Whether you are looking for a memorable experience, aiming to visit a university friend, or wanting some relaxation - Hamilton in Madison County is the place to be. It is home to Colgate University and offers numerous attractions and activities for everyone. The town was named after the late American Founding Father, Alexander Hamilton, who became “the man on the 10-dollar bill.” Your crash course into Hamilton’s history will begin at Hamilton Grange National Memorial and Trinity Church Museum. Hamilton has some great spots for dining and shopping as well. If you want to experience the best, you have to find a superb accommodation first. Read on and check out our list of the best Airbnb vacation rentals in Hamilton, New York!
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on May 25, 2025.
1. Relaxing and comfortable home (from USD 120)
This lovely home, which is located close to Hamilton Village offers newly renovated bedrooms and a bathroom, which means more comfort and convenience. If you want to prepare your meal, a well-equipped kitchen is at your disposal. But, if you want to explore the local’s delicacies, you are not far away from plenty of restaurants and eateries. The whole area is serene, which makes this accommodation great if you want to take a break from the world.
Top guest reviews
Location:
great location close to town and colgateCleanliness:
very clean and neatsuper clean and comfy place to staythe apartment was very clean quiet and cozyRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
wifi was a nice addition as well as treats for our pup
2. Spectacular home with lovely touches (from USD 99)
This lovely home puts you in a prime location. Athletic facilities, Colgate University, and more are just walking distance from the property. The accommodation features everything you need to make your stay a blast, from a smart television with a basic cable to a cozy king-size bed, from a mini-fridge to WiFi. The bedroom has a good interior and decorated with lovely touches, which makes it more charming and relaxing to rest.
Top guest reviews
Host:
the host room and location were perfectLocation:
cute place that is very convenient to the universityeasy walking to hamilton colgate campus athletic facilitiesthis is a perfect place to staybest place to stay if you are visiting colgateCleanliness:
interior is clean and well-appointedRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
the room was cozy and had snacks and beverages for us to enjoy
3. Self-catering unit that is well furnished (from USD 150)
Make this awesome accommodation your second home in Hamilton. Situated 4 km (2.5 mi) from the campus, this 1-bedroom private in-law unit got you covered from day one up to your last day. It comes with a private entrance, so your privacy is guaranteed. The kitchenette is at your disposal, which is equipped with a microwave, though a stove is not included. Entertainment centers like WiFi and Roku with access to Netflix will keep you entertained. The bedroom has two cozy beds that can accommodate four guests.
Top guest reviews
Host:
the hosts are fabulous peoplethe hosts are very friendlykristin is a great hosthost was very responsive and we enjoyed it immenselythe owners are a sweet young familyLocation:
great location for visiting colgategreat place 2 miles from campus and close to great restaurantscozy spot in a lovely neighborhood close to towngreat location cool atmosphere awesome buildingthe location is great just a 5 minute drive to the downtown hamilton area and campusCleanliness:
very clean and privatevery clean and cozylots of clean towelsthe apartment was clean and cozythe space was very clean and cozyRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
the selection of keurig coffee and bathroom supplies was a nice unexpected bonusthe kitchen has everything you need and bed comfortable the couch toothe apartment suite is wonderful plenty of space to relax very comfortable beds and furnishings and nicely decoratedcheck in was a breeze and the stay was very comfortablethe bed is super comfortable
4. Lovely and cozy cottage right off the lake (from USD 82)
The only problem when you rent this cozy accommodation is once you checked in, it’s really hard for you to check out. This private and intimate cottage is located right off the lake. It is charming and cute and can accommodate a small group. If you truly want to experience water escapades, there’s no better place in Hamilton than here. Kayaking, fishing, paddle boarding - all are just around the corner. This lovely cottage features all the necessities for a fantastic stay, from a well-equipped kitchen to entertainment facilities.
5. Renovated farmhouse near eateries (from USD 357)
This home is a combination of old charm and modern amenities. Built in 1839, this lovely rental is fully renovated, which means more comfort and fun. Custom cabinetry, high-quality quartz countertops, equipment, to name a few - all of which contributed to encouraging you to be the Iron Chef of the day. There are two spacious living rooms with HDTV that has a basic cable. It is situated just steps away from restaurants and bars.
Top guest reviews
Host:
thank you to our wonderful hosthosts were more than responsive and we will certainly be backerin the host is super responsive and went out of her way to accommodate usamazing house and great hosterin is a wonderful and helpful hostLocation:
the location is greatthe location is fabulousgreat location when visiting colgategreat location for walk into towngreat house close to both colgate and the villageCleanliness:
house was clean and comfortableclean comfortable and convenientsuper clean and well equippedeverything was clean and tidy when we arrivedthe house was clean and very spaciousRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
the bedrooms each had their own air conditioner to adjust to your comfortcomfortable sleeping and the house had everything we needed for our stayawesome comfortable home with space to spread out and a great kitchenerin was a terrific host making our stay in hamilton both comfortable and enjoyablewe all slept comfortably and had plenty of room
6. Charming residence in a top notch location
The moment you step onto the premises of this lovely farmhouse, which was built in the year 1835, you may not want to go out. Staying here allows you to experience the rustic charm of a country’s lifestyle. It is newly renovated and equipped with plenty of amenities. It is situated in the middle of Broad Street and Colgate University, plus it is surrounded by shops and eateries. The newly renovated kitchen is fully stocked with Keurig coffee maker for caffeine lovers.
