10 Best Airbnb Vacation Rentals In Sandy Hook, New Jersey - Updated 2024

Alyssandra Raiza
Alyssandra Raiza 
Updated
| 5 min read

Sandy Hook is a barrier spit sitting at the east side of Middleton Township and faces the mighty Atlantic Ocean. Once a military base, much of the land here now serves as a tourist spot and is maintained by the National Park Service. The lighthouse, multiple batteries, and Gunnison Beach are just some of the notable spots you can visit here. There are many awesome places you can stay in after a long and exciting tour day, and we have made it easy for you to choose. Scroll down for the best Airbnb vacation rentals in Sandy Hook, New Jersey, to make your trip a memorable one.

We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on February 06, 2024.

1. Bayfront home with an enclosed porch (from USD 575)

If you want the sea to be right by your doorstep, this house might be ideal for you. You can get a one-of-a-kind experience, with Sandy Hook Lighthouse just a few meters away. There is a plaque in front of the house that reminds visitors of the military history of the houses along the officer’s row. Inside, there is plenty of space and amenities for up to 10 guests. Four bedrooms and two baths mean that all of you can sleep well and keep fresh every day. Plenty of new furniture is present here including cabinets, chairs, and even beds. The enclosed porch is the highlight of the house, with plenty of sun coming in and a sofa set to keep everyone cozy no matter the season.

Stayed at this property?
Highlands, New Jersey, United States
2.77 km (1.8 mi) from Gateway National Recreation Area
37 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
Entire cottage 8 Beds 10 Guests 4 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 10

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the mattresses were very comfortable for sleeping
brian’s place is very cozy and relaxing
the beds were all comfortable (even the bunk beds ) and had nice linens
sit down dinners in the dining room can be enjoyed in a warm glow from the sunset
Cleanliness:
clean safe and well stocked
the entire house was very clean
his place is impeccably clean tastefully decorated has a well stocked kitchen and full of extra amenities
Host:
gracious and communicative hosts
brian was a great host and answers all questions in a timely manner
brian was a great host
brian is a great host
brian was an amazing host and always in contact
Location:
really unique and special place a short boat ride or drive from manhattan
Read more reviews

Nearby options

1. Charming seaside home along the main highway (from USD 374)

Sitting off the coastal highway right beside Highlands Beach, this welcoming home is a treat for small families and groups. The interior is filled with sea-themed decor, from the carpets to the wall paintings. A family of four can sleep comfortably in the two bedrooms with multiple pillows and sheets. The living area has a large TV and couches, while the sun porch can give you a brilliant view of the sea. There is a large seafood restaurant sitting just next door, and the junction to Sandy Hook is also just down the block, giving you easy access to the rest of New Jersey.

Stayed at this property?
Sea Bright, New Jersey, United States
5.32 km (3.4 mi) from Gateway National Recreation Area
144 reviews   Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 3 Beds 4 Guests 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 4

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the view from the living room is fantastic
beautiful interior and cozy
house was very cozy and comfortable with an amazing view of the beach
there’s a wonderful view of the beach from the sun room
the accommodations are great with 2 good size rooms and a pullout sofa option
Cleanliness:
the place was clean and thoughtful touches like beach towels and toiletries were provided
the apartment was very clean and well kept
perfect space for a weekend trip super clean and convenient
it was clean and was what we expected from the pictures
clean adorable little nook loved our stay
Host:
christopher was a great host
christopher is a great host always responding any messages very quickly
great host i highly recommend
our hosts stayed in contact with us and made us feel very welcome
christopher and his family were also so accommodating and helpful if we had any questions or needed anything
Location:
great quiet location just a quick walk to beach
great location and nicelyn decorated apartment
such a cute place and very near the beach
perfect place if you are looking for location location location
perfect location - just over the highlands bridge
Read more reviews

2. Lovely home with town views (from USD 220)

This Jersey Shore home is a modern interpretation of the seaside home and is perfect for the younger families and working groups. There are three bedrooms that can accommodate a total of six guests. One-and-a-half baths can make sure everyone keeps fresh all day. Granite counters highlight the full kitchen, complete with state-of-the-art appliances. You can also get other nice perks like a large TV, cozy couches, WiFi access, and even a balcony where you can view the town.

