Top 10 Airbnb Vacation Rentals In Allendale, New Jersey, USA - Updated 2024

airbnb Allendale NJ
Catherine
Catherine 
Updated
| 6 min read

About an hour’s drive from New York City, Allendale is a low-key getaway destination that offers a small-town vibe. Encompassed by plenty of natural beauty, Allendale is the premiere place to enjoy both winter and summer activities. Allendale is home to a nature preserve called the Celery Farm. Hundreds of animals, including deer, fox, frogs, rabbits, turtles, and exotic birds can be found here. But what truly put Allendale on the map is Crestwood Lake. This 71 acre (28.73 hectare) park includes a man-made lake, 3 beaches, several sports fields, and a barn pavilion. Ice skating on the lake is a big draw during the winter months. Close proximity to the Hudson Valley, and the surrounding mountains, makes skiing and other winter sports ideal as well. No matter what time of year you choose to visit, don’t forget to book an awesome stay at one of these top Airbnb vacation rentals!

We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on May 16, 2024.

1. Close to NYC, private room in a charming home (from USD 100)

Just a quick train ride to New York City, this private room in a cozy home is a great alternative for travelers who don’t want to pay New York City lodging prices. The village-like setting of this town is a less frenetic pace than the Big Apple, making it an ideal spot for enjoying quiet strolls, relishing tasty restaurants, which, by the way, are Bring-Your-Own-Bottle-affairs, and partaking in the inviting nightlife. Guests have access to WiFi, honors bar, laundry facilities, lots of parking, TV room, and even a baby grand piano! A wonderful outdoor area allows guests great al fresco dining. There’s also an outdoor fire pit, and a lovely porch for napping or reading.

Stayed at this property?
Ridgewood, New Jersey, United States
8.3 km (5.2 mi) from Wood Dale County Park
161 reviews   Wifi Available
PRIVATE ROOM IN HOME 1 Bed 2 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 2

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
our bedroom had a comfortable king-sized bed a large closet and plenty of room for luggage
Cleanliness:
the bathroom was clean and sunny
room is very clean and well furnished
nice rooms clean and suzanne was very accommodating
beautiful place super clean and organized
clean and comfortable and personable host
Host:
she makes you feel at home and she is so helpful
she was very attentive and welcoming
she was friendly and informative about the area
susanne was such a great host
susanne is a lovely host and made sure i had everything i needed
Location:
perfect location and beautiful town
just 10 min walk to beautiful ridgewood downtown with so many great shops and unique restaurants
location was great for us as well
neighborhood is very quiet and very safe
commercial streets are very close but you are actually in a quiet nice neighborhood
Read more reviews

2. Immaculate one bedroom, with private entrance near transportation (from USD 69)

Conveniently-located, this brand new one-bedroom basement apartment is a short walk to trains and buses into New York City and many other points of interest. Guests are also just minutes from Pearl River and Blue Hill. This accommodation, with a private entrance and French doors for plenty of sunlight, offers generous amenities. Enjoy a fully-equipped kitchen with 2-plate stove, counter oven, coffee machine, and blender. Wifi, and TV with Netflix, Hulu, and Amazon Prime are available. The queen-size bed provides cushy comfort, and a daybed in the living room offers rest for a 3rd person. A splendid backyard area affords lush green landscaping, comfy seating, and a hot tub!

Stayed at this property?
Montvale, New Jersey, United States
3.22 km (2.0 mi) from Wood Dale County Park
132 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE RENTAL UNIT 1 Bed 3 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 3

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
very good shower and they left us snacks and a bottle of wine
the room and bed were very comfortable and the whole place had a wonderful atmosphere
she left us a very nice personalized note with wifi information and other good info for the apartment
Cleanliness:
very clean and all you need
the apartment was clean and comfy
very clean hot tub was great
mandy’s place was extremely clean and comfortable
the apartment is clean cute and comfortable
Host:
thank you for being a awesome host
mandy was a wonderful host
mandy was an excellent host
hosts were very pleasant and thoughtful
great host and great place
Location:
the location was great
god location and nice house for a weekend away
great location close to the train and in a nice neighborhood
great place super close to ny and nj spots the town is also cute
place was an easy walk from the train station
Read more reviews

3. Private cottage with a kitchen & bath (from USD 92)

Recently remodeled and furnished, this private cottage is a real jewel. Boasting a nicely equipped kitchen and bath, this cottage definitely has everything for a comfy stay. In addition, there’s a comfy double bed, cable TV, WiFi, off-street parking, private entrance, and bath essentials. No washer/dryer is available for guests, but a laundromat is close by. If the owner isn’t using the wonderful backyard, guests are welcome to relax and enjoy this space that provides a nice picnic table for outdoor dining. This accommodation has easy access to much, such as several state parks and Sterling Forest, a great place for hiking. Bear Mountain is only a 30-minute drive. Guests can walk to town, and enjoy restaurants, boutiques, and a movie theater. Be aware the train station is nearby, and actually runs along the back of the lodging. The hosts do not hear any unwanted noise, but light sleepers might.

