Sag Harbor is a village in Suffolk County, New York, and nestles on Gardiner’s Bay with a working port. The village features various places to visit and things to do. Among the historic visits, Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum is an interesting visit, along with the Old Whalers Church in the town. Fresh air fun can be had at the public Havens Beach with its playground or the lovely Foster Memorial Beach with its pretty park and gardens. The village also features many restaurants and shops. Enjoy your vacation here by staying in one of the best Airbnb vacation rentals in Sag Harbor, New York, listed below.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on April 09, 2024.
1. Beach Tree Cottage (from USD 400)
With modern comforts and a great location, Beach Tree Cottage provides an ideal home base for your getaway in Sag Harbor. Main Street’s Waterfront is only a five-minute walk away from the property. You can also reach the beach with a short stroll or drive.
The rental is available for short stays, except between Memorial Day and Labor Day when the host requires a minimum booking period of one week. Amenities include Wi-Fi, a high-definition TV, and free parking. In addition to air-conditioning, there is also a fireplace installed in the cottage for comfort.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
there is a nice backyard area with a hammock and poolCleanliness:
very clean and cozyvery clean and an amazing backyard and porchrooms were clean and house was cozyeverything was very clean and the apartment was very charming cozy and welcomingthe cottage itself was very clean spacious and comfortableHost:
the hosts are helpful whenthe hosts are very nice toothe hosts were quick to respond and helpfulthe hosts were so nice and welcoming and we really enjoyed our stayemma and stephen were wonderful hostsRead more reviewsLocation:
location / proximity to downtown was excellent - very convenient locationgreat location close to townthe location was greatwalking distance to town yet far enough to enjoy a quiet weekendit’s literally a 5-10 minute walk to the town center - with amazing restaurants and shopping
2. Pet-friendly retreat for families (from USD 1200)
Bright and thoughtfully renovated, this rental is one of the best places to stay for groups or families on a getaway in Sag Harbor. They can also bring their pets along as this is a pet-friendly property with a secure backyard. Kid-friendly features, including a baby bath, crib, and high chair, are available in the rental. Other modern conveniences, such as air-conditioning, Wi-Fi, and TVs, are provided as well. For quality bonding moments with the group, there is a drop-down movie screen available in the living room.
The rental’s location provides guests with easy access to various restaurants, boutique shops, and galleries.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the beds were very comfy nice bathroomsour kids loved the bunk bed and all the games and toysCleanliness:
it was very clean toovery clean and organized for our tripthe house is incredibly beautiful clean and well maintainedvery clean and stylish incredibly thoughtful presentation and detailthis house is everything it promises to be it’s super clean completely updated and grainne is extremely responsiveHost:
grainne and rory were excellent hostsrecommend this house and hosts to all airbnbersgrainne and rory were were terrific hosts — friendly thoughtful and wonderfully communicativegrainne and her husband were very responsive with any concern and were able to give great local suggestionsgreat home location and hostRead more reviewsLocation:
central amazing walkable locationbeautiful house and great locationgreat location and a great place to stay with childrenbeautiful house great location close to downtown sag harborgreat location short walk into town and to local bay beach
3. Quaint cottage in a historic district (from USD 181)
This cute studio cottage is located on the grounds of a private home in the historic district of Sag Harbor. The cottage is close to the beaches, ideal for swimming, sailing, and kayaking, and within easy walking distance of the restaurants and shops downtown. The space is ideal for a couple or single person and features a small fridge, coffee maker, and microwave. Guests can relax in the garden, watch TV, or make use of free Wi-Fi.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the small refrigerator and window air conditioner were much appreciatedvery comfortable room and joan was very kind to provide some late night advila comfortable space for yourself or for a couple that’s out to escapejoan provided the most charming and comfortable airbnbfull sized bed so best for 1 or 2 smaller peopleCleanliness:
very nice clean cottagethe room was cozy and cleanvery clean and cozy little room it honestly seemed a lot roomier than i was initially expectingit is a cute space very clean and very comfortablejoan is extremely responsive and helpful and the apartment is very well-located and cleanHost:
lovely place very cozy and joan the host is wonderfuljoan was super responsive to questions about the area a lovely hostjoan was super helpful and all around great hostjoan is sweet and a great hostjoan was also great to communicate with and very responsiveRead more reviewsLocation:
