Sister Bay, Door County in Wisconsin, USA, is indeed a charming destination with a wide range of attractions and activities to enjoy. The Sister Bay Marina provides modern amenities for boaters, ensuring a comfortable stay for visitors. Additionally, the Village of Sister Bay Sports Park offers a variety of activities, including skating, sledding, hockey, and basketball. Don’t forget to explore the Farmer’s Market on Saturdays, where you can find fresh, locally grown fruits and vegetables, beautiful flowers, unique crafts, and delicious local foods. For some added entertainment, make sure to catch the free waterfront park concerts and movies in specific months, such as the New Year’s Eve Fireworks.
Sister Bay is the perfect place for recreation and relaxation, so why wait? Secure your booking now and experience all that this delightful village has to offer. Scroll down to pick one of the best Airbnb vacation rentals in Sister Bay, Wisconsin.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on April 15, 2024.
1. Modern cottage right across the beach
This accommodation boasts a prime location, close to popular restaurants such as Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza and Grille and Door County Creamery, with the latter currently closed as of writing. Just a short walk from the beach, it’s the perfect getaway for large groups of friends or families.
The modernized cottage features several spacious bedrooms, along with well-decorated bathrooms for more convenience. The fully equipped kitchen includes barbecue utensils. Plus, there’s an outdoor dining area and a private patio or balcony. Conveniently, it offers free street parking and self-check-in via a door code.
Sister Bay, Wisconsin, United States
42.99 km (26.8 mi) from DeYoung Family ZooSuperhost
Accommodates: 12
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
we used the outdoor fire table often and it was awesomeCleanliness:
very clean and fun placevery comfortable and clean accommodationslovely super clean and comfortablegreat location and very clean updated interiorswe had a great stay everything was very neat and cleanHost:
the hosts were wonderfulthe hosts were communicative and helpfulkim & adam were also very responsive hosts to any messages throughout the weekendthe hosts were attentive beds were comfortable and modern updates made the stay extra nicethe communication with our hosts was superior overall a fantastic stayRead more reviewsLocation:
location was amazing and walking distance to everythinggreat place great location thanksthe location was perfectthe location is super convenientfantastic accommodations and location was fabulous
2. Luxurious downtown condominium (from USD 564)
Apart from comfy bedrooms, this downtown condo provides flat-screen TVs and streaming services access. While it doesn’t feature a fully fenced backyard, the private entrance is a nice touch. The well-equipped kitchen with custom cabinetry and quartz countertops is a standout feature. You can enjoy your coffee on the private patio, thanks to the espresso machine. Plus, the indoor fireplace adds a cozy touch to the atmosphere.
It’s worth noting that there are no security cameras on the property, but the self-check-in feature with a door code provides convenience. Additionally, pets and long-term stays are allowed, making it a flexible choice for your needs.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
it was a generous amount of room for our grouplooking out from the living room and kitchen is an amazing view of the lakewifi worked perfectly even with 4 teens using it tooCleanliness:
it was clean and had everything we could possibly needeverything felt modern and cleaninflatable bed rails sound machines) the coziness of the space and cleanlinessbeautiful condo beautiful decor super clean and very comfortablewonderful stay perfect location condo was very clean and well appointedHost:
mary is very responsive and kindmary was the best host we have ever hadmary is a super host and was available if needed anythingmary was a great hostess who was very communicative and responsivemary was very responsive and helpful when we needed herRead more reviewsLocation:
the location is absolutely terrific101 sister bay place is the best and the location is primeawesome downtown location very convenient walk to the local shops restaurants and marinagreat accommodation very close distance to everything in sister baylots of cute shops in town
3. Vibrant house near the beach (from USD 210)
This smoke- and pet-free property presents bedrooms with a total of two queen beds and one bunk bed, making it ideal for a family holiday. Checking in is a breeze with the lockbox.
The location is fantastic, just a short walk from Sister Bay Beach. Inside the unit, you’ll find free washer and dryer facilities. Moreover, the kitchen includes barbecue utensils for your convenience.
