Those who eagerly spent time discovering Casey Key will not leave with any regrets. It may be just a small stretch of land off the coast of Sarasota, but it is a lovely destination with lots of quiet and less populated beaches that will introduce you to a side of Florida not known to many. Some of the top activities here include visiting Oscar Scherer State Park, enjoying fresh fish at Casey Key Fish House, soaking in the sun on the beach, touring the Historic Spanish Point, and jet skiing facilitated by numerous equipment rental companies in the area. If your trip here is in the works, then read below for the top beachfront rentals in Casey Key, Florida.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) host status, recent guest reviews, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and location with easy access to beach. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on August 30, 2025.
1. A spectacular beachfront home with stunning sea views (from USD 326)
If you are looking for an intimate vacation spot, then this is probably one of the best you will come across. It is a one-bedroom condo with direct access to the beach and is fully equipped, granting you a comfy and memorable stay.
Some of the top features of this unit include a spacious living room with a queen sleeper sofa, a fully equipped kitchen, and a comfy bedroom with a king bed and a private bathroom. Guests will also have access to a patio area with unobstructed views of the ocean.
Nokomis, Florida, United States
6.25 km (3.9 mi) from Oscar Scherer State Park
Top guest reviews
Location:
perfect location quiet and sweet place if you want to get awayconveniently located to grocery stores restaurants and shops we easily walked to most placesgreat spot close to lots of food choices and things to dothere are several nice places to eat just a few minutes awaywe definitely recommend this place and hope to stay here again in the futureCleanliness:
clean and nicely decoratedthe condo was very clean and suited us wellthe unit was impeccably cleaned and beautifully decoratedthe condo was very clean my fiancé and i had an amazing weekend herethe unit was spotless and even smelled clean upon arrival which was of utmost concern during this pandemicRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
the furnishings were modern and the beds and linens were so comfortablethe beds were super comfy and we loved eating out on the balconywe really liked the cottage breakfast and also pops sunset grill
2. A two-bedroom beach retreat with spectacular outdoor spaces (from USD 441)
With this two-bedroom beach retreat, you will have plenty of spaces outdoors to maximize the weather and the views. The indoor area is equally lovely, with a comfy living room where you will find a leather sofa, a fireplace, and a flat-screen TV. For your self-catering needs, the unit comes with a fully equipped kitchen, complete with a dining area for four.
And, for your sleeping and grooming needs, you will have access to two comfy bedrooms and a full bathroom.
Nokomis, Florida, United States
5.99 km (3.8 mi) from Oscar Scherer State Park
Top guest reviews
Host:
the owners were very cordial and responsiveLocation:
location was excellent would like to come back another yearenjoyed our time being so close to the beachCleanliness:
the grounds were very well kept and everything seemed clean and freshRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
it was a beautiful place to stay we had 8 people and there was still plenty of room
3. A nicely decorated one-bedroom condo with direct beach access (from USD 276)
With this condo, you will have access to a beautifully decorated living space, featuring a comfy living area with a plush sofa and a flat-screen TV, a fully equipped kitchen, a breakfast bar, a private bathroom with a toilet and a tub, and a comfy bedroom with a king bed, a TV and plenty of storage. Another great feature you should consider is that the beach is just a short walk away from here.
Nokomis, Florida, United States
6.21 km (3.9 mi) from Oscar Scherer State Park
Top guest reviews
Location:
really like it very convenient location definitely we’ll come backlovely little cottage very close to beachwalked to two local restaurants that we're excellent wish i was there nowRead more reviewsCleanliness:
very clean and homeygreat place cozy clean and privategreat property beach accessproperty was very clean and well-keptclean cottage was perfect for usbut we still had a nice trip and the beach is clean and not very crowded
4. A one-bedroom condo with beautiful ocean views (from USD 376)
Consider staying in this gorgeous one-bedroom condo for comfort and easy access to lots of attractions and amenities in the area. Inside this fully furnished condo, you will have access to a kitchen, a spacious dining area, and a comfy living room. The bedroom features a king bed, but for more options, there is a queen-sized sofa bed in the living room.
You will also love the fact that the condo is in a relatively quiet location but still in proximity to shops, restaurants, and rentals for bikes and kayaks, which will really come in handy during your stay.