Stayed at this property?
Suffern, New York, United States
14.17 km (8.9 mi) from Wood Dale County Park
113 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
Entire guesthouse 1 Bed 2 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 2

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
kitchen utensils cable tv air conditioning perfect little home
it is very cozy and beautiful with all the amenities you could possibly need
the amenities are great: full bed closet tv full kitchen bathroom all in a cute self contained space
great small apartment/cottage like setting nestled in a small neighborhood
i spent four months at their apartment and had many pleasant interactions with them
Cleanliness:
darien and his wife had it spot-on clean and well-stocked with cleaning supplies
darien's place is very nice and clean
very clean and in a very nice neighborhood
everything was very clean and it was great to have off the street parking
darien's place was super and as advertised very clean and comfortable and i would highly recommend as stay there
Host:
darian was an awesome host
thank you for being a great host
seriously kind seriously recommend
darien was a great host
they were great hosts always willing to assist
Location:
wonderful location with plenty of restaraunts nearby
nice area and very close to where we wanted to be
darien’s place was super close to several restaurants hiking areas and lakes
the area was quiet and safe with downtown suffern being a couple minutes walk away
we had family events all weekend in nj and this location was absolutely perfect
Read more reviews

4. In-law apartment near NYC & Hudson Valley (from USD 65)

Beauty in a country-like setting is what this one-bedroom guest suite at the end of a cul-de-sac offers. A basement apartment in a lovely Colonial-style home, this lodging surrounds guests with many attractive features, like an outdoor deck, 3-tiered garden with picnic space, and spacious yard with a play-set for children. A cushy queen-size bed graces the warm and functional bedroom, and a queen-size air bed is also available. Lots of public transportation is nearby, so you can travel to vibrant New York City, beautiful Hudson Valley, or many other great neighboring areas. The kitchen is well-appointed. There’s a Hungry Hollow Co-op which provides a wonderful natural food selection, should you want to spend a night in and cook a meal. The host and her young family live on the top 2 floors above, so expect the typical noisiness of children.

Stayed at this property?
Chestnut Ridge, New York, United States
7.91 km (5.0 mi) from Wood Dale County Park
44 reviews   Wifi Available
Entire guest suite 1 Bed 2 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 2

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
bed and air mattress were comfortable
beautiful back yard and view of the sunrise very spacious living room area
reminder there’s no tv here but they've got a good wifi-signal
the fact that everything was organic from the dish detergent to the toilet paper was amazing
the basement apartment was painted brightly with baseboard heating and a functional kitchen
Cleanliness:
quiet neighborhood clean and cozy apartment
very quiet clean and comfortable
convenient spacious clean and friendly
the place was clean and cute
the apartment is spacious clean and comfortable
Host:
chasya was a wonderful host and treated us like we were family
chasya was a lovely host and helped me feel welcome
the hosts were incredibly responsive and accommodating
helpful good and swift communication
chasya is a good communicator and responsive
Location:
great location for green meadow
perfect location and accommodations for nearby conference
it is a lovely peaceful location with easy access to the surrounding area
great space great location and great hosts
my girlfriend and i took a bike trip from brooklyn to the palisades and stayed at chasya's lovely place
Read more reviews

5. Cozy bed & breakfast with private rooms near New York City area (from USD 67)

This private room on the 2nd floor is warm with cozy furnishings. A nice comfy queen-size bed will send you promptly to dreamland, and a smart TV will keep you entertained. A large green backyard is a welcome place to unwind, along with a spacious outdoor 2nd floor wooden deck. A basic breakfast is offered, and is just enough to get you going in the morning. The host occupies the ground floor, and the very tidy and clean bathroom is shared. This accommodation is near public transportation, either bus or train, that can deliver you to New York City in about 70 minutes. A drive by car takes 30 minutes. WiFi, free parking, and bath essentials are available.