As for entertainment, you’ll have access to a 55-inch (139.70-centimeter) HDTV with standard cable, a ping pong table, various board games, and a selection of kid’s books, toys, and even a travel crib. Plus, there’s free Wi-Fi to keep you connected during your stay.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the space is perfect for 2 couples or families with additional bunk bedshaving a clean comfortable house/yard/deck in such a perfect location was a real treatCleanliness:
clean and well equippedsuper clean beds very comfortablevery clean and large enough for a familyeverything was very clean and we had all that we neededfantastic location and extremely clean accommodationsHost:
walter is super responsive and a wonderful hostwatching the waves from the living room is so relaxing the owners are super friendly and helpfulblue house is a great house walter the host is always availablewalter is a great host and the home cannot be in a better locationwalter is amazing and incredibly responsiveRead more reviewsLocation:
great location with a short walk to the beachgreat location in sister baygreat place in a great locationgreat place with great locationwalking distance from a wonderful swedish restaurant
4. Newly renovated rental directly behind a bar (from USD 351)
This rental is situated directly behind Husby’s Food and Spirits, known for hosting nightly music shows during the summer season. If you’re not a light sleeper and you enjoy music, this is an ideal spot for you. Additionally, it’s just a four-minute walk to Sister Bay Beach.
The rental itself is quite spacious, capable of accommodating a large group. It features a couple of bedrooms and well-maintained bathrooms so that everyone has enough space. While it offers a private backyard, please note that it’s not fully fenced. However, it does have a private entrance for your convenience, and self-check-in is made easy through a smart lock.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
our group of 8 could fit around the high top kitchens tables drink coffee play gameseach bedroom is roomy with extremely comfortable bedsthe kitchen is well-stocked with utensils carrie was so kind and accommodatingwe cooked in a few nights and the kitchen is very well equipped everything you needCleanliness:
entire house spotlessly cleanplace was clean comfortable spacious and nicely renovatedfantastic location clean great communication about check in a great space to staythe house was beautiful inside and very cleanhouse was exactly as pictured and super cleanHost:
she was extremely responsive to all requeststhe host was very easy to communicate withi highly recommend this property and hostcarrie was an awesome host very communicative and helpfulRead more reviewsLocation:
great location with everything in town within easy walking distanceamazing location in the heart of sister baywe loved being in walking distance to the main streetthe location was fantastic being right downtown sister baysuper comfortable and a convenient location with lots to do within walking distance
5. Rustic accommodation with modern amenities (from USD 800)
This country-style lodging is designed to accommodate a medium-sized group. There are six beds available, including two king beds, two queen beds, and a bunk bed. The elegant design features contrasting colors in most spaces, creating a sophisticated atmosphere.
The rental includes Wi-Fi access and a dedicated workspace. The fully equipped kitchen is a standout, featuring a modern refrigerator with filtered drinking water and even a reverse osmosis system. There’s also a private entrance and an open space in the backyard.
Guests can take advantage of the beach, which is just a short walk away. And if you’re in the mood for Swedish cuisine, Al Johnson’s, a renowned Swedish restaurant known for its meatballs and pickled herring, is about a five-minute walk from the property.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
loved having the ambiance of the fireplace in the living roombeds were very comfortablethe welcome bag was an awesome surprise the kitchen is fully stocked with anything you may needgreat bathrooms comfortable beds and a well equipped kitchenCleanliness:
super clean and well cared forthe house was new and clean and pictures accurately reflect the housebeautiful clean well-appointed home in a fantastic locationvery clean decorated beautifully and the kitchen was well stocked for cookingthe house was clean well kept and as described in the listingHost:
the hosts were responsivevery responsive hostjeffrey and barb were excellent hosts and very responsivein addition the hosts were so very friendly welcoming accessible and responsivethese are exceptionally gracious and welcoming hostsRead more reviewsLocation:
we loved the locationwalking distance to all sister bay attractionsa perfect location to explore sister baybut overall great house great locationgreat location house and experience at vacation sister bay
6. A Northern Suite Life (from USD 379)
A Northern Suite Life offers a picturesque view of Sister Bay Beach, and you can admire it even more by heading to the private, well-furnished balcony. Although there’s no private entrance, access to the unit is convenient, thanks to the lockbox. The property provides free parking on-site and has the added convenience of an elevator, too.
Indoors, you can enjoy free Wi-Fi, a well-equipped kitchen, and an indoor fireplace to enhance your comfort and overall experience during your stay.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
great location the condo has excellent layout great balcony very comfortable for usthe kitchen setup is fantasticCleanliness:
very clean and new and owner was very responsivethe unit was spotless when we arrived and we enjoyed our trip to sister bayHost:
terri is a wonderful host - easy communication at every point through the processRead more reviewsLocation:
what a wonderful condo great location and close to everything we needed in sister baywalking distance to sister bay shops beautifully styled just perfect we will be back this summerthe unit and the location cannot be beat terri was always responsivebeautifully decorated place awesome view & loved that it was walkable to nearby restaurants and bars
7. Cozy birch cabin retreat near the marina (from USD 249)
This wooded cabin provides a serene retreat, perfect for a peaceful getaway, yet it remains close to Sister Bay Beach and various local establishments.
