Sapphire blue waves and sandy beaches surrounding the Atlantic Ocean and Block Island Sound, it is to no one’s surprise that Montauk, New York, remains one of America’s top destinations for a seaside vacation. With a two-centuries-old lighthouse overarching the Long Island town, one is free to explore scenic views through intricate nature trails and seal-watching walks for a rejuvenating experience. Summer is best spent partying downtown where its thriving music and arts scene is enriched with bustling restaurants, pubs and bars to uplift the party spirit. With luxurious accommodations in abundance, Montauk promises a beach vacation beyond your wildest dreams. Read on to discover the best hotels in Montauk, New York, awaiting your arrival today!
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on December 20, 2024.
Why Trust Trip101?
✅ Over 50,000 articles reviewed and published by our experienced team
✅ Over 50 years of combined experience researching, writing and reviewing travel articles
✅ Over 40,000 hours spent on research and fact-checking from credible sources (last year’s data)
✅ Optimizing content from data-driven insights collected directly from users on our platform
✅ Focus on authentic and up-to-date information by collaborating with local guides, global travelers and other industry experts
✅ Long-standing partnerships with credible brands like Airbnb, Booking.com, Agoda, Expedia, GetYourGuide, Viator, RVShare and more
✅ Full disclosure on any partnerships or sponsored content
Trip101’s team of writers, editors, and content managers oversees the publication of all travel content, including destination guides, accommodation recommendations, and travel tips. They have extensive experience in the travel industry and no content, written or visual, gets published without a review. Many of our team’s work has also been featured in Travel+Leisure, National Today, The Indian Express, The Telegraph (India), Robb Report, The Adventure Handbook, Tripoto, Korea Tourism Organization, and Korean Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism. Some of them are also members of professional organizations like the Society of American Travel Writers and the International Travel Writers and Photographers Alliance.
Each member of the team follows Trip101's methodology and strict editorial guidelines to ensure accuracy, authenticity, and relevance.
1. Montauk Manor (from USD 169)
Built on the dream of multi-millionaire Carl Fisher in 1925, Montauk Manor is a splendid sight to behold with its 140 fully furnished condominium apartments (ranging from studios to three bedrooms) that overlook the Atlantic Ocean, Gardiner’s Bay and Block Island Sound from the grassy hilltops. While preserving its historical roots and years of quality service, the Manor is also equipped with modern amenities such as outdoor and indoor pools, spas, meeting rooms, wireless connectivity and tennis courts for a truly luxurious experience. Guests will be glad to know that the hotel also offers exclusive beach services (Hampton Beach Service) for easy booking of quality beaching equipment at Hampton Beach.
Montauk Manor
Address: 236 Edgemere Street
47.34 km (29.5 mi) from Foxwoods Resort Casino
2. The Montauk Beach House
Delicious on-site restaurant with a casual vibe. Varied menu with standout dishes like truffle pizza.
Reasonable pricing for the location and amenities offered.
Conveniently located within walking distance to the beach and town center. Safe and vibrant neighborhood.
Beautiful pool area with attentive service. Complimentary bicycles and texting feature for guests' convenience.
Being a stone’s throw away from Downtown Montauk, The Montauk Beach House is a top destination for locals and tourists alike who fell in love with its proximity to the Atlantic Ocean surf beaches and the thriving downtown scene. With seasonal events designed for the private and public, this hidden oasis is well-equipped with rustic charm and modern convenience. One can choose to stay at either of its exquisitely designed lofts, terraces and bungalows, and soak in its private pool to soothe the body’s aches away. The Montauk Beach House even has a bar and grill available to keep the summer heat going.
The Montauk Beach House
Address: 55 South Elmwood Avenue
48.93 km (30.5 mi) from Foxwoods Resort Casino
3. Haven Montauk (from USD 470)
If you are seeking to relax in a quiet abode amid the sound of crashing waves, Haven Montauk is the best option available. A boutique motel located on the harbour, the bay beach surrounds Haven Montauk for a serene ambience that avoids the commotion of the city and its bustling engines. Instead, one gets treated to the sight of fishermen hauling their harvest against the backdrop of a vermillion sunset.
Haven Montauk
Address: 533 West Lake Drive
44.49 km (27.7 mi) from Foxwoods Resort Casino
4. Beachcomber at Montauk (from USD 286)
With oceanic views on private balconies, outdoor heated pools and saunas, The Beachcomber Resort is an ideal destination for families and is located across the road from downtown. Outfitted with 88 rooms with kitchens that range from studios to two-bedroom suites, the hotel even ensures lower level studios are handicapped accessible in consideration of their diverse guests. The resort is famed for its kid-friendly amenities and meticulous service throughout the years. They even newly released a COVID-19 Guest Toolkit to protect the safety of their guests during this tumultuous time. With The Beachcomber Resort striving to meet your every need, a luxurious vacation is practically guaranteed.
Beachcomber Resort at Montauk
Address: 727 Old Montauk
49.45 km (30.8 mi) from Foxwoods Resort Casino
5. Sun and Sound Montauk (from USD 137)
Get treated to spectacular views of the setting sun from the sundecks at Sun and Sound Montauk as you picnic or barbeque under the crimson hues with your loved ones. Sun and Sound Montauk offer units from one room suites to deluxe suites that come with lofts and modern kitchen equipment which makes it ideal for guests seeking to prepare their meals. Being a short stroll away from Montauk Harbour, Sun and Sound Montauk is a perfect avenue to experience the quiet charm of the seaside hamlet without missing out on too much fun. Fishing boats, fine dining, shopping and outdoor concerts, for instance, are easily accessible by foot in a matter of minutes. The village of Montauk is also just a short drive away.
Sun and Sound Montauk
Address: 22 Soudview Drive
44.43 km (27.7 mi) from Foxwoods Resort Casino
6. A Wave Inn (from USD 583)
An ocean escapade on land - this former sentence is apt in describing what exactly A Wave Inn has to offer. With luxurious pools, WiFi and refrigerators from a penthouse to a studio plus suite, A Wave Inn delivers quality service and entertainment with it being a foot’s away from all the action in Montauk town. Located on the peninsular near oceanic waters, the unparalleled scenery and luxurious amenities make this inn too good of a steal to be missed!
A Wave Inn - Montauk
Address: 32 Elmwood Avenue
49.07 km (30.5 mi) from Foxwoods Resort Casino
7. Gosman's Culloden House (from USD 575)
Gosman’s Culloden House is the pinnacle of a luxurious hotel experience. Not only do guests have access to Wi-Fi throughout the premise, but they also get to receive free self-parking and express check-in and check-out services. Each of the 34 guestrooms is uniquely decorated and furnished with iPod docks, flat-screen televisions, balconies and private yards. Famed attractions such as the Star Island Yacht Club, Montauk Marine Basin, Gin Beach, Montauk Downs State Park, Second House Museum and the Marina are also easily accessible from the hotel.
The Sunset Montauk
Address: 540 West Lake Drive
44.49 km (27.7 mi) from Foxwoods Resort Casino
Take a break in Montauk
Everyone deserves to be treated like royalty on vacation. Whether you are seeking a serene solitude in nature or a swim in the cerulean blue waves, Montauk is outfitted with various accommodations guaranteed to fulfil your every single need. From the cinematic sunset viewed from a private balcony to the live music and arts a doorstep away from town, a luxurious experience awaits you here at the sandy shores of Montauk. Don’t hesitate to book a room today.
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data