Stayed at this property?
Park Ridge, New Jersey, United States
3.07 km (2.0 mi) from Wood Dale County Park
165 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
PRIVATE ROOM IN HOME 1 Bed 2 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 2

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the room and amenities were "as promised
snacks were available an excellent coffee maker and either bagels or muffins/ pastries were provided at breakfast
fan or window a/c might have been helpful
breakfast included was a excellent touch in customer service
room fit the description and posted
Cleanliness:
clean and comfortable space
expect an amazing and clean room and a great stay
the room is very clean comfortable and very quiet
very well kept and clean
rooms are good and clean
Host:
kind and hospitable hosts
mary is the perfect host
mary and kent were excellent hosts
mary is an amazing host
mary is a great host
Location:
mary's airbnb is located in a nice quiet neighborhood
easy to find and park on site
" great location central to hillsdale westwood montvale etc
a great place to stay comfortable bed quiet neighborhood
Read more reviews

6. Warm, top-notch single room; true New York/New Jersey hospitality (from USD 62)

Top accommodation for a solo or business traveler, this affordable private room in a home provides a single bed in an ocean-themed bedroom. This room has TV, and a work-friendly desk with a chair. Smart TV and Netflix are a few of the other amenities available. The glistening bathroom is shared. The neighborhood is surrounded by lots of tall trees and is quiet. Though tranquil, it’s still close to everything: a wonderful restaurant is a couple of minutes away. Be aware, this may not be best for those who are night owls, as many at this lodging retire early. The host is friendly, attentive, and provides a tasty breakfast for her guests. Snacks and drinks are also provided by the host.

Stayed at this property?
Park Ridge, New Jersey, United States
3.2 km (2.0 mi) from Wood Dale County Park
69 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
PRIVATE ROOM IN HOME 1 Bed 1 Guest 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 1

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
free ample wifi free parking was a bonus
the room is appropriately appointed with access to an efficiency kitchen; there are nice amenities too
the bathroom included all the necessities i needed and it was an enjoyable stay
room was great and had everything needed
kitchen area with goodies were a nice touch
Cleanliness:
this is a clean comfortable and quiet b & b
great place clean and convenient with plenty of parking
mary's place is clean quiet and comfortable
very comfortable and clean
mary's place provides a clean quiet and comfortable and clean home and a great value
Host:
mary was very helpful and kind
thank you for being a wonderful host mary
mary and kent were very friendly and welcoming
the owner was a gracious host and had everything i might not of thought i needed
mary's a wonderful host and a terrific baker don't miss her corn muffins
Location:
wonderful location quiet beautiful neighborhood
great location to surrounding areas very hospitable and comfortable home
off street parking in a quiet and safe neighborhood with all the necessities provided
Read more reviews

7. Nice comfortable room - a peaceful place

Situated on 1 acre (0.404 hectares) of woods, this tidy, comfy, and peaceful private room is located in an adorable house. Rich hardwood floors and casual furnishings comprise this home, that also boasts a great yard area with comfortable outdoor furniture. This room offers a cushy full size bed, and there’s ample closet and drawer space. Guests have unhindered use of the cozy living room. The fully-equipped kitchen is available for cooking light meals from 7.00am to 8.00pm. Please note, a freight train passes nearby, so if you’re not a heavy sleeper this could pose an issue. Additional amenities include WiFi, cable TV, free parking, breakfast, central heating, and bed and bath essentials.

Stayed at this property?

11.06 km (6.9 mi) from Wood Dale County Park
115 reviews   Wifi Available
PRIVATE ROOM IN HOME 1 Bed 2 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 2

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the room and bath bathroom were quite lovely and the coffee was delicious
i highly recommend patricia’s private room
the ceiling fan was wonderful when the temp outside went up
the bed was a bit small for 2 people but very comfortable and great amenities available to use
the room was very comfortable and i had two excellent nights of rest
Cleanliness:
clean and great value
very clean room and private bathroom
the room was clean and cozy
her place is clean and comfortable
patricia's place is clean and beautiful
Host:
perfect host in a nice home
patty was a great host
patty was an absolutely wonderful host
she was very kind and made sure i had everything i needed
patty was an excellent host thank you
Location:
i loved the location
convenient to shopping great restaurants and major highways
a very pretty house in a good location
great location in northern nj and ny city metropolitan area
very comfortable home and a great location
Read more reviews

