7 Best Cheap Motels In Long Island, New York, The USA - Updated 2024

Hardik
Hardik 
Contributing Writer
Updated
| 4 min read

Long Island is a South Eastern New York State with a mixture of rural and urban culture. Every year New York sees a considerable amount of tourists that visit Long Island to experience the rich culture this place has to offer. It provides a spectrum of adventures including boat rides, wildlife sanctuaries, large wetlands, and nightlife. Long island is also famous for having over 60 wine distilleries that offer wine-tasting tours. It is a perfect place to visit with family and kids, providing a full family adventure with its amusement park and interactive museums. This place is also rich in art and culture and offers a Gatsby-styled Gold Coast mansion, museums, and Broadway-calibre creations. Tourists can enjoy fresh seafood and farm-to-table food. Visiting soon? Here are some of the best cheap motels in Long Island, New York, the USA.

We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on May 19, 2024.

1. Rodeway Inn Macarthur Airport (from USD 111)

Rodeway Inn is a conveniently placed motel that is preferred by a lot of travelers. It is an hour away from MacArthur Airport in New York. It is a cozy motel to stay in for a pit-stop and rest. It provides a Wi-Fi facility and photocopying machine. It has a free parking service for all travelers. The motel offers non-smoking rooms and vending machines for drinks and snacks. The motel is a few kilometers away from popular local restaurants and bars.

Stayed at this property?

Rodeway Inn MacArthur Airport

7.1 User Rating Wifi Available

Address: 3055 Veterans Memorial Hwy., Hauppauge, Hauppauge (NY), United States, 11779
10.11 km (6.3 mi) from East Islip Marina Park

Parking 24-HOUR FRONT DESK Non-smoking rooms Free parking Internet services Heating WiFi Available Free WiFi

2. Americas Best Value Inn Smithtown/ Long Island (from USD 99)

This little motel is one of the best motels in town for a perfect short stay. It is 15 minutes from MacArthur Airport in New York. It is only a few kilometers away from the famous tourist attractions of the town such as Adventure land Amusement Park and Fire Island National Seashore. The motel rooms are equipped with cable TV and you can watch HBO. The motel provides free Wi-Fi connection and great continental breakfast. The closest eatery to the motel is Taco Bell. The front desk is open 24/7.

Stayed at this property?

Americas Best Value Inn Smithtown/Long Island

Wifi Available

Address: 755 Smithtown Bypass
16.12 km (10.1 mi) from East Islip Marina Park

24-HOUR FRONT DESK Non-smoking rooms Business centre Internet services Heating Fax/photocopying WiFi Available Free WiFi

3. Travelodge by Wyndham Bay Shore Long Island (from USD 83)

Travelodge by Wyndham Bay Shore Long Island is a snugly tucked motel in Bay Shore. It is a budget-friendly hotel and has a 24/7 front desk. Even though this property doesn’t have dining options, Bay Shore has a lot of seafood restaurants. It is conveniently placed in the middle of prominent landmarks in Long Island. Travelodge is a few minutes’ walk away from The Sangtikos Manor and The Himes Museum of Motor Racing Nostalgia, which are some of the main attractions in Bay Shore. Tea and coffee are available in the common area of the motel and free Wi-Fi and parking facility are also provided for its lodgers.

Stayed at this property?

Travelodge by Wyndham Bay Shore Long Island

Wifi Available

Address: 501 East Main Street
4.23 km (2.7 mi) from East Islip Marina Park

Parking Room service 24-HOUR FRONT DESK Non-smoking rooms Free parking Internet services Heating WiFi Available

4. Bay Shore Inn (from USD 93)

Bay Shore Inn motel is one of the best motels for a couple’s stay. Travelers usually prefer it for a pit-stop to the next destination. The motel has two vending machines, one for coffee and the other for snacks. The motel offers a safe parking lot for travelers’ vehicles. All the rooms come with a TV and some of them have a bath-tub. So, you have the choice of choosing the one with the bath-tub or shower. The rooms are divided into smoking and non-smoking ones. There are three restaurants within the proximity of the motel. The first is Monsoon: Steak and Sushi. The second is Verde which is a lively bar and the last is Chipotle Mexican Grill, famous for its Mexican food.

