14 Seafood Restaurants In Sarasota, Florida

1. Veronica Fish and Oyster

Editor's Note: Photo taken from the establishment's official social account

Veronica Fish and Oyster is an oyster bar that pays homage to classic supper clubs of the past. Its menu, composed of a variety of oysters and seafood, evokes the memory of fish and oyster bars from the north. Some of the dishes you’ll find here are steamed black mussels, sea scallops, Faroe Island salmon, lobster fra diavolo, and swordfish.

There is also a service bar for those of you more inclined to drink and a happy hour menu is served every day from 5pm to 7pm.

Veronica Fish and Oyster

Address: 1830 S Osprey Ave, Sarasota, FL 34239, United States

Website: Veronica Fish and Oyster

Opening hours: Mon - Thu: 5pm - 9:30pm; Fri - Sat: 5pm - 10:30pm (closed on Sun)

2. Spearfish Grille

Editor's Note: Photo taken from the establishment's official social account

Located at Siesta Key Marina, Spearfish Grille serves classic dishes with a twist and creative food ventures that are sure to leave a lasting impression in your mouth, not to mention that fresh local fish is used as an ingredient. As for the menu, the restaurant presents a wide variety of dishes for you to choose from, with some having varying prices depending on the market value. Some of these dishes include freshly-caught gulf fish, lobsters, tuna, and many more.

Finally, the restaurant has a patio dining area and a custom firepit and is decorated by the marina owners in order to pay homage to the local fishing community’s past.

Spearfish Grille

Address: 1265 Old Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242, United States

Website: Spearfish Grille

Opening hours: 11am -10pm (daily)

3. Fresh Catch Fish Market & Grill

Editor's Note: Photo taken from the establishment's official social account

Fresh Catch Fish Market & Grill is a family-owned fish restaurant in Sarasota that offers seafood dishes cooked with freshly caught ingredients. As for the menu, there are a wide variety of dishes to choose from but all of them are guaranteed to be fresh and delicious. Some of these dishes are clam chowder, smoked fish, ahi tuna, stone crabs, crab pot, and crab cake BLT.

You won’t be disappointed as the fresh ingredients and masterful cooking of the chefs alongside the restaurant’s casual and humble atmosphere makes for a wonderful dining experience.

Fresh Catch Fish Market & Grill

Address: 7119 S Tamiami Trail, Sarasota, FL 34231, United States

Website: Fresh Catch Fish Market & Grill

Opening hours: Mon - Sat: 11am - 8pm (closed on Sun)

4. Lazy Lobster

Editor's Note: Photo taken from the establishment's official social account

Describing itself as a neighborhood choice, Lazy Lobster proudly displays its casual atmosphere that complements the various seafood dishes it serves. A far cry from the first word of its name and true to the second word, Lazy Lobster specializes in lobster dishes as it has an entire section of the menu dedicated to them. Of course, those are not the only food on the menu as there are also several dishes like fried shrimp dinner, pecan-crusted salmon, and island-style mahi.

Lazy Lobster

Address: 7602 Lockwood Ridge Rd, Sarasota, FL 34243, United States

Website: Lazy Lobster

Opening hours: Tue - Sun: 4pm - 8pm (closed on Mon)

5. Walt's Fish Market Restaurant

Devour their freshest, top-quality seafood that is locally sourced from around the world. It has been their restaurant’s mission and they have definitely established excellent quality and service as they are one of the favorite seafood restaurants in Florida. Get hooked on their freshest catch of the day as their fishermen deliver various seafood for the Chefs to cook in whatever style the customers request. From Grouper, American Red Snapper, Mussels and huge red Lobsters, customers drool for exciting and interesting ways to enjoy the seafood choices. Also, make sure to check out their catering services which the owner personally heads from seafood selection to ensure customer satisfaction.

