10 Best Vacation Rentals In Green Lake, Wisconsin - Updated 2024

Contributing Writer
| 5 min read

Green Lake is a city in Green Lake County, Wisconsin. It houses the eponymous lake which is 237 feet (72.24 meters) deep and the deepest inland lake in Wisconsin. The surrounding scenery and waters of the lake lure people to visit the place every year. Due to Green Lake’s location, there are a lot of things to do in the area. Aside from fishing, boating, kayaking, and swimming in the lake, visitors can also visit museums such as Dartford Historical Society. They can also watch a show at Thrasher Opera House, or check out the activities at Town Square Community Center. Are you looking to visit this place overnight or spend a few days? Read on to find the best vacation rentals in Green Lake, Wisconsin, for your much-deserved vacation!

We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on July 16, 2024.

1. Cozy cottage near Hattie Sherwood Beach (from USD 585)

Situated 1.5 blocks from the Marina, this clean and comfortable cottage is just a short walk away from Hattie Sherwood Beach. It also features a full kitchen and dining and living areas with windows that allow natural light to come in.

In the living room, you can chill on the couch while watching TV. Additionally, guests can also have a view of the lake through the rental’s front porch, and you can also enjoy the sunset on a quiet afternoon on another porch in the kitchen.

Stayed at this property?
Green Lake, Wisconsin, United States
cottage 10 Guests 5 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

2. Huge house on a ranch (from USD 360)

Aside from its modern amenities such as a full kitchen and a flatscreen TV, the best part about this rental is its recreation room where guests can play pool or relax on the futon. This house also features a spacious outdoor area where you can relax by the fire pit on a cold evening. There’s a patio with six chairs and a barbecue grill as well if you want to hang out outside.

Regarding its location, this rental is conveniently situated because it’s only within walking distance to Downtown Green Lake and less than 1 mile (1.61 kilometers) from Green Lake Town Square and Green Lake Marina!

Stayed at this property?
Green Lake, Wisconsin, United States
PRIVATE VACATION HOME 8 Guests 4 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

3. Spacious house with excellent amenities (from USD 592)

You can’t visit Green Lake without exploring the beautiful lake! You’re lucky because this property is in front of the water and has a pier with a boat slip. Guests will surely enjoy paddle boarding, kayaking, or swimming!

In addition to its ideal location, this house offers spacious bedrooms and a full kitchen with bar-like seating. There’s also laundry available on the property, which is very convenient. Apart from its lovely interior, there are chairs and tables outside if you wish to chill outdoors and have a bonfire with the whole group.

Stayed at this property?
Green Lake, Wisconsin, United States
PRIVATE VACATION HOME 16 Guests 5 Bedrooms 4 Bathrooms

4. Luxurious home located near Green Lake (from USD 271)

This 1,260-square-foot (117.06-square-meter) home is ideal for big groups, as it offers multiple bedrooms with comfortable beds and a spacious open floor concept. If you enjoy cooking for the whole group, you can do so in the full kitchen with an island. There’s also a furnished patio if you and your loved ones want to hang out outside after kayaking or swimming on the lake.

By booking this property, guests are expected to have a cozy vacation, as this rental provides a smart TV, free WiFi, and other amenities such as a cozy corner for games!

Stayed at this property?
Green Lake, Wisconsin, United States
PRIVATE VACATION HOME 6 Guests 3 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

5. Lovely home with floor-to-ceiling windows (from USD 697)

Breathe some fresh air and have a tranquil vacation by booking this rental near Green Lake! This house is built by a protégé of Frank Lloyd Wright and features floor-to-ceiling windows that allow guests to enjoy views of the beautiful Green Lake. In addition, the rental’s location is just walking distance from the town of Green Lake, which is convenient if you want to explore shops and restaurants in the area.

This house also offers a spacious outdoor area with a backyard that has a fire pit and picnic table. It also has a full kitchen and a patio where you can watch the sunset on the lake.

Stayed at this property?
Green Lake, Wisconsin, United States
PRIVATE VACATION HOME 9 Guests 3 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

6. Spacious rental located in a restored hotel (from USD 266)

Located less than a mile away from Green Lake, this spacious rental has a lovely view of the dam and Puchyan River. It’s also close to downtown, which means you can easily access different shops and restaurants.

If you’re a big group, you’ll surely have a comfortable stay in this property given that it offers huge bedrooms with queen beds and a fully-equipped kitchen. What’s even more impressive is its 10-foot (3.05 meter) ceiling and family room where you can play pool!

Stayed at this property?
Green Lake, Wisconsin, United States
PRIVATE VACATION HOME 8 Guests 3 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

7. Beautiful modern cottage (from USD 335)

In addition to comfortable bedrooms, this modern cottage features a living room with a TV and a fireplace. There’s also a huge window in the living area, making the space naturally bright.

