Top 10 Mansion Rentals In Long Island, New York - Updated 2024

Contributing Writer
| 5 min read

As its home to many famous destinations in New York, it is no wonder that tourists from around the globe stop by Long Island when visiting the state. It is home to The Hamptons, known for housing many affluent celebrities, breathtaking homes, fine restaurants, and scenic beach views. Aside from that, you will also find Macari Vineyards on Long Island. This attraction is ideal for wine connoisseurs as it offers tours, wine tastings, and even lunch. Meanwhile, for travelers who love thrills, The Adventure Park at Long Island is the place to be. You must also remember to explore Jones Beach State Park for a relaxing experience. For a memorable trip in luxurious accommodation, read on for a list of the top mansion rentals in Long Island, New York.

We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) host status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on May 31, 2024.

1. Luxurious estate house with a beach area; Greenport (from USD 2299)

This vacation rental will provide you with a private 7-ac (2.8-ha) slice of Menantic Peninsula, adorned with greenery and picture-perfect water views. Just like the scenery, the estate house’s design is pleasing to the eyes, with modern Scandinavian influences. It showcases an all-white interior with oak floors, an open-plan layout, and floor-to-ceiling windows that allow patrons to admire the magical views in comfort. The kitchen is a paradise for culinary enthusiasts, featuring high-end stainless steel appliances and marble countertops.

You can spend mornings frolicking on the beach and afternoons admiring sunset views from the seaside hot tub. Nights are best spent stargazing on the balconies.

Stayed at this property?
Shelter Island, New York, United States
34.68 km (21.6 mi) from Splish Splash Water Park
PRIVATE VACATION HOME 8 Guests 4 Bedrooms 4 Bathrooms

Top guest reviews
the hot tub was amazing clean and fresh and simple to operate
the house was spotless with fresh flowers left for us by the host
from the onset and throughout our stay the hosts made us feel welcome and addressed any questions we had
aimee is a great host and this is a wonderful wonderful beautifully decorated extremely comfortable house
Read more reviews

2. Newly redesigned accommodation with outdoor fire pit; Eastport (from USD 4736)

This newly redesigned and spacious abode is an excellent getaway for big groups of travelers. Aside from featuring well-appointed rooms with pool or bay views, the rental also comes with relaxing decor complemented by live indoor plants. Preparing meals are easy here - thanks to the huge, fully functional kitchen. Guests can enjoy their breakfast on the kitchen island or the dining area.

Moreover, you will hardly ever be bored here. There are indoor games to engage in in the game room, a Smart TV for movie marathons, a stereo to play your favorite music on, and books. Outside, there is a heated pool to enjoy on sunny days. And if you feel like roasting marshmallows, the outdoor fire pit is at your disposal.

Stayed at this property?
Eastport, New York, United States
11.66 km (7.3 mi) from Splish Splash Water Park
PRIVATE VACATION HOME 24 Guests 11 Bedrooms 11 Bathrooms

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
plenty of room to enjoy each other we had 6 couples and plan to go back again
it was perfect for our needs with amble kitchen space to share cooking and cleaning duties
jordyn and the crew were wonderfully responsive and accommodating
highly recommended to all a++ host jhoanna was amazing
jhoanna and the owner are very accommodating and responsive
excellent location with nice views
fit my family and friends very well spacious and good location
Read more reviews

3. Renovated 250-year-old mansion; Southold (from USD 760)

In a stroke of genius, this 250-year-old retreat was blessed with a renovation to provide visitors with a characterful, comfortable, and convenient home away from home. With classy furnishings, including bright walls, wooden floors, and stunning chandeliers, this accommodation is a sight for sore eyes. Guests can expect a well-appointed kitchen, where they can show off their cooking skills, and two fireplaces, around which they can gather around with their loved ones on cold winter days.

Resort-inspired amenities are in store for patrons, as well. While the swimming pool is only a seasonal treat, the hot tub is accessible year-round. The fire pit area is the perfect spot to cap off the day, sharing s'mores and laughter.

Stayed at this property?
Peconic, New York, United States
25.99 km (16.2 mi) from Splish Splash Water Park
PRIVATE VACATION HOME 11 Guests 0 Bedrooms 4 Bathrooms

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
spent a lovely weekend with a few friends and thoroughly enjoyed the pool and other amenities
the pool hot tub and fire place were great
everything was very clean and organized
the pool and hottub were clean and beautiful
everything was clean and ready for our stay
we had the greatest time amazing host and amazing property
the owner was easy to communicate with and very responsive with any of our needs
andrew was friendly and accommodating
andrew was very pleasant and informative
the location was perfect for what we wanted to do
the hot tub was a great bonus and the location is close to everything on the north fork
it was a great location to easily get around and loved the amenities offered
Read more reviews

4. Stunning oceanfront property with a movie theater; Montauk (from USD 15000)

Beautiful surroundings and lovely amenities will greet you in this stunning oceanfront property in Montauk. Here, guests can enjoy waking up to breathtaking beach scenes and falling asleep to the soothing sounds of the crashing waves. Aside from that, the rental boasts glass windows, high ceilings, and wood floors that give the place a warm and inviting ambiance. In addition, there’s also a wet bar in the living room, a library, and a chef’s kitchen for your use. A movie theater is another highlight of this accommodation.