Walt's Fish Market Restaurant

Address: 4144 South Tamiami Trail, Sarasota, FL 34231

Website: Walt’s Fish Market Restaurant

Opening Hours: Fish Market (Mon - Sat: 9 - 9 pm, Sunday: 10 - 9 pm) Restaurant (Mon - Sun: 11 - 10 pm)

Price: 13 USD- 30 USD

6. Crab & Fin Restaurant

Crab & Fin Restaurant create a fresh and unique seafood menu daily to serve customers. Their seafood is locally sourced and is found in ecologically responsible fisheries and they are not farm raised. The Chefs at the restaurant take pride in intricately preparing each meal so the customers are left with taste buds that crave for a more enticing and exciting dining experience. Aside from their freshest seafood selection, they also offer homemade pasta, bread and pastries to complete the experience.

Crab & Fin Restaurant

Address: 420 St. Armands Circle, Sarasota, FL

Website: Crab & Fin Restaurant

Opening Hours: 11:30 AM- 10:00 PM

Price: 20- 34 USD

7. KaCey's Seafood and More

KaCey’s Seafood and More has a casual and upbeat vibe to it. Customers can enjoy outside seating for al fresco dining. Peak hours tend to create a queue as customers anticipate a delectable seafood experience but waiters are very welcoming and service runs fast. Customers love their daily catch of fresh seafood that is cooked to perfection with sensational flavors that will surely leave guests wanting for more. Lobster Bisque, Fish and Chips are a crowd-favorite but they also offer all-time favorite classics like ribs and tacos. KayCey’s Seafood is one of the busiest restaurants in Sarasota, Florida, but they don’t compromise food quality and has a great value for money.

KaCey's Seafood and More

Address: 4904 Fruitville Rd., Sarasota FL 34232

Website: KaCey’s Seafood and More

Opening Hours: MON-SAT (11:00 AM - 9:00 PM), SUN (11:00 AM - 8:00 PM)

Price: 10- 51 USD

8. Duval's Fresh Local Seafood

Duval’s is an elegant seafood dining experience with the freshest seafood served to customers’ satisfaction. One thing that stands out in this restaurant is that they value customer relationship, thus, they prepare only the finest and top quality food. Guests love their various ways to cook and serve seafood that makes it interesting, like their Duval’s Famous Po’ Boys. They make sure that their fantastic food is accessible to customers right at their doorstep with their online ordering and delivery. There is also a free local shuttle service available that take customers to and from their restaurant which makes enjoying their sumptuous meal easy and quick at the comfort of their home.

Duval's Fresh. Local. Seafood.

Address: 1435 MAIN ST., SARASOTA, FL 34236

Website: Duval’s Fresh. Local. Seafood.

Opening Hours: Monday — Thursday: (11am — 10pm), Friday — Saturday: (11am — 11pm) Sunday: (11am — 9pm)

Price: 11- 30 USD

9. Barnacle Bill's Seafood

Enjoy seafood perfection at Barnacle Bill’s Seafood wherein the freshest catch of the day is served in a platter of goodness. Barnacle Bill’s Seafood also offers a seafood market which everybody loves. They display the freshest fish, crab legs and other seafood delicacies that guests can request to be cooked, preferably with their chosen style or the chef’s recommendation. They have served the public for 15 years and they have always offered top quality seafood. For guests who love to devour meaty goodness, one of the crowd-favorite is their Prime Ribeye Steak paired with the King Crab or Maine Lobster Tails on their Surf and Turf Steak Special Set.

Barnacle Bill's Seafood

Address: 1526 Main St. Sarasota, Florida 34236

Website: Barnacle Bill’s Seafood

Opening Hours: Monday- Thurs 11:30 AM- 9 PM, Friday- Saturday 11:30 AM- 10:00 PM, Sunday 4 PM- 9 PM

Price: 11- 30 USD

10. Connors Steak & Seafood

Connors Steak & Seafood is a classy restaurant for seafood lovers. The place is adorned with furnished wood and bricks for accent and walls painted in white. It’s perfect for an intimate gathering with family and friends or a romantic date with a special someone. The restaurant offers the freshest seafood and sumptuous meals for an unforgettable seafood experience. Guests love the warm welcome of the servers and how knowledgeable they are with the entire menu for suggestions. They also have a full bar complete with a wide selection of wine and cocktails for a fun night.

