Located just south of the picturesque Cape Cod, Martha’s Vineyard, formerly called Noepe or the “land between two streams,” is a charming island in Massachusetts. It is renowned for its long sandy beaches, rolling hills, and wildflower meadows. One of its many attractions is Vineyard Haven, a beautiful ferry port and the island’s commercial center. The port is adorned with numerous restaurants serving delicious dishes and quaint shops offering a wide array of items. Another must-visit destination is Oak Bluffs, known for its charming Victorian cottages and the oldest carousel in the United States, the Flying Horses Carousel.
To complete the island experience, be sure to stay in one of the accommodations from our list of the best cottages for rent in Martha’s Vineyard, Massachusetts.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on October 29, 2025.
1. Stylish three-bedroom cottage (from USD 815)
Are you one of those people who love booking stylish accommodations for Instagram? If yes, you’ll definitely like this rental. It’s a 1930s traditional cottage with an exposed wooden ceiling that adds to its character. The open-floor-plan living, dining, and kitchen area makes conversations easy and the place spacious and bright.
Additionally, the living room opens up to the newly landscaped granite terrace featuring a fire pit, dining area, and various seating options, making it a delightful space for entertaining guests.
Tisbury, Massachusetts, United StatesSuperhost
Accommodates: 8
Top guest reviews
Host:
wonderful home and fabulous hostjim was an amazing hostthe host was extremely gracious and welcominghost was very attentive and took care of anything that was neededjim is a great hostLocation:
great location a short walk to downtown and the busthe location was ideal and within walking distance to restaurants and shoppingthe location is idealthe location is perfectthe location was fabulous a walk to everythingCleanliness:
everything was clean and comfortablethe house was clean and nicely decoratedwe’d recommended it to anyone looking for a clean convenient and relaxing place to stayhouse was spotless and very comfortable- would highly recommendthere were thoughtful touches throughout and the space was clean spacious and had everything we neededRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
jim’s spring st cottage is comfortable and charmingtons of natural light in the living roomthe coffee corner at the kitchen has all you need to have the perfect cup of coffee/espresso/french press/cuban coffeequality furnishings and great kitchen and dining areathe kitchen is complete for cooking and was stocked with basics like oil and spices
2. s cabin with outdoor shower (from USD 2168)
A few minutes’ walk to the beach, restaurants, shops, and fish markets, this 1950s cabin, renovated in 2014, is your go-to vacation rental in Menemsha. The house is spacious with three bedrooms, a brightly lit dining area, a cozy sitting area, and a sunroom where you can lounge. You will also have access to a well-equipped kitchen, complete with an island and bar stools.
On the balcony, you’ll find another seating area and a gas grill for cooking meat and more. Moreover, the cottage features a spacious lawn and an outdoor shower.
Chilmark, Massachusetts, United StatesAccommodates: 6
Top guest reviews
Host:
whitney is a welcoming and responsive hostwhitney was a very responsive and communicative hostwhitney and walker are excellent hostsshe was always available kind and accommodatingwhitney is the perfect host her communication with us was excellentLocation:
lovely house in a great locationa lot to offer in a rare rental location and a perfectly allocated layoutgreat location away from the craziness of down island in the summerwhat a gem menemsha is a wonderful village you can walk toit’s a fantastic location for small children — walking distance to a shallow beach the galley and larson’sCleanliness:
cottage was clean and well appointedsuch a lovely house - picturesque and also feels clean and extremely well-maintainedthe house itself was clean comfortable and had everything we neededit had everything we needed was very clean and we were very comfortablevery clean space and the host were very responsive to all our needsRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
serene back deck to relax and plenty of room inside for a familythis is a charming comfortable cottageby far my most favorite outdoor shower the setting is idyllic and quintessential “up island” martha’s vineyardsuper charming house with a cozy reading nook and wild garden viewwe had such a lovely stay in the cottage it’s so charming cozy and super convenient to menemsha
3. Beachfront cottage (from USD 2873)
When in Oak Bluffs, book a stay in this peaceful cottage with beach access. This accommodation is perfect for guests who love the beach but want to avoid the crowd. Though it is a dog-friendly vacation rental, you should still inform ahead of time as the hosts only allow certain dog breeds.
