A popular summer destination and a nature lover’s paradise, Kelley’s Island lies within Lake Eerie. Perfect for a relaxing getaway, being far from the chaos of urban life, this island destination is a close-knit settlement. From hiking the trails that wind past the scenic coastline to kayaking the waters of the lake, there’s plenty to keep you busy here. The island is also home to Glacial Grooves State Memorial where you can see marine fossils tucked away into the limestone bedrock. This small community is big on fun and entertainment with beaches, local markets, and even a specialty fudge store. When it comes to mealtimes, fresh seafood delicacies top the list of things to try. For a truly fun and relaxing getaway, stay at one of these top vacation rentals on Kelleys Island, Ohio.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on April 11, 2024.
1. Summer Wind Lake House (from USD 370)
An ideal pick for a memorable getaway, this welcoming summer house has three bedrooms and a bathroom. It can sleep up to a maximum of eight guests and is suitable for families or large groups of friends. Located steps from the water, this charming property has a wooden deck for you to enjoy your morning cuppa in peace.
The screened porch makes for lazy afternoons while the fire pit is perfect for roasting marshmallows on chilly evenings. The property is a great base for exploring the local attractions or simply staying put and enjoying a laid-back vacation!
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
there was lots of room for everyone with a great king bed queen bed bunk beds and couch’sbunk bed mattresses were a little thin for adults but i’m sure kids wouldn’t have an issueCleanliness:
this house was so clean and perfect for a girl's weekend in kellys islandit was a wonderful island house spacious very clean with plenty of space including a screened in porchoverall the house was clean and a good size for our group of 7Read more reviewsLocation:
we usually walked or rode bikes into town so the location was perfect
2. Old Stone Place (from USD 430)
If a fun and relaxed family vacation is what you’re looking for, then this rental is just right for you. Located close to the town center as well as the beach, state park, and nature trails, this spacious cottage is well placed for exploration. It offers a pleasing blend of old-world charm with all the modern amenities to make you feel at home.
The three bedrooms can accommodate up to 12 guests comfortably. The backyard with a campfire pit and the deck with a gas grill are some highlights of this property.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the bedrooms were huge and the room air conditioners were perfectall of the bedrooms were nice and cool with air conditioners in eachthe downstairs stayed comfortable with the windows opencozy feel but plenty of space what a wonderful property quiet and quaintCleanliness:
clean spacious and centrally locatedthe house was clean spacious and in a perfect locationproperty was clean and well appointed with all the essentials needed away from homeHost:
would really love to thank the home ownersowners are very good at communicationhost was very helpful and the house was cleanRead more reviewsLocation:
this is a central location for our family and we would definitely consider staying here againthis property is in a great location between downtown and the beachthe house was nice and in a nice quiet locationperfect place to stay on the islandthanks for a great place to stay
3. Our House (from USD 299)
This spacious house can accommodate up to eight guests in its four bedrooms. It is within easy reach of the downtown area and Sandy Beach. A beautiful wooden deck is fitted around three sides of the house and makes an ideal spot to take in the gorgeous sunsets and even enjoy leisurely barbecues as it is furnished with picnic tables and an outdoor bar area.
A hammock and campfire pit complete the idyllic picture! The interior features an open plan layout for the kitchen, dining area, and living space.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
a lovely well-decorated and comfortable home surrounded by natural beautyCleanliness:
everything was clean and accessiblehome is clean modern and nicely appointedthe first thing i noticed when we stepped in the door was the clean smell and restful atmospherevery clean and easy check in/out with great communication from the hostwe cleaned well and ready for the next family to enjoyHost:
the owners were always quick to respond and very helpfulbeautiful home description is on point neil was very easy to communicate with and responsiveRead more reviewsLocation:
great house great property great location great islandwe couldnt have asked for a better property or locationit was a perfect place to escape the clamor of lifewe loved the private quiet location- tucked in the woods in the center of the islandgreat place for a family vacation
4. Spacious house with screened back porch (from USD 180)
Enjoy a comfortable stay in this airy house that can accommodate up to six people in three bedrooms. The ranch-style house includes a full-service kitchen equipped with Keurig coffee-makers and a screened back porch. There is ample parking space on the property for up to two trucks with boat trailers.
The beach is an easy walk from the house and indoor entertainment options include books, games, a DVD library, and TV. This property does not accept pets.
Top guest reviews
Cleanliness:
very quiet clean and quietcommunication was excellent excellent house was well stocked on extremely cleanthe vacation home was clean and in good repairit's like having your own island home everything is clean and neatHost:
the owners are extremely helpful and quick to answer all of our questionsRead more reviewsLocation:
location & property perfectwe have stayed many places on the island in the past 30 years and this is the best
5. Luxurious home on private road (from USD 325)
This newly built two-story house can accommodate up to ten people within its sprawling interiors. You will find the master bedroom, great room, dining room, and kitchen on the first floor while the other three bedrooms are all upstairs. The lake is just steps away from the house such that you can hear the lapping of the waves from the patio.
