10 Best Airbnb Vacation Rentals In Jamestown, New York - Updated 2023

| 5 min read

Boasting numerous historic sights and a verdant cityscape worth admiring, Jamestown is a stunning destination in New York state. This city has plenty of its own interesting offerings, including Lucille Ball Desi Arnaz Museum - a museum dedicated to popular American actress Lucille Ball, the historic Jamestown Gateway Train Station, Fenton History Center, and Northwest Arena. Visitors can also enjoy tons of fantastic outdoor activities at Allegany State Park, among other attractions. Start planning your vacation right away and start by booking the best accommodation. Scroll down to find out about the best Airbnb vacation rentals in Jamestown, New York.

1. A centrally located apartment (from USD 74)

An easy distance away from attractions, such as Lucille Ball Desi Arnaz Museum, National Comedy Center, and Fenton Historical Museum, this two-bedroom vacation rental is quite the ideal abode for upto five guests. It has been spaciously laid out to be able to accommodate all occupants comfortably while providing all facilities and amenities. Not just inside the house, there’s also a fenced backyard, porch, and a driveway parking. And, to top it all, the house has been newly remodelled, so it is less likely you’ll find anything missing.

Jamestown, New York, United States
56 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE RENTAL UNIT 3 Beds 5 Guests 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 5

Top guest reviews
was very clean and well out together space
nice clean comfortable and lisa will be right there if you need anything
we had a great stay easy to get access to the house clean organized and great location
lisa's place is a great location for anyone who wants a very clean place with all the necessary amenities
awesome owner very helpful very clean and anything we needed we had it right away great stay
she is a great host and responds quickly
great place and nice host
lisa was a considerate host
Read more reviews

2. Spacious home with a view of the neighborhood (from USD 123)

Complete with two bedrooms, a spacious common area, and a full kitchen, this two-bedroom apartment is an awesome option for those of you travelling in groups of upto six. The most celebrated feature of this rental (according to previous guests) are the floor-to-ceiling windows in the common room, allowing brilliant views of the neighbourhood as well as livening up the area with ample of light. Moreover, the apartment’s location is another huge plus point – it is located in the heart of the city’s downtown, so commute to several attractions, such as Lucille Ball Desi Arnaz Museum, National Comedy Center, etc is easy.

Jamestown, New York, United States
135 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE RENTAL UNIT 2 Beds 6 Guests 2 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 6

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
great space awesome views very spacious apartment
be sure to bring your netflix and amazon passwords as you’ll need them to use the internet tv
big apartment with beautiful windows overlooking jamestown
fantastic location huge space with abundant natural light amazing water pressure in the shower comfortable bed
loft area kitchen / living space was comfortable and quiet
the place was beautiful clean and super spacious
everything was clean and with 2 beds and 2 baths a great value
beautiful stylish spacious and clean
the very spacious apartment was fresh bright clean and stylish
the apartment was spacious bright quiet and clean
kristin is a gracious host
kristin has an amazing apartment and she was a wonderful host
unexpectedly spacious beautifully appointed and a wonderful host that was extremely accommodating
kristin was super friendly and helpful
space and location is fantastic
excellent location - easy walk to the main attractions
very convenient location cannot stress that enough
location is great too
amazing space for a downtown location
Read more reviews

3. Pet-friendly cosy home (from USD 81)

Spread out on the first floor of its bungalow, this rental is a great option worth considering for family travellers. It is equipped with all standard amenities and gives off an entirely humble, home-away-from-home vibe. This rental also welcomes pets, so if you’re a pet parent, go through some detailed instructions (on the listing’s Airbnb page) on how to go about making your pet’s bookings and also some rules that will need to be kept in mind. Reservation aside, do remember to inform the host that you’re bringing along a pet, so necessary arrangements can be made prior to your arrival. Plus, apart from the facilities inside the house, you’re also welcome to make use of the bungalow’s front yard and porch on the ground floor – a huge bonus for pet parents. As for the location, the downtown is walking distance away.

Jamestown, New York, United States
217 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE RENTAL UNIT 2 Beds 4 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 4

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
it is nicely heated has a claw foot tub and a fully equipped kitchen
he also provided "extras" like an iron umbrella etc
super comfy bed and quiet neighborhood for easy sleeping
not a fancy place but comfortable
ryan's place is as describedvery comfortable and convenienti will stay again if needed
clean & quiet
apartment was clean and comfortable
this place was very clean and comfortable
very clean comfortable and cozy
everything was clean and well-maintained
just a good host and nice dude
host is very responsive and helpful
ryan was a gracious host
i recommend this host highly
awesome host highly recommended
great location to easily get around jamestown
nice place good location everything you need
location is perfect for my needs
perfect location and what an amazing little apartment that’s a 15min walk to town
nice part of town within walking distance of downtown
Read more reviews

4. Plush home in a great location (from USD 138)

An Airbnb Plus property, this two-bedroom historic home is nestled right above one of Jamestown’s famous craft beer and wine lounges. The house has been done up in a thoroughly posh fashion, complete with eclectic furnishings and modern essentials to ensure guests spend an amazing time while checked in. Upto six guests can be easily accommodated here and there are plenty of amenities for you to kick back and enjoy indoors. Else, step out and explore the city’s many restaurants, bars, shops, Lucille Ball Desi Arnaz Museum, and Chautauqua Lake, all an easy distance away.

