In the movie “Eternal Sunshine the Spotless Mind,” one of the main characters whispered to “meet [her] in Montauk,” and there are a lot of reasons why it’s a good idea to head to this coastal hamlet. Located on Long Island’s South Shore, Montauk is home to several landmarks that are iconic to the area. Visit Montauk Point Lighthouse Museum when it reopens and climb all the way up for panoramic views of Block Island Sound. If you’re up for the challenge, try and surf the waves at Ditch Plains Beach. Prefer the land? Explore Camp Hero State Park and Hither Woods Preserve. After all that exploring, you maybe be in need of accommodations with convenient amenities to unwind in. Continue reading for the top Airbnbs with pool in Montauk, New York.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and access to pool. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on April 13, 2024.
1. Upscale beach house with a hot tub
No high-end beach house rental is complete without a sparkling outdoor pool. This rental’s private pool is open by the season, typically from Memorial Day until the first of October, making late spring and summer the best times to book this Airbnb to make full use of it. The hot tub, which is next to the pool, can be used from the middle of April to October. Do note that the pool can be heated for a small additional fee that’s charged daily.
Finally, the rental comes with rare private beach access too.
Montauk, New York, United StatesSuperhost
Accommodates: 8
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the house had all amenities for a comfortable stayCleanliness:
extremely clean and the pictures didn’t do it justicethe house is newly renovated and extremely cleanHost:
host is very responsiveRead more reviewsLocation:
the house and location were greatvery close to beach and fantastic yard/pool areahouse is well located and perfect for a family with a toddlerterrific location in montauk with easy acces to beaches (with parking pass ) grocery stores farmers markets and restuarants
2. Airy oceanfront home (from USD 1500)
Step inside this contemporary Airbnb and be greeted by picture-perfect views of the ocean. If you want an even better spot, come out to the deck where the gunite outdoor pool awaits. When the sea’s too rough for a swim, the pool will be the best place to take a dip. It can also be used for most of the year except during the winter season.
Alternatively, you can leave your slippers on the deck and walk the 90 ft (27 m) to the shoreline and feel the sand between your toes.
Top guest reviews
Cleanliness:
the sheets didn’t feel clean and we found multiple stains (lipstick and otherthe house itself is casual and simple yet impeccably clean beautiful and comfortableHost:
robert the property manager was incredibly responsive kind and took great care of usbryon was a responsive host who was easy to work withbryon was easy to communicate with and very responsive as was the property manager sethRead more reviewsLocation:
excellent location great house layoutonce you look out from the windows you realize the location doesn’t get betterbeautiful lot/location but the house is dingy & run down- does not look at all like the photographs
3. Beach condo with pool access (from USD 125)
This Airbnb is a unit at Royal Atlantic Beach Resort North, which makes it an ideal destination. You can access the two outdoor heated pools the resort offers, both of which are within walking distance from the beach. Check if the pool area is crowded from your private balcony where you will have views of the courtyard and the north pool. Other resort amenities you can look forward to include a mini golf course as well as a beach bar.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
amazing stay comfortable bed awesome viewsuper basic and simple room/beds to sleep in and do everything else in town (dining shopping beach etc)Cleanliness:
very clean and nicely decoratedthe place was clean comfortable and simplethe place was very affordable and kept cleanthe condo is very simple and would probably need some upgrade but it was really clean and cosythe place was very clean and the beach is basically right outside the doorHost:
malissa is an awesome host always available to answer any questions we hadsuper recommendations for dining from the hostmalissa was a great host she was very communicative nice and informativemalissa was responsive and very helpful with any questions which were minimal anywayoutstanding host place was perfect and cleanRead more reviewsLocation:
super close to the beachmalissa's place is in a great locationgreat location and easy access toothe location was perfect; right across the street from beach access and right in the middle of townperfect location right near the center of montauk
4. Luxurious coastal abode with an infinity pool (from USD 1213)
Nestled on the shores of Lake Montauk, this Airbnb rental’s outdoor infinity pool has vistas that are hard to beat. From its edge, the landscape expands to a private lawn that leads all the way to the lake, where you can go paddle boarding or kayaking. Best of all, the pool comes fitted with a bench so that you can truly relax while you’re in the water.
The infinity pool is open from Memorial Day weekend until the 15th of October. There’s an adjacent waterfall feature as well as several loungers on the deck to complete the experience.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
we lounged by the pool most of the time and the view from the deck is breathtakingstaying here was great beautiful view very spacious and has a great kitchen for cookingplenty of space comfortable beds and just about everything in the kitchen you could want forHost:
very communicative and responsive hosterin and tabitha were very communicative and made checking in and out very easyquick <10 min drive to nearby spots and responsive hostsRead more reviewsLocation:
amazing waterfront house in a great location in montaukgreat house beautiful location definitely recommendwe had a wonderful time at this beautiful house in this beautiful locationthe house was beautiful very comfortable for our trip and in a great locationthe weather was great and the location/views are amazing the house is nice but worn
5. Cozy home with a brand-new pool (from USD 314)
There are no broken tiles or stale water to worry about in this rental. Located in the Culloden Shores neighborhood, the property recently received a new addition: a sparkling outdoor swimming pool. Around this feature are lounge chairs, a shower, and a grill that will elevate your outdoor experience here. Until the pool becomes unavailable starting October 10 until Jan, feel free to hang out in the space.
