend quality time with your loved ones. The backyard and the patio are perfect for a gathering or a barbecue brunch or dinner.
Top guest reviews
Host:
above and beyond with extra special touches by the hostmarisa is a spectacular host and will take good care of youRead more reviewsLocation:
had a great time and i would recommend this place and it’s great locationgreat location lots of space the screened in porches were amazing at night we will definitely book again
5. Captains Quarters (from USD 318)
Captains Quarters is a two-bedroom cottage in Put-in-Bay, ideal for six guests with an all-wood interior and lofted ceilings. Located downtown, it’s a relaxing retreat. Rent a golf cart at Erie Island Carts beside the cabin, and off you go to explore Put-in-Bay!
You can also stay indoors and relax by the fireplace while watching TV or scrolling through your social media in the living room. Prepare a meal in the fully equipped kitchen, or head outside to use the gas grill.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
very comfortable place to stay with all the amenitiesfull kitchen allowed us to easily make our own meals when we wishedplenty of space to spread out and the beds/couches are very comfortablenice place nice host weak wifilovely cabin perfect location and the beds were super comfyCleanliness:
clean and inviting cabinvery clean and spacious housegreat place and very cleanit was very clean new and just beautifulit was very nicely decorated very clean and very quietHost:
sharon is an excellent hosthost was very kindsharon is terrific hostsharon was responsive and helpfulthanks sharon for being a fabulous hostRead more reviewsLocation:
the location was good right near the ferry and about 2 miles from downtownthe location is perfect right off the ferry within walking distanceclose enough to get downtown quickly but far enough away for peace and quietit is the perfect locationthe location was great for us
Superhost
6. Island Club #64 (from USD 70)
Island Club #64 is a home ideal for eight guests. It has three bedrooms, two bathrooms, and a fully equipped kitchen for preparing and cooking meals. In the living room, put your feet up on the couch and lazily watch cable on the TV. Use the wifi for work or to stay connected.
Outside, you can use the outdoor dining area to cook on the gas grill, or sit out on the patio and have a morning or afternoon coffee. If you feel like swimming, you have access to the Island Club swimming pool nearby, so bring your swimsuits and get ready to make a splash!
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
very nice place on the island the house interior is well laid out with 2 bathroomsCleanliness:
exactly as listed very clean and the owner and very responsiveHost:
great atmosphere and rochelle is a great hostRead more reviewsLocation:
good location and close to the ferrythe house was in a great locationwe enjoyed being close to the state park beach and golf coursegreat place to stay its close to everything and the cabin is big and has a lot of storagealso we have stayed in this location before and this cabin was in better shape than others
Stay in your private cabin in Put-in-Bay
Put-in-Bay has plenty of exciting things to do and staying in any of these cabins will allow you to enjoy the tranquility and stay close to nearby attractions.
Frequently asked questions about cabin rentals in Put-in-Bay, Ohio
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data
Create an account to