amazing location about 20 min walk to downtowncute spot in a great locationeasy walk to townamazing location and great spacesuper close to town and secluded
4. Artist's retreat in Sag Harbor village (from USD 186)
This light and beautiful village studio apartment is a ten-minute stroll from Sag Harbor’s historic Main Street and a five-minute walk from the beach. Ideal for all seasons, the studio offers heat from the working fireplace and air conditioning. French doors lead to an outdoor furnished seating area. High-speed Wi-Fi is available throughout and there is a flat-screen TV with cable channels, Netflix and YouTube for entertainment. A basic kitchenette features a fridge, coffee- and tea-making facility, and a microwave. The bedroom has a king-sized bed, while the bathroom has a large jetted tub.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
all of the thoughtful amenities and touches made everything very comfortable and enjoyablethe bed is super comfortable and there is a nice small kitchenette like in a hotelbedding is very comfortablethe king bed is very comfortable and the jet tub was so relaxingthe space is enjoyable and comfortable even with it's own thermostat and fireplace we enjoyed our time thereCleanliness:
absolutely beautiful room very clean and cozyvery clean and bathroom was hugeit was superbly clean and extremely cozylovely clean quiet and secluded retreatfantastic tub and very cleanHost:
roisin was a wonderful hostroisin was a great hostroisin is an amazing hostfantastic host and wonderful spaceyou can expect a very nice hostRead more reviewsLocation:
the location is wonderfulamazing location - easy walk to town and the beachwe loved our stay such a cute space and very close to townclose to town easy walking and in & out for bikes / cargreat location walking distance to main st sag harbor
5. Spacious apartment with a minimalist design (from USD 185)
This light and spacious second-floor apartment is located in historic Sag Harbor, a ten-minute walk from Main Street and a five-minute stroll from Bay Beach. Located in a private home, the apartment is self-contained with a private entrance and parking. The apartment features air conditioning and high-capacity Wi-Fi. The living area offers a TV and the kitchen has all the necessary appliances. Sleeping arrangements include a comfortable king-sized bed in the bedroom and there is one bathroom.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the bed was fantastic wifi was fastbed is very comfortable and internet is fastwhat a sweet place the apartment was very cool- modern cozy and light-filledthe bathroom with gorgeous green glass sink - and gleaming wood floors is lovely as wellvery comfortable bed loved the additional small touches like additional washcloths beach chairs and umbrellas for guestsCleanliness:
extremely clean and tidyquiet and clean with comfy touchesthe unit was very clean and quietclean comfortable - would stay there againthe entire home was spotless incredibly clean with fresh airHost:
roisin was a fantastic hostroisin is a great host and went above and beyond with her hospitalityroisin is a wonderful host considerate accommodating and privateroisin was a very gracious host - clear and communicativeroisin was very helpful and responsiveRead more reviewsLocation:
wonderful apartment walking distance to towngreat location easy check in and very close to towngreat location centrally located in sag harbora short walk from the center of sag harbor the location was idealit's an excellent location and a short walk to town and the beach
6. Fascinating studio close to Havens Beach (from USD 290)
This cute and cozy studio is located in Sag Harbor village, close to the shops and a five-minute walk to Havens Beach. A bicycle and beach chairs are available to guests. The studio has central air conditioning, a flat-screen TV with cable channels, and free Wi-Fi. A kitchen is available for daily cooking and a queen-sized bed is located in the living area. Free parking is available on the property.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
it has a fully functional kitchen with a comfy bed premium tv thoughtful amenities and appealing design accentsthe bed was super comfortable and i enjoyed sleeping on it thoughall as described nice comfortable studioCleanliness:
it was sparkling clean and communication was extremely easya lovely little (website hidden by airbnb) was very clean and quietit is well localed clean and with comfort itensjohn’s place was very clean comfortable and in a great locationclose to the beach very clean and great hostsHost:
john was a great host toojohn is a wonderful hostjohn is an excellent hostthe owner was easy to comunicate with and flexibleoverall a great place and good hostRead more reviewsLocation:
great location - comfortable studiothis cute place is everything it claimsthe location was perfect for usperfect little spot and fantastic locationgreat space and close to town and beaches
7. Beach retreat at Eden Cottage (from USD 554)
Eden is a beautiful rental house in the historic village of Sag Harbor, within walking distance from the shops, restaurants, museums, theaters, marinas, and galleries of the village. The cottage is also steps from Sag Harbor Bay and the beach.
