Long Island, New York, is a must-visit destination for those seeking a mix of natural beauty, rich history, and exciting urban life. You can stroll along the boardwalk in Long Beach and Jones Beach State Park, explore the stunning mansions on the Gold Coast, or indulge in some retail therapy at the mall at Roosevelt Field, the largest one on Long Island. History buffs will enjoy touring Sag Harbor and learning about its whaling past. If you’re seeking outdoor adventures, head to Fire Island for miles of untouched beaches and beautiful hiking trails. Of course, no visit to Long Island would be complete without experiencing the award-winning wineries of the North Fork. What better way to experience Long Island than staying in a mansion with top-notch amenities? For a one-of-a-kind vacation, read on to find the best Airbnb mansions in Long Island, New York.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on April 14, 2024.
1. Newly built mansion surrounded by green foliage; Wainscott (from USD 2500)
This 7,000-square foot (650.32-square meters) mansion, located minutes away from East Hampton, Bridgehampton, and Sag Harbor, offers luxury and exclusivity in a quiet cul-de-sac. It has lavish bedrooms that can sleep up to 14 guests. Moreover, it features a spacious recreational room with indoor games, amenities for the family to watch movies, and a professional popcorn machine.
Outside, the property is adorned by a well-maintained lawn. You can plunge into the heated pool while your kids play in the wooden swingset with a rock climbing wall, a tree house, a slide, swings, and hanging bars. At mealtime, your family can comfortably enjoy alfresco dining on the deck as it is furnished with two outdoor heaters.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the house and amenities were fantastic: the pool the deck the lower level playroom the well equipped kitchenthe house was beautiful with 3 great living rooms and open spacebackyard is great and well kept with a nice size poolHost:
the property manager is very responsivelaura is the best hostboth the owner and property manager had good communication leading up to and throughout the weekendlaura & lloyd are super responsive and there is a house manager to help with any questionsthank you to laura and lloyd for being amazing responsive hostsRead more reviewsLocation:
great house in a great locationclose to great cafes and restaurants plus a short distance to the beachwithin walking distance to deli liquor store bakery good restaurants and levain bakery quiet on beautiful street
2. Modern mansion with private pool; Eastport (from USD 1450)
If you’re planning a vacation with a group of 16 people or more, this mansion in Eastport, just across the marina, will be perfect for your getaway. The mansion’s interior is predominantly decorated in shades of gray and white. Glass doors and windows also allow ample natural light to fill the space. Additionally, it has a gym, 10 full bathrooms, and a parking space that can fit 8 cars. Pets are allowed on the premises for 75 USD per night.
You can grill and savor your meals on the patio or spend intimate quality time with your loved ones around the cozy outdoor firepit. Guests can dip in the seasonal pool from mid-April through October. Sports equipment is also complimentary.
Top guest reviews
Cleanliness:
super clean accommodating and thoughtful there was nothing more we could have asked forHost:
perfect for hosting a large groupRead more reviewsLocation:
absolutely loved this home and the location
Superhost
3. Jericho Mansion; Jericho (from USD 3500)
Whether on a retreat or looking for a place to host an event, Jericho Mansion is an ideal haven for its secluded location and over 1.6 acres (0.65 hectares) of landscaped yard. As soon as you step into the mansion, you will be charmed by a sophisticated foyer that features sleek black and white marble flooring and an Art Deco chandelier.
Every bedroom has its own bathroom, while the main suite boasts a huge walk-in closet, a balcony overlooking the surrounding park, and a spacious bathroom with a tub and heated floor. The all-marble kitchen extends to a family room with a fireplace and TV.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
so cool sonos music throughout the entire house in every single room (optional)the size of the master bedroom closet alone is about the size many people's entire nyc apartment loleach bed room has its own bathroom and they are nicely appointedCleanliness:
it’s clean spacious and has a very convenient locationHost:
eddie is a wonderful hostthe place was amazing & and the host was perfectbeautiful home wonderful host 100 % great all aroundRead more reviewsLocation:
in addition it is close to major highways and you can find it easy through basic directionsthe house is huge but also extremely classy and just a great place to be
4. Villa East; Old Brookville (from USD 3000)
Villa East is located in a village on the North Shore of Long Island, commonly called the Gold Coast. Guests at this mansion will feel like they’ve booked an entire 5-star luxury hotel! It is nestled on 3 acres (1.21 hectares) of park-like grounds, 30 minutes away from New York City.
The entire property is elegantly decorated, especially the grand foyer with marble floors and a high ceiling accented with a crystal chandelier. It features a parlor room with a grand piano, a sunken lounge area, a theater room, and spacious suites with balconies. The full outdoor kitchen on the expansive patio is perfect for cooking delicious meals for parties. Down the patio is the seasonal pool with a spa surrounded by a gorgeous lawn.
Top guest reviews
Host:
host was accommodating and very helpful and responsive upon moving inamazing house and they were great hosts that responded quickly and helped with anything we neededthe owner was so responsive and helpful when we navigated the amenitieson top of the gorgeous house you get a fantastic hosteddie was super responsive so any questions or concerns are addressed quicklyRead more reviewsLocation:
the neighborhood is also quiet and beautifulsuper quiet block and near a ton of great restaurants supermarket cvs etc
5. Villa Osprey; Port Jefferson
This beachfront villa has a minimalist approach but does not compromise on comfort and luxury. It is a 20,000-square-foot (1,858.06-square-meter) home sitting on 8 acres (3.24 hectares) of land. Aside from one indoor and one outdoor infinity pool, you can swim or hop on a boat from the private beach.
A tennis and basketball court is nestled away on the other side of the property in a wooded setting. Other recreational amenities you can enjoy are the gym, two dry saunas, and one wet sauna.
Port Jefferson, New York, United States
3.06 km (1.9 mi) from Cedar Beach Town Nature PreserveAccommodates: 16
6. Unique luxury compound with Buddha gardens; Sag Harbor (from USD 1671)
A group of 26 people can reserve this 9-bedroom property at Sag Harbor. You won’t need to go out for a fun night since you can let your hair loose at the home’s private nightclub featuring a wet bar. In addition, you can also take advantage of the massage room.
For outdoor activities, a tennis, volleyball, and basketball court is at your disposal, or you can borrow the bikes the host provides if you want to go around the town. You may also relax in the large outdoor swimming pool or the hot tub.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
great space for a large group lots of amenities and room for everyonelovely en suite bedrooms the heated pool outdoor grilling area tennis courts etctennis basketball a great warm pool and a large hot tubCleanliness:
the house was very clean and is exactly as advertisedHost:
great host and awsome houselawrence was a very gracious hosti highly recommend lawrence as a host and his gorgeous homegreat place amazing owner a one of a kind propertythe host lawrence was responsive and texted me back in instantlyRead more reviewsLocation:
i loved the location close to sag harbor and bridgehamptonthe place was perfect for a large family get together
Indulge in an unparalleled luxurious retreat on Long Island
Whether looking for a relaxing getaway or an adventurous vacation, Long Island will surely exceed your expectations. Its unique blend of natural beauty and vibrant culture makes it a gem worth visiting. Top it up with fantastic accommodation for the most unforgettable experience! Book one of the best Airbnb mansions listed above for a unique experience that is sure to be remembered for a lifetime.
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data
Create an account to