In addition, this Airbnb comes with towels to help you dry off after a day in the pool or at the beach.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the living room was a comfortable place to sit and readthe yard and the pool are fantastic and i couldn’t say more wonderful things about the entire experienceCleanliness:
the place was clean quiet and comfortablethe house was super clean and very cozythe house was clean well equipped and beautifully appointedthe house is in an ideal location is clean so comfortable and adorableHost:
host communicated very welljaime was a super hostthe kitchen is perfect for any kind of mealjaime was very responsive and helpfulRead more reviewsLocation:
the location was perfect so close to town and the harborthe ability to walk to the beach is greatgreat location for access to hikes all the montauk beaches restaurants etcthe neighborhood is peaceful and quiet and it's a 5' drive to towngreat place to stay for the weekend newly renovated including the backyard pool
6. Modern lakefront bungalow (from USD 964)
Vacation in style in this elegant rental set on 1.1-ac (0.45-ha) of lakefront property. Lake Montauk is beautifully highlighted from each spot in the home but most especially from the pool deck.
Established trees and a well-trimmed hedge will make sure you get to enjoy the heated swimming pool in private. By the poolside, there are loungers, a hot tub, and an outdoor dining table for delicious meals under the sun or the starry night sky. Do note, however, that the pool is only available from May to October.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
absolutely stunning home and the views are even more spectacular in person outdoor pool area is fantastic as wellCleanliness:
beds were comfortable house was very clean and well equippedHost:
gorgeous home with a wonderful hostthis a great choice for wonderful accommodations and great hostsbeautiful property & great host would highly recommendjanelle was extremely responsive if we ever reached out with any concerns we had which was greatRead more reviewsLocation:
perfect place to have a lovely summer bbq lunch with friends and familythis is a beautiful house with four great bedrooms and a great locationsuch an accommodating and responsive host the location and house are absolutely beautiful on the lake
7. Relaxing vacation home with beach access (from USD 1021)
There’s plenty of room to play in this Airbnb rental. The outdoor area alone is massive, with a large heated pool and a water slide to boot. Play pool games, swim a couple of laps, or just lounge by the pool’s edge with a refreshing drink in hand. The swimming pool is available from May until October and closed until the following year. This largely depends on the weather, so check with the host to be sure.
Furthermore, this property will put you within a five-minute walk of the beach where you can use the provided kayaks and stand-up paddleboards.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the pool was awesome and the view was unbelievablethe pool was beautiful and the kitchen modernCleanliness:
home very clean and cozythe house itself is well laid out tastefully decorated and cleanHost:
the home was very clean and the hosts were responsive to questions during our stayRead more reviewsLocation:
great house in a great locationbeautiful location and inside is all modern updatedkitchen is gorgeous so close to beautiful beach and quiet neighborhood we truly enjoyed the staythe house was beautiful sunsets were magnificent perfect location close enough to town and beautiful views
8. Elegant open-concept rental (from USD 700)
Traveling to Montauk with your family or closest friends? This Airbnb is the perfect option for an intimate get-together. The open-concept interior features beautifully furnished living, dining, and kitchen areas, which will make it easy to keep the conversation going.
For some fresh air and sun, step outside to the backyard. It’s an extension of the living areas, with an outdoor dining area and grill. Best of all, it has an inviting swimming pool with a water slide for splashy fun. The pool isn’t too large, but it’s just the right size for relaxing chats in the water. You’ll also find lounge chairs where you can rest between laps.
Top guest reviews
Read more reviewsCleanliness:
very clean and a great kid and pet friendly home with a fenced in yard
9. Newly renovated beach home (from USD 699)
For your upcoming trip, enjoy the new features of this vacation rental. That includes a brand-new gunite pool that can be heated to a nice, comfortable temperature. Just take note that pool heating is a seasonal feature that won’t be available from September 30 onward. Fortunately, cold plunges can be good for you!
Other additions include a light-filled open floor plan. The kitchen has also been upgraded with top-of-the-line Keurig appliances.
Top guest reviews
Host:
tabitha was very friendly and her home was exactly what my family neededRead more reviewsLocation:
it comfortably fit our extended family was well equipped and in a great location
10. Tasteful farm house with a saltwater pool (from USD 643)
This rental could be your home while you’re in Montauk. It’s a good family-friendly size with 4,000 sq. ft. (372 sq m) of total livable space. That includes the open-concept dining and living areas bathed in natural light. The highlight of the property, however, is the emerald back lawn where you can find the gorgeous saltwater pool.
Surrounded by manicured landscaping and trees, it’ll feel like you’re in a luxury spa resort. The swimming pool and hot tub are seasonal, with the latter closing later on November 1. Both amenities will reopen in the summer.
Top guest reviews
Cleanliness:
the house itself is also great - lot of appliances large private yard/pool and super cleanHost:
the hosts were patient understanding quick to respond and run an efficient homebeth the host is wonderful and attentive she texted me to make sure everything was going wellbeautiful house and super responsive hosta delightful and easy owner to deal withvery communicative host and great house pictures don't do it justiceRead more reviewsLocation:
really good location near beaches and mtk townthe house is very nice and in a wonderful locationit was a most enjoyable weekend close to local beaches and restaurantsgreat house with a quick walk to great beaches and beth is a lovely helpful host
Experience Montauk's underrated gems
Montauk, New York, has plenty of attractions that you can take advantage of during your visit. When you’re done exploring, you can easily retreat back to one of the rejuvenating Airbnb rentals above and take a relaxing dip in the pool.
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data
Create an account to