The longest of New York’s glacial Finger Lakes, Cayuga Lake offers several fun activities. Paddle out into the lake or dive in for a swim when the lifeguards are around - adventure and enjoyment are guaranteed. A boat ride along the lake as the setting sun’s golden rays set the serene waters ablaze is a phenomenon worth witnessing. Several beach access parks offer pleasant spots for family picnics. Award-winning wineries along the Cayuga Lake Wine Trail offer exotic bouquets deserving of every wine lover’s attention. The scenic beauty around invites you to spend a few days in the area, especially if you’re exhausted from city life’s drudgeries. If you plan to take a trip here, year-round lake homes offer incredible opportunities for an unforgettable lakeside getaway. Discover the top Airbnb vacation rentals near Cayuga Lake, New York, and set out on a vacation you are sure to remember for a lifetime.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on April 11, 2024.
1. Cozy waterfront cottage (from USD 141)
The peaceful surroundings will make you feel blissful. Set right on the lakeshore, this bungalow will fill your days with a chance to swim whenever the mood strikes or enjoy a refreshing beverage while watching the sunset from the patio. Fishing is also possible if you find the activity calming. The soothing murmur of waves lapping against the shore will lull you to a restful sleep at night. The kitchen provides all the equipment you need to fix a gourmet meal. This is the right place to be if you are looking for an intimate and romantic nature escape.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
amazing setting on the lake very cozy unique cottagethe views from the bungalow are stunning and the home itself is cozy and had everything we neededCleanliness:
everything was super clean and neat as a pinthe place was clean and perfectly furnished and designedminka is well equipped and very cleanknow that you will have a clean and comfortable place to stayHost:
jude is a gracious hostjude is amazing host makes you feel at homejude was the most gracious hostjude is a wonderful person and hostjude and bill are amazing hostsRead more reviewsLocation:
it’s a beautiful place and the location is perfectan adorable little place in a beautiful locationthe space was beautiful and the location was perfectit is a short drive to great wineries and places to eatthe location is breathtaking and all of the neighbors are so lovely and friendly
Superhost
2. Rustic building providing solitude (from USD 130)
This red-brick one-bedroom studio presents a cozy retreat for couples or two friends traveling together. Standing in the middle of a grove, the property ensures seclusion. You will love the place if you are looking to break away from the bustle of the city. A cathedral ceiling and radiant heating create a snug ambiance inside. Sunrays filtering in through stained-glass portals turn the space magical. Quaint touches in the decor, such as hurricane lamps and antique shelves, add to the rustic vibe. Although it appears bucolic, this accommodation provides every amenity you need for a comfortable stay. Also, if you are a pet lover, you’ll make fast friends with the dogs living in the main house.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the space is adorable and very cozy warmwe enjoyed our stay in this cozy cabin as we played cards and gameswe loved the cabin’s radiant flooring bed warmer and cozy winter decorthe loft area is perfect and the overall space feels so cozyCleanliness:
cottage was immaculately clean and cozyvery clean and feels like homethe cabin was sparkling clean and warm on our arrivalclean well stocked with anything you could think oflots of personality while also clean and convenientHost:
heather was a lovely hostthis was perfect heather and jeremy were wonderful hosts the accommodations were great can’t wait to returnowners answered all my questions in a timely manner would surely stay in the futuresuper cool super accommodating & super communicative hosta wonderfully relaxing place with super friendly hostsRead more reviewsLocation:
great space and great locationwe highly recommend this cute placeadorable house in a wonderful location into the woodsthe location is excellent - close to ithaca while feeling secluded and woodsythe cabin is very close to cornell university we highly recommend this amazing place
3. Cayuga Cottage (from USD 120)
Situated on a private road right beside Cayuga Lake, this one-bedroom cottage features a deck offering stunning sunset views right from the house. The tranquil atmosphere helps relieve stress, and the wonderful views will revive your energy levels. The property provides all the basic necessities you’ll need for comfort and convenience. A dock on-site offers a place for family picnics, and the barbecue setup will help you prepare delicious grilled dishes. However, remember to bring your drinking water, grocery supplies, and cooking essentials. You will find basic spices and dishware in the kitchen. Luckily, a grocery store nearby will help you stock up if you forget to pack something you need for meal prep.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the ac is in the living room and nicely cools the whole housewe cooked most nights and the grill and equiped kitchen was greatoutside fire pit was awesome nice deck with table & grillgorgeous cottage great docks to swim from one to eat at and also great firepit and seatingdebbie's place is fabulous the view is amazing and the house is very cozy and comfortableCleanliness:
very clean and extra touches was appreciatedit is clean and very stylishvery clean and quite cute interiorthe cottage was immaculately clean and well stockedvery relaxing and cleanHost:
debbie is a fantastic host she answered all of our questions in a timely mannerdebbie is an amazing host and really went above and beyondsuperb host great overall listingdebbie was a super hostdebbie is a gracious host with attention to detail and extra touchesRead more reviewsLocation:
