Hayward is a popular destination for freshwater fishing and ATV enthusiasts. The city is a favorite vacation spot for outdoorsy travelers and families who appreciate scenic woods, calm lakes, and rich flora and fauna. Hikers and skiers who seek a challenging trail can go to American Birkebeiner. Meanwhile, anglers will enjoy checking out Fresh Water Fishing Hall of Fame and its museums. Couples will love the old-town charm of Hayward’s shops, restaurants, and pubs. Those who like wine can sample the array of flavors at Out of the Woods Winery. For a complete Midwest experience, stay in a lovely country home. Check out the top vacation rentals in Hayward, Wisconsin.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status. recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on November 24, 2023.
1. Beautiful cabin beside the lake (from USD 134)
This beautiful log cabin for four, situated in idyllic woodland, is just a stone’s throw from the splendid Hayward Lake. It is also just a stroll away from downtown. National Fresh Water Fishing Hall of Fame and Museum is less than 1 mile (1.6 kilometers) away, while American Birkebeiner Trail is just 4.7 miles (7.6 kilometers) away.
Hand-built in Germany, this authentic log cabin and its carved beams, posts, and drip edges exhibit excellent craftsmanship. Astutely arranged furnishings give a degree of airiness to the studio. The bedroom beside the window evokes a feeling of sanctuary. Cooking is enjoyable in the snug yet well-equipped kitchenette. You can also have some wine on the deck or roast barbecue in the campfire.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
air conditioner kept the cabin cooli loved it other then the air-conditioner fan noise from factory nearby when outsideCleanliness:
place was very cleanour cabin was clean cozy and well kepti love this little cabin it was scrupulously clean; comfortable and easy to findit was small which we new in advance but very clean and comfortableeverything was great very clean organized & fully stockedHost:
the owner clearly considers the comfort of his guestsmike (owner) was super helpfulif you have any questions or concerns mike is an excellent host and very receptiveRead more reviewsLocation:
feels secluded but pretty much walking distance to everythingwe went there over new years becaucse we like peace and quietsuper quaint place and very convenient
2. Spacious rental with a jetted tub (from USD 400)
This house pairs formal and contemporary pieces in a delightfully sophisticated way. This spacious rental comes with five bedrooms and five baths, capable of sleeping up to ten guests. The sumptuous master bedroom has a fireplace and its en-suite bath comes with a jetted tub. All bedrooms exude a relaxing air of refinement.
Cozy up while watching a movie on the massive HDTV. The house has a fireplace that not only warms the living area but also accentuates the space. Aside from a complete kitchen, the fire pit on the patio is ideal for a smoking barbecue. Depending on the season, hiking, ATVing, or skiing is fun at Birkebeiner Trail, which is only 4.3 miles (6.9 kilometers) away.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the entertainment center tv with lots of viewing choices was also really niceCleanliness:
this home is wonderful the house is clean (even during current covid 19) and spaciousthe home was thoroughly cleaned and the grounds well cared forRead more reviewsLocation:
this was a great location for a family winter retreatloved the selection of kid’s books and close proximity to the park
3. Lakefront abode with a complete kitchen (from USD 188)
Found right beside the serene Lake Hayward, this cabin has a private dock. Only a few steps away is the patio, which comes with loungers and a fire pit. Furniture with striking carvings, a plush sofa, a flat-screen TV, and a wood-burning stove give the living and family rooms an approachable ambiance. The complete kitchen is roomy and comes with a big dining table and Windsor-style chairs. With three unassuming and cozy bedrooms, the rental can sleep eight.