The large covered patio in the backyard is equipped with a grill for fun barbecues. Alternatively, you can just lounge and enjoy the warmth of the outdoor fire pit. You could rent bicycles or golf carts to get around the island.
Top guest reviews
Read more reviewsHost:
host was very responsiveowner was easy to communicate with and responds quicklythe owners are great to work with as well
6. Cedar Cottage (from USD 325)
Living up to its name, this elegant cedar cottage makes for a great base to explore Kelleys Island. Set in a wooded region, with ample parking space and a large private yard, it offers opportunities for relaxation inside and outside the house. The great room with its TV and sectional couch invites you to unwind after a day spent exploring. So does the deck with its gas grill and seating area.
The campfire pit with its custom-made Adirondack benches and the outdoor picnic table are some other highlights. This cottage can accommodate up to eight people and includes three bedrooms, one with a bunk bed.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
nice and quiet cell phone reception and wi-fi sometimes non-existentthe yard and deck were great spaces that we thoroughly enjoyed and inside was nice and cozythe cottage air conditioners worked great the place is clean and well-maintained and everyone had their own bedonly one bathroom but we did okCleanliness:
very clean amd nicevery clean and comfortablevery clean and furnished nicelythe unit was clean and cozyoverall everything was neat & cleanHost:
owner was very easy to communicate withowner is very good at answering any questions you have in a prompt mannerthe owner was very responsive and wonderful to work withowner was also very responsive and easy to work withRead more reviewsLocation:
good location close to townnice location not to far from town but yes far enough away to enjoy the quietnessvery peaceful and quite location and an easy bike ride to either the town or the beachit was quiet and relaxing yet close enough to the attractionswe would love to come back again ( don’t forget cash for the transfer station
7. Casa del Sol (from USD 450)
This sprawling Cape Cod-style house offers splendid lake views and is set within a cul-de-sac. With seven bedrooms, this house can accommodate up to 18 guests quite comfortably. All three of the master suites offer scenic views of the lake as does the backyard. The family room is perfect for some quality bonding and comes equipped with a TV and a DVD player.
The tiki bar overlooking the lake on the lower deck is the highlight of the three-level deck. There’s also a gas barbecue grill and patio set to allow you to wine and dine in a leisurely ambiance.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the back deck was so comfortable having a lovely view of the lakethe kitchen had all of the necessary cookware the house was huge and the back deck was fantasticCleanliness:
house was very clean when we arrivedit was clean and seemed well cared forthe suite was clean and comfortable with a private bathroomthe inside at first glance was clean but then started to notice many things were not cleanthe house was very clean and there was a lot of space to spread out inside and outdoorsHost:
the owners were very responsive to our needs and concernsowner was very responsive during this processthe owners were very responsive after we got in and settledour family truly enjoyed our stay at this home and the owner/manager couldn't have been more accommodating and graciousoverall very pleased with this property and our communications with the ownerRead more reviewsLocation:
loved the location and solitudewe could easily walk or ride bikes to towneverything functioned well and location was great especially for childrenwe enjoyed this roomy and comfy house in it's quiet locationlocation is great on the island and our four generations had a great stay
8. The Old Nest (from USD 595)
This cozy home dating back a hundred years is located within easy reach of the town. The interiors exude an old-world charm with period furniture and elegant furnishings. The beautiful front porch offers gorgeous lakefront views.
The house is set on a sprawling private estate with plenty of hiking trails to explore. A bonfire pit and a barbecue grill make for a relaxing time after a busy day outdoors.
9. Kelleys Island Escape (from USD 208)
This inviting house with two bedrooms is located just steps from the downtown area. With space for up to six people, it is equipped with all the comforts of home: from a spacious kitchen to the living room, you’ll find everything you need such as TVs, dining ware, and board games.
There is ample parking space for multiple vehicles and the outdoor fire ring is perfect for chilly nights.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the grill let me cook dinner and the kitchen is very well stockedtwo televisions with direct tv and a dvd player so there are entertainment optionsmy only wish: that they had wifiCleanliness:
it is spotlessly clean and very comfortablehouse is clean and tidythe property was clean and quietthe house was clean and exactly as expectedthe few things that would have been helpful were a hose and a table for cleaning fishHost:
the owner was wonderful to work withowners were easy to work with and quick to replythe host was very good with communicationthe owners could not have been more responsive or pleasant to work withthe whole rental process was smooth and we had great communication from the property ownerRead more reviewsLocation:
great location and large spacejust far enough away from town to enjoy a good walkit was also close to downtown which was nicealso an easy walk to the fishing pier and dock
An idyllic island vacation
Enjoying a relaxed getaway comes easy at Kelleys Island with its beautiful lake, water activities, and small-town ambiance. Staying at one of the charming rentals here can make your vacation a truly memorable one. Pick your accommodation from this list of the top vacation rentals on Kelleys Island, Ohio.
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data
Create an account to