Additional amenities include an outdoor pool and a spa with beautiful views. An outdoor shower and surfboards are also available for the use of beach bums.

Stayed at this property?
Montauk, New York, United States
63.63 km (39.6 mi) from Splish Splash Water Park
PRIVATE VACATION HOME 10 Guests 5 Bedrooms 7 Bathrooms

Top guest reviews
great location near montauk shops and restaurants
great location near montauk shops and restaurants
an amazing experience a beautiful location a wonderful spot
Read more reviews

5. Upscale vacation rental with an outdoor pool; Tuckahoe (from USD 1250)

This vacation rental is a dreamy retreat, curated with manicured grounds, Gambrel design, and top-of-the-line facilities. From the gourmet kitchen to two fireplaces, every detail in this not-so-humble abode is well thought out to provide comfort and luxury. The formal dining room makes sharing meals extra special, and the basement offers a bar, inviting you to wind down with some late-night drinks.

On a fine sunny day, the landscaped yard with a lovely outdoor pool will entice you to spend the time playing in the water and dosing on vitamin D.

Stayed at this property?
Southampton, New York, United States
26.0 km (16.2 mi) from Splish Splash Water Park
PRIVATE VACATION HOME 10 Guests 5 Bedrooms 5 Bathrooms

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
i enjoyed cooking in the gourmet kitchen making local cuisine
the house was immaculate well stocked with a picture perfect gorgeous pool
this is a beautiful clean and well stocked house that was perfect for our extended family
this is a beautiful clean and well stocked house that was perfect for our extended family
the owner was incredibly helpful and available too
lori was a gracious host and easy to communicate with
lori was responsive kind and extremely thoughtful
Read more reviews

6. Family-friendly estate house with outdoor play area; Hampton Bays (from USD 1224)

Families and friends might find this Southampton Estate an ideal vacationing spot during the holiday. It is family-friendly and has lots of space for everyone to spread around. The rental is nestled in a 3-ac (1.21-ha) land that overlooks the bay, providing guests with plenty of outdoor activities. You can play volleyball, tennis, or basketball here for group entertainment. An outdoor play set is also available for the kids’ enjoyment.

Other noteworthy amenities to look forward to include the heated pool, hot tub, and multiple fireplaces.

Stayed at this property?
Hampton Bays, New York, United States
16.75 km (10.5 mi) from Splish Splash Water Park
PRIVATE VACATION HOME 15 Guests 5 Bedrooms 4 Bathrooms

Top guest reviews
megan was super responsive and quickly handled any issues that came up
Read more reviews

7. Breakwater Estate; Mattituck (from USD 1685)

Tucked in lush greenery and with proximity to beaches and vineyards, Breakwater Estate ticks off all the boxes of your ideal vacation rental checklist. The setting is peaceful and relaxing, and the house has been beautifully renovated to provide a luxurious stay. Apart from standard home fittings, such as a fully stocked kitchen, comfortable bedrooms, and pristine bathrooms, it provides resort-inspired add-ons. Patrons can relish a sunroom with fitness equipment, a heated swimming pool, and a year-round hot tub.

For your convenience, a housekeeper can be provided for you on request.

Stayed at this property?
Mattituck, New York, United States
16.82 km (10.5 mi) from Splish Splash Water Park
PRIVATE VACATION HOME 14 Guests 6 Bedrooms 4 Bathrooms

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
plenty of room and an amazing relaxing setting
living room family room and kitchen were large and spacious - perfect for gathering together
kim is an absolute joy of a host
kim our host and her daughter made sure we had everything we needed for our stay
the owner was quick to help and provided recommendations and amenities for a nice easy weekend
the location was central to many great things in mattituck including groceries farms vineyards etc
i was with a large group of close friends and this house was perfect for us
Read more reviews

8. The Ocean House; Mount Sinai (from USD 1744)

From the perfectly placed setting, just steps away from the beach, to the stunning interior design, this vacation rental has all the makings of a fabulous hideaway. With a state-of-the-art gourmet kitchen, you will be enticed to unleash your inner master chef. Your family can wait for delicious meals in the living room while admiring magical views of the Sound or enjoy the fire pit on the deck while relishing fresh air. In your free time, you may take advantage of the sauna for a more relaxing time. An outdoor shower is also available for when you return from the beach with sandy toes.

This upscale dwelling is pet-friendly, delighting fur parents.