Just at the end of the driveway, you will find a paved bike trail. In summer, catch your trophy fish or swim in the lake. During winter, you can go on the ski trails that are conveniently located near the lake. Downtown Hayward is also just 1.5 miles (2.4 kilometers) away.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
I loved the long kitchen tableThe beds were very comfortable with plenty of closet and drawer space for those that like to unpackThe cabin was perfect and the town of Hayward was amazingThe cabin was well kept and stockedThe cabin is very well stocked from the kitchen to the bath towelsCleanliness:
The cabin was exactly as picturedIt was clean and everything was in orderThe cabin was awesome - very cleanHost:
Janean was very communicative leading up to our arrival for check in check out available amenities recommendationsSteve was also super responsive when we had a question as wellit definitely has the feeling of being secluded Stocked with all the basics and moreThis property is well maintained and def a cabin feel-Very accurately advertised Excellent support via email Property clean and comfortable Fantastic experienceRead more reviewsLocation:
I am not sure there is a better property on the lake if you want the convenience to walk into town but still have a tucked away house with privacyGreat location near town & biking trailsThis place has everything you need and is in a great locationthe location was amazing and the views of the lake from the house and backyard were incrediblenot modern but very nice and appropriate- very close to downtown which was great
4. Luxurious property for large group (from USD 949)
The beauty of this lake home is already apparent from the outside. Inside, it manages to combine elegance with coziness. With two master suites and two bedrooms, the house sleeps fourteen.
Cathedral ceilings, stone-walled partition with an elegant fireplace, and high-quality wood furniture give the cabin a restful charm. Additionally, its huge windows and roomy deck, which is just a stone’s throw from the lake, beckon you to come out and enjoy the outdoors. Catch the captivating sunrise on the deck or roast mallows in the fire pit. Whether you want to kayak on the peaceful lake, swim, or fish for muskies, the activities are overflowing.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
as others have said the great room and deck are terrific areas to enjoy time togetherwonderful large family room and decksunrise to sunset beautiful views of lake hayward from grand great room and lodge surrounding decksthe house was very comfortable and we loved how the swimming area was easily visible from the deckevery bedroom had its own bathroom which was awesomeCleanliness:
very clean and well maintainedthe house was clean and the beds comfortableit's beautiful and clean and so comfortable especially the bedsthe lodge was spacious clean and well suppliedthank you for spacious and exceptionally clean accommodationsHost:
the owner lee was more than helpfulthe owner lee was extremely helpful and answered our questions promptlylee and mary jo where so accommodating and gracious hoststhe owners graciously greeted us upon arrival making us feel so welcomethe owners are wonderful people and really take pride in their homeRead more reviewsLocation:
amazing location on a penninsula pretty muchproximity to hayward is great for shopping groceriesgreat nearby hiking trails and short walk to downtown haywardwhat a beautiful location with water surrounding the house on three sidesideal location beautiful setting great entertaining venue and very nicely appointed
5. Spruce Chalet (from USD 220)
Have a relaxing afternoon in the living room with a gleaming lake in full view. Discover the beauty of Hayward’s exquisite sunset from the deck or row on the resplendent lake and appreciate nature’s effortless beauty. If you crave a more challenging adventure, the famous bike trails and ski trails of Birkebeiner are only 4 miles (6.4 kilometers) from the property.
High-vaulted ceilings and glass-wall windows allow an abundance of light to brighten the interiors. Meanwhile, the upholstered sofas, tufted leather ottoman, and elegantly carved furniture speak of a gracious lifestyle. The kitchen is complete while the baths are well-kept. Spacious and cozy, the accommodation alone can sleep eight. If you include the nearby chalets, the place can sleep 21.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
cozy cabin with amazing view on the lakeCleanliness:
the houses were lovely and clean and perfect for entertaining our groupHost:
owners seem good / nice/helpful when notifiedpatrick was very kind and got us everything we neededpatrick our host was very accommodating and very friendlypatrick was an excellent host and everything mentioned in the vrbo pictures and descriptions were spot onthanks to the hosts for the s’more supplies which we used at our bonfire the second nightRead more reviewsLocation:
great location on the water but close to townconvenient location to all in hayward which was nicehad everything we wanted comfy and beautifully decorated close to town which was plus
6. White Birch Retreat (from USD 185)
An unpretentious sophistication emanates from this charming cabin by the lake. Situated in pine-clad slopes, White Birch Retreat’s country style and location appeal to those who appreciate the grandeur of nature and value outdoor adventure. Enjoy a laid-back day in the living area, which comes with a stone fireplace and a view of the lake. The complete kitchen is bright, while the bath with a tub is cozy. With three bedrooms, the cabin can sleep seven.
Hiking in autumn, mountain biking on the verdant trail in summer, or skiing on the white slopes in winter will be easy since American Birkebeiner is just 4 miles (6.4 kilometers) from the rental.