15.7 km (9.8 mi) from Stoney Pond State ForestSuperhost
Accommodates: 9
Top guest reviews
Location:
it’s comfortable spacious and well located close to town and campus but on a quiet side streetvery close to the center of town and was great to host a large group of peoplethis place is in excellent conditionwe thoroughly enjoyed our stay and would recommend caroline’s placeRead more reviewsCleanliness:
fantastic stay - clean amazing beds great space wonderful communication
7. Nice accommodation located near the university
This accommodation offers spectacular Hamilton experience. It is a great choice to stay when you are planning to meet your university friends or aiming to explore the beauty of the town. Location wise, Colgate University and the heart of the town, which is the home to numerous shopping and dining scene are just a walking distance away from the rental. It comes with all the modern conveniences you need like television with Roku and/or cable, a fully stocked kitchen, plus a lovely backyard, which is a good spot to play games.
Hamilton, New York, United States
14.96 km (9.3 mi) from Stoney Pond State ForestTop guest reviews
Host:
kathleen made sure we had everything we needed and was very responsive to any requests for infowe couldn't have asked for a better hosthostess was incredibly responsive and helpful with travel tips and dining suggestionskathleen is a gracious thoughtful and super responsive to questionsLocation:
great house within walking distance to downtown hamiltonperfect location for colgate eventsadorable house with great locationgood place and price near antique fairgreat location walkable to downtown and campusCleanliness:
very clean and nicevery clean and well cared forfantastic home - clean adorable and excellent communication thank youthe house is well maintained and very clean throughoutthis beautiful clean organized home was perfect for our visit to colgateRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
beds were super comfy and we felt very safethe cottage is very cozy and the perfect locationfull kitchen large living room (perfect for watching the patriots win the afc)this house provided just the right amount of cozy cheer that made it a lovely experience
8. Homey stay good for a small family
Homey and quaint - that’s what this lovely ranch is all about. The ambiance is just like a typical grandma’s home, which means, in every corner, there’s plenty of thoughtful touches. The neighborhood is quiet and warm, which adds to the experience. The location is also top-notch, you’ll be minutes to town where you can explore some attractions and dining scene. It comes with a nice living room equipped with entertainment facilities like a television and BluRay/DVD player. The cozy bedrooms can accommodate up to four guests.
Hamilton, New York, United States
14.79 km (9.2 mi) from Stoney Pond State ForestAccommodates: 4
Top guest reviews
Host:
ryan is a great host super responsive and helpfulhosts are fabulous very quick responses and house was perfect in a fantastic locationCleanliness:
it was simple clean and worked well for usvery nice and clean little place only about 2 minutes from townsparkling clean and close to colgateRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
small comfortable & cozy
9. Rustic cottage located on the lake
This wonderful rental gives you a feeling of contentment. Serene, located right on the water, the ambiance is warm - all of this contributed to making this rental a great place for a little soul searching. This accommodation is not a kid-friendly environment because of the location of the cottage and has steep stairs. It comes with all the comforts you need, from television to hot water, from essentials to free parking. No matter where you are in the corner of the house, you will certainly find a beautiful view.
16.07 km (10.0 mi) from Stoney Pond State ForestAccommodates: 4
Top guest reviews
Host:
allen is an amazing host who was always available to answer questions and help with anythingallen was a responsive and gracious hostRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
it was cool the night we arrived but the space heaters easily took the chill offbeds were super comfortableit was hot the last day we were there but with fans we were able to sleep comfortably
10. Luxurious rental with sumptuous continental breakfast
This luxurious home is a gem. Situated 3.2 km (2 mi) from the heart of town and the campus, this charming accommodation features modern comforts, from a living room space to a kitchen. Two bedrooms can comfortably cater to up to four guests. The real draw of this rental is the friendly host that will accommodate you throughout. High-speed WiFi is available, which is great to document your Hamilton escapade. The best part? Sumptuous continental breakfast items are also available.
Hamilton, New York, United States
18.33 km (11.4 mi) from Stoney Pond State ForestAccommodates: 4
Top guest reviews
Location:
lindsey’s place was as described clean and close to hamilton very convenient if visiting colgateCleanliness:
her home was very clean and comfortableRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
fantastic great room and amazingly appointed kitchen
Adventure in Hamilton
Great scenery, outstanding attractions, Broadway, superb accommodation - the list just goes on and on. If you want to learn more about the man in the 10-dollar bill, Hamilton is the place to be.
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data