Jamestown, New York, United States
379 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE RENTAL UNIT 3 Beds 6 Guests 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 6

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
jonathan’s place was comfortable and spacious with lots of natural light
plenty of room to chill at the space beds are very comfortable
the bedding and sheets were unbelievably comfortable
breakfast and great coffee at the lab below before hitting the road the next day too
i could chill and read while the others played games in the dining room
bathrooms were both nice and clean
the apartment was very clean and well organized
i especially appreciated the clean crisp white bedding
it was clean tastefully decorated and comfortable
the apartment is huge clean and well decorated
jonathan was very helpful
very accommodating and friendly host
jon is a remarkably gracious accommodating & available host
the host provided lots of helpful info about the space and the town
we felt right at home and the hosts were kind and thoughtful
a great centrally located space in jamestown- close to everything
the location was great within walking distance to the comedy center
walking distance to some attractions
location is ideal - steps away from many of the local attractions
amazing location we could walk just about everywhere
Read more reviews

5. Homely cottage for three (from USD 85)

Newly remodelled, sparking clean, cosy space, and all amenities – these are some of the many features of this brilliant apartment that can easily sleep upto three guests across two bedrooms. It is housed on the first floor, wherein the ground floor is a separate rental, but complete privacy is guaranteed to occupants of both units. As for the space itself, it has been done up in a wholly homely manner to ensure you don’t find anything missing while vacationing. Plus, there’s an outdoor deck for you to soak in some of that amazing sunshine. Curt, the rental’s host, has been touted to be extremely reliable and responsive, so do get in touch with him if there’s anything you need.

Jamestown, New York, United States
59 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
Entire cottage 2 Beds 3 Guests 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 3

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
comfortable beds sofa and temperature controls
) very short ceiling fan and light pulls
plenty of space and so comfortable
the bed was very comfortable as well as the couch and living area
tv is nice size but be prepared to download an app to control the volume
the whole place was very clean and the bed was very comfortable
cozy clean stay we will be back
the place was so fresh clean and inviting
the decor is fun and it was clean and well maintained
the place was clean and easy to find and access
curt was a great host and kindly communicative
host was great with resolving issues and communication
curt is a great host and his place is great the beds are comfortable and everything was as described
curt was an amazing host and this place is perfect check in and out was extremely easy
it is located in a good area close to town
super cute place two seconds from downtown
curt's place is cute and inviting
firstly the location is definitely on the seedy side of town
great trip the place was cozy
Read more reviews

6. Complete house with all amenities

Remodelled as recently as May 2019, this Airbnb vacation rental is an awesome choice if you’re a party of six guests. The house is located in a quiet neighbourhood and offers three bedrooms, a formal dining room, two common areas, full kitchen, and a spacious open porch for guests to have themselves a gala time. Plus, you can also make use of the laundry facilities housed in the basement. Several attractions of the downtown are an easy walk away. Else, the neighbourhood itself is an awesome area to head out for casual strolls.

Jamestown, New York, United States
70 reviews   Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 3 Beds 6 Guests 3 Bedrooms 1 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 6

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
it was so much better than staying in a hotel with all of the room and amenities
great tv and living space
beds were comfortable
clean and stylish
very clean and well appointed
it was clean and well-appointed
it was clean and comfortable for our stay
inside was beautifully decorated and very clean
curt is a great host and is always a phone call away
host communicated often to be sure everything was satisfactory
curt is a wonderful host
host was friendly and available before and during the stay
neighbors are friendly and town is adorable
great place in a great location
gorgeous home location was great for walking into town each morning
cleanliness style value quality and location is exceptional
Read more reviews

7. Historic mansion for large groups (from USD 599)

Planning to travel as a large group? Fret not, this five-bedroom mansion for upto ten guests is a fabulous option worth considering. The mansion is listed in the National Register of Historic Places and is an absolutely stunning space to live in. Aside from the usual bedrooms, common areas, kitchen, and laundry, you’ll also have access to the on-site solarium, front yard, large verandah, backyard, and even parking spots for two vehicles. Indoors, it is every bit the regal, historic mansion you’d expect it to be and has even been done up to retain this sort of a charm. While it’ll be pretty easy not wanting to get out, if you so wish, the Lucille Ball Desi Arnaz Museum, National Comedy Center, and other attractions are within easy reach.

