Known for picturesque villages, waterfront parks, and a lively art scene, Long Island is set near the East River. It is situated very close to Manhattan. A short distance of about 51 miles (82 kilometers) separates the island from New York City, which means a little over an hour’s journey can take you to the big city. Some fun things to do here include joining wine tours and visiting museums. Popular attractions on the island include Montauk Point Lighthouse Museum, Long Island Aquarium, and Oheka Castle. If you are in New York City or are looking for an alternative weekend getaway, this island can offer a pleasant stay. Scroll down for the best staycations in Long Island, New York.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on April 09, 2024.
1. The Garden City Hotel (from USD 237)
Boasting world-class hospitality and posh accommodations, The Garden City Hotel proves that you don’t have to travel far for a relaxing getaway. Red Hots Spa, the hotel’s own retreat center, provides rejuvenating treatments to soothe your mind, body, and soul. It offers massages, full-body scrubs, and hydro facial enhancements. For the best experience, avail of the Rest & Relax Package, which comes with overnight accommodations, a daily breakfast buffet, spa credits, and a bottle of bubbly.
For more relaxing moments, take a dip in the lovely outdoor pool of this 4-star hotel in Long Island or have a craft drink in one of the bars.
The Garden City Hotel
Address: 45 7th St
85.51 km (53.2 mi) from Long Island Aquarium
Top guest reviews
Cleanliness:
beautiful classy place with quiet clean well-appointed rooms with comfortable bedsHost:
excellent and accomodating staffRead more reviewsLocation:
very nice property in great locationEarn OneKeyCash for every dollar spent on eligible hotels, vacation rentals, flights, car rentals, and more when you book across our family of brands.
2. Danfords Hotel and Marina (from USD 159)
Danfords Hotel and Marina is a luxurious staycation spot nestled on Long Island Sound estuary. With an on-site spa and wellness center, the hotel provides locals with a relaxing escape without leaving their hometown. Guests can enjoy a wide array of facial treatments and body massages during their stay. They can also indulge in fresh offerings of food and beverages offered by Ferryman’s Grille. Rooms and suites in this 3-star hotel are tastefully appointed and equipped with high-speed Wi-Fi and a flat-screen TV.
To make the most of their staycation, guests are provided with access to the Marina, where boating opportunities abound.
Danfords Hotel and Marina
Address: 25 E Broadway
34.77 km (21.7 mi) from Long Island Aquarium
Top guest reviews
Read more reviewsLocation:
loved the location the roomwonderful location and a comfortable staywe enjoyed walking around the town and shopping at the cute little shopsright next to ferry easy to walking and shopping
3. Gurney's Star Island Resort & Marina (from USD 504)
Gurney’s Star Island Resort & Marina is located on Lake Montauk, featuring a private beach and two adults-only swimming pools. You can rent a boat and sail through the waters of the lake. The accommodations are nautical-themed and offer a private wooden balcony with views of the harbor and the lake. Apart from a wide selection of spa services such as fitness, body treatments, and beauty packages, you can enjoy cycling, hiking, fishing, water sports facilities, and a tennis court. Also, there is a children’s playground and a games room for the whole family as well as two on-site restaurants.
Montauk Yacht Club
Address: 32 Star Island Road
63.03 km (39.2 mi) from Long Island Aquarium
4. The Surf Club Resort (from USD 599)
Occupying an area of 8.5 acres (3.4 hectares) in Montauk, The Surf Club Resort features a private beach. Throughout the day, you can enjoy the sun with your feet on the sand or in the ocean waters. Beach chairs, umbrellas, and beach towels are available on the property. When you feel like having a change of scenery, you can refresh your body in the seasonal outdoor swimming pool. You can also spend some time in the picnic area or enjoy local activities such as playing tennis, cycling, fitness and yoga classes, and watching live performances.
The Surf Club Resort
Address: 20 Surfside Avenue
61.59 km (38.3 mi) from Long Island Aquarium
5. Hamlet Inn (from USD 149)
Located a few steps away from Shinnecock Bay in Southampton, Hamlet Inn offers a welcoming and friendly atmosphere. As a courtesy, coffee and water are available during the day to make your stay more comfortable. You can visit Cooper’s Beach and enjoy the beach facilities such as sun umbrellas, towels, and chairs. There is a seasonal outdoor swimming pool with pool toys, a picnic area, and barbecue facilities. You can try some outdoor activities such as snorkeling, horse riding, cycling, hiking, canoeing, and windsurfing.
Hamlet Inn
Address: 300 Montauk Highway
17.74 km (11.1 mi) from Long Island Aquarium
6. Montauk Manor (from USD 142)
With on-site spa services including massages, Montauk Manor can offer a relaxing escape. This 5-star hotel in Montauk, Long Island, features an indoor and outdoor swimming pool and a picnic area with barbecue facilities. Moreover, the rooms have a full kitchen. There is even an electric car charging station for convenience. Several outdoor activities can be enjoyed here including horse riding, cycling, hiking, and fishing. You can also borrow books, DVDs, and music for children, besides board games and puzzles.