Stayed at this property?

Bay Shore Inn

Wifi Available

Address: 300 Bay Shore Road
7.81 km (4.9 mi) from East Islip Marina Park

Parking 24-HOUR FRONT DESK Non-smoking rooms Facilities for disabled guests Free parking Internet services Heating WiFi Available

5. Relax Inn North Babylon (from USD 130)

Relax Inn is a beautiful and comfortable one-star motel built in the heart of West Babylon. It is a perfect motel for travelers who are looking for a night’s stay in West Babylon. The motel has a vending machine for beverages and photocopying machines for any emergency printing work. It also has a laundry facility which proves to be perfect for a traveler since you can wash your clothes on the run. The motel provides rooms with air conditioning and heater as well as non-smoking rooms. The motel offers a Wi-Fi facility and there is a public parking lot that is safe. It is under 10 kilometers (6.2 miles) from great tourist attractions in West Babylon like Firemen’s Memorial Park, Green Park, Adventure land, Nikon theater, and the Paramount. JFK Airport is an hour away from the motel, which makes it pretty convenient.

Stayed at this property?

Relax Inn North Babylon

5.6 User Rating Wifi Available

Address: 915 Sunrise Highway
11.65 km (7.3 mi) from East Islip Marina Park

Parking 24-HOUR FRONT DESK Non-smoking rooms Laundry Free parking Internet services Heating Fax/photocopying

6. Budget Inn Massapequa (from USD 100)

This motel is only 30 minutes away from JFK International Airport. The motel provides traditional-looking rooms with TV. The TVs are accompanied by DVD players. Budget Inn Massapequa has a common refrigerator and a 24/7 functioning reception desk. The motel provides free Wi-Fi and parking facilities for the travelers. The motel also has individual family rooms. The motel is in close proximity to Firemen’s Memorial Park, Indian Island Country Park, and Green Park. These parks are famous for hiking and fishing are excellent ways to pass time.

Stayed at this property?

7. Lakeland Inn Bohemia (from USD 93)

This motel is only five minutes away from MacArthur Airport in New York. It is a perfect place to stay if you are traveling from the airport and haven’t decided on a place to stay. You can also ferry a ride to Fire Island from here. The motel is only half an hour away from Heckscher State Park, which is famous for fishing, beaches, and hiking. It is only a kilometer’s (0.6 mile) walk away from the famous local restaurant, Mama Mia Ristorante. Fishing is a popular local sport and therefore, you can go fishing to pass your time.

Stayed at this property?

Lakeland Inn - Bohemia

Wifi Available

Address: 1630 Lakeland Avenue
10.79 km (6.8 mi) from East Islip Marina Park

Parking 24-HOUR FRONT DESK Non-smoking rooms Facilities for disabled guests Free parking Internet services Soundproof rooms Heating

Neat and cheap accommodations with all the necessities in Long Island

Any motel that you choose should be close to the airport or other modes of transportation. The place you decide to stay in should be neat and clean and provide for basic necessities like a vending machine for food and drinks. It is a plus point if the place is close to entertainment facilities. Keep these places in mind for cost-efficient but satisfactory accommodation options in Long Island.

Any must-sees we missed? Tell us about them in the comments section or write a post here to help out fellow travelers!
Disclosure: Trip101 selects the listings in our articles independently. Some of the listings in this article contain affiliate links.

History


Get Trip101 in your inbox

Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data

A Wellness Coach by profession, a Writer by Passion, and a Fitness Enthusiast by Choice. Always looking for new opportunities to share his knowledge and wisdom by helping more and more people to...Read more

 Want to contribute as a Local Expert?
Explore Long Island
Looking for accommodation?
x
Good things are meant to be shared!
Back to top
Visited any of these places? Click this button to activate our "Add a Tip" feature to share your experience.