Top 6 Airbnb Vacation Rentals In Palmyra, New York - Updated 2021

airbnb palmyra ny

If you’re a history buff, you’d think we’re mixing up the ancient city of Palmyra in Syria and USA, but we’re not. Palmyra is located in New York’s Wayne County, but very much owes its name to its historical Syrian counterpart. While this American town is humble in most aspects, a namesake village within the town is its biggest highlight. The Palmyra village was once the centre of religious revivalism. Today, it is among the most visited spots in the area. So, if you’re planning to visit this historic town, check out our list of the top Airbnb vacation rentals in Palmyra, New York.

1. Well-equipped spacious home (from USD 349)

Complete with an on-site outdoor swimming pool, open-air poolside seating area, fully fenced yard with a play-gym, an outdoor barbecue grill, and spacious interiors is this thoroughly well-equipped 7-bedroom house that can easily accommodate up to 16 guests. It has been recently remodelled to incorporate latest furnishings and amenities to ensure you don’t have to worry about a thing while checked in. It is split across two floors, wherein the common areas and two bedrooms are on the ground floor, while the rest of the bedrooms including two loft spaces and one bedroom are on the first floor. Aside from the ground and first floors, guests can also access the gaming room in the basement. It has Wii gaming system, air hockey table, foosball table, darts board, etc. The rental is about 5-6 minutes’ drive from Interstate-90, downtown Palmyra, and Erie Canal.

Cumorah Carriage House-6/7 bdrms-3 full baths
Palmyra, New York, United States
70 reviews
Entire house 10 Beds 7 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the game room and all the amenities were a huge hit for us
the pool and deck were lovely and luckily we had perfect weather for it
great space plenty of beds and lots of amenities in a surprising & quaint little town
but our favorite room was the kitchen we all congregated in there
and a huge family room for gathering movies
very clean and safe
christine's communication was faultless and the house was very clean
the house is clean and the large eat-in kithen is great for a group
beautiful clean home with lots of space for everyone
everything was clean and well stocked with enough bedding for our big group
wonderful host and wonderful home
the hosts are kind and flexible
the hosts were wonderful and very quick to reply
host is generous and helpful
host was very responsive and helpful
great location - quiet but close to town
great central location for a visit to palmyra
the location was safe and quiet
kids had a great time in the pool and it's walking distance to downtown
the house's close proximity of all the sites and destinations made it a fantastic location for our trip
Read more reviews

2. Family apartment on sprawling farmland (from USD 78)

This Airbnb vacation rental is an ideal abode for family travellers. Upto four guests can be accommodated in its two bedrooms, on a double-occupancy basis. Hosts have provisioned all amenities to ensure you don’t find a thing missing. Additionally, the apartment also has laundry facilities. You can also make use of the private patio deck for some al-fresco chilling. Do note that this rental is located on the host’s farm estate, where they raise some farm animals (chickens and geese), so be mindful of that. Rest assured, you are welcome to make use of the sprawling farmland to spend time outdoors, enjoy at the swing set (for kids), or explore the nature trail through the wooded section of the property.

Twelve Baskets Farm
Palmyra, New York, United States
215 reviews
Entire apartment 4 Beds 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
we enjoyed playing some cards at night as there was no tv or internet
no wifi but with a place so nice why would you want to be on the grid?
the bonus middle room allowed me to read in the morning without bothering my roommates
the fireplace in the living room is a nice touch and provides a wonderful warmth and ambiance
no tv no wifi no bathtub but we felt comfortable and happy in their clean place
nice and clean place to stay
house is exceptionally clean and well furnished
the kitchen is very clean and charming
overall it was very clean quiet and spacious
the apartment was clean and had a great kitchen
they were wonderful hosts and were very responsive to our questions and concerns
lovely hosts and lovely countryside
the hosts were so helpful and friendly
host are super great
very friendly hosts and family
good location for seeing the palmyra sites
it is in a lovely rural location in palmyra
loved the history and settings beautiful place
visiting historical church sites nearby was close and easy from this location
wow what an amazing place to get away and relax
Read more reviews

3. Historic home at a sheep farm (from USD 75)

This spacious 6-bedroom bed-and-breakfast rental is another fabulous option for those of you travelling in groups of 10 people. It is an easy distance away from Hill Cumorah, Erie Canal, Lake Ontario, and several wine trails, thus making it a good option for those of you looking to explore around the town. The rental sits at a sheep farm, so aside from excellent amenities, brilliant views outdoors are also guaranteed. While this historic house retains its quaint charm, it has been done up with all modern amenities.