Stayed at this property?
Highlands, New Jersey, United States
4.64 km (2.9 mi) from Gateway National Recreation Area
92 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
Entire townhouse 3 Beds 6 Guests 3 Bedrooms 1 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 6

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
really charming large space with beautiful breakfast views and a playground across the street
my only real complaint is that the hot water wasn't very hot (not the most pleasant showers)
but the remainder of the house was nice and comfortable
Cleanliness:
place was very clean and comfortable
this place was amazingly clean and had everything we needed
very quiet clean and family oriented
the house is very spacious -especially the bedrooms- and very clean and quite
it is clean and it is a lot of space for what we paid
Host:
alicia was a great host
very comfortable living room and communicative host
alicia's home was in the absolute perfect location and she was a great host
alicia was a great host with clearly timely communications on all topics
alicia was super helpful from the beginning
Location:
we loved this location close to everything including a 2 minutes walk from bay ave
the location is great - walking distance to a bakery and multiple restaurants
great location house more spacious than expected
i loved it great location as well
location was great so many great restaurants and things to do in the area
Read more reviews

3. Serene home with seaside views

Sunset viewing is a pretty scene from the front porch of this romantic apartment unit that can easily sleep a couple on holiday. The Bohemian-style interior has plenty of attention to detail, from the patterned textiles to the two-tone wooden furniture in the bedroom. The bed is fitted with plush beddings and a bedside shelf for some reading. You can get all the conveniences including a fridge, stove, TV, and WiFi access, to name a few. You can even get a dedicated table for coffee and tea, along with a microwave oven for an easy breakfast.

Stayed at this property?
Highlands, New Jersey, United States
3.73 km (2.4 mi) from Gateway National Recreation Area
34 reviews  
Entire apartment 1 Bed 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
bright airy cozy and good vibes only
Cleanliness:
her place was clean and inviting
heather's apartment is very clean comfortable and has good vibes
lovely clean quiet close to great food
heather's place is wonderful the space itself was super clean well-appointed and had a really sweet vibe
beautifully kept apartment comfy and clean highly recommend for a nice quiet get away
Host:
heather made the process easy and provided helpful local info
warm and responsive host
heather was very communicative and nice and she offered tons of great recommendations for restaurants and bars
our hostess was responsive and super clear in her directions
Location:
great location walking distance to the ferry some smaller beaches restaurants and bars
i recommend a car but the bike rental place is a short walk away (kranky's) which heather recommended
fantastic location peaceful and easy access to seabright and sandy hook
sandy hook beach was very close by which we also enjoyed
lots of great restaurants within walking distance place itself was cozy and clean
Read more reviews

4. Beautiful home with a spacious front deck (from USD 215)

Are you a family of four looking for a spot that stands out? This house might be ideal for you. This beach getaway is situated in a quiet neighborhood near the bridge to the mainland. You can get your own private entrance to the two-bedroom apartment. Inside, there is plenty of space for the living and dining areas. Cooking is possible in the well-equipped kitchen. The front deck faces the sea, so having a meal here can be such a scenic experience.

Stayed at this property?
Highlands, New Jersey, United States
5.05 km (3.2 mi) from Gateway National Recreation Area
95 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE RENTAL UNIT 2 Beds 4 Guests 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 4

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
lovely renovated apartment with a beautiful view
fantastic views beautiful apartment with great outdoor space and super friendly hosts - we wouldn't hesitate to come back
Cleanliness:
clean & quite
everything was very clean and check in was super easy
the unit was very clean and very well kept
the house was super clean well stocked and very comfortable
clean quiet and awesome location
Host:
the hosts were very attentive and kind
the hosts were friendly and more than available to help with any questions we had
they are attentive and helpful
they were very helpful and thoughtful
lizette and lorine were great hosts
Location:
the house and location was perfect
house is in a great location in walking distance of the beach restaurants and stores
beautiful house and fantastic location
great location very stylish and comfortable apartment
the location was great too–tucked away but still close to restaurants shops and the beach
Read more reviews

5. Fabulous ocean home with a private beach (from USD 381)

Looking for something modern with plenty of amenities? This home is stylish and carefully decorated with sleek furniture, contemporary artworks, and patterned carpets. It features two bedrooms, each with a relaxing minimalist layout and enough space to comfortably sleep up to four guests. A bar-style counter highlights the kitchen, where you can cook up any meal with all the tools at your disposal. Lastly, you can enjoy views of the water from the yard over a barbecue.

