Garden City is a charming village in the heart of Nassau County, about 28 km (17 mi) from New York City. With its tree-lined streets, beautiful parks, and historical architecture, it is a popular destination for visitors from near and far. Visitors can explore the boutiques and shops, savor delicious cuisines, or catch a show at the local theater. The village is also home to iconic landmarks, including the famous Garden City Bird Sanctuary and the stunning Cathedral of the Incarnation. Whether you’re a history buff, a food enthusiast, or looking for a relaxing getaway, Garden City has something for you. Experience the beauty of this village for yourself and indulge in a cozy home base during your visit. Check out these best vacation rentals in Garden City, New York.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on April 13, 2024.
1. Humble vacation rental (from USD 123)
This rental is the place to stay if you’re searching for a location in Garden City close to famous restaurants and shops. This property includes dependable WiFi and a designated office, so you don’t have to lose out if you need to work on something.
Its basic kitchen has all you need to make dinner preparation a breeze. You will also have access to the property’s communal patio, where you can relax while taking in the outdoor sights. Moreover, books and toys for children are also accessible here.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the rooms were great and as shown on airbnbthe space is private well decorated and comfortable with everything we needed for a weekend tripbed and bedroom are comfortable and overall very quietCleanliness:
everything is very clean and well organizedthe room is clean and simplethe space was clean and true to its descriptionconveniently located near stores and very clean my family felt extremely comfortablethis is a great find the place is clean and the owners are kind and attentiveHost:
wendell was a great host with quick responseswendell and arlene were nice hostswendell is a great host he greeted us with such warm welcoming hospitalitywendell is a great host who quickly responded to questions and ensured we had a pleasant tripthe host was very nice and very responsiveRead more reviewsLocation:
the location was great walking distance to everythinggood stay close to stores and a mall nearbycomfortable space and close to what you needthe mall across the street is shopping heaventhis place is cute and cozy it’s super close to nearly all you would need
Nearby vacation rentals
2. Charming studio rental with gardens (from USD 115)
This holiday home is great for people looking for tranquil accommodation. Its first floor has high ceilings, allowing a pleasant atmosphere. You can even use the complimentary WiFi if you need to work or connect with your loved ones. Moreover, you can enjoy an al fresco meal on the fenced-in patio.
This home is also in a quiet neighborhood and has lush gardens. After exploring outdoors, you can lounge by the pergola while enjoying coffee.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
just enough room to spread out including a full kitchen and a very pleasant outdoor seating areajust enough room to spread out including a full kitchen and a very pleasant outdoor seating areaCleanliness:
guy is an extremely helpful host the space was immaculately clean and the beds were super comfortablegreat location very clean and has a great setupit was very clean guy was a very nice host i will definitely go back in the futureit was very clean guy was a very nice host i will definitely go back in the futureHost:
the host is easy to reach and returns messages promptlythe host is easy to reach and returns messages promptlyRead more reviewsLocation:
wonderful studio in a great quiet location which is accessible to a variety of destinations
3. Renovated home for a large group (from USD 368)
Do you want to spend your vacation in a former governor’s home? If you do, this rental is an ideal place to stay. It is a renovated house with wood floors and a fireplace, ensuring a comfortable stay. You don’t have to worry about cooking meals with the accessible equipped kitchen. Moreover, it has a washer and dryer, perfect for those who intend to extend their vacation.
This place is ideal for a large group and allows guests to have events here upon approval. However, note that general admission events are prohibited. Kids will also enjoy the variety of books and games here.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the kitchen had all the basics and the washer/dryer machine in the basement worked very wellRead more reviewsHost:
absolutely loved our stay host was very responsive and prompt at supplying whatever we needed at anytime
4. Cozy apartment near restaurants and shops (from USD 110)
This apartment is tastefully decorated to provide a soothing ambiance to its guests. You will also delight in the kitchen with appliances and pantry items perfect for preparing and cooking meals for your family. For amusement, you will have access to the property’s smart TV and a large selection of books. Another highlight of this property is its complimentary parking, so you don’t have to worry if you bring your car.
Top guest reviews
Read more reviewsHost:
we could not have asked for a nicer hostour host was thoughtful to provide plenty of coffee for the morning and water
5. Studio home with a balcony (from USD 120)
This homey guest suite has essential amenities that will make your stay enjoyable and convenient. This holiday rental has just been remodeled to meet your needs. Green Acres Mall is just minutes away from this cozy vacation property if you enjoy shopping.
You can use the modest and functional kitchen to prepare meals for you and your company. You can also lounge in the private yard with tables, chairs, and umbrellas to unwind and relax with your loved ones.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the room was small but had all the necessary items to be comfortablehowever the room itself was good and is as it’s described and listedHost:
the host was vertical friendly and communication was quickbed was super soft and comfy veronica was super responsive and helpfulthe owner quickly responds to communication and thoughtfully stocked the unit with everything you might needRead more reviewsLocation:
nice place good location quiet neighborhoodvery accommodating was the perfect location near to the marina we were going togood for a single person short stay good locationher place was easy to find and really cute
6. Adorable waterfront loft (from USD 156)
This waterfront apartment is perfect if you want a holiday property with a laid-back vibe close to the beach. Because of its location, this vacation home has a relaxing ambiance.
