Located on the tip of Long Island, Montauk is a charming little escape from the rigors of life. With the Atlantic Ocean on the eastern coast and several bays on the west, there is no shortage of beaches or water activities. Spend a day on Ditch Plains Beach, go hiking in Camp Hero State Park, and finish off your day star gazing from gorgeous rentals. Although most rentals in the area offer panoramic views, visit Montauk Point Lighthouse for a brush with history. The best thing about visiting this tiny hamlet is that it also loves to host your pets. There are dog-friendly beaches, hiking trails, and restaurants that your furry friend will enjoy as much as you. Continue reading to learn more about the best pet-friendly rentals in Montauk, New York.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) host status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and pet-friendly rules and regulations. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on April 13, 2024.
1. Cute rental close to the Atlantic (from USD 999)
Close to both Lake Montauk and the ocean, this place is perfect for those who love the water. Don’t plan your city escape without your fur babies, as this rental allows guests to bring their pets. If you do decide to bring your pet, a pet fee may apply.
Pets will love to play and lounge in the garden as well as accompany you to the beaches. South Edison Beach and Kirk Park Beach are both 0.1 mi (0.16 km) from the cottage and are pet-friendly. Kirk Park Beach even has a cordoned-off section where dogs can try paddling in a safe environment.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
large bathroom which is helpful with kidsCleanliness:
beds were comfortable and bathroomwas cleanHost:
j is a great hostrobert was responsive to any questions we hadrobert was very responsive to any questions we hadRead more reviewsLocation:
awesome location robert is greatyou're a stones throw away from two beach entrances that were great to walk to every morning
2. Cottage with perfect waterfront location (from USD 529)
Guests enter this house via a stone-lined pathway in the lawn that leads you to the entryway porch. The house is surrounded by a garden on all sides, which is further fenced and lined with a hedge to offer privacy. This rental welcomes dogs for a 250 USD fee per animal for a maximum of two pets. Your fur babies will love to play in the garden, and spend lazy afternoons lounging under the warm sun.
Stairs from the garden lead directly into the water, where you can kayak, swim and fish. If you wish to stay on land, get a tan on the loungers or fire up the grill for a delicious picnic-style lunch.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the cottage is beautifully decorated and thoughtfully designed with high end kitchen appliances and furnitureHost:
the host was a delightlaura (property owner) was so kind and accommodatingbeautiful house exactly as advertised and the owner was fantasticlaura is a most gracious hostRead more reviewsLocation:
the location on the pond was perfect for sunset dinners at the dining room tableeasy walk to town and the beachjust the perfect place in so many ways
3. Lovely 1928 stone cottage (from USD 600)
Bordering Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course, this historic cottage is an absolute treat. Spread across over 1.5 ac (0.61 ha), the cottage offers plenty of open space. A maximum of two cats or dogs are allowed to accompany their humans as long as they weigh under 20 lbs (9.07 kgs). A 150 USD fee is charged for one pet, and the cost becomes 250 USD if you bring two pets along for the holiday.
Begin your days with a swim in the heated pool, and you can end them with sizzling barbecues and chilled beers out on the pool deck or in the conservatory.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the house had everything we wanted including a heated pool that was perfect for our chilly september stayHost:
the care taker was wonderful and very helpfulthe property manager grant was great and was super helpful with all of our questionsbeautiful grounds easy to communicate with super helpful property managergrant the estate manager was also super helpful and available whenever i neededRead more reviewsLocation:
also loved that property is spacious and private but so close to town/beach
4. Split level house with a pool and hot tub (from USD 1510)
This absolutely gorgeous house with multiple indoor and outdoor spaces is a treat to stay in. The double-height living room and the adjoining dining room both open on the large ocean-facing deck. The deck includes a next extension and now has a pool, hot tub, outdoor dining, seating, and barbecue facilities.
This rental allows pets on a pre-approved basis only and charges a 500 USD one-time fee. It is best to book the rental only after you have gained pet approval if you plan on bringing your furry friends along. Long-stay guests are responsible for paying for the expense of the weekly cleaning service.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
most time spent at the home on back deck while enjoying heated pool and hot tubthis is a spacious home with a beautiful pool and hot tub and huge deck overlooking the atlantic oceanCleanliness:
well-managed property and very cleanHost:
the team was responsive when we had any questions regarding the houseRead more reviewsLocation:
great location clean amazing home
5. Renovated house with private beach access (from USD 850)
The interior and outdoor spaces provide a harmonious and well-designed setting to take a break from the city. Play frisbee in the garden, take a dip in the saltwater pool, and enjoy al fresco meals under the cooling shade of mature trees. This rental is located in the prime Hither Hills community, which allows guests exclusive access to a private beach with a special key for entry.
Your pets will also love this property with its vast and secure open spaces. The garden area is fenced, and several outside seating areas mean that it is easy to keep an eye on your pets. Up to two pets of any size are allowed on a case-by-case basis, and renters need to seek approval prior to arrival.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
great property with a private fenced backyard and a beautiful pool and hot tubHost:
carter is the best host you can ask forcarter was a great host attentive to what we neededvery nice and helpful ownerthank you so much carter and kate for hosting usthe home was toddler friendly and our family was quite comfortable during our stayRead more reviewsLocation:
great location to town and beachabsolutely beautiful house with perfect location for montauk’s beach and townloved this property perfect location and setting for a girls getawaythe beach is a quick walk away easy for multiple visits every day
6. Family home with private beach on Lake Montauk (from USD 800)
The open-plan living room has multiple windows, along with sliding glass walls that offer uninterrupted views of the lake. Step onto the spacious deck that extends to two sides of the house to lounge, barbecue, or nap on the hammock. The deck leads to the garden, where a large farmhouse-style table can be used for conversations and meals. With all this open space along with a private beach, it would be a crime to leave your dogs at home.