8. Comfy private bedroom with private bath & WiFi

With easy access to major highways, this quiet and large private room in a townhouse is in a secure gated community and offers a flexible sleeping arrangement. Guests have the option of modifying the bed to sleep as a cozy and spacious king-size bed or 2 efficient twin beds. And the mattress is the real deal, not an air mattress! The pretty bathroom is private, with toiletries and fresh fluffy white towels provided. This room also features a small fridge, desk, and speedy WiFi. There’s on-site parking, and guests are welcome to lounge in the living room. The kitchen is available for light meals. On a mission to keep the carpet as pristine as possible, the host requests the removal of shoes when entering.

Stayed at this property?
Ramsey, New Jersey, United States
9.58 km (6.0 mi) from Wood Dale County Park
34 reviews   Wifi Available
PRIVATE ROOM IN CONDO 3 Beds 2 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 2

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the air is on when you're at the house so temperature-wise it's very comfortable
a lot of little thoughtful touches to the room
the room is private and huge
Cleanliness:
house is clean bedroom is clean large and comfy
the bedroom and ensuite bathroom were clean comfortable and quiet
the room is super clean and comfortable
susan's condo is surprisingly spacious clean and comfortable
the bathroom was so clean and has the prettiest toilet seat
Host:
susan was a wonderful host
susan was a great host
susan was a great host
thank you so much to my very friendly hosts
susan is a great host
Location:
and it's a good location for the price if you're in need of a place in the area
her place is just like described even better
susan made everything about staying at her place super easy
susan's and bill's place is a very nice place to stay
Read more reviews

9. Spacious apartment in park setting

If you want to enjoy fresh eggs every morning, build an igloo in winter, or enjoy a stockpile of complimentary supplies to make s'mores on an outdoor fireplace grill, then this is the place for you. The host even provides tickets for the easy train ride into New York City! This roomy, one-bedroom, downstairs apartment actually offers a comfortable stay for up to 6 people. With a Sleep Number queen bed, twin daybed with a trundle underneath, and a full-size sofa bed in the living room, all members of your party will get a good night’s rest. The wonderful backyard houses a flock of chickens, along with a vegetable and herb garden. This lodging may not be right for you if you have mobility, fear of animals, or dog/cat allergy issues. This apartment is near top attractions, like Bear Mountain and the quaint town of Nyack, New York.

Stayed at this property?
Spring Valley, New York, United States
6.28 km (3.9 mi) from Wood Dale County Park
71 reviews  
Entire guest suite 3 Beds 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
sleeping arrangements are comfortable
sofa bed was easy and comfortable
half-kitchen great for morning coffee snacks etc
fantastic secluded apartment with lots of space and thoughtful touches
(and it's a comfortable sofa as i can attest to personally
Cleanliness:
very clean and cozy
michelle s place was clean and secluded quiet and clean
it was clean and comfy
the place was very clean and peaceful
clean spacious and well equipped
Host:
michelle and nick were excellent hosts
she is such a wonderful host
michelle was a great host
michelle was one of the best hosts i have ever had
amazing host and beautiful apartment in a quiet neighborhood
Location:
beautiful location close to town but quiet and peaceful
the location was perfect for our weekend needs
the location was perfect for our weekend event in nearby chestnut ridge
park like setting and quiet
nice place in a quiet neighborhood very close to a park
Read more reviews

Hello Allendale!

Because of its prime locale, Allendale, a former farming community, has emerged as a place to explore during any season. You can take a dip in the lake and hike the scenic trails of Sterling Forest during the summer, or hit the slopes at Bear Mountain and ice skate on Crestwood Lake in winter. Lose yourself in Allendale’s surrounding beauty, and enjoy the comfort and convenience that can be found at these Airbnb vacation rentals. Happy booking, and happy travels to Allendale!

Any must-sees we missed? Tell us about them in the comments section or write a post here to help out fellow travelers!
Disclosure: Trip101 selects the listings in our articles independently. Some of the listings in this article contain affiliate links.

History


Get Trip101 in your inbox

Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data

Catherine has written professionally for over 10 years, and a sizable amount has been travel writing. Her desire to see the world was sparked at a very young age. Growing up, there were many family...Read more

 Want to contribute as a Local Expert?
Explore Allendale
x
Good things are meant to be shared!
Back to top
Visited any of these places? Click this button to activate our "Add a Tip" feature to share your experience.