This rental is also ideal if you enjoy cooking for your family. You may use its kitchen, which is outfitted with modern appliances to make dinner preparation a breeze. Moreover, this place is in a quiet neighborhood, ensuring a good night’s sleep.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the apartment looks exactly like the pictures and the deck along the canal is amazingwe were very comfortable and the view looking down the canal was beautifullate night bathroom run would be easierCleanliness:
the apartment was clean and comfortablethe loft was very cozy clean and comfortablethe loft is incredibly clean well-kept & extremely comfortableHost:
to start with kevin & brian are the perfect hosts the loft was super clean & comfortablealthough the accommodations were close to our hosts we had a very private experience and enjoyed our unique spacewe absolutely enjoyed our stay at the loft brian and kevin were the perfect hostsRead more reviewsLocation:
the location was perfect for us bc it kept us close to all of our friendsand it's in a great locationwe would definitely recommend this place
7. Laid-back stay with a view (from USD 125)
Do you want to unwind in a vacation home with a view? If you do, this waterfront cottage is perfect! You can spend your afternoons relaxing on your private deck. Alternatively, you can go fishing or crabbing for a fun outdoor activity. It also features a grill for barbecue meals.
This holiday rental features a modest kitchen with the necessary equipment you need for meal preparations. Plus, you can use the washer and dryer, making your stay convenient.
8. Tranquil and equipped apartment (from USD 180)
Book this apartment for a relaxing vacation in Hewlett. It has easy access to neighboring places such as Brooklyn, Long Beach, and Queens and is about 30 minutes from Manhattan. It is also close to four synagogues for those seeking spiritual guidance.
This vacation home has a lovely living area where you can spend time with family or friends. Additionally, you can use the kitchen with appliances for pleasurable food preparation.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
we understand the big screen tv will soon have access to a better variety of channelsthe unit was just as described and very comfortable for our groupCleanliness:
place was clean and exactly as describedother than that the place was super clean and cutethe place is a quiet clean perfectly sized for a family and in a calm neighborhoodthe place was neat and tidyHost:
the perfect combination the hosts always responded quickly gave great recommendations and were extremely welcomingeyal our host was super responsive and accomodatingthe hosts give you a five star place in the beautiful city of hewlettour host had great communicationeyal was very responsive when we had questionsRead more reviewsLocation:
it is in a safe location central to queens and long islandwe rented this unit because we loved the tasteful decor & close proximity to mtlocation was great for our plansexcellent property in a quiet neighborhood and very close to the beach
9. Family-friendly home with a parking space
Don’t be deceived by the appearance of this holiday property. Outside, it has a rustic character but has modern fixtures and facilities inside. The floor-to-ceiling windows and wooden floors add to the cozy ambiance of the home. You can also request a crib and kiddie dinnerware if you plan to bring your children. Moreover, the kitchen is big and equipped with everything you need for stress-free meal preparation.
This vacation property is also in a quiet neighborhood near shops, parks, malls, and restaurants.
Baldwin, New York, United StatesSuperhost
Accommodates: 8
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the view from the living room is great the bay window is awesome it brings the outside inRead more reviewsCleanliness:
the place was clean and convenientthe place was clean well put togetherthe place was great clean spacious with new appliancessuper clean and great hospitality and attention to detail on decor
10. Private studio with a reliable WiFi (from USD 81)
This private apartment is ideal for visiting couples who want to avoid hassles during their stay. The charming vacation rental includes a dependable WiFi connection, so you won’t have to worry about posting your vacation photos. There is also a dedicated workplace and dining room. In terms of transportation, this property is close to a railway station and a subway if you want to explore around. Alternatively, you can bring your car since the place has a parking spot.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
we appreciated the added amenities of parking toiletries and the kitchen appliances along with coffeecomfortable bed and roomy nice bathroom with nice amenitiesCleanliness:
very clean comfy bed privatenice clean place in a suburban areawell maintained quiet and clean place to stay with a family even with little kidskatherine was great responded quickly & her place was super cleankatherine was a wonderful host and the space was perfectly clean when we arrivedHost:
hosts were extremely personable and nicehostess family is very friendly & kindbed was very comfy and the hosts were very kindgreat host and great place nice local restaurants and bars tooi have stayed here 3 times and it’s an amazing place and katherine is a great hostRead more reviewsLocation:
great locationgreat location close to restaurants and stores and transportation into manhattangreat location walking distance to convenient stores restaurants and the lirrkatherine was a good communicator and the location worked great for my work tripgreat place to stay very friendly and convenient location with good parking
Come and visit Garden City!
Garden City is a must-see destination for anyone looking for a unique and unforgettable experience. With its mix of history, culture, and natural beauty, this charming village offers something for everyone. So, book any of these best vacation rentals in Garden City, New York, for a comfortable and convenient getaway.
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data
Create an account to