Inside, you’ll have a dining area by the window with a sea view, a cozy sitting area, and a functional kitchen. Additionally, you’ll find several outdoor amenities, such as an outdoor shower, a bulkhead area, and more.
Oak Bluffs, Massachusetts, United StatesAccommodates: 2
Top guest reviews
Host:
anne was a wonderful host and very responsiveanne is a great host toomany thanks to our exellent hostsanne was an excellent host 10/10 would recommendanne and greg are fantastic hostsLocation:
an incredible location and beautiful cabinthe location was close to town but still quiet and peacefulwe received detailed location instructions and great local tipslocation makes it easy to get to vineyard haven oak bluffs or edgartown for shopping or food/drinksexcellent location direct access to the beachRead more reviewsCleanliness:
wonderful clean and stocked cottagethe place is clean and privatethe house was very clean and invitingit was very clean and right on the waterthe bed is very comfortable and everything is very clean
4. Charming cottage with private beach
If you’re looking for a peaceful abode away from the city’s noise and crowded touristy places, you’ll definitely want to book this vacation rental. It’s a picture-perfect secluded cottage surrounded by greenery, with private beach access. The property features large windows that flood the space with natural light, providing an unobstructed view of the outdoors. The open-plan living area offers various seating options, the dining setup is ideal for groups, and the modern kitchen is equipped with a stovetop and a microwave.
Additionally, you’ll find the outdoor amenities delightful and convenient, including a small deck with dining space and an outdoor shower.
Aquinnah, Massachusetts, United States
Top guest reviews
Host:
kyle is a great hostLocation:
loved the location loved the privacyRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
beautiful sound views bird watching tranquil peaceful cozy and clean amenities a well cared for house with heartfelt memorieswe had a wonderful time the views were unbeatable and the house was comfortable well equipped and very clean
5. Cozy cabin with views of the Atlantic
With easy access to the beach and a pond where you can kayak and boat, this cottage offers a dreamy vacation on Martha’s Vineyard. Wake up to the views of the Atlantic Ocean, step out onto the balcony with a coffee in hand, and take in the beautiful surroundings and the fresh beach air.
The two bedrooms and the open-floor space will make you feel at ease with the home-like features, including a functional kitchen where you can cook a full meal. If you plan to stay longer, the cottage is well-equipped with a dryer and a washer.
Chilmark, Massachusetts, United States
Top guest reviews
Location:
beautiful location and home in a remote part of the islandRead more reviewsCleanliness:
the cottage was very clean and nicely decorated with a well-equipped kitchen; owner was very responsive when needed
6. Tiny cottage in a peaceful neighborhood
Are you up for experiencing living in a tiny home? If so, you’ll surely adore this little cottage with a small deck to appreciate the outdoors and bask in the sunlight while having a cup of coffee. The vacation rental has a shabby and chic interior. Though it is small, it is complete with home conveniences, including a dining set-up, a desk, a sofa, and a functional kitchen with a Keurig Machine, a toaster, and a microwave oven.
Up in the loft, you’ll find an additional king-sized bed and a small window, making the place bright and airy. Another great feature of this property is its quiet neighborhood location, just a short drive away from many attractions, including Inkwell Beach.
Oak Bluffs, Massachusetts, United States
Top guest reviews
Host:
lori was a very accommodating and gracious host thanks so very muchlori was so great to work with and she was so helpful with everythingthe cottage was very comfortable and the host was great i couldn’t recommend this place enoughRead more reviewsLocation:
small adorable and close to downtown oak bluffsgreat outdoor shower and excellent locationwe had a car but you could easily walk to town and the beach if not
7. Chappy Butterfly Cottage
Located on Cross Chappy Trail, surrounded by trees and greenery, this lovely two-bedroom cottage is everything you need for your vacation to Martha’s Vineyard. The interior features a cathedral ceiling, two bedrooms, and a cozy open living room with two sofas, a dining setup, and a functional kitchen with a stovetop for cooking meals and a refrigerator to store food.
