10 Seafood Restaurants In Long Island, New York

seafood restaurants in long island
Hannah
Hannah
Published

Nestled between the wide expanse of the Atlantic Ocean and the warm waters of Long Island Sound, this bright destination of Long Island is filled with brilliant things to see, try, and do. There are expansive museums to explore, such as Nassau County Museum of Art or Vanderbilt Museum and Planetarium, as well as breathtaking beaches to lounge upon. Spend your day exploring Gilded Age estates like Old Westbury Gardens or hiking the beautiful trails in Montauk Point State Park, before shopping in the east end island’s luxurious The Hamptons. If you’ve worked up an appetite after a busy day of sightseeing, Long Island is also home to many fantastic seafood restaurants to try. Enjoy lobster tails, local oysters, clams, crabs, and more by checking out the list below for the best seafood restaurants in Long Island, New York.

1. The Snapper Inn

Seafood platter
Source: Pixabay

Photo is only for illustrative purposes

The Snapper Inn is a wonderful, family-owned restaurant that has been a local favorite on Long Island since it opened in 1929. This understated, elegant restaurant is located in the town of Oakdale and offers both a lunch and dinner service from Thursday through Sunday. The menu is wide-ranging and includes delicious appetizers, soups, salads, entrees, and desserts. For a taste of fresh seafood, try the clams or oysters from the raw bar, or get the classic seafood platter, blackened, boiled, or fried. You can’t go wrong with a cup of their award-winning chowder, either! With its picturesque setting overlooking Connetquot River, The Snapper Inn boasts beautiful views in addition to its terrific meals and offers both indoor and outdoor dining options.

The Snapper Inn

Address: 500 Shore Dr, Oakdale, NY 11769, United States

Website: The Snapper Inn

Opening hours: Thu: 12pm - 9pm; Fri: 12pm - 12:15am; Sat: 12pm - 10pm; Sun: 11:30pm - 8pm (closed from Mon - Wed)

2. Captain Bill's Restaurant & Catering

Oysters on the half shell
Source: Pixabay

Photo is only for illustrative purposes

Captain Bill’s Restaurant & Catering offers a brilliant blend of wonderful ambiance, a beautiful location, and a delectable menu. The harbor-front location at the Bay Shore Marina contributes to the restaurant’s romantic atmosphere, and the menu is filled with hand-crafted, seasonal dishes. Feast on the fresh catch of the day, and enjoy clams, oysters, or local fish, try freshly shucked oysters from the raw bar or opt for a juicy cut of steak instead. Just make sure you save room for a bite of their signature decadent desserts, as well!

Captain Bill's Restaurant & Catering

Address: 122 Ocean Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706, United States

Website: Captain Bill’s Restaurant & Catering

Opening hours: Wed - Thu: 12pm - 9pm; Fri - Sat: 12pm - 9:30pm; Sun: 12pm - 8:30pm (closed on Mon & Tue)

3. H2O: Seafood & Sushi

Sushi
Source: Pixabay

Photo is only for illustrative purposes

For unbelievably tasty food made with the best, fresh ingredients, you can’t miss H20: Seafood and Sushi. Located in Smithtown, this mouthwatering restaurant serves up a menu of brilliant starters, salads, specialty rolls, seafood, and more. Enjoy regional favorites such as New England clam chowder or Blue Point oysters from Long Island Sound, or go for global-inspired dishes with New England scallops and crispy rice or shrimp empanadas. There is also a list of extensive drinks such as wines, beers, and cocktails, as well as delicious desserts to finish your meal.

H2O: Seafood & Sushi

Address: 215 West Main St, Smithtown, NY 11787, United States

Website: H2O: Seafood & Sushi

Opening hours: Mon - Thu: 4pm - 10pm; Fri: 4pm - 11pm; Sat: 3pm - 11pm; Sun: 3pm - 9pm

4. The Steam Room

Seafood platter
Source: Pixabay

Photo is only for illustrative purposes

Nestled in the historic Port Jefferson Village, The Steam Room is a local treasure that has been a part of the community for over 35 years. The restaurant is renowned for its fresh seafood dishes and scenic views across Port Jefferson Harbor and offers both indoor and outdoor dining. The menu is filled with amazing entrees, from the hearty fisherman’s platter that’s loaded with fish, shrimp, clam strips, and scallops, to the homemade chowders served in a fresh bread bowl. Whether you prefer your seafood baked, broiled, fried, or raw and on the half shell, there are plenty of great options for you at The Steam Room.

The Steam Room

Address: 4 East Broadway, Port Jefferson, NY 11777, United States

Website: The Steam Room

Opening hours: 8am - 9pm (daily)

5. Mill Pond House

Cooked lobsters
Source: Pixabay

Photo is only for illustrative purposes

Overlooking the beautiful Mill Pond in Centerport, this restaurant is historic, delicious, and charming. In addition to its fantastic views, Mill Pond House has a terrific menu that features daily specials, sushi options, raw bar options, entrees, and more. There are tons of fantastic options for seafood lovers, from jumbo shrimp scampi to sautéed littleneck clams, and even a baked lobster dinner special on Monday nights. Finish your meal with one of the decadent house-made desserts for a perfect meal.