Stayed at this property?
Sea Bright, New Jersey, United States
5.3 km (3.3 mi) from Gateway National Recreation Area
78 reviews   Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 3 Beds 4 Guests 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 4

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
on the back of the house is the canal with comfortable chairs where you can just relax
there is a nice yard in the back that has a grill and table to eat at
very comfortable little apartment and chris and his cleaner/ housekeeper were lovely and very helpful
comfortable leather sofa to watch tv while relaxing
the house was great and has plenty of room for a family of five
Cleanliness:
very clean very comfortable
the place was exactly as pictured and clean as a whistle
nice place right on the beach very clean and comfortable
Host:
the owner is very responsive and helpful
the hosts are easy to communicate with
the hosts are really nice and accommodating
great host comfortable space very happy with our accommodations
chris was really quick and responsive with any questions we had during our stay
Location:
great location with excellent beach access
great location to all resturants and shops
it's a great place in a fabulous location
we loved that it was so close to the beach
great space in a fantastic location
Read more reviews

6. Classic beach home with a lovely yard (from USD 300)

This bright home is cozy, offering you all the comforts you’ll need such as numerous chairs and couches to make sure your legs are well-rested. There are large beds that can accommodate up to six guests. Multiple cabinets and tables can make sure you have space to store your valuables and catch up on some work. Cooking any meal is possible with a fully functional stove, fridge, oven, and other utensils. There is even a backyard with a whole sofa set and barbecue grill to make your outdoor dining experience memorable.

Stayed at this property?
Sea Bright, New Jersey, United States
5.5 km (3.5 mi) from Gateway National Recreation Area
97 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 3 Beds 6 Guests 3 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 6

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
we had a very relaxing stay and felt so comfortable with all amenities we ever needed
the outdoor shower was a huge plus as were the beach chairs and toys for our toddler
beachy vibes cozy but uncluttered very clean
the living room was large and cozy- perfect for board games and chilling with the kids
a generous and delicious bottle of rose was left for us in the kitchen and a nice touch
Cleanliness:
house is clean and neat
extremely clean and well appointed
the place was very clean
the house was very clean and inviting
the place was very clean and everything you need is there
Host:
linda is an amazing host
linda is an outstanding host
linda is also a really wonderful host
the owner was very responsive and accommodating
linda was a terrific host
Location:
good location for beach and river
we were even able to walk to a delicious place right up the street
the house is beautiful and close to the beach
our family loves sea bright and the location couldn’t be better
perfect location & linda is a true host
Read more reviews

7. Little haven for five (from USD 190)

This newly renovated beach abode is a pretty home for a traveling family. With three bedrooms, five guests can easily spend their nights in comfort. All the rooms are air-conditioned and heated, so the house can be comfortable no matter the season. The kitchenette is complete with a stove, microwave, and fridge that can keep all your food fresh and tasty. The back door opens to a beach, with a barbecue pit and outdoor dining area so you can enjoy al fresco dinners. The port to New York City is just a few minutes away, so you can get to Broadway and Soho in just an hour.

Stayed at this property?
Highlands, New Jersey, United States
3.93 km (2.5 mi) from Gateway National Recreation Area
88 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
Entire bungalow 3 Beds 5 Guests 3 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 5

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the kitchen is cozy with smaller-scaled appliances but very functional and well appointed
beds are small but as described and a good value for the price
Cleanliness:
robert’s place is a little gem the place was clean and comfy and decorated in keeping with its era
Host:
great place great host private beach
robert's place was warm and welcoming and robert is a terrific host
Location:
great location and a super cute place
walkable from the ferry landing and you can bike to great beaches
great handy place in a great place
friendly community beaches nature hikes this bungalow puts you in just the right place to enjoy it all
Read more reviews

8. Relaxing beach house with a yard (from USD 249)

Your vacation can be more serene in this home by the bay. You can have a comfortable stay here, with two bedrooms providing enough sleeping space for up to five people. A large sofa set can make watching your favorite shows a much more exciting experience, and the sun porch can help give you some light during the wintertime. There is ample space for cooking in the kitchen with a fridge, stove, and plenty of utensils. The coffee station can make sure you start your day right.