You can find a spacious garden or lawn within the property, and guests can also hang out by the patio with outdoor seating arrangements after relishing water activities on the lake. Also, it’s important to note that two pets are allowed on this property for 150 USD per reservation.

Stayed at this property?
Green Lake, Wisconsin, United States
cottage 9 Guests 3 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

8. Bungalow with a big screened-in porch (from USD 199)

A vacation should be relaxing, and this bungalow provides you with a peaceful and lovely time. Featuring a full galley kitchen, and a homey living room with a TV, guests are expected to enjoy their trip to Green Lake on this rental. Apart from this, you can enjoy a book or a cup of coffee on the furnished screened-in porch. There’s also a huge backyard if you wish to sit on the grass with your family or friends.

Stayed at this property?
Green Lake, Wisconsin, United States
157 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
Entire bungalow 4 Beds 6 Guests 3 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 6

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
beds older but surprisingly comfortable comfortable couch for evening leisure
the screened-in porch has a large table for eating and plenty of seating for relaxing playing games etc
the house was clean and well-supplied
clean cozy and comfortable home on a quiet neighborhood street
it was cozy clean and exactly what we needed
when we arrived everything was nicely made clean and smelled great
fantastic experience - the home was clean and cozy
matthew is a great host and i would highly recommend staying here
great place to stay matthew was a wonderful host
- host was responsive and kind
matthew is a great host and we had an awesome time relaxing at this cabin
matthew is very responsive
cute little house great location
easy walk to downtown
easy walk to restaurants and shopping
great location for a fun getaway
cozy and close to fun downtown green lake
Read more reviews

9. Modern cottage with a lot of entertainment (from USD 441)

Being near The Golf Courses of Lawsonia, this cottage is ideal for golf enthusiasts. However, this rental can also cater to anyone, given that it’s only a short walk to Norton’s of Green Lake, offers HDTV with different subscriptions such as Netflix, and a foosball and ping pong table.

Also, this cottage has a lake view and a fully-fenced backyard where guests can watch the sunset. There’s also outdoor furniture, including a fire pit and barbecue grill, that allows guests to relax and have quality time together.

Stayed at this property?
Green Lake, Wisconsin, United States
83 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
Entire cottage 11 Beds 12 Guests 4 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 12

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
we were a huge fan of kiehl's products in the bathrooms
nicely remodeled kitchen great big back yard and fire
plenty of room to gather or find a quiet spot for a moment of peace and tranquility
beautiful house clean and well maintained
the property was clean well-maintained and very comfortable
great place clean accommodating and helpful
very cozy and clean
all linens pillows beds were very clean and comfortable
daniel was a wonderful very responsive host
the hosts were communicative and helpful
loved the fireplace very accommodating host communication easy
perfectly located close to world class golf at lawsonia
beautiful house in a great location
great location wonderful property close to downtown green lake quiet and relaxing
super nice great location and tastefully decorated
the location was a perfect spot for our get together
Read more reviews

10. Gorgeous two-bedroom apartment (from USD 259)

This lovely rental is nestled in the heart of Green Lake, making this apartment close to shops, restaurants, and water activities such as fishing, swimming, boating, and hiking. To ensure guests have a relaxing stay, this property offers one queen bed and two single beds. Its full kitchen and living space also have an open concept, which allows you and your loved ones to easily hang out together. A TV and WiFi are also available for your needs and entertainment.

Stayed at this property?
Green Lake, Wisconsin, United States
16 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
Entire vacation home 3 Beds 4 Guests 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 4

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the beds were super comfy and we had plenty of space for 4 people
owners host both apts on the floor and have a shared washer/dryer in the hallway
the apartment is very clean and nicely decorated
the apartment is very clean & beautiful inside
the host was great thank you i’m sure it’s more vibrant in the summer months
great location with a nicely equipped kitchen
comfortable beds great shower good location
everything is new super clean and the location is perfect for green lake
this is a great place to stay
Read more reviews

Enjoy a memorable holiday in Green Lake

Green Lake has a lot to offer aside from its water activities. With cool museums and restaurants, this place is indeed a safe haven for travelers who want a peaceful vacation. Make use of our carefully curated list to choose the best vacation rentals in Green Lake, Wisconsin, for your upcoming trip!

Any must-sees we missed? Tell us about them in the comments section or write a post here to help out fellow travelers!
Disclosure: Trip101 selects the listings in our articles independently. Some of the listings in this article contain affiliate links.


Get Trip101 in your inbox

Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data

Lyza is a freelance writer and linguist who loves traveling around the Philippines. She especially enjoys going to the beach, trying cool adventures, and exploring new things with friends. Aside...Read more

 Want to contribute as a Local Expert?
Explore Green Lake
Good things are meant to be shared!
Back to top
Visited any of these places? Click this button to activate our "Add a Tip" feature to share your experience.
adults only hotels wisconsin

Top 7 Adults-Only Hotels In Wisconsin, USA - Updated 2024