but there are still a few fantastic wineries in close proximitythis is a particularly good location if you would like to stay lakeside and low keygreat location in terms of lakeside with great viewscayuga cottage was perfect the weather was lovely and the location is primeworth it completely it's a wonderful place and so quiet
4. Adorable shiplap cottage set in a country garden (from USD 89)
Located around the mid-Finger Lakes region, the property is close to scenic lakes and gurgling waterfalls. The single-bedroom cottage is large enough for two guests, featuring a comfortable bed and top-notch appliances. Fully furnished, the home offers every convenience you would expect at a country homestay. Heating and air conditioning keep the interiors toasty or cool depending on the weather. The high-speed Wi-Fi connection lets you share spectacular pictures of the surroundings without any lag. The deck presents a cozy setting for tête-à-têtes with your loved one over a steaming cup of coffee, with the verdant greenery of the garden as the backdrop.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the cottage had a homey feel with comfortable furnishingsthis wonderful cozy cottage is just as describedthe cottage was immaculate cozy and charmingit is a lovely cottage and very comfortableac kept us feeling comfortable and everything we needed to live was there highly recommendCleanliness:
very clean and well appointedvery clean and well equippedsuper clean very comfortablethe place is very clean and comfortableit was clean quiet and well appointedHost:
and the owner was very responsive and awfully kindand the hosts are 100% greatthe owners were very responsive and available to help with any questions we had - very helpfulwe would definetly recommend this hostthey provided a very helpful folder of locations and brochures to help us locate themRead more reviewsLocation:
the cabin is a very cute very quiet hideaway located about 15 minutes from ithacanice quiet place away from the hustle and bustleit was a good location for our pursuit of waterfallsit's perfect for couples quite secluded but close enough to everythinginternet was fast and the location was everything we hoped for in our finger lakes getaway
5. Charming cottage near a waterfall
Presenting awe-inspiring views of the lake, the cottage also sits parallel to a waterfall, adding to the beauty of the surroundings. Featuring two bedrooms, the property comfortably hosts up to four travelers. Whether you plan to hike, explore the town of Ithaca, or just want to stay indoors watching movies, this place is an ideal choice. Inside the house, you will find a kitchen stocked with all that you need to prepare filling meals.
Ithaca, New York, United States
10.98 km (6.9 mi) from Taughannock Falls State ParkAccommodates: 4
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
comfortable beds plenty of amenities and valerie is quick to respond to messagesthe amenities were great and the house was very comfy and cozyplay video games in the room upstairsbeautiful cottage comfortable and cleanvalerie’s place is a hidden gem the cottage is cozy and well locatedCleanliness:
very clean and modern cottagethe house was clean and comfortablethe space was very clean and just the right size for a small groupvalerie's place is very cleanfeel safe and protected in this quaint house that is both extremely clean and extremely charmingHost:
valerie was an amazing hostvalerie was an excellent hostvalerie is wonderful and responsive hostshe was an excellent host who went above and beyondour host was thoughtful and responsiveRead more reviewsLocation:
ideal location for seeing everything around ithacait’s in a great locationperfect size and location for our quick weekend stayjust enough seclusion but close enough to the local attractionsone of the best things was the location
6. The Timber Garden Cottage (from USD 111)
Constructed with classic timber frames, this cottage lends a pastoral charm to your holiday. The majestic wooden beams, the spacious living area, and the sunlight filtering in through the skylight create an inviting atmosphere inside. Providing two beds and a sofa, the studio is cozy enough for three guests. Downtown Ithaca, Taughannock Falls State Park, and Cayuga Lake Wine Trail are all located close by. Formerly a bakery, an added charm of this home is the availability of plenty of baking supplies, which might encourage you to whip up fresh cookies and muffins for breakfast.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
wifi and netflix works greatit is a home filled with books kitchen in good shape beautiful wood and art on wallsthe setup of the cottage is really spacious and comfortableceiling fan started clicking loudly in the middle of the night which made sleep impossibleboth beds were very comfortableCleanliness:
very clean and comfortablenice clean and peacefulbeautiful place very cleanvery clean and the design was really greati had a great stay the place was clean and so cozyHost:
awesome place with a great hostaudra is an amazing host so go ahead and book with confidencemany sweet art and book touches throughout that add a sense of kind soulaudra was a great host who was always quick to respond and clear with communicationaudra is a great hostRead more reviewsLocation:
audra’s place location is greatthe location is greatcute little cottage great locationnice quiet house close to the cityvery cute house very close to town but still far out enough to feel secluded
7. Rustic-style wooden cabin with extraordinary views (from USD 202)
Set on the west shore of Cayuga Lake, this cabin provides direct access to the water via a dock, and you’ll have ample space to spend fun moments under the sun, fishing or enjoying the view. The screened-in porch presents an ideal setting for sharing intimate moments with loved ones. Start your day by sipping a fresh hot beverage while looking out at the incredible scenery. Tall windows by the dining area give the feel of al fresco lunches. If you are searching for some peace and quiet to reconnect with nature, this is the place to be!
