Top 10 Historic Hotels In Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

1. Maxwell Mansion (from USD 252)

1/5 lake geneva historic hotels | maxwell mansion

2/5 maxwell mansion

3/5 maxwell mansion

4/5 maxwell mansion

5/5

Show all photos

This is a boutique property close to Main Street that was built by a prominent surgeon as a summer house in 1856. General Grant was once a guest here, and the walls of the mansion have been witness to the courtship of President Reagan and his wife. After changing hands several times, the property is now owned and run by an experienced hospitality couple.

This was the first property that was built in Lake Geneva and is surrounded by ancient oak trees and landscaped gardens. The luxurious rooms in the main mansion are decorated with timeless antiques, with additional rooms available in the Carriage House and Stables. Guests can also take a step back in time when they enter the Apothecary Bar where each cocktail is handcrafted for each individual.

2. Baker House Hotel (from USD 245)

1/5 lake geneva historic hotels | baker house hotel

2/5 baker house hotel

3/5 baker house hotel

4/5 baker house hotel

5/5

Show all photos

Baker House Hotel dates back to 1885 and is spread across 17,000 sq ft (1,579.35 sq m). It is a protected property where guests can take a look at the ornate handiwork that has been carefully preserved over the years. The hotel also includes 13 fireplaces, each surrounded by handcrafted floor-to-ceiling mantles.

After a day spent on the lake or exploring the nearby trails, guests can sip on exquisite seasonal cocktails. The property also organizes weekend events and festive menus throughout the year. Additionally, while the lake is best explored during the summer, Baker House Hotel can be enjoyed year-round.

Nearby historic hotels

3. The Pfister Hotel (from USD 276)

This Milwaukee hotel has been serving guests with grace and exemplary service since 1893. The Pfister Hotel has the honor of holding the largest collection of Victorian art by any hotel in the world. Guests can gain in-depth knowledge about these pieces by booking a tour with the Artist-in-Residence.

The signature rooms offer personalized stays with a pillow menu and customized sleep amenities. These offer a city or Lake Michigan view. For the best views, guests cannot go wrong with the premier room, which is located on the top floor of the tower. Further, if you wish to stay in the original hotel, make sure to book the rooms located in the historical section of the hotel.

4. Hilton Milwaukee City Center (from USD 169)

1/5 lake geneva historic hotels | hilton milwaukee city center

2/5 hilton milwaukee city center

3/5 hilton milwaukee city center

4/5 hilton milwaukee city center

5/5

Show all photos

A glittering chandelier and ornate gold columns welcome guests into the lobby of this Hilton property in Milwaukee. Designed in the Art Deco style, the property continues to retain many of its original features dating back to 1927. Business travelers will love its proximity to Baird Center and the Skywalk at the hotel, which provides a direct link to the convention center.

Despite the age of the property, the hotel is exceptionally maintained and has been upgraded to include complimentary Wi-Fi and air conditioning in all guest rooms. Hilton Milwaukee City Center also includes an on-site Starbucks, which is ideal for those who cannot begin their day without their favorite brew.

5. The Brewhouse Inn & Suites (from USD 149)

1/5 lake geneva historic hotels | the brewhouse inn & suites

2/5 the brewhouse inn & suites

3/5 the brewhouse inn & suites

4/5 the brewhouse inn & suites

5/5

Show all photos

Located within the Brewery District, this property is housed within the original Pabst Brewery. The original copper brewing kettles and a stained glass image of the patron saint of beer, King Gambrinus, are still part of the hotel.

This is an all-suite property that features a variety of layouts to accommodate the original design of the building. Guests booking a stay at The Brewhouse Inn & Suites can choose from studios as well as one- and two-bedroom suites. The headboard and the tables in the suites have been built using wood from the property that dates back to the 1880s.

6. Dubbel Dutch (from USD 228)

1/5 dubbel dutch

2/5 dubbel dutch

3/5 dubbel dutch

4/5 dubbel dutch

5/5

Show all photos

Originally an abandoned English Renaissance-style double house, the property was saved by the city’s Historic Society and today welcomes visitors from all over the country. The hotel is designed by prominent local architects George Bowman Ferry and Alfred C. Clas. Additionally, Dubbel Dutch may be a historic property, but its facilities have been upgraded to keep up with modern times.

Each of the distinct guest rooms not only varies in size but also in shape and architectural details. Many include the original hardwood floors, while all feature large windows and a custom backlit vanity. This 17-room property can also be rented out for a weekend and can easily accommodate 75 guests.

7. Hilton Garden Inn Milwaukee Downtown (from USD 130)

This downtown Hilton property is part of the historic Loyalty Building, dating back to 1886. Guests are a two-minute walk away from N Riverwalk Way, from which they can appreciate the beauty of the Milwaukee River.

The Social American Tavern is an on-site restaurant that features a weekday Happy Hour and live music on Thursday nights. A 24-hour snack shop is also located in the hotel. What’s more, the prime location means there are also numerous dining venues in the immediate neighborhood.

8. The Iron Horse Hotel (from USD 314)

This popular boutique hotel was once a mattress factory, which was followed by its usage as a cold storage unit. The Iron Horse Hotel sought inspiration from local and American elements to create a property that is much loved by locals and tourists alike. Guest rooms here feature photographs that have been hand-embellished by the renowned local artist Charles Dwyer. Rare superhero art pieces by the late Jerry Pfeil also grace the walls of Branded Bar.

Guests can taste the rich flavors of a seasonal American menu at Ash Hearth and Bar, which relies on an open fire to prepare delicious plates of meats and vegetables. The Iron Horse Hotel is also quite popular with bikers as it provides covered bike parking, an on-call repairman, and special storage space for riding amenities.

9. The Knickerbocker on the Lake (from USD 117)

1/5 the knickerbocker on the lake

2/5 the knickerbocker on the lake

3/5 the knickerbocker on the lake

4/5 the knickerbocker on the lake

5/5

Show all photos

Enjoy an urban summer from this historic property steps away from Lake Michigan. Guests can easily walk down to the waterfront Juneau Park and Veterans Park. Not only is the location ideal for tourists, but locals can also book it for an excellent staycation in the city.

The Knickerbocker on the Lake has maintained a steady presence since the 1920s, even while the city and the surrounding neighborhood underwent transformative changes. It is one of the few original structures still remaining in Milwaukee and finds a mention in the National Register of Historic Places.

10. Hotel Metro (from USD 437)

This luxurious property offers guests a chance to experience the Art Deco charm and elegance of the 1930s. The plush guest room evokes a sense of calm and provides a soothing space to retreat to at the end of the day. Further, the carpeted rooms are designed to accommodate both business and leisure travelers and include ergonomic workspaces and family rooms.

Despite the building being nearly a century old, many of the rooms at Hotel Metro are designed for disabled travelers. These feature wide doors, hearing and visual aid kits as well as audible and visual detectors.

Escape to Lake Geneva for the perfect break

It is easy to understand the long-standing popularity of Lake Geneva as soon as you drive into the city and witness its hiking routes, state parks, and more. Make the most of your stay by using a decadent historic property close to the lake. These are some of the top historic hotels in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin, if you are looking to take a step back in time.