15 Best Airbnb Vacation Rentals In Long Island, New York - Updated 2024

| 6 min read

When tourists think about the state of New York, many think about the ‘greatest city in the world’, the glamourous New York City. However, southeast of New York lies a huge and densely populated island, Long Island. Although Long Island consists of large boroughs of Queens and Brooklyn, many people don’t consider them as part of Long Island. Instead, many think that Long Island begins where the city ends. There are plenty of different areas to visit and many restaurants in Long Island to try out. A wide range of amazing accommodations are available as well, such as bed and breakfasts and vacation rentals. So, check out our list of the top Airbnb vacation rentals in Long Island, New York.

We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on May 19, 2024.

1. Modern suite with a hot tub (from USD 450)

Make your stay in Long Island a remarkable one with this charming rental that comes with a relaxing hot tub. This pet-friendly property features a dedicated workspace perfect for travelers who have business matters to attend to. You can also use its free washer, dryer, and clothing storage for your convenience.

You can drop by its private backyard if you want a breath of fresh air. You can also bring your car and use the free parking space on its premises. If you want to cook some delicious meals, you can do so hassle-free in the fully equipped kitchen.

Stayed at this property?
Shirley, New York, United States
4.71 km (3.0 mi) from Smith Point County Park
204 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 4 Beds 8 Guests 3 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 8

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
great a/c for the hot months
upon arrival daniel immediately refuged us from the 95f temperature; the house's ac made our stay exceedingly comfortable
the kids (and their dad) had a great time playing pool foosball and old school video games
the large kitchen and the outdoor hot tub where definitely nice features we used a lot
the kitchen was well stocked we felt comfortable and safe
beautiful clean and comfy
the rooms were clean and fully furnished
beautiful house very clean and so much to do
everything was clean has everything you need and very relaxing
the property was very clean and well-equipped for everything you'll need
the host is amazing
daniel was a great host
daniel was a great host
daniel was very responsive
daniel was incredibly responsive
location is great with stores within 5 minutes
great location and house for a nice family getaway
the homes is a great stay and location is perfect
very close to the nice beach and downtown area
amazing place with literally everything you can possibly need
Read more reviews

2. Quaint cottage on Long Island's South Shore (from USD 159)

Whether vacationing alone or with your partner, this quaint cottage is the perfect spot to stay for your escapade in Long Island. The interior features a rustic design that adds charm to the place. The hedges around the property are not only aesthetically pleasing but provide privacy as well. The pad also has great amenities like cable TV, WiFi, air-conditioning, and a full kitchen for your convenience. Downtown Patchogue is just minutes away, providing access to many dining and shopping options.

Stayed at this property?
Patchogue, New York, United States
9.63 km (6.0 mi) from Smith Point County Park
206 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
Entire cottage 2 Beds 2 Guests 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 2

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
cozy comfortable cabin with all the necessary amenities
the cottage was wonderful very cozy and quaint
leah’s cottage was perfect for a cozy weekend getaway
this cottage was so cozy and beautiful in a quiet and secluded neighborhood
the cottage was very cozy and the wandering chickens and ducks kept me entertained throughout the day
cozy clean and comfortable
there was some old dog poop under the bed (which leah came over to clean immediately)
this is a special place—quiet quaint well-appointed and clean
the cottage was clean quaint and a relaxing place to stay
super cute clean cozy comfortable i felt cared for
leah was a great host
leah is a great host too
leah was a very communicative and respectful host
the hosts are very thoughtful and provide anything you could ever think of for a little farm getaway
leah was a wonderful host with great communication
great location and very comfortable
good location for me…
we loved walking the neighborhood and felt very secluded but close to everything in town
a perfect place to get away and relax
the space was perfect for working and close to downtown
Read more reviews

3. Wonderful and beautiful suite with pool (from 180 USD)

you can have a tranquil sleep in the vibrant and pleasant bedroom of this Airbnb with a pool in Long Island. It also comes with a small desk, so if need to complete some work while on vacation, you can do so here. You’ll also have access to the spacious walk-in closet where you can put all your belongings away neatly. Make use of your own private en-suite bathroom to go about your daily business or wash up with ease. Feel free to relax and unwind in the shared living room, and even play a game of pool! For another type of pool, head outdoors and make a splash in the swimming pool.

Idyllic Bayside Westhampton Suite

Address: Westhampton, New York, United States (see map)

Price: from 180 USD

Number of Guests: 3

Stayed at this property?

4. Three-bedroom house with an indoor fireplace (from USD 428)

Featuring three spacious bedrooms and two full baths, this lovely home can comfortably accommodate up to six guests. Outside, you can find cozy seating areas where you and your loved ones can enjoy your meals. A gourmet kitchen is available for guests who want to prepare their own food. The fenced backyard is the perfect place to play with your kids. There is an indoor fireplace to keep you warm and cozy when it gets chilly outside.

Stayed at this property?
Shirley, New York, United States
2.32 km (1.5 mi) from Smith Point County Park
124 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 5 Beds 6 Guests 3 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 6

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the ac works well and the wifi is great as well
the signla for wifi was perfect but the network didnt worked
the house was spacious and comfortable with everything we needed to both work and relax
the kitchen appliances made cooking several delicious meals a delight
the house was very clean really appreciated the hotel style towels
this place is beautiful clean and comfortable
house was very clean
all rooms are clean and tastefully decorated
clean bright and everything as described
zbigniew was quick to answer any questions we had and helpful with suggestions
the hosts are very welcoming and quick to respond
the home owners are very kind and get back to you very quickly with any questions or concerns
host responded very quickly and very helpful if needed anything
zyggi and vicky are great hosts and have great communication
great location - close to beach and food
location was great away from most city traffic
it’s very close with a walking distance to a nice beach
nice house in close proximity to smith point
this is a beautiful home located very close to a wonderful beach
Read more reviews

5. Illuminated and modern studio

You’ll definitely feel like you’re in the mood to cook yourself a simple and delicious meal in the lively kitchenette of this Airbnb vacation rental. Despite the space looking small, it doesn’t feel that way because of the murphy bed. When the bed is folded up, you could move around easily and comfortable; and while you want to rest, you can pull it down to sleep on it. Clean yourself up with ease in the vividly coloured and well-stocked bathroom. You could also relax on the covered back porch, or have a meal at the outdoor dining area.