7. Fancy Fireflies (from USD 79)
Fancy Fireflies is a well-furnished studio in a small cabin community that sits a few steps from the calm Lake Hayward. The studio is the perfect abode for couples looking to explore Hayward, especially since downtown is just 0.5 miles (0.8 kilometers) away. Canoeing or angling for muskies in the calm lake is a favorite pastime among locals. Meanwhile, American Birkebeiner Trail, which is just 4.7 miles (7.6 kilometers) away, offers more challenging hiking and skiing trails.
After a day filled with adventure, retreat into the quaint and relaxing studio cabin. The queen-sized bed is soft and fitted with crisp bedspreads. A massive Smart TV, a well-equipped kitchenette with a Keurig machine, and an outdoor grill make the stay a lot more relaxing.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
i loved all of the extra touches: snack basket toiletries in the bathroom coffee etcone thought might be to provide better instructions on tv remotes (for us non-techies)very cold weather cabin was comfortable but glad we brought another down comforterCleanliness:
the property was clean and cozythe cabins are clean and cozy and stocked with necessitiesthe cabin was very nice clean and cozyHost:
the manager was very responsive to our request of a different coffee maker when ours didn’t workRead more reviewsLocation:
we enjoyed the relaxing privacy of the cabin while still close enough to town to enjoy shopping and restaurantsthis cabin along with another cabin on the property was the perfect location for a getaway with friendsalso there is a “small town“ downtown area that is in walking distance with nice shopsit was cozy and warm convienent location and the check in/out was easy
8. Charming log cabin with a convenient location (from USD 185)
This log cabin puts guests in a restful mood. The open floor plan allows light and air to penetrate freely, while carefully selected art, draperies, decors, and carpet add dynamic energy to the interiors. Unfussy furnishings, big sofas, and a wood-burning stove give an airy and unassuming vibe in the living area. The kitchen is both functional and lovely. Upstairs, each of the two bedrooms conveys a relaxing countryside atmosphere.
Just minutes from downtown, this property is in a convenient location. Hayward Lake is only 0.6 miles (1 kilometer) away, while American Birkebeiner Trail is only 3.6 miles (5.8 kilometers) away.
Top guest reviews
Cleanliness:
the cabin was very cleanit was very clean and had all what we neededthe cabin was clean and very nicevery nice place and cleanthe cabin is well appointed and very cleanHost:
owners were friendly and helpfulthe owner was professional and easy to work withproperty owners were wonderful to work with very informative and quick responsesgreat owners who maintain a wonderful place to staygreat communication from owner nathan from the startRead more reviewsLocation:
very close to many nice lakesthe location was great as well close to all hayward has to offeroutstanding experience with delightful property in a perfect locationnice clean cabin close to towngreat place to stay in the hayward area
9. Cozy vacation rental in Lumberjack Village (from USD 200)
Just a minute from Hayward Lake and part of Lumberjack Village, this authentic log cabin with knotty pine paneling, exposed beams, and relaxing furnishings convey an outdoorsy lifestyle and frank easiness. Guests have exclusive use of canoes and paddleboards. Lumberjack Village also has a relaxing riverside restaurant and a mini-golf course. Explore Hayward’s shops and bars; downtown is only a 10-minute walk away.
Huge windows in the lightly furnished living area allow in soft light and fresh air, while the wood-burning stove keeps the space cozy. The kitchen with a breakfast bar is complete. Meanwhile, the two bedrooms with custom-made log beds can sleep four. For a rustic feel, roast barbecue in the spacious yard beside the lake.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
it was a little rustic but had two really nice updated bathroomsHost:
everyone was super friendly and helpfulrhonda was very helpful with all questions during our stayRead more reviewsLocation:
the location was greatclose to town cute little village areawalking distance to a cute little beach toothe lumber jack village was a great location to everythingwalmart is close and norske nook pie was awesome
Relax at Hayward
With its idyllic lakes and woods, as well as interesting local scene, Hayward is the perfect place to unwind with family and friends. Its charming downtown is also a treasure trove of quaint shops and friendly pubs. Before you pack your bags, consider booking one of Hayward’s best vacation rentals.
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data
Create an account to bookmark our articles, like local expert tips, receive great stories in your inbox, and follow writers and topics that you love.
Log in with Google ×