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the screened in porch was perfect for morning coffee and drinks before bedmy wife and i were very comfortable and we would hands down book here againCleanliness:
clean bright and convenientthe cottage is clean and comfortablethe sheets and towels were clean and soft and the beds were quite comfortablethe cabin had everything we needed during our stay and was clean beyond expectationsthe cabin was clean comfortable and had easy access to the waterHost:
the host is super friendly and very responsiveconstantine responded quickly to all our questions with helpful responsesconstantine was an excellent host and quickly responded to any questions we hadyou could hear the waves lapping on shore the host was excellent with communicatingconstantine was a great host and very responsive and considerateRead more reviewsLocation:
the location is greatgreat location constantine was very helpfulconstantine’s place was perfect the location was greatgreat location right by the lakegreat location to take advantage of all the finger lakes has to offer
8. Lakefront cottage with uninterrupted lake views (from USD 229)
Set on the banks of the lake, this three-bedroom property offers easy access to the water and fantastic sunset views. The open-concept living area allows you to enjoy the vista even when you are inside, and a wrap-around deck is great if you want to stay in the shade. The two-story wooden dock enables you to relax, go fishing, or sunbathe. You can enjoy a picnic with your loved one in the yard overlooking the lake. In the kitchen, you will find modern equipment to help you cook your favorite dishes.
Top guest reviews
Cleanliness:
awesome spot could not believe how clean it was spotlessthe house was very clean & spaciousprivate clean safe environmentprivate and great community everything was sparkling cleanclean location and helpful hostHost:
a very special place and amazing hostjennifer is a wonderful hosti also thought the value was great definitely want to stay again jennifer was a great hostRead more reviewsLocation:
this is a great place in a great locationgreat place right on the lake for a relaxing long weekendbeautiful location and amazing views
9. Sunset Haven Cottage (from USD 199)
Tall glass doors and windows in this two-level cottage bring nature’s splendor right inside. Whether you sit on the wrap-around wooden deck upstairs or the patio below, you get to enjoy panoramic views of the sparkling water. A six-person capacity hot tub provides the perfect recipe for relaxation. The private dock with an expansive sun deck offers a great spot to enjoy the sunshine, cast a line, and access the lake. Boat lifts allow you to explore the lake on your boat, and a waterslide enables you to dive right in whenever you fancy a refreshing swim. The living area inside is wheelchair accessible via the ground-level deck.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the kitchen was well equipped and the included amenities made our trip much easiera very cozy & peaceful cottage overlooking the lakethe "sunset haven" has an amazing view with a cozy interiordebbies place was so beautiful and cozy with the wood stoveCleanliness:
the whole place was super clean and felt really homeygreat place very clean with everything one could needeasy to get in plenty of towels clean beautiful kitchenit was really clean and well taken care ofstaying there during some snow and really chilly nights we made great use of the super clean hotHost:
hosts were kind and responsivepaul was very helpful with instructions always extended hospitality above and beyondhosts very responsive flexible and cordialthe wine left by the host was a thoughtful touchbeautiful cabin on the lake hosts were friendly accommodating and wonderful to work withRead more reviewsLocation:
the location was breathtakingclose to all but far enough away to be quiet and relaxinggreat location for fishing and very close to a public boat launchamazing location right on the waterspacious and perfect location we loved it
10. Tiny house with modern amenities (from USD 128)
If you admire the tiny house lifestyle, you will be right at home in this one-room Airbnb. The floor plan is designed to allow maximum use of the space. Inside, you will find everything necessary for a comfortable holiday. A kitchen stocked with cutlery, cookware, and appliances to help you prepare meals, television, internet connection, air conditioning, and other facilities ensure you’ll want for nothing during your stay. You can share the host’s Empire Pass for hiking or to park your vehicle for free at any New York State Park. Moreover, the proximity to the lake and waterfalls make this property an appealing accommodation choice.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the amenities added were so helpful too - from the fully stocked kitchen to the empire passit was great for staying in on the sofa and eating takeout dinner with the movable tvit has all the modern comforts of a nice hotel room but is far more welcomingCleanliness:
awesome place clean and exactly as describedeverything is sparkling clean and well maintainedit’s clean stylish and uniqueeverything was clean when we got there and cozy warmthe place was superbly clean cozy and exactly as describedHost:
she was also very helpful and accommodatingdonna was a great hostdonna is an amazing hostour host donna was so welcoming and very knowledgable of the surrounding areadonna is so cool she is an amazing host and is welcoming in every wayRead more reviewsLocation:
the location of the house is perfectgreat location and the place is awesomethis truly is a cute place to get away and do a little shopping or winery toursthe tiny house was the perfect location to explore the finger lakes especially cayuga and senecagreat space and a good location
Delightful vacation homes for a heavenly nature escape
Presenting amazing views to refresh your mind and modern amenities to keep you comfortable, the vacation homes around Cayuga Lake set the stage for idyllic lakeside holidays. Don’t delay and miss out on the dates you plan to visit the lake region. Book one of these top Airbnb vacation rentals near Cayuga Lake, New York, to ensure you enjoy your trip to the fullest.
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data
Create an account to