Cayuga boasts a small-town charm and gorgeous landscapes, perfect for your next holiday. This village, located in New York’s Cayuga County, is known for the Finger Lakes as well as having one of the greenest and most tranquil regions in the state. This village hosts three of the Finger Lakes, namely Cayuga, Owasco, and Skaneateles, and all of them feature stunning views, thanks to their picturesque vineyards, rolling green hills, and charming houses. Don’t miss out on visiting Auburn, Cayuga County’s largest city, and pay a visit to Harriet Tubman National Historical Park. Cayuga is also known for having Cascadilla Gorge Trail and Buttermilk Falls State Park.
If you want a tranquil stay, there are plenty of cabins situated by the lakes, allowing you to marvel at the natural beauty at any time of the day! Read on for the best lake cabin rentals near Cayuga, New York.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) host status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and access to lake. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on April 13, 2024.
1. Cozy cabin by the lake; Romulus (from USD 272)
This cabin is the perfect idyllic retreat for those seeking to escape the monotonous daily life and bask in the luxury of the great outdoors.
Standing on a lush green landscape right by Cayuga Lake, this rental offers a breathtaking vista of blue waters. Upon entering the cabin, you’ll be greeted by the interior’s homey and cozy ambiance, further amplified by its exotic rugs and wooden furniture. Large windows offer a perfect panoramic view of the serene lake, all from the comfort of your living room. Moreover, the electric fireplace is a great thing to use when the weather gets too cold.
Top guest reviews
Cleanliness:
plenty of clean towels toiletries etchouse was extremely cleanthe house was clean well-stocked and spaciouseverything was well maintained and clean in the cabineverything was well maintained and clean in the cabinHost:
the host was very responsive gave great ideas for trails winery's and food choicesronnie our contact person was friendly responsive and helpfulfrom the first communication with the host to the first sight of the property amazingRead more reviewsLocation:
this house is close to two of our favorites: thirsty owl and knapp
2. Cayuga Cabins; Tompkins County (from USD 1350)
Get ready for a fun-filled getaway with your loved ones by staying at Cayuga Cabins! This place has everything you need to keep the good times rolling – from top-notch amenities to fun entertainment.
The stunning lake is right in front of the renovated cabins, and you even have access to a dock from where you can swim in comfort. You can also make use of the kayaks provided to properly explore the lake. Inside the cabins, have a fun time in the Cornell-themed “Big Red Room,” a game room with a dartboard and billiards. When the weather is nice, have a fun barbecue session with a Weber barbecue grill at the back, or grill some marshmallows on the beautiful firepit in the yard.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
well appointed kitchen and superb views for sunsetscozy living room to chill and play board games with friendsCleanliness:
clean very nicely furnished everything was there that we neededboth cabins were spacious clean and very comfortablewhat sticks out the most is how clean and well stocked it wasthe place was perfect it was exceptionally cleanHost:
the owner is very attentive and makes you feel very welcomeowner is engaged and responsive to make sure everything is righthe is probably the most responsive property owner on vrbo i've ever encounteredsteve was a great host the property is so cool it has a rustic feel with modern conveniencessteve was extremely responsive and helpful with all questions i hadRead more reviewsLocation:
couldn't have stayed at a better locationmany of the area's best known parks are within an hour's drive of the housea fun place to stay
3. Magnificent cabin on the eastern shore of Cayuga Lake; Lansing (from USD 296)
Escape to a secluded haven on the eastern shore of Cayuga Lake and bask in the blissful serenity that this magnificent cabin offers. Standing on a 90-foot (27.43-meter) elevated position right by the lake, this property offers breathtaking scenery of the lake’s pristine surface and the scenic landscape beyond.
This property features a gorgeous wooden balcony, an ideal spot to savor a cup of coffee and marvel at the scenery. Within the cabin, a harmonious blend of natural elements and modern amenities creates an ambiance of supreme relaxation. The wooden floorboards and the stone fireplace enhance the cozy feel, while the cabin’s heating system ensures complete warmth.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the mattress was terrific and the bed linens were softcome for the views hiking and lake but stay for the cozy cottage with amazing amenitiescomfortable beautiful view fully equipped and a lovely host with great communicationbeds were very comfortable and cheryl provides plenty of fans for everyone to use if neededwe had a lot of fun cooking in the kitchenCleanliness:
the cabin was very clean and well preparedcheryls place is very well stocked and very cleannice house clean good locationHost:
cheryl (the host) was a good communicatorthe host provided everything we needed to enjoy the water including kayaks and life jacketscheryl was extraordinarily responsive and took care of everything we needed and answered questions quicklyhosts like her are what keeps airbnb a pleasure to be part ofcheryl was so kind communicative and generousRead more reviewsLocation:
great location on the lakegreat location right on the lake close to ithacagreat location on the watergreat finger lake locationexcellent location and cheryl is great
4. Tranquil cabin surrounded by greenery; Penn Yan (from USD 295)
Hidden among plenty of large shaded trees by Seneca Lake, this cabin is the ultimate back-to-nature retreat. Here, amidst the calm and quiet surroundings, the only sounds you’ll hear are the melodic chirping birds and rustling leaves. Free parking is also offered.
