Bay Shore is a charming hamlet situated on the south shore of Long Island in Suffolk County, New York. Nestled against the picturesque Great South Bay, Bay Shore is a part of the beautiful Town of Islip. The town is famous for its lively and bustling downtown area, which offers local restaurants, shops, and cultural attractions. For avid readers and book lovers, Bay Shore-Brightwaters Public Library is a must-visit spot. Families can unwind and spend quality time together at Bay Shore Marina Park, with a playground, picnic areas, and a boat launch. Visitors looking for a beach day can head to the breathtaking Robert Moses State Park, which boasts miles of soft, sandy beaches, scenic hiking trails, and abundant recreational activities such as fishing and boating. If you’re a traveler seeking a memorable vacation getaway, check out our list of the top hotels in Bay Shore, New York.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on October 28, 2025.
1. Residence Inn Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex (from USD 197)
Residence Inn Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex is located in the heart of Central Islip, offering easy access to the nearby Bay Shore attractions. Guests will have access to a complimentary buffet breakfast every morning. The hotel welcomes families offering free cribs, on-site laundry facilities, and access to a grocery store.
Guests can take a refreshing dip in the indoor pool or work a sweat in the gym. The hotel offers a business center for business travelers and an on-site barbecue grill and picnic area for outdoor meals.
Residence Inn Long Island Islip\/Courthouse Complex
Address: 7 Courthouse Drive
8.41 km (5.3 mi) from Blydenburgh County Park
2. Marriott Melville Long Island (from USD 269)
Marriott Melville Long Island offers easy access to nearby Bay Shore attractions in the heart of the business district. Guests can enjoy a delicious cooked-to-order breakfast on weekends for an additional fee. Those looking to maintain their fitness routine can take advantage of the on-site gym. For ultimate relaxation, in-room massages are also available.
Families will appreciate the hotel’s free area shuttle, baby cribs, and laundry facilities. Additionally, business travelers have access to the 24-hour business center to stay connected and productive during their stay.
Marriott Melville Long Island
Address: 1350 Walt Whitman Road
17.91 km (11.2 mi) from Blydenburgh County Park
3. Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex (from USD 138)
Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex is near several local eateries and Bay Shore’s noteworthy attractions. Guests can indulge in a delicious breakfast for a nominal fee, ranging from 4.50 USD to 12 USD. The hotel also offers the convenience of complimentary on-site self-parking and a charming picnic area.
Fitness enthusiasts can stay active using the gym, while those seeking relaxation can dip in the indoor pool. The hotel also provides a business center for guests requiring a professional working environment.
Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip\/Courthouse Complex
Address: 11 Courthouse Dr.
8.39 km (5.3 mi) from Blydenburgh County Park
4. La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Islip - MacArthur Airport (from USD 109)
La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Islip - MacArthur Airport provides complimentary roundtrip airport shuttle service between 7am to 9pm. It also welcomes pets with an extra charge of 25 USD. Explore the nearby Bay Shore area, as the hotel offers complimentary on-site self-parking.
Start the day with the hotel’s complimentary continental breakfast. Families with young children can take advantage of free infant beds and extra beds, while fitness enthusiasts can use the hotel’s gym to stay on track with their workout routine.
La Quinta by Wyndham Islip - MacArthur Airport
Address: 10 Aero Rd
12.37 km (7.7 mi) from Blydenburgh County Park
5. Hyatt Regency Long Island (from USD 144)
Hyatt Regency Long Island is in the charming suburb of Hauppauge near Bay Shore local attractions. This luxurious hotel offers an indoor and outdoor pool catering to swimming guests. Additionally, the hotel provides exceptional wedding services and golf and tennis lessons on the premises.
Guests can indulge in the ultimate relaxation experience with in-room massages, while those seeking grand events can use the stunning ballroom. A video game console is available for indoor entertainment for fun nights with friends and families.
Hyatt Regency Long Island
Address: 1717 Motor Parkway
4.85 km (3.1 mi) from Blydenburgh County Park
6. Courtyard by Marriott Long Island MacArthur Airport (from USD 152)
Courtyard by Marriott Long Island MacArthur Airport is conveniently located in the charming Ronkonkoma. Guests can kick off their mornings in the on-site coffee shop and cafe while reading the complimentary newspapers from the lobby. Fitness enthusiasts can stay active with the hotel’s 24-hour gym.
Have a dip in the refreshing swimming pool while relaxing on a sunny day or exploring Bay Shore’s local attractions. Business travelers can stay productive at the 24-hour business center. The hotel offers a serene picnic area for those who enjoy outdoor gatherings.
Courtyard Long Island MacArthur Airport
Address: 5000 Express Drive South
10.4 km (6.5 mi) from Blydenburgh County Park
7. Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia (from USD 139)
Located in Islandia’s bustling business district, Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia extends a warm welcome to your furry friends with a pet fee of 50 USD per accommodation. Take advantage of the hotel’s convenient location and explore the nearby Bay Shore area, which boasts a variety of attractions and restaurants to suit all tastes.
Start your day with a delicious complimentary buffet breakfast, hit the gym for a quick workout or take a refreshing dip in the pool.
Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia
Address: 1600 Veterans Memorial Highway
4.46 km (2.8 mi) from Blydenburgh County Park
8. Residence Inn By Marriott Long Island Hauppauge (from USD 196)
Residence Inn By Marriott Long Island Hauppauge is in the business district of Hauppauge, offering convenient access to the nearby attractions of the Bay Shore area. Guests can start their day with a delicious and complimentary buffet breakfast, while fitness enthusiasts can maintain their workout routine at the 24-hour gym.
Families traveling with infants can use the crib, indulge in the snack bar, on-site laundry facilities, and business services cater to corporate travelers. Furthermore, the hotel has an electric car charging station and provides self-parking.
Residence Inn By Marriott Long Island Hauppauge
Address: 850 Veterans Memorial Hwy
2.32 km (1.5 mi) from Blydenburgh County Park
9. Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport (from USD 154)
Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport’s location near the airport and train station makes it a great place to begin exploring the Bay Shore area. Guests can start their day with a delicious cooked-to-order breakfast available for an additional fee. The hotel also features a restaurant where guests can enjoy a meal and a fitness center for those looking to stay active during their stay.
Business services are available for guests who need to stay connected while on the road. The on-site bar is ideal for relaxing and unwinding after a long day.
Hilton Garden Inn Islip\/MacArthur Airport
Address: 3485 Veterans Memorial Hwy
9.92 km (6.2 mi) from Blydenburgh County Park
10. Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge, an IHG Hotel (from USD 127)
Discover Bay Shore by staying in Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge, an IHG Hotel, close to the airport and train station. This establishment offers a complimentary continental breakfast to start your day. Take advantage of the 24-hour gym to keep up guests’ fitness routines or relax in the indoor pool after a long day of exploring.
The hotel also provides essential services for business travelers to help them stay productive. Moreover, enjoy the pleasant weather by picnicking in the hotel’s outdoor area.
Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge by IHG
Address: 2050 Express Dr S
3.22 km (2.0 mi) from Blydenburgh County Park
Discover Bay Shore's hidden charm
By staying in one of our top hotels in Bay Shore, New York, you can explore the unique charm of this community. Bay Shore has a rich history and culture, and immersing yourself in the local scene allows you to experience all this town offers.
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data