Stayed at this property?
Mount Sinai, New York, United States
24.85 km (15.5 mi) from Splish Splash Water Park
46 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 5 Beds 8 Guests 5 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 8

Top guest reviews
the house is spacious and impeccably clean
a lovely spot prefectly clean house great views
it is so charming the sound itself was warm and clean
the hosts are friendly attentive and responsive
but best of all… was carley our host
you won't be disappointed with this beach house and its hosts
the location is great with plenty of things to do and shopping nearby
amazing stay in a gorgeous location
peaceful beach stay and close to the city
this is a five-star weekend getaway beachfront close to restaurants and peaceful
really enjoyed staying at erik’s place for a family reunion
Read more reviews

9. Gorgeous waterfront home; East Patchogue (from USD 1000)

Million-dollar views of the bay, luxurious amenities, and an idyllic setting await you in this airy and bright mansion. It has a spotless interior boasting pristine white walls, wood floors, and floor-to-ceiling windows in the living area that offer scenic outdoor views. Aside from that, there is a long expansive outdoor pool, perfect for morning and evening laps. On one side of the pool, guests can lounge and watch the sunset while enjoying a glass of wine.

The best part? You can bring your fur babies and take advantage of the spacious backyard.

Stayed at this property?
East Patchogue, New York, United States
28.04 km (17.5 mi) from Splish Splash Water Park
45 reviews   Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 5 Beds 6 Guests 5 Bedrooms 4 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 6

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the beds and furniture are comfortable
the amenities are great and we definitely love the pool and balcony
every bedroom and bathroom are decorated beautifully with top knotch amenities (baths showers etc)
even on a hot day the fans make it incredibly comfortable
the rooms had splendid views and the house was exceedingly comfortable
everything was very clean and beautifully decorated
place was very clean and kitchen was stocked
it was spotlessly clean beautifully decorated and well stocked with everything we needed
this house is amazing it is very clean and has plenty of space and security
all of the bedrooms kitchen and bathrooms were impeccably clean
she is an excellent host
the host was excellent and very responsive to all of our questions
the host responds quickly and is very nice
elizabeth is a great host who resonds quickly if you have any questions or issues
you can certainly tell she takes pride in her home as well as being a host
beautiful house in a stunning location on the water
this would be a great location for a family trip
perfection this place is perfect
the location was terrific as we were only 3 miles from the beautiful little town of bellport
elizabeth’s place was a great location to spend the weekend
Read more reviews

10. Massive property with an Olympic-sized pool; Shelter Island (from USD 1495)

This massive and unique dwelling on Shelter Island is a perfect retreat amid lush greenery. French doors, sleek walkways, and white walls dominate its interior. It has all the ingredients needed for a memorable getaway. From entertainment facilities to relaxation options, this place is brimming with attractive offerings.

While you are preparing a healthy meal in the gourmet kitchen, others can enjoy a movie in the theater room. Indulging in a dip in the Olympic-sized pool or a soak in the shaded hot tub is also ideal after a long, tiring day. To cap off the night, enjoy some wine by the fireplace in the sprawling living room.

Stayed at this property?
Shelter Island, New York, United States
35.39 km (22.0 mi) from Splish Splash Water Park
203 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 6 Beds 12 Guests 6 Bedrooms 5 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 12

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
we loved the view from the living room that looked out onto the deck
gorgeous home with incredible backyard filled with gorgeous pool hot tub deck putting green and large grass-filled yard
my family loved the large dining tables that allowed us all to sit together for meals
i'm sure the huge pool would be a treat in the summer
the room is so large and most couples enjoy the extra space
very clean and responsive host communication
house was very clean and spacious
it was spotless and even more gorgeous in person
the home was exactly as advertised and was very clean
incredibly beautiful & clean home perfectly laid out for large families and lots of different common areas to hang
puja was a lovely host
she was a great host overall and made sure our group enjoyed all aspects of our stay
puja is an amazing host
puja was an excellent host and was quick to respond to any questions during our stay
puja was responsive and an amazing host
we preferred it due to the easy access to the kitchen and being close to the fireplace
lastly great location close to beaches the supermarket and the state park
shelter island is a great destination and this house is within close reach of it all
puja’ place was a perfect hide-away on shelter island
Read more reviews

Experience a luxurious stay in Long Island

Beautiful things await you in Long Island. Pristine coastlines, exciting food scenes, and must-visit attractions are only a few things to look forward to here. You won’t even have a problem looking for a place to stay, as Long Island offers many lovely accommodations. Feel free to book any of the private dwellings listed above for a lavish stay.

Any must-sees we missed? Tell us about them in the comments section or write a post here to help out fellow travelers!
Disclosure: Trip101 selects the listings in our articles independently. Some of the listings in this article contain affiliate links.


Get Trip101 in your inbox

Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data

She is a lover of life and a very optimistic person. She thinks of herself as a vessel of a billion possibilities, which can harness limitless potential. Trying new experiences, going places she's...Read more

 Want to contribute as a Local Expert?
Explore Long Island
Good things are meant to be shared!
Back to top
Visited any of these places? Click this button to activate our "Add a Tip" feature to share your experience.