The landscape transforms with the seasons - from lush emerald green in the summer to golden and crimson in the fall. Winter also transforms the area into a picturesque winter wonderland, with the snow-covered path to the cabin only adding to its tranquility. Spring is also an ideal time to visit as the nearby vineyards start their wine trail events, and you’ll get to explore them and sample the freshest wines.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
plenty of room for just two of us but definitely enough space for moremy parents were totally comfortableCleanliness:
the cabin was very clean and cozyan amazing place everything you need clean and cozyso cozy and cleanit was spotless clean but had a warm and cozy feel the second you walk in the dooreverything about this trip was fantastic the cabin was clean and kept in great shapeHost:
sarah is a wonderful hostsarah is a wonderful hostsarah was responsive when neededsarah is very responsive and answered any questions we hadshe was very responsive and all the info was accurateRead more reviewsLocation:
great location tucked away in the woodsgreat location for a private get away yet still close to everything you may want to dothe location is peaceful and quietlocation is close to great restaurants and wineries as wellit was a perfect location for us
5. Homey 1950s cabin; Lodi (from USD 275)
Comfort is the highlight of this charming, 1950s-built cottage. Tucked on a tranquil bank of Seneca Lake, surrounded by massive hundred-year-old oak trees, this cottage boasts its own private swimming dock to the lake – it’s like having the lake as your own pool!
After swimming, head to the nearby neighborhood and immerse yourself in the local rural flavors with an array of authentic Amish eateries. Meanwhile, the cabin’s cozy living room features a lovely fireplace – a perfect place to gather with your loved ones while playing some board games the property provides. Pets are also more than welcome here.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
our bed was comfy and the views of the lake were lovelylovely comfortable and extremely well-located for enjoying seneca lake views and the seneca wine trailthe cottage is adorable comfortable and in a great locationthe cottage is very charming cozy and cleanwe had beautiful weather and sat out on the screened in porch/room as long as we couldCleanliness:
sparkling clean with comfy beds the cabin is larger than we imagined it would bethe cottage was clean and well-equippedadorably decorated very comfy and so clean hoping to visit againrosemary's cottage was perfect very clean and well keptsuch a cozy cottage with many personalized touches and so very cleanHost:
rosemary and jim were wonderful hostsrosemary and jim were wonderful hostsgorgeous setting rosemary and jim were fantastic hoststhey were the perfect hosts before during and after our stayrosemary was very helpful in answering all questions i had prior to the tripRead more reviewsLocation:
perfect getaway locationreally comfy and great locationit’s a lovely quiet location but within easy driving distance to the many attractions in the areathe location on lake seneca is truly delightfullovely place great location the lake is great for dogs
6. Romantic wooden cabin; Tompkins County (from USD 180)
If you’re planning for a romantic getaway, there’s hardly anything better than this beautiful wooden cabin in Tompkins County which exudes an air of intimate and captivating allure. Its interior is almost completely made of timber wood for a more rustic stay. Its bathroom comes with a lovely tub, perfect for two.
Sit on the balcony to watch the calm surface of Cayuga Lake while sipping on a nice warm coffee brewed by the in-house coffee maker. Alternatively, savor a romantic meal al fresco, cooked on a gas grill on the deck, as you take in the lush surrounding views.
Top guest reviews
Host:
the owner was accommodating and responsivenancy is a fantastic hostowner was very helpful with informing us of our personal experience and what to expectowner is one of the nicest ladies i’ve ever met felt like staying with familyRead more reviewsLocation:
it's cozy quirky and really just ideal for a calm getaway and mental resetit was the ideal place for our dog who had what seemed the best vacation of her lifewe even brought our two dogs who loved the scenic walk along the railway tracks
7. Lovely cabin with kayaks; Lodi
Nestled on the eastern shores of Seneca Lake is this incredible cabin, ideal for a romantic escape for two. This cabin provides six kayaks and three stand-up paddle boards if you’re itching to explore the water more.