The property uses a smart lock for secure access. Inside, you’ll find a gas indoor fireplace, Wi-Fi, and a fully equipped kitchen for your convenience. Please take note that the rental includes a front porch camera that records both video and audio. Furthermore, there are two smart home devices —one installed on the living room ceiling and another in the patio area— that continuously track noise levels but do not record audio or video.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
great stay cozy cabin in a beautiful wooded areakitchen: immaculate modern well-equipped spacious bright and cheeryCleanliness:
everything was clean and easythe space was absolutely beautiful brand new and super cleanthe check-in process was seamless and the property itself was spotless + comfortableRead more reviewsLocation:
it is less than a mile to downtown and a peaceful walka lovely and thoughtfully appointed haven in the woods so close to everything yet quiet and privatequick walk to town with lots of great restaurants and shops
8. Adorable maple cabin (from USD 306)
This charming lodging provides a sweet retreat from the hustle and bustle. Surrounded by lush greenery and simple yet convenient furnishing, guests are sure to have a memorable time. Additionally, it features a private backyard with a pergola.
Guests have the convenience of free Wi-Fi access during their stay. Moreover, the well-appointed kitchen presents an enticing option for culinary enthusiasts to take their meals outdoors and savor the fun experience of grilling, thanks to the charcoal barbecue grill, making it a delightful addition to their stay.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the great room allowed for us all to be together yet do our own thingsplenty of hot water great linens and bedsmight be the most well equipped kitchen we've ever rented (even sharp knives )the living room area was roomy and comfortablethe beds are really comfortable and the living room is very spaciousCleanliness:
nice clean and very convenientit was very clean and cozyplace was very cleanthe place was extremely cleanhouse was very clean and very well organizedHost:
excellent host thank youwe contacted audrey once and she was very responsivethe hosts were responsive and yet respectful of our space - the best kind of airbnb hostscommunication with owner was quick and easygreat communication with the hostRead more reviewsLocation:
the location is fantasticcute place with a great locationoutstanding location to explore the peninsulathe location is very nice and close to downtown sister baygreat location and a comfortable stay
9. Elegant lodging with an outdoor dining area (from USD 263)
Nestled on a tranquil and wooded cul-de-sac, this smoke- and pet-free accommodation is designed to comfortably host a family. Plus, the bathrooms are thoughtfully equipped with essential amenities and a hair dryer for your convenience.
Additionally, the well-appointed kitchen allows you to prepare your own meals, which you can savor at the outdoor patio table for a delightful dining experience.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
good wi-fi and a nice large tv in the living roombrandon and danielle shared their recommendations (hikes breakfasts etc) which we really liked tooCleanliness:
the house was clean and well stocked for the staynice and clean and well-stocked with essentialsvery clean had everything we needed in the housespacious clean and welcoming environment a great home base to explore door county or as a relaxing destination itselfclose walk to sister bay clean and lots of games and entertainment on siteHost:
brandon was a great host that helped make christmas special for our familythe house is super kid friendly and even better than the picturesgreat communication with owner and smooth checkinRead more reviewsLocation:
perfect location close to towngreat location for a 15 minute walk into sister baygreat location about a half mile from downtown sister bayit’s really in a perfect locationloved the decor and the location was perfect
10. Spacious and comfy cottage with a hot tub (from USD 251)
The location is conveniently just a five-minute walk from Sister Bay Marina. Notably, it boasts a private hot tub that’s accessible year-round, available 24 hours a day for your relaxation. Additionally, there’s an EV charger and a secure parking garage on the premises, all meticulously monitored by security cameras for added safety.
To keep guests entertained, the accommodation offers various amenities, including a TV, a game console, and a selection of reading materials.
Top guest reviews
Cleanliness:
spacious and clean prefect for familythe kitchen was so clean and was perfect for our needsthe house was cleanthe house was very nicely organized and cleanthe bathrooms and bedrooms were cleanHost:
thomas was a gracious hosthost was super responsive friendly and made us feel very welcomethomas was very communicative and a great hosthe was a very responsive host and the listing was very accuratethomas was very attentive and an overall excellent hostRead more reviewsLocation:
great neighborhood great location great housegreat house in a great locationgreat house size and locationloved this stay the location is fantastic- walking distance to several restaurants in sister baya great location for a cozy winter getaway
Where fun and adventure are sisters
Whether you seek a peaceful retreat or a lively getaway, Sister Bay’s best rentals offer the perfect home base for your Wisconsin adventure. Enjoy a range of accommodations, from spacious and inviting cabins to charming cottages, all equipped with modern amenities for a memorable stay. Choose any one of these best vacation rentals in Sister Bay, Wisconsin.
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data
Create an account to