Nokomis, Florida, United States
6.21 km (3.9 mi) from Oscar Scherer State Park
Top guest reviews
Host:
the manager on site was also very helpful and kindRead more reviewsLocation:
great location right on the beach and walking distance to everythingthe location to restaurants gas stations grocery stores were very close as wellgreat location on the beach quiet property during the weekgreat location clean and easy access to the beachthe location to the beach could not have been any better
5. A one-bedroom duplex with beach access (from USD 207)
Wake up to beautiful views and the fresh ocean air in this spacious one-bedroom duplex located along the Intracoastal Way, complete with direct access to the beach. This unit is fully furnished, hence, it offers a comfortable stay.
It also features a private porch overlooking a tropical landscaped garden where you can always enjoy some quiet outdoor moments. You will also love the fact that the house is just a short distance to bars, restaurants, and grocery stores in the area.
Nokomis, Florida, United States
5.79 km (3.6 mi) from Oscar Scherer State Park
Top guest reviews
Host:
the owner was more than helpful and accommodatingmillie was so kind and made sure all our needs were metmillie was an excellent host and met us upon arrival to give a tourLocation:
really enjoyed the location and the placethe location was perfect for us and we thoroughly enjoyed getting acquainted with the areaCleanliness:
incredibly clean and comfortablethe unit was very clean with plenty of extrasthe duplex was very clean and comfortablethe home was clean and modernit was clean and well equipped with plenty of chairs and towels for the beachRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
and the shower - amazing water pressure would definately book again
6. A charming Casa Cay unit (from USD 190)
This Casa Cay unit is an intimate and friendly place ideal for relaxing and unwinding away from the troubles of the big cities. It is a charming studio that comes fully furnished with all the amenities you may need for a decent stay, including a comfy living space, a king bed, a dining area, and a kitchenette. You will also love the gorgeous seating area, ideal for enjoying your morning coffee or a glass of wine in the evening.
Casey Key, FL, US
7. A beachfront bungalow with an Old Florida charm (from USD 595)
Enjoy your stay right next to the water in this lovely beachfront bungalow that still oozes an Old Florida charm. A cozy living room, a fresh, white kitchen, and pristine marble flooring are some of the exciting features you should be looking forward to here. This is not to mention the master bedroom, where you will find a king Tempurpedic mattress and a full bathroom.
Nokomis, FL, US
8. A waterfront boathouse with private beach access (from USD 395)
Consider staying right next to the water in this awesome waterfront boathouse that features private beach access. It is clean and located in a secluded area. It is in pristine condition, with all the amenities you may need for a comfortable stay. These include a spacious and bright living area, a comfy sleeping area with a queen bed, a fully equipped kitchen area, and a lovely front porch with calming river views.
Nokomis, FL, US
9. A private two-bedroom beachfront home
Enjoy your stay in this lovely one-story beachfront home that boasts epic views of the Gulf of Mexico from the kitchen, dining room, and living room. It is a lavishly furnished unit, featuring a fully equipped kitchen, a welcoming living area, a patio with outdoor furniture, and a beautiful shared bathroom.
The master bedroom is fitted with a queen bed while the other bedroom features two twin beds. For the further convenience of the guests during their stay, this rental also comes with two bicycles and a kayak that they can use.
5.93 km (3.7 mi) from Oscar Scherer State ParkAccommodates: 4
Minimum Nights: 7
Refund Policy : 100% refund if you cancel at least 14 days before check-in.
Top guest reviews
Host:
the owner was very friendly and gave us some wonderful dining recommendations we hope to stay there againal and scott were fantastic hostsour host was so warm and easy to communicate withal was a charming host very quick to respond and fundamentally a very kind manal is a terrific hostLocation:
really well equipped beautifully located and quietexcellent location love being able to walk right out the back to the beachbeautiful property and facility in an extraordinary locationperfect location on casey key for walking biking beaching and kayakinggreat location property and owners we love itCleanliness:
house is adorable and cleancomfortable beds impeccably clean and great condition kitchen bath living area etcit's fastidiously clean and the sunsets are spectacularRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
al made our stay so comfortable and his personal touch when we arrived set the tone
10. A lovely condo steps away from the beach
This lovely one-bedroom beachfront condo is just a few steps away from the ocean, and less than a 20-minute drive to Downtown Sarasota. It features a gorgeous bedroom with a king bed and a private bathroom, a fully equipped kitchen, a spacious living room with a queen sleeper sofa, and air conditioning to ensure that the temperature us right all the time.
Nokomis, FL, US
Have a great stay beside the beach in Casey Key
Casey Key offers a unique and fun experience to everyone, and you can maximize your stay here with great accommodation. Consider one of the top beachfront rentals in Casey Key, Florida, listed above, for quality accommodation.
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data