Jamestown, New York, United States
32 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 9 Beds 12 Guests 5 Bedrooms 4 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 12

Top guest reviews
eddy takes great pride in his house and was a gracious interactive host
ed’s place the sheldon house is an amazing historical mansion
Read more reviews

8. Comfortable home for eight

Done up a humble manner, complete with high ceilings, wooden flooring, and standard amenities, this four-bedroom house is a nice option if you’re upto eight guests. It is split across two floors wherein the common area, dining area, and kitchen are on the ground floor, while the bedrooms and bathrooms are on the first floor. However, do note that the neighbourhood can get a tad noisy and the house’s furnishings are not entirely new. Rest assured, do get in touch with the host if you find something lacking and she’ll be more than happy to accommodate your requests. Location wise, it is an easy distance away from Chautauqua Lake, so will be a hit with those of you planning water activities.

Jamestown, New York, United States
34 reviews   Wifi Available
Entire residential home 5 Beds 9 Guests 4 Bedrooms 1 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 9

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
very comfortable beds with more sleeping space than we anticipated from the posting
the beds are comfortable and the back deck was nice place to rest after a long day
all of the beds were super comfortable
clean everything functioned highly recommend it
the house is updated where it counts with lovely clean bathrooms and new kitchen appliances
chandra’s home was very clean and spacious
older home but clean and nicely cared for
it's an older house not really updated but it's clean
host is extremely responsive to any requests
chandra is a great host we loved the little decorative touches throughout the home
the host was very responsive professional and pleasant
chandra is an excellent host
chandra was extremely accommodating and kind
great location for visiting the comedy center and festival
nice location comfortable spot well equipped
this place was amazing great location and very easy check in
chandra's place is nice fully equipped near mall restaurants and lake
the location was convenient and the neighbors were very friendly
Read more reviews

9. Modern home in the heart of the town

This upscale, modern home is located near the downtown, so is quite the top choice for those looking to explore large parts of the town, while looking for a bit of a luxurious accommodation. It is spread across three bedrooms, full kitchen, spacious common area, and fenced backyard, allowing upto nine guests to spend a great time here. The backyard is also equipped with an open-air barbecue for you to enjoy fun cook-outs with your loved ones. Else, step out and tour through downtown Jamestown’s many interesting haunts. Do note that the rental’s attic and basement are not accessible to Airbnb guests.

Jamestown, New York, United States
27 reviews  
Entire house 4 Beds 3 Bedrooms 1 Bathrooms
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the extra amenities in the kitchen and the bathroom were especially appreciated
note: open bathroom window and put box fan in front
the interior is well-appointed and comfortable
modern fixtures quality linens outstanding hvac system service-oriented and comfortable/cozy
super clean and cozy with lots of nice amenities any questions or concerns were quickly answered and remedied
very nice and clean house
the house is super clean and comfortable with thoughtful touches everywhere
super clean and the two bathrooms really helped out with the four people we had
the place was super cleaned and smelled refreshing when we walked in
the home is sparkling clean with great amenities
adrienne was a wonderful host
this host and house could not have been any better
adrienne is a great host and goes above and beyond to make your stay as comfortable as possible
the hosts service was good too would choose a different neighborhood tho
the location was super quiet and easy to get to
will be definitely be using this place in the future
would definitely use barbeau’s place again if work happens to bring me into the area
Read more reviews

10. Well-appointed home for business travellers

Great option for two travellers, this two-bedroom apartment is fully stocked, thoroughly well-appointed, and the perfect place to explore Jamestown. It has been newly remodelled and boasts latest amenities as well as appliances, along with aesthetically done up furnishings. While this rental is a great choice for all travellers alike, it is especially popular among business travellers due to its convenient location and top-notch facilities. The National Comedy Center is about five minutes’ drive away, and several other attractions of Jamestown’s downtown are also an easy distance away.

Jamestown, New York, United States
68 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE RENTAL UNIT 1 Bed 2 Guests 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 2

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
good space for eating and relaxing with wifi
really nice amentities like tvs and abundant stations
6/5 stars on the bed it was amazing we had everything we needed and more
we had a great stay at this apartment
new appliances but we didn't find the bed comfortable
great place and very clean
pictures do it justice it is clean
clean large ideally located
great place to stay everything was super clean and well kept up
clean stylishly furnished and still cozy and comfortable the place is fantastic
host was also great
even the neighbor humberto was friendly and pleasant
eric and ashley are amazing hosts this rental is beautiful spacious and exactly what i needed
good location and good price
spacious place nice location right in town
great location to go around the allegheny national forest
great space and quiet location
eric’s place is comfortable and in a great location
Read more reviews

Visit Pearl City

Visit Jamestown - Pearl City - New York and enjoy great attractions, parks with fresh air and hiking spots, and comfortable accommodations. Start planning your trip and book any of the above-listed Airbnb vacation rentals in Jamestown, New York.

Disclosure: Trip101 selects the listings in our articles independently. Some of the listings in this article contain affiliate links.

Get Trip101 in your inbox

Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data

A self-proclaimed aesthete striving for a fulfilling personal and professional life. Transforming intangible thoughts/wishes into words for a tangible living. Endeavouring to transport you into...Read more

 Want to contribute as a Local Expert?
Explore Jamestown
Good things are meant to be shared!