Connors Steak & Seafood

Address: 3501 South Tamiami Trail, Ste. 1165, Sarasota, FL 34239

Website: Connors Steak & Seafood

Opening Hours: Sun-Thurs (11am-10pm), Fri-Sat (11am-11pm)

Price: 11-30 USD

11. Owens Fish Camp

Owens Fish Camp is a very laid-back, casual dining, truly fit for a camper. The design of the restaurant resembles a barn but it’s classy and clean. It’s mostly made out of wood with outside dining for an al fresco feel, adorned with yellow lights for a chill aura. The restaurant exudes a Southern old beauty and warmth. It definitely aims for a quality meal all the time, served hot on the plates of customers. With their recommended meals like the Soft Shell Crabs and big Lobsters with classic craft beers to complement the dining experience, this is a great place to eat seafood in Sarasota. Guests are in for an unforgettable seafood adventure.

Owens Fish Camp

Address: 516 Burns Court / Sarasota, Florida

Website: Owens Fish Camp

Opening Hours: Mon- Thurs & Sunday (4 PM- 9:30 PM), Fri- Sat (4 PM- 10:30 PM)

Price: 11-30 USD

12. Marina Jack

Marina Jack is an exquisite and elegant restaurant with diverse entertainment for everyone to enjoy. Experience fine dining at the Dining Room without needing a formal attire; the restaurant will take care of the impeccable meal preparation with the freshest seafood, award- winning steak, and pasta. For some evening entertainment, head over to Blue Sunshine Patio for a live band and wide selections of wine to complement the evening. For a perfect way to experience coastal sunset, all aboard the Marina Jack II Cruises for a sunset ride through the best Sarasota view with a delicious dinner and welcoming servers.

Marina Jack

Address: 2 Marina Plaza, Sarasota, FL 34236

Website: Marina Jack

Opening Hours: Mon- Sunday (11 AM- 11 PM)

Price: 11-30 USD

13. Phillippi Creek Oyster Bar

Phillippi Creek Oyster Bar is a casual dining establishment with a waterfront view. They take pride with their freshest and juiciest oysters that the guest love. It has been a long- time family restaurant which they are passionate about and ensures customer satisfaction every time guests come to dine. The restaurant is inviting and guests can enjoy gift shopping at their Island Creekside Trader. For an overall fantastic night with amazing seafood and sumptuous steak complemented with their imported and draft beers, guests will surely have a memorable time.

Phillippi Creek Oyster Bar

Address: 5353 S Tamiami Trail, Sarasota, FL 34231

Website: Phillippi Creek Oyster Bar

Opening Hours: Sun-Thurs: (11am-10pm) | Fri-Sat: (11am-10:30pm)

Price: 11- 30 USD

14. Captain Brian's Seafood Market & Restaurant

Captain Brian’s Seafood Market & Restaurant is a traditional restaurant, preserving the sea to table freshness of the seafood. They take pride in their Swordfish with its richest color and juiciest meat fish. It’s flown in overnight from an island and is served fresh and sweet to customers. They also offer fresh oysters and clam that are cultivated to perfection and have a sweet, full flavor that is best eaten raw on the half shell. Captain Brian’s Restaurant is really one of the few that stays true to the quality dining experience.

Captain Brian's Seafood Market & Restaurant

Address: 8421 N TAMIAMI TRAIL SARASOTA, FL 34243

Website: Captain Brian’s Seafood Market & Restaurant

Opening Hours: Mon-Sat (11 AM- 9 PM)

Price: 11- 30 USD

Experience a taste of the sea

There is truly an abundance of the freshest seafood in the state of Sarasota, Florida. This list could go on and on with the best seafood restaurants in Sarasota but it’s rest assured that all are top-quality and exquisite seafood served on the guests’ plates in interesting and unique ways to enjoy. Come to Sarasota soon and experience seafood goodness.