The cottage offers beautiful views and accommodates up to six adults and two children. The living area features a smart TV with cable channels and air-conditioning and Wi-Fi are available throughout. The kitchen comes equipped for daily cooking while an outdoor grill is available for al fresco dining. Two of the bedrooms have double beds, while the other two have two single beds. The home has one family bathroom.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
what a wonderful stay the house is spacious comfortable and well-appointed with lovely views and great outdoor spacethis place was so comfortable for the five of us with plenty of space and every comfortwe enjoyed the beach and the comfortable beach chairswe each had our own room but could have comfortably fit more guests if we had neededthe space was well set up with everything provided which made for a very comfortable and relaxing experienceCleanliness:
it was very very cleaneverything was immaculately clean and perfect for a long weekendbig clean and well equipped housethe house is clean and practical for a familyit was well decorated and very cleanHost:
valerie is a fantastic hostvalerie was a wonderful hostshe was a great hostvalerie is a wonderful host she was very responsive to my messages/questionsvalerie was a great host and her house was amazingRead more reviewsLocation:
i would recommend this location to anyonegreat location minutes from beachjust a quick walk to a private beach and very close to a charming downtown areathe house is in a beautiful location near its own private beachit was the perfect location for a weekend getaway with five friends
8. Exclusive private compound in Sag Harbor (from USD 380)
This beautiful compound sleeps eight guests and is located a short walk from the center of historic Sag Habor. The property has a Gunite pool, in-ground trampoline, outdoor ping-pong table, two outdoor showers, a big fire pit, and a large treehouse for the kids. Enjoy beautiful sunsets by the pool while cooking on the fire pit or cook up a meal in the fully equipped kitchen.
The living area features a flat-screen TV with cable channels. When it’s time for bed, the master bedroom and second bedroom have king-sized beds, while the third has a queen-sized bed and the fourth has two single beds. Air-conditioning and Wi-Fi are available throughout this vacation rental in Sag Harbor.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
a large garden and great deck outside the kitchenthe deck pool big yard and fire pit made for great family timethe pool was delicious and the grounds were expansive and stunningit was clean comfortable and had all the amenities we wantedwe especially enjoyed the modern well-equipped kitchen which was a lot of fun to cook inCleanliness:
the house was exceptionally clean and beautifully renovatedthe house was very clean and very comfortablehome was sparkling clean and very spaciousgreat place clean new nice kitchenvery clean and spacious and the kitchen is beautifulHost:
ben was an excellent hostthe host is very organized and responsiveben was a great host responsive informative and very professionalben is such an amazing host he is quick to reply and has such an amazing placethe host was immediately responsive to every questionRead more reviewsLocation:
the location is perfecteasy walk to downtownthe location is great as it is a short walk to towngreat location and love the privacyit was a perfect location for a restorative weekend away from the city
9. Luxury suite in a private Sag Harbor home (from USD 425)
This beautiful two-bedroom luxury suite is located in a historic village home. The suite has its own private entry and offers views of the artist owner’s sculpture garden. Cable TV and Wi-Fi are available in the suite as well as a small fridge and washer/dryer. The bathroom has a shower and a whirlpool bath. One bedroom has a queen-sized sleigh bed while the second has an antique double bed. Central air conditioning keeps the suite cool and a Smart, 36” HD TV offers Netflix.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
two sun-filled bedrooms and a great bathroom with a massive jacuzziyou have your own entrance a washer/dryer a mini-fridge and a beautiful bathroombathroom was luxurious bed (memory foam mattress) was divinebedding etc is very nicethat said if you're just looking to rent rooms it's a great optionCleanliness:
spotless clean cute and artistic interior designclean with lovely artlarge tub and clean and plenty spacethe rooms were ready for us and perfectly clean and stocked with ammentitiesthe house is charming and clean and in a great locationHost:
jonathan was a great hostjohn was a really great hosthost was very warm and friendlywonderful host a charming home and wonderful neighborhoodjonathan was such a thoughtful hostRead more reviewsLocation:
the location was perfecteasy walk to townquaint little place walking distance to delicious foodvery close walking distance to main street private cute and lovelysuper fantastic location and beautifully appointed place
10. Comfy East Hampton queen room
This lovely and comfortable room has access to the outdoors with spectacular views. It is nestled in a private house, located within walking distance from the village. The room is air-conditioned and features a queen-sized bed and a pullout bed, plus a private en suite bathroom. An organic continental breakfast is served each morning and guests are welcome to use the home’s kitchen for light cooking. Free bicycles and kayaks are available to guests and free wireless Internet is provided.
