Montauk, New York, is a charming and popular tourist attraction found at the tip of Long Island’s South Fork peninsula. Whether you are going there for work or to take a break from the noise of the city, you will surely have a good time. Indulge in activities such as surfing at the beach, visiting the six state parks, and meeting other people by hanging out in different bars. A landmark in this hamlet is Montauk Point Lighthouse, a historic site that offers sweeping views that everyone must visit. Going to Montauk is also an opportunity for you to take your time and focus on your relaxation. Staying in a hotel that gives you access to a pool could be your chance to add luxury and leisure to your stay. For that, continue reading below for the best hotels with pool in Montauk, New York.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and access to pool. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on November 21, 2024.
Why Trust Trip101?
✅ Over 50,000 articles reviewed and published by our experienced team
✅ Over 50 years of combined experience researching, writing and reviewing travel articles
✅ Over 40,000 hours spent on research and fact-checking from credible sources (last year’s data)
✅ Optimizing content from data-driven insights collected directly from users on our platform
✅ Focus on authentic and up-to-date information by collaborating with local guides, global travelers and other industry experts
✅ Long-standing partnerships with credible brands like Airbnb, Booking.com, Agoda, Expedia, GetYourGuide, Viator, RVShare and more
✅ Full disclosure on any partnerships or sponsored content
Trip101’s team of writers, editors, and content managers oversees the publication of all travel content, including destination guides, accommodation recommendations, and travel tips. They have extensive experience in the travel industry and no content, written or visual, gets published without a review. Many of our team’s work has also been featured in Travel+Leisure, National Today, The Indian Express, The Telegraph (India), Robb Report, The Adventure Handbook, Tripoto, Korea Tourism Organization, and Korean Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism. Some of them are also members of professional organizations like the Society of American Travel Writers and the International Travel Writers and Photographers Alliance.
Each member of the team follows Trip101's methodology and strict editorial guidelines to ensure accuracy, authenticity, and relevance.
1. The Montauk Beach House
Delicious on-site restaurant with a casual vibe. Varied menu with standout dishes like truffle pizza.
Reasonable pricing for the location and amenities offered.
Conveniently located within walking distance to the beach and town center. Safe and vibrant neighborhood.
Beautiful pool area with attentive service. Complimentary bicycles and texting feature for guests' convenience.
The Montauk Beach House is situated in the heart of Downtown Montauk. This hotel gives allows you to access their outdoor pool and enjoy the beach, which is just a block away. Each room comes with WiFi and TV access and chic furnishings. Aside from relaxing within the comfort of your room, you can also hang around on the property and enjoy the special events that this hotel offers. If you are planning to stay here for the summer season, you’re in luck as this hotel has lounge areas where you can interact with other people. They keep their summer calendar busy with entertaining activities, promising you a fulfilling stay.
The Montauk Beach House
Address: 55 South Elmwood Avenue
8.3 km (5.2 mi) from Montauk Point Lighthouse Museum
2. Ocean Colony Beach and Tennis Club (from USD 750)
This hotel is a great option whether you are looking for a place to relax or enjoy sports activities. Ocean Colony Beach and Tennis Club has two tennis courts and a clubhouse with ping pong and table games. If you choose to relax, they have an outdoor pool and a private beach area. The hotel’s rooms are equipped with a TV and a private bathroom. They also have also terraces and free WiFi if ever you want to stay inside the rooms.
Ocean Colony Beach & Tennis Club
Address: 2004 Montauk Highway, Beachfront, Montauk (NY), United States, NY 11930
17.73 km (11.1 mi) from Montauk Point Lighthouse Museum
3. Hermitage Amagansett (from USD 838)
If you are the kind of tourist who enjoys fitness activities wherever you go, you’ll enjoy your stay in Hermitage Amagansett. This hotel provides two tennis courts for people who love sports, a fitness center, and a heated pool with a spa where you can relax after a long day full of fun activities. The hotel offers 52 studio suites with full kitchens, WiFi, and a private deck. Daily housekeeping is also available. To top it all off, you will have free access to the private beach where you can enjoy various activities under the sun.
The Hermitage at Napeague
Address: 2148 Montauk Highway, Beachfront, Montauk (NY), United States, NY 11930
17.72 km (11.1 mi) from Montauk Point Lighthouse Museum
4. Haven Montauk (from USD 470)
Located close to Gin Beach, Haven Montauk is truly a heaven for tourists who love to walk by the bay. From here, you can go to the bay in four minutes. This hotel also offers beach parking passes and an outdoor pool that you can enjoy under the sun. All rooms are provided with a TV and WiFi for your entertainment. If you are planning to enjoy a night activity, they have a fire pit where you can get warm and comfortable with your friends or family.
Haven Montauk
Address: 533 West Lake Drive
7.11 km (4.5 mi) from Montauk Point Lighthouse Museum
5. Beachcomber Resort (from USD 286)
If you are a beach lover and want to experience waking up in the morning with a beautiful view of the ocean, Beachcomber Resort is the hotel for you. This hotel will provide you the relaxation you need as each room has its own private balcony, perfect for unwinding and looking at the horizon. You can also make use of the cable TV to watch your favorite shows and WiFi to stay connected online. You can take a dip in their pool and sauna or play on their tennis court. This hotel is just within walking distance from the town, so you don’t need to worry about transportation if you are planning to go there.
Beachcomber Resort at Montauk
Address: 727 Old Montauk
9.76 km (6.1 mi) from Montauk Point Lighthouse Museum
6. The Montauk Soundview (from USD 592)
The views this hotel offers will surely leave you in awe. The Montauk Soundview is only 0.7 miles (1.1 kilometers) from Gin Beach, and it has access to a private beach area. Here, you can enjoy wonderful views and access to the outdoor pool. Each room here is air-conditioned and comes with balconies that allow you to look outside. You can choose among a variety of room types such as studios, one- and two-bedroom units, two-bedroom cottages, or if you are with your whole family, a spacious 1,100-square-feet (102-square-meters) two-bedroom house unit. All rooms have access to WiFi.
The Montauk Soundview
Address: 6 Soundview Drive
7.18 km (4.5 mi) from Montauk Point Lighthouse Museum
7. Sun and Sound Montauk (from USD 137)
For tourists who love to do activities under the sun, you will surely love this hotel. Some of the things you can do here include enjoying the outdoor pool and or eating with your friends in the barbecue and picnic area. All of the rooms are fully equipped with a kitchen, TV, and WiFi. However, you can also choose a room with a deck. The hotel has a terrace where you can relax and adore sunset views. If you are planning to enjoy outdoor activities such as golf, this hotel is only seven minutes away from Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course.
Sun and Sound Montauk
Address: 22 Soudview Drive
7.24 km (4.5 mi) from Montauk Point Lighthouse Museum
Have an unforgettable vacation
Montauk, New York, has the best accommodation that can give you the relaxation you need on your trip, especially if you stay in a hotel where you can dip in a pool anytime you want. No matter what you do or where you go in Montauk, make sure to make it unforgettable and fun by choosing the right hotel that will best provide your wants and needs. Book one of the hotels on this list to experience a vacation in Montauk, New York, that you’ll surely treasure for a lifetime.
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data