Outside, you’ll have a semi-screened porch and shared amenities, including a barbecue grill, outdoor furniture, and a shower. Also, you’ll love that it has easy access to many things, such as beaches and trails.
Edgartown, Massachusetts, United States
Top guest reviews
Host:
van was a very communicative friendly professional host among the best i’ve experiencedLocation:
definitely need a car for this locationwe split our time between chappy and mv equally and this was a great locationCleanliness:
very clean and well maintainedthe cottage was clean spacious and we loved the decorfantastic quiet clean little cottage in the heart of chappyRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
cozy cottage perfect for the combination of myself my husband and our adult son
8. Idle Hour Cottage
Live expensively in this designer cottage in Edgartown. With free Wi-Fi to keep you updated with everything, which may come in handy when you plan to work, this vacation rental has all your needs and wants covered.
The living area features modern and vintage furnishings and is seamlessly attached to the dining and kitchen space, creating a bright and well-organized atmosphere. The bedroom has luxury foam and bedding to help you sleep comfortably, while the bathroom is marbled and has a shower and a large bathtub.
Also, let’s not forget about the outdoors with its private deck that has dining and chaise lounges where you can unwind or have breakfast.
Edgartown, Massachusetts, United States
Top guest reviews
Host:
the owner was very helpful with the check in processbut the very best amenity is the owner herselfbarbara the owner was very helpfulthe owner has been very helpful the two times that we have stayed therefirst the owner is a gem she cared about our stay and paid particular attention to usRead more reviewsLocation:
this is a lovely cottage in a convenient location
9. Lovely waterfront cottage
A beautiful waterfront cottage with beach access, located right on Vineyard Haven Harbor, just across from Black Dog Tavern, this vacation rental is ideal for couples, solo travelers, or two friends looking for a comfortable place to stay.
The cottage has two decks with lounges and outdoor furniture, perfect for relaxing and watching the boats come and go at the marina. To ensure a comfortable stay, the cottage has a kitchen with an island where you can cook freely, a sitting area to cozy up, and a dining setup that can seat two.
Tisbury, Massachusetts, United States
Top guest reviews
Host:
the owner is greatmike the owner is very responsive cordial professional and has created a truly wonderful escapemike was great responsive and very helpfulvery responsive and friendly mike helped us a lot from the minute we made the reservationmike is an awesome host the views are incredible - we will be back sandra and billLocation:
it's a very quick walk from the ferry and super easy to rent a car nearbyit's a great location base for a martha's vineyard vacation - we can't wait to come backCleanliness:
every detail is well planned & executed- this is a very comfortable home beautifully decorated and very cleanRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
wonderful harbor views we loved the cottage very clean and comfortablethe house was truly perfect for us both extremely tasteful and extremely comfortable
10. Pet-friendly cabin with fenced yard
A laid-back cottage within walking distance of the beach and cycling paths, this home away from home is a lovely place to stay for people who are planning to come with their fur baby. The rental is pet-friendly and comes with your usual conveniences and more, including a fenced yard with outdoor furniture where you can unwind, a gas grill for barbecue nights, and an outdoor shower to help you shake off beach sands before going inside.
To top it all off, it has a laundry facility to keep your clothes clean and dry.
Edgartown, Massachusetts, United States
Top guest reviews
Host:
mike and sandy were wonderful hosts thank youLocation:
easy walk to the beach and very close to edgartownpleasant walk to both town and beachwe were able to walk to edgartown along a separated bike path which was lovelyCleanliness:
the place was clean and convenient for our tripthe décor was cozy and welcoming and pretty clean although a little bit mustyRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
my favorite feature of the cottage was the outdoor shower
Eat, stroll, and stay in Martha's Vineyard
Have a wonderful time exploring the beautiful island of Martha’s Vineyard. As you take more photos, make sure you also take the time to try the area’s many offerings, including swimming at their stunning beaches and savoring the delicious seafood dishes from the best restaurants on Martha’s Vineyard. For the best stay experience, choose any one of the rentals mentioned above.
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data