Alternatively, explore the cabin’s verdant surroundings, and pay a visit to nearby wineries, breweries, and even waterfalls. But, if you’re looking to spend intimate nights inside, the cabin is fully equipped to make your stay experience truly memorable, including a TV as well as a seamless WiFi connection.
Lodi, New York, United StatesSuperhost
Accommodates: 2
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
stunning views and a cozy cabincozy cottage on three cottage compound on beautiful lake with long dockthe cabins are so comfortable with beautiful landscaping as well as beautiful views on the lakebeds were super comfortablethe cottage was cozy and cleanCleanliness:
water was clean and warmthe cabin was so clean and cozycabins are clean quiet and warmextremely clean and equipped with necessitiesit is extemely clean and neatHost:
the host was incredibly helpful and provided local suggestionsmaura was a great hostmaura is a wonderful hostmaura was an amazing hostmaura is an amazing hostRead more reviewsLocation:
the location is beautifulawesome location and a beautiful spot on the lakethis place is a gem amazing location right on seneca lakegreat location and excellent tips about local food and winerieslocation is outstanding you have a beautiful dock and access to kayaks and paddle boards
8. Beyond The Bunkhouse!; Owasco Lake
This gorgeous lakefront house on the bank of Owasco Lake is truly special. This house is personally designed by its owner, Susan, with the utmost attention to family comfort. No wonder you’ll feel exactly at home the moment you step in.
This rental is filled with plenty of personal touches to amplify that sense of home – from displayed trophies to the antique piano. This property also includes books, family-friendly DVDs, and plenty of board games. The rental also boasts a lovely kitchen where you can easily whip up a hearty meal.
Owasco Lake, New York, United StatesAccommodates: 4
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
her place has an impressive lake view and balconies and is very comfortableyou will get an amazing lake view outdoor kitchen with picnic areasusan's lake house is a gorgeous welcoming relaxing setting with wonderful amenities for the kitchen and the bathroomthe s’mores supplies were a welcome surprise we loved cooking outdoors and appreciated her fully equipped kitchenCleanliness:
the house was sparkling clean as wellthe house is spotlessly clean and comfortablethe space is open clean funthis house on owasco lake was spectacular super clean cozy and a fabulous viewthe beds and linens were comfy and cleanHost:
sue is an amazing hostshe is a great host and i would definitely stay here againsusan is a fantastic hostsusan is a very thoughtful hostthanks sue for being a great hostRead more reviewsLocation:
wonderful location right on lake owascogreat location and beautiful housethe perfect location right on owasco lakewe really liked the location and felt very relaxed therethe location is perfect right on the lake
9. Paul's Lodge; Skaneateles (from USD 775)
If you’re looking for the ultimate relaxation in your trip, this lovely cabin is one of the best around the Finger Lakes, nestled in the middle of a forest by Skaneateles Lake.
With its serene spa-inspired atmosphere and emphasis on wellness, this retreat offers a truly rejuvenating escape from the hustle and bustle of daily life. Soak in the soothing waters of the outdoor hot tub, heated to perfection, and take in the relaxing views of tall green trees in your surrounding. As the sun sets and the cool night air descends, cozy up by the classic woodburning fireplace, nestled beneath a stunning organic stone wall that adds a touch of rustic elegance to the lodge’s cozy interior. A stay here is guaranteed to leave you feeling refreshed, restored, and utterly pampered.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
comfortable fit for large families with room for people to spread out a bitthere was plenty of room for 9 of us to sleep comfortablyHost:
paul was very responsiveproperty manager mike was super nice and responsivegreat place to stay mike and paul are very helpfulRead more reviewsLocation:
beautiful location loved the outdoor fireplaceawesome property beautiful secluded location very clean and set up for entertaining i would definitely vacation here againone of my favorite aspects of this place was that there were so many interesting nooks to enjoy
10. Elegantly rustic lakefront cabin; Moravia (from USD 300)
Staying at this lakefront cabin makes it feel like the whole Skaneateles Lake is your front yard. Take a seat on the beautiful dock and bask in the stunning vistas of the pristine waters and the verdant green hills that encircle the lake, as far as the eye can see.
Inside the cabin, you’ll be transported to a world of rustic elegance that perfectly complements the tranquil surroundings. Admire the striking game trophy and antique art pieces that adorn the wooden walls. A classic fireplace serves as the centerpiece of the living room, lending a touch of grandeur to the already majestic interior.
Relaxing getaway to Cayuga
Cayuga is the perfect place for a peaceful, relaxing getaway, with the Finger Lakes and the lush green landscape in its surroundings. Maximize your trip to Cayuga and the Finger Lakes with one of these lakefront cabins, and have yourself a soothing retreat by the water.
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data
Create an account to