This rental allows guests to bring a maximum of two dogs who weigh less than 55.12 lb (25 kg). A pet fee will be charged per booking when bringing your furry friends along with you. The house comes with two paddle boards and three kayaks that guests and their dogs are welcome to use.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the beds were super comfortable too which made us very happy we would definitely come backHost:
the owner is so accommodating and coolthe host was very helpful and accommodatinggreat house and property and owner is super nicethe house was lovely and brandon was a fantastic hosthouse is bright and airy brandon was a great hostRead more reviewsLocation:
house was great as was the location and the propertythe house grounds and location was just perfecthad a wonderful time wonderful house in beautiful locationhouse is amazing location is great and the perfect place to relax and unwindthe location is beautiful and the house is set up well to hang
7. Modern rental close to the beach (from USD 429)
Clean and minimalist, this single-level house has been designed to make the most of the outdoors. Use the sliding door to easily walk outdoors from each of the bedrooms. The kitchen is sleek with modern amenities that eliminate the inconvenience of cooking during holidays. The house is surrounded by a manicured garden on all sides, which includes several trees for shade.
This property welcomes pets, and they will simply love the open space around the house. The yard is not completely fenced, so owners will have to keep an eye on their beloved fur babies.
Ditch Plains Beach is within walking distance from the house, and dog owners will love the pet-friendly nature of the beach. During the off-season, dogs are allowed leash-free on the beach, while they are allowed before sunrise and after sunset during the on-season. Instructions and rules are posted along the beach, and as long as you follow them, your pup will have an incredible time.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the only cons were that the third bedroom with the murphy bed isn’t a true third bedroomCleanliness:
very clean and comfyit is clean comfortable and well-appointedthe house is decorated ikea-style with the clean lines and charming feel of a euro chateauit was a clean modern house with open living spaces plenty of seating and comfortable bedsHost:
wonderfully thoughtful and accommodating hostRead more reviewsLocation:
it was a great house in an amazing location for everything in montaukgreat place to forget about the city for a few days and very close to the ocean
8. Beautiful home with garden close to the beach (from USD 361)
Located in Culloden on the western side of the island, guests renting this property enjoy a private beach. Two surfboards, a paddle board, and a kayak are available for guests’ use. Bring your pets along for the beach holiday and have them enjoy a session of paddle boarding along with you. The completely fenced and landscaped yard is the perfect place for your fur baby to hang out. And they are sure to find a cozy spot to nap in the sunny living room.
The kitchen leads out to the back deck, where you can switch on the string bulbs for a truly dreamy evening setting. Enjoy this space for late-night barbecues and conversations under the clear sky.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the wifi wasn’t the strongest and the photos are a bit datedHost:
super responsive host with lots of local tipsvery accommodating thank youthe location and private beach is great and judy is an extremely responsive and kind hostjudy has been very responsive and available at any timeRead more reviewsLocation:
cute house in a great locationthe location is great short walk to the beachgreat location near a very beautiful private beachgreat location near private beach and by big pondthis place is perfectly located on a dead end street within a great walking neighborhood
9. Oceanfront studio cottage (from USD 126)
This is the perfect little space to spend a few days on the beach with your partner and your furry friend. The cottage includes a garden where you can grill and enjoy ocean views. The garden is only partially fenced; therefore, it is not recommended to leave your pets alone. The studio includes both air conditioning and a fireplace making it ideal for year-round getaways. Despite the small size, the cottage includes a full kitchen where you can prepare meals.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
cottage was perfect amazing views very comfortable and quick access to beach/townthe bed is very comfortable and the linens are high qualitythe shower is small but functional and there is a cute table in the center of the roomfrom the cabins to the pool everything is beautifulCleanliness:
the cabin was clean and comfortablethe community is great and the bathroom is clean with plenty of towelsthe place itself is clean bright and invitingthe cottages are very clean and comfortablethe inside was beautifully decorated and very cleanHost:
ron is a wonderful host and he was quick to respond to any questions i hadron is the best hostgreat host thanks again ronron was responsive and quickly availablewe had a perfect stay ron was an extremely responsive host and the cabin was well-appointedRead more reviewsLocation:
wonderful location will come back againit’s a perfect location and adorable spotcute cottage and great location right across the street from a private beach and just 2 miles from townit’s a quick drive to town and about a 20 minute walk if the weather is nicegreat stay close to the ocean
10. Gorgeous house on the shores of Lake Montauk
An absolutely unbelievable location on the shore of Lake Montauk, this lake house is the ultimate place to recharge and reset. Surrounded by manicured greens and landscaped fencing, this house is completely secluded. The all-white interiors provide a cozy and inviting vibe.
This lake house allows renters to bring their pets along to enjoy the wonderful location. Guests need to indicate the breed and size of their pets at the time of booking this property for approval. If your pet is approved, you might need to pay an additional fee.
Bring your paddle board and kayaks, and simply follow the route down to the beach and into the water. Allow your fur baby to enjoy the beach while you keep an eye on them.
Montauk, New York, United StatesSuperhost
Accommodates: 6
Top guest reviews
Read more reviewsLocation:
older ranch style house on lake - beautiful and peaceful location
Enjoy a laidback holiday in Montauk
With miles of coastline along with gorgeous rentals with wide open spaces, it s difficult to find faults in Montauk. Combine that with several pet-friendly options available in this coastal town, and you are in for a holiday that is truly for the entire family. Hurry and book one of these best pet-friendly rentals in Montauk, New York.
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data
Create an account to