Stayed at this property?
Sea Bright, New Jersey, United States
5.38 km (3.4 mi) from Gateway National Recreation Area
124 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 2 Beds 5 Guests 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 5

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the couch can easily fit four people in full reclining mode and is incredibly comfortable
the rooms and mattresses were so comfortable
plenty of space and comfortable
the kitchen had everything we needed plus a great grill in the backyard
comfortable beds and tvs in both upstairs bedrooms
Cleanliness:
clean we found the beds very comfortable
it’s clean and roomy
the house is very clean with attractive room colors and finishing
linens were clean and cozy
the house was very clean and tidy
Host:
jim was a perfect host
jim was a great host
the hosts were responsive yet unobtrusive
jim was a great host
jim was responsive with any questions i had and have great local recommendations
Location:
the location is amazing
the location was great
so many good close restaurants
the location was fantastic
so cute and comfy and the location was amazing
Read more reviews

9. Well-located guest suite with a hot tub (from USD 279)

Just moments away from Sandy Hook Beach, this house is a beach shack with loads of indoor and outdoor goodies. The rental can accommodate two, making it a great holiday date spot. The bedroom has fine blankets and a large cabinet that can give you plenty of storage space. The living area and kitchenette are also for guests’ use, complete with appliances like a fridge, microwave, kettle, a large TV, and a sofa. Outdoor features are also plenty, with chairs on the front porch, a dining area on the wooden deck, and a new hot tub, which can give you more relaxation options during cooler months. All these you can do while watching beautiful sunsets over the bay.

Stayed at this property?
Highlands, New Jersey, United States
4.85 km (3.1 mi) from Gateway National Recreation Area
100 reviews   Wifi Available
Entire guest suite 1 Bed 2 Guests 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 2

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
unbelievable views and super comfortable furnishing
once we signed into the house wifi this improved significantly
she provides beach chairs all linens and a beautifully decorated apartment
we also loved the cozy lounge area on another patio and enjoyed sitting out there
room and bed were comfortable
Cleanliness:
the apartment is really cozy and was very clean when we arrived
very clean well maintained and megan was awesome
megan’s place was outstanding it was super clean and modern
the place was clean and comfortable and walk able to bars/restaurants
the apartment was spotlessly clean - we probably could have eaten off the floor
Host:
megan is an amazing host who cares
meg was quite the gracious host
thanks megan for accommodating us you were an excellent host
megan is an easy going friendly and very attentive host
megan is a wonderful host and made sure we had everything we needed
Location:
her house is beautiful and the location is great
a wonderful experience very close to the ferry and many amazing restaurants
megan’s place was so cute close to nearby beaches and shops
the location is perfect for enjoying highlands & surrounding beach areas including easy access to sandy hook
beautiful home within walking distance to the beach and all other necessities
Read more reviews

Explore the history and natural beauty of Sandy Hook

With the sea breeze and waves hitting from two directions, this barrier land formation is a unique natural attraction. It also has plenty of historical military outposts and homes. Stay in one of the best Airbnb vacation rentals in Sandy Hook, New Jersey, and enjoy a lovely break with your loved ones.

Stayed at this property?
Any must-sees we missed? Tell us about them in the comments section or write a post here to help out fellow travelers!
Disclosure: Trip101 selects the listings in our articles independently. Some of the listings in this article contain affiliate links.

History


Get Trip101 in your inbox

Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data

Aly is an ever-curious wanderer who enjoys constantly learning and exploring the world. With more than five years of experience as a travel writer based in Manila, she enjoys writing about her...Read more

 Want to contribute as a Local Expert?
Explore Sandy Hook Gateway National Recreation Area
x
Good things are meant to be shared!
Back to top
Visited any of these places? Click this button to activate our "Add a Tip" feature to share your experience.