Sag Harbor, New York, United States
15.57 km (9.7 mi) from Orient Beach State ParkSuperhost
Accommodates: 2
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
air conditioner in window extra fan in closet if neededthey also have air conditioning and a fan if neededthe fan and refrigerator in our room were a plusbreakfast and coffee on site was a great added bonusbreakfast was delicious and the back porch was enchanting to sit and admire the viewCleanliness:
the beds were clean and comfortablespacious bedroom clean and comfortablethe bedroom w/bathroom was clean and comfortablehouse is very clean especially the bathroomthe room was very best and cleanHost:
our hosts were extremely helpful and attentivelovely hosts helpful with any questions easy conversationincredible hosts and made me feel like homethe hosts have great recommendations and are happy to help however they cananton is a wonderful host his home a beautiful havenRead more reviewsLocation:
easy walk or bike ride therebeautiful hosts location and energygreat location near the heart of sag harboranton’s home is ideally located close to town yet quiet and secludedoutstanding location and fantastic hosts
11. Private beach retreat in Sag Harbor
This laid-back Hamptons home is ideal for a beach getaway and is steps from the private neighborhood beach of Sag Harbor Bay. The second-floor room is perfect for lounging and watching cable TV or relaxing on the sun deck. Cook up a storm on the Weber grill with sea views, plus the kitchen has all new stainless steel appliances. The home has high-speed Wi-Fi throughout. All four bedrooms feature queen-sized beds and there are two bathrooms available to guests.
Sag Harbor, New York, United States
14.45 km (9.0 mi) from Orient Beach State ParkTop guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
but the living room and large deck were wonderfulpicture of dinning room windows states great viewswe had plenty of room for entertaining in the house with the wide open common areasCleanliness:
everything was super cleanher places was very clean and nicely organizedthe house was clean and comfortable with plenty of linensvery clean and well stocked with everything you'd needwhat a great place the home was clean and comfortableHost:
the hosts are solicitous and helpfulsydney was a great hostsydney was an amazing hostthe hosts and space were awesomegreat hosts and it was a wonderful experienceRead more reviewsLocation:
amazing house in an amazing locationlocation is superb with just a short walk to a quiet beachthe house was in a great location about 2 miles from the shops/restaurants in sag harborshort drive or a nice 30 minute walk along the beachcomfortable beach cottage walking distance to the beach
12. Beautiful Hampton's Cottage with a pretty garden
This beautiful and typical Hampton-style home is ideal for summer getaways and winter retreats. The home is located in the Bay Point neighborhood, within walking distance of the beach and five minutes from Sag Harbor village. Guests have access to the lush gardens and screened porch and can cook up a storm on the Weber gas grill on the patio. The living area has plenty of seating and a flat-screen TV. Free wireless Internet is available throughout. The kitchen comes equipped with all stainless steel appliances, including a dishwasher. The master bedroom has a king-sized bed, while the second bedroom offers a queen-sized bed.
Sag Harbor, New York, United States
14.85 km (9.3 mi) from Orient Beach State ParkTop guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
bedding was super comfortable and kitchen fully stocked for cookingwe had beautiful weather and were able to enjoy breakfast in the backyard and walks to the beachwe loved the decor and found everything to be perfect: great beds powerful a/c and wifi spotlessly cleanthe upstairs bed was very comfortable and the temp control was greatwe found the property very peaceful and a comfortable place to relaxCleanliness:
impeccably clean and beautifully decoratedeverything was very clean and nicely decoratedit is tastefully decorated clean and comfortableit was very clean and had everything you would need for your stayspotless clean nice stylish touches and a responsive hostHost:
the host was very responsivethank you for being a fantastic hostthe host was very responsive and friendlythe hosts are super responsive and thoughtfullisa the property manager was a delight was responsive professional and graciousRead more reviewsLocation:
the location was great - we were close to wherever we wanted to gogreat house at a great locationthe location was great just a quick walk to the beachbeautiful house in a quiet neighborhood close to towngreat house with a great location
Have the perfect vacation in Sag Harbor, New York
Whether spending the days on the beach or exploring the harbor, shopping in the quaint local shops and boutiques, or dining out in the excellent restaurants, make sure you stay in comfort in one of the best Airbnb vacation rentals in Sag Harbor, New York, USA.
If you’re looking for places to stay outside Sag Harbor, there are also amazing Airbnb vacation rentals in The Hamptons, just 15 minutes away.
Frequently asked questions about Airbnb vacation rentals in Sag Harbor, New York
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data
Create an account to