Montauk Manor
Address: 236 Edgemere Street
61.11 km (38.0 mi) from Long Island Aquarium
7. Sound View Greenport (from USD 220)
Sound View Greenport is a beachfront hotel in a private beach area on the North Fork. From the rooms, you can see the Long Island Sound. Some units offer a seating area so you can watch the sunset. You can relax by using the sauna or taking yoga classes. Enjoy fun activities on site such as karaoke and other evening entertainment. You can use the tennis court, swim in the outdoor pool, grab a drink at the pool bar, and eat at the restaurant.
Sound View Greenport
Address: 58775 County Rd 48
29.54 km (18.4 mi) from Long Island Aquarium
8. Hero Beach Club (from USD 225)
A bit pricey but worth every penny. Free parking. Resort fee for beach amenities.
Great pool, beach chair and umbrellas, fire pit every night, complimentary coffee and muffins/fruit, complimentary bikes.
Centrally located, walking/biking distance to restaurants and shops, steps from the beach, close to Montauk Brewery.
Basic breakfast, complimentary S’mores kit and fire pit at night, small breakfast in the lobby each morning.
This beachfront property features an outdoor swimming pool, so if you like being close to the water, Hero Beach Club can be your next getaway in Long Island. Don’t forget to book a room with a balcony or deck so you can enjoy some stunning water views. You can check the in-room massage services if you want to enjoy a relaxing experience. You can also join yoga classes at the on-site spa and wellness center. Later, you can go shopping in the shops on the premises or prepare delicious meals in the picnic area with barbecue facilities. Add some fun activities such as bike tours or movie nights to enhance your experience.
Hero Beach Club
Address: 626 Montauk Highway
60.43 km (37.6 mi) from Long Island Aquarium
9. Royal Atlantic Beach Resort (from USD 144)
Royal Atlantic Beach Resort is set on a private beach in Montauk. Besides the ocean, there are two heated outdoor swimming pools with a poolside bar, allowing you to enjoy some refreshing drinks by the water. This beachfront property features a picnic area with barbecue facilities and a restaurant that serves breakfast. All rooms have a compact kitchen with a fridge, microwave, double-burner stovetop, and a coffee maker. You can take a look at the activities offered here including arcade games and table tennis.
Royal Atlantic Beach Resort
Address: 126 S Emerson Ave
61.23 km (38.1 mi) from Long Island Aquarium
10. Hilton Long Island/Huntington (from USD 160)
Competitive pricing with good deals, especially in off-peak seasons and for Hilton Honors members.
Indoor and outdoor pools, gym facilities, and a beautiful atrium. On-site bar and restaurant available.
Convenient location with easy access to nearby restaurants and attractions. Close to train station and various venues.
Great dining experiences with a breakfast buffet, omelette station, and delicious meals at the on-site restaurant.
Located in the heart of Melville, Hilton Long Island/Huntington offers a wide range of on-site recreational activities. From a tennis court to a fitness center, this accommodation comes with facilities to enjoy during your stay. The relaxing amenities include a hot tub and two swimming pools open all year round. Furthermore, there is a shuttle service from Monday through Friday and an electric car charging station. An on-site restaurant serves a continental breakfast every morning.
Hilton Long Island/Huntington
Address: 598 Broad Hollow Road
66.97 km (41.7 mi) from Long Island Aquarium
11. Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa (from USD 310)
High room rates, pricey in-room bar items, and additional charges for beach amenities.
Beautiful beachfront location, spacious outdoor fireplace, state-of-the-art fitness center, and a lovely spa (when open).
Stunning oceanfront setting with beach access, but some noise from events and construction.
Delicious dining options with some vegan and gluten-free choices, but limited room service and slow restaurant service.
Gurney’s Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa is situated right on the beach, featuring an ocean view from every room and a full-service spa with healing and beauty treatments. Each unit is spacious and quiet, which makes it the perfect place for a relaxing getaway. With direct access to a private beach, you can either enjoy the sea or the ocean-fed seawater pool. The property offers two on-site restaurants with American and Italian dishes as well as craft cocktails. If you are staying here with your children, you can check out the kids’ club and the water sports facilities on site. Your pets are also welcome to join you on your relaxing staycation.
Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa
Address: 290 Old Montauk Highway
56.87 km (35.4 mi) from Long Island Aquarium
12. Hyatt Regency Long Island (from USD 169)
Hyatt Regency is a property in Hauppauge that offers free WiFi to its guests. Each room features an iPad, a TV, a work desk, and a dining area with a refrigerator and a coffee machine. The property has a fitness center where you can work out. It also features an indoor and outdoor swimming pool where you can have a soothing dip during your stay. There is a mini market on site as well as a shared lounge area.
Hyatt Regency Long Island
Address: 1717 Vanderbilt Motor Pkwy
44.96 km (28.0 mi) from Long Island Aquarium
Enjoy a lovely staycation on Long Island
Long Island is a well-known summer destination with an inviting coastline. Apart from the beaches, you can visit lighthouses, vineyards, and farms. Looking for staycation ideas in Long Island? Check out any of the best staycations in Long Island, New York, and enjoy a memorable time with your loved ones.
Frequently asked questions about staycations in Long Island, New York
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data
Create an account to