6 Best Kosher Restaurants In Monticello, New York

kosher restaurants in monticello ny
| 3 min read

Situated in Thomson in Sullivan County, Monticello is a charming little village that is famous for Monticello Raceway, an attraction that is known in all of America. Though no longer a raceway, it still attracts tourists who are into gambling and horse racing. If you’re into entertainment and luxurious attractions, Resorts World Catskills might pique your interest. Planning a vacation with family and friends during the winter season? Holiday Mountain Ski & Fun is a paradise that you might want to check out. For visiting or resident Jews, here is a list of the best kosher restaurants in Monticello, New York. Feel free to browse below.

1. Nature's Delight Pizza

Mmm... white pizza
Source: Photo by user jeffreyw used under CC BY 2.0

Looking for a fantastic kosher restaurant in Monticello where you can gorge on palatable eats? If so, you might want to check out Nature’s Delight Pizza on West Broadway. This charming, no-frills dining spot showcases a simple yet cozy restaurant with a homey ambiance. It offers delicious pizza specialties and some fish dishes that will surely leave you wanting more. Plus, it has a variety of drinks, from juices and milkshakes to coffee and sodas. This restaurant is open year-round, so you can have your fill of kosher foods any day of the year.

Nature's Delight Pizza

Address: 554 W Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701, United States

Website: Nature’s Delight Pizza

Opening hours: Mon - Thu: 11am - 9pm; Fri: 11am - 6pm; Sat: 10pm - 12am; Sun: 12am - 9pm

Visited this place?

2. Simply Sushi LLC

Sushi platter
Source: Photo by Wikimedia Commons user chidorian from Japan used under CC BY-SA 2.0

Craving some delicious sushi fares? Are you someone with Jewish ancestry or just a regular Tom with a specific diet? Here is another place in Monticello where you can enjoy kosher foods, including delicious sushi. Swing by Simply Sushi LLC and get your fill of this delicious Asian specialty. This restaurant makes their sushis using fresh, locally sourced ingredients. It has a wide range of sushi varieties, from salmon to tuna, red ocean roll, scallions, and even sashimi. Plus, this culinary business operates with a specific motto in mind, which is “If you don’t see what you’re looking for, ask us… we’ll make it!”

Simply Sushi LLC

Address: 343 E Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701, United States

Website: Simply Sushi LLC

Opening hours: Sun - Wed: 8am - 10pm; Thu: 8am - 11pm; Fri: 8am - 4pm (closed on Sat)

Visited this place?

3. The Flame

Smoked pork rib, pulled pork, brisket, collard greens, mac-n-cheese
Source: Photo by user T.Tseng used under CC BY 2.0

Need a quick fix for your hunger? Not in the mood for expensive restaurants that take years to serve orders? If so, why not drop by the Flame on East Broadway? This fast food kosher restaurant is your one-stop destination for immediate carb-loading needs. It is a small yet lovely dining spot with simple and minimalist decors. Also, it has two seating areas for customers: an indoor dining room and a more laidback outdoor seating area where guests can people watch. While here, you might want to try the bestselling fares, including rib steak, grilled chicken, pulled brisket, corned beef, and house salad.

The Flame

Address: 287 E Broadway #1, Monticello, NY 12701, United States

Website: The Flame

Opening hours: Sun - Wed: 12:30pm - 11pm; Thu: 12:30pm - 2am (closed on Fri & Sat)

Visited this place?

4. Two Guys Kosher Grill

Editor’s Note: Establishment is permanently closed.

If barbecue delights are what your palate craves for the day, you might want to check out the food and the vibes at Two Guys Kosher Grill. This place is located on East Broadway. It is a charming fast food joint in Downtown Monticello, close to businesses, recreational areas, and other restaurants. It is a fantastic place that offers signature burgers. Aside from tasty burgers, they also serve other specialties, including pulled brisket, poppers, nachos, pizza, schnitzel, kishke, wraps, and more. Plus, it showcases a modern and rustic dining place with a cozy atmosphere.

Two Guys Kosher Grill

Address: 277 E Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701, United States

Website: Two Guys Kosher Grill

Opening hours: Mon - Thu: 4pm - 11pm; Fri: 9am - 5pm; Sun: 1pm - 11pm (closed on Sat)

Visited this place?

5. West Broadway Kosher Pizza and Falafel

Source: Photo by user momo used under CC BY 2.0

Another exquisite pizza place you’ll find in the charming village of Monticello is West Broadway Kosher Pizza and Falafel. It is situated on 544 Broadway. Open all year round, this fantastic dining place features a lovely interior design with a nice ambiance and lots of natural light. It is clean, well-organized, and has a well-curated menu filled with delicious and hearty fares. You might want to sample their fresh pizza, falafel, tasty potato fries, and savory soups.

West Broadway Kosher Pizza and Falafel

Address: West, 544 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701, United States

Opening hours: Sun - Thu: 9am - 9pm; Fri: 9am - 6pm; Sat: 9:30am - 1pm

Visited this place?

6. Starlight Cafe Kosher Restaurant

Ya we know . Come see (and eat) for yourself open till 1 am . #food#summer#lunch#dinner#pasta#fish#salads#drinks#dessert#lake#theview#bliss#sun @starlight_cafe17

Posted by Starlight Cafe on Thursday, 10 August 2017

The last but not least of excellent kosher restaurants to check out in Monticello is Starlight Cafe Kosher Restaurant. Located on Starlight Road, this place is a haven for foodies. It showcases a captivating interior with bright furnishings and well-curated decors. For guests who want a more laidback dining experience, they can take advantage of the outdoor table settings that face lovely nature views. This establishment serves delicious American fares and fantastic drinks to pair with meals. To top it all off, everything is within a competitive price bracket.

Starlight Cafe Kosher Restaurant

Address: 299 Starlight Rd, Monticello, NY 12701, United States

Website: Starlight Cafe Kosher Restaurant

Opening hours: Sun - Wed: 10:30am - 8pm; Thu: 10:30am - 11pm; Fri: 10:30am - 2pm (closed on Sat)

Visited this place?

Check out these kosher restaurants in Monticello

Monticello is a charming village that is an ideal hideaway destination for tourists who want an escape from life in the concrete jungle. It has lots of parks and recreational areas where you can make lasting memories with your loved ones. Aside from that, it also has upscale attractions for people who want to have a good time. Plus, it has a multitude of restaurants and cafes, including kosher restaurants.

Visited this place?
Any must-sees we missed? Tell us about them in the comments section or write a post here to help out fellow travelers!
Disclosure: Trip101 selects the listings in our articles independently. Some of the listings in this article contain affiliate links.


Get Trip101 in your inbox

Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data

Nicole, a writer and traveler, also identifies herself as a free spirit with a wild heart. She is dedicated to telling authentic stories in a relatable manner. Nicole also enjoys exploring new,...Read more

 Want to contribute as a Local Expert?
Explore Monticello
Looking for accommodation?
Good things are meant to be shared!
Back to top
Visited any of these places? Click this button to activate our "Add a Tip" feature to share your experience.