Mill Pond House

Address: 437 East Main Street, Centerport, NY 11721, United States

Website: Mill Pond House

Opening hours: Mon - Thu: 12pm - 10pm; Fri - Sat: 12pm - 11pm; Sun: 12pm - 9pm

6. Harbor Mist Restaurant

Creamy Linguine with Ham
Source: Pixabay

Photo is only for illustrative purposes

Situated along the waterfront in Cold Spring Harbor, this beautiful restaurant serves wonderful food in an amazing, scenic setting. Harbor Mist Restaurant is elegant and fascinating and has a menu filled with award-winning dishes. The restaurant features daily and weekly specials in addition to its stellar line-up of starters, sandwiches, and entrees of seafood and prime meats. In the winter, warm up with a bowl of their renowned New England clam chowder, or enjoy the weather of the warmer months from the restaurant’s picturesque outdoor seating. A seafood sampler of shrimp, clams, and oysters is the perfect accompaniment to a waterfront sunset, after all.

Harbor Mist Restaurant

Address: 105 Harbor Road, Cold Spring Harbor, NY 11724, United States

Website: Harbor Mist Restaurant

Opening hours: Mon - Thu: 11:30pm - 9:30pm; Fri - Sat: 11:30pm - 10:30pm; Sun: 11:30am - 8:30pm

7. Popei's Clam Bar

Black Linguine seafood pasta
Source: Pixabay

Photo is only for illustrative purposes

Popei’s Clam Bar is a casual restaurant with a menu bursting with seafood specials. This family-owned, family-friendly restaurant has been a local favorite in the area of Bethpage for over 30 years and it’s no surprise why. The menu is extensive and filled with seafood entrees prepared in a plethora of styles. With hearty starters, homemade soups, seafood pasta, and fried, broiled, blackened, and Cajun seafood entrees available, you can always find something delicious to try here. There is also a great drinks menu with wine, beer, and signature cocktails to choose from.

Popei's Clam Bar

Address: 384 North Wantagh Ave, Bethpage, NY 11714, United States

Website: Popei’s Clam Bar

Opening hours: Mon - Thu: 11am - 10pm; Fri - Sat: 11am - 12am; Sun: 12pm - 10pm

8. Psari

Grilled Octopus platter
Source: Pixabay

Photo is only for illustrative purposes

This stylish restaurant serves wonderful seafood dishes that sizzle with Greek-inspired flair. Psari, which means “fish” in Greek, has a menu bursting with tasty dishes and an extensive, international wine list. Try the local catch of the day, broiled or fried, opt for options from the raw bar, or feast on grilled octopus or Maine lobster. With so many starters, salads, soups, sides, and entrees to choose from, every meal turns into a feast fit for a king at Psari.

Psari

Address: 32-10 36th Ave, Long Island City, NY 11106, United States

Website: Psari

Opening hours: 11am - 12am (daily)

9. Anchor Down Seafood Bar and Grill

Roasted Beet Salad
Source: Pixabay

Photo is only for illustrative purposes

Anchor Down Seafood Bar and Grill is a casual, American seafood restaurant located in South Merrick. With a wide selection of starters, sandwiches, main courses, and sides, there is a lot to love at this family-friendly restaurant. The seafood here is fresh and locally sourced whenever possible, and there are many delectable dishes to try on such as the lobster pot pie, fisherman’s stew, and stuffed Montauk fluke. Indoor and outdoor dining options are available.

Anchor Down Seafood Bar and Grill

Address: 1960 Bayberry Avenue, Merrick, NY 11566, United States

Website: Anchor Down Seafood Bar and Grill

Opening hours: Tue - Thu: 4:30pm - 10pm; Fri - Sat: 12pm - 10pm; Sun: 12pm - 9pm (closed on Mon)

10. The Jolly Fisherman & Steak House

Flower Crab Curry
Source: Pixabay

Photo is only for illustrative purposes

Set in an elegant restaurant overlooking Roslyn duck pond, The Jolly Fisherman & Steak House is classic, delicious, and fresh. This family-owned restaurant has been a staple in the town of Roslyn since 1957 and offers a tantalizing menu of fresh seafood and prime steaks. The restaurant has an exceptional lunch and dinner service, and there are plenty of options to delight seafood lovers with dishes such as broiled Maine lobster, fried deep sea scallops, and baked scallops. There are also amazing desserts on offer, including banana cream pie, a favorite since the restaurant opened.

The Jolly Fisherman & Steak House

Address: 25 Main Street, Roslyn, NY 11576, United States

Website: The Jolly Fisherman & Steak House

Opening hours: Tue - Thu: 12pm - 3pm, 4:30pm - 9pm; Fri - Sat: 12pm - 3pm, 4:30pm - 10pm; Sun: 12pm - 8:30pm (closed on Mon)

Feast on fresh and flavorful seafood

Long Island is the perfect place to enjoy a flavorful seafood feast. From freshly shucked oysters to New England clam chowder, these restaurants highlight the rich bounty of local ingredients and the delectable flavors of the region. Whether you’re in the mood for sushi rolls or classic fish and chips, these restaurants offer menus packed with amazing meals. Next time you’re in Long Island, stop by one of these seafood restaurants for an unforgettable feast.

Disclosure: Trip101 selects the listings in our articles independently. Some of the listings in this article contain affiliate links.

Get Trip101 in your inbox

Unsubscribe in one click. See our privacy policy for more information on how we use your data

Hannah is a freelance writer, list making aficionado, and world traveler currently based in Germany. She is an avid explorer, and believes in creating new experiences to put on her bucket list to...Read more

 Want to contribute as a Local Expert?
Explore Long Island
Good things are meant to be shared!