Thomas Galloway House Bed and Breakfast
Palmyra, New York, United States
91 reviews
Private room in bed and breakfast 8 Beds 6 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
for breakfast she prepared us some delicious french toasts with coffee
all of the rooms are decorated with great antique furniture
margaret made delicious omelets for breakfast and has a beautiful yard and garden
the breakfasts were delicious and the coffee plentiful the house is gorgeous and full of antiques
but the bathroom has a heater and the downstairs sitting area and dining room were nice and toasty
well kept and very clean
the house was very clean and well put together
clean and ready for a family
the tub was new and clean although quite small
historic cozy beautiful clean home and grounds
margaret was an amazing host
the owner is great
rustic country farmhouse with a gracious host
margaret was an outstanding host
she was kind and respectable
we loved the location as well
many room options and good location
margaret's place was in a great location to visit palmyra
great location tucked up against a forest on a quiet road
the house is beautiful with a great location
Read more reviews

4. Cute barn home for twos (from USD 62)

Ideal for those travelling in twos, this lovely one-bedroom barn home oozes a rustic yet comfortable vibe. It sits in the middle of a working sheep farm, with the host’s own residence on site. However, don’t worry, complete privacy is guaranteed to guests occupying this barn. All daily facilities like linens, basic toiletries, etc. and kitchenette essentials such as water dispenser, microwave oven, mini refrigerator, etc. are available. There’s also a yard, equipped with outdoor seating and some space to park bicycles, as well. Sheep pasture surrounds this property and a few other farm animals may also be present on site, so be mindful of that, if you’re not comfortable around animals. Location-wise, the rental is close to several attractions including Erie Canal, Palymra’s historic sites, Hill Cumorah, Lake Ontario, and several wine trails.

The Milkhouse
Palmyra, New York, United States
112 reviews
Barn 2 Beds 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
wifi works perfect as same as netflix
the futon is a nice bed with an air mattress on top
the milk house was turned into a little sleeping room with some cute details
the modern outhouse (real plumbing fully finished) and outdoor shower were awesome
place is clean and cozy
rustic clean and comfortable
margaret’s place was very comfortable and clean
;) the outhouse was also exceptionally clean and private; plenty of clean linens were provided
it was very well decorated and it was clean
margaret was a nice host
she was a great host
she was a great host
the host is kind and accommodating
the host was wonderfully responsive and helpful
the location was perfect for us
this location was perfect for our needs
very cute small place we loved the location and everything about it
this is a very beautiful location
it was a cool location
Read more reviews

5. Comfortable apartment for couples

Another excellent accommodation for couples is this one-bedroom apartment that has dropped into the Airbnb vacation rental list as recently as 2018, hence boasts brand new furnishings, modern amenities, and complete comfort for those occupying the unit. The apartment also receives ample natural light and from the room, you can watch the birds and deer feeding outdoors. If you’d rather step out, the historic Erie Canal Trail, Finger Lakes, and several other sightseeing spots are an easy distance away from the property.

Charming One Bedroom Apartment in Palmyra NY
Palmyra, New York, United States
12 reviews
Entire apartment 1 Bed 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom
Top guest reviews
very clean space and thoughtful hosts
if you are looking for clean safe and quiet
the apartment is very private and clean and with its own entrance
they were prompt and helpful with responses
the hosts are truly great people and the space is exactly what i hoped it would be
pat was responsive and always pleasant
Read more reviews

6. Great home with spacious backyard

Spread across four bedrooms and spacious common areas, this Airbnb vacation rental is another fabulous option worth considering for those of you travelling as a group of nine. Aside from the well thought-out interiors and a spacious yard, two garage parking spots have also been made available for guests checking in with private vehicles. The backyard is a real highlight with groups travelling with children or for those of you who enjoy picnics. However, aside from reservation tariffs, a refundable deposit of 100 USD and cleaning fee of 60 USD will have to be paid to confirm the reservation here. The Palmyra Temple, Sacred Grove, Joseph Smith Home, and Hill Cumorah can all be easily accessed from this rental.

Temple Ridge- Quiet, Family Friendly
Palmyra, New York, United States
56 reviews
Entire house 5 Beds 4 Bedrooms 1 Bathrooms
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
beds were great
spacious bedrooms easy checkin very comfortable
very clean and beautiful home
this was a clean place
this house was clean and quiet
spacious and clean
clean and uncluttered a great place to rest
amazing place really nice host
very responsive host thank you nichelle
had a minor issue with the home and the owner was responsive to the issue
best house and host in the area
oh how gratefully glad we were that our thoughtful hosts provided the items for us
the location is ideal
this was the perfect location for our family
very close to city center and easily accessible
best part about the house is the location
great location near the sacred grove
Read more reviews

Stay amidst nature in Palmyra

Aside from the Palmyra village, which is easily the town’s biggest highlight, the Erie Canal Heritage Trail is a brilliant spot for some hiking and biking. While you get down to your itinerary planning, don’t forget to narrow down on accommodations. Check out these top Airbnb vacation rentals in Palmyra, New York.

Disclosure: Trip101 selects the listings in our articles independently. Some of the listings in this article contain affiliate links.

Get Trip101 in your inbox

Unsubscribe in one click. See our privacy policy for more information on how we use your data

A self-proclaimed aesthete striving for a fulfilling personal and professional life. Transforming intangible thoughts/wishes into words for a tangible living. Endeavouring to transport you into...Read more

 Want to contribute as a Local Expert?
Explore Palmyra
Good things are meant to be shared!