Stayed at this property?

21.01 km (13.1 mi) from Smith Point County Park
320 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE RENTAL UNIT 1 Bed 2 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 2

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the apartment has all the amenities you need for a comfortable stay
being given honey jam breakfast staples was so unexpected and thoughtful
the apartment is tidy and features lots of natural light and the surrounding property is quite beautiful
every morning we enjoyed coffee and breakfast on the porch
everything in the apartment is as described - the porch is beautiful for a good-night drink
very clean and comfortable
the space is very clean and well kept
it was clean and had little extras throughout
the apartment was perfectly clean and with beautiful decor
the space is super clean and lovely
shirley was an excellent host
shirley was the perfect host with the perfect space
shirley and her husband were excellent hosts
the hospitality was excellent - we felt very at home thanks to our hosts
bananas apples and kind bars
the location was fantastic and close to it all
walking distance and well worth it
great location for visiting wineries in north fork
this is the perfect location for a romantic weekend get away
location was great to explore the area
Read more reviews

6. Well-decorated and bright apartment

This homey Airbnb apartment comes extremely well decorated from top to bottom, and you can relax and unwind while watching TV comfortably in the roomy and bright living room. You could also whip up a tasty meal in the warm and well-appointed kitchen, and tuck into it immediately. Lounge back on the bed while watching TV before falling asleep on the soft pillows. You can also request a queen-size air mattress to accommodate 2 more guests. When you want to wash up, you can make use of the provided toiletries in the fully-equipped bathroom of this vacation rental.

Stayed at this property?
Southampton, New York, United States
42.9 km (26.7 mi) from Smith Point County Park
207 reviews   Wifi Available
ENTIRE RENTAL UNIT 2 Beds 4 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 4

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
apartment has great amenities
charlotte’s apartment is an outstanding light-filled private space the apartment is large and comfortable
sleep arrangements were really comfy wifi was great bathroom had everything you need would definitely stay again
the apartment is truly just as attractive and cozy as the photos make it look
the bathroom was filled with lovely lotions and any products you might need and might have forgotten
very charming clean and comfortable
it was clean quite and adorable
it’s just as the pictures depict - very clean and cozy
very clean and super responsive host
perfect everything comfortable clean and cozy
hosts were extremely helpful
very gracious host
they are great hosts
host was very friendly and accommodating
host was lovely and very accommodating
good location that is close to everything
very convenient location and comfortable space
this is a cute place to stay
we stayed for 8 days and the location was perfect to the village beaches and great restaurants
a beautiful house with everything you might need in a very nice location
Read more reviews

7. Roomy, private suite close to creek (from USD 200)

Feel free to just laze about on the sofa while reading a book or watching the TV in the lovely living room of this Airbnb retreat. The sofa can then be pulled out into a sleeper that can sleep 1-2 people perfectly. If you want to fall asleep in an actual bed, head into the well-decorated bedroom and have a restful sleep. The bright and pristine bathroom comes with just about everything you’ll need to wash up easily. From grilling up a feast to relaxing on the lounge chairs, you can do all of that on the large shared deck. Or even head down to the nearby creek and go kayaking or canoeing!

Stayed at this property?
Patchogue, New York, United States
10.5 km (6.6 mi) from Smith Point County Park
269 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
Entire guest suite 2 Beds 3 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 3

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the accommodation was great and included private sitting room with sofa large screen tv and fireplace
the bed is extremely comfortable the breakfasts were yummy- what more could you ask for?
everything was very nice quality from the mattress we slept on to the towels in the bathroom
there is a very comfortable private living room space to relax and unwind in
cozy suite with a perfect mattress and an easy distance to great restaurants
the place was immaculately clean with soft towels and comfortable bed
titus keeps the suite clean and stocked with all the essentials including really nice towels
everything was clean and well thought out
it was clean and the bed was really comfortable
it was clean comfortable and well maintained
titus is a great host
titus is an amazing host
and titus and mary elisabeth are lovely hosts
the accommodation is sumptuous and the hosts are delightful
titus is the best host you can dream of
the creekside location is particularly nice
this is an excellent location at a wonderful price
a perfect getaway that is conveniently close to patchogue's bustling main street
close to the big city but quite a refreshing retreat
fantastic location delightful hosts and delicious homemade breakfast every morning
Read more reviews

8. Private and contemporary village cottage (from USD 252)

If you’re looking for vibrant yet home-like vacation rentals on Long Island, then this is the vacation rental for you! Feel as though you’re in your own home in this vibrant and comfortable Airbnb; laze on the sofa and watch TV comfortably. When you’re feeling hungry, you can prepare a nice meal in the modern and well-appointed kitchen. Also, feel free to make use of the basic toiletries and clean up in the well-decorated and fully-stocked bathroom. With all the dresser space, you can keep your belongings away neatly in the bedroom, or just have a private sleep in the huge bed. Sit back and relax while enjoying the warmth of the sun on the private patio of this tiny house rental.

Stayed at this property?
Southampton, New York, United States
43.08 km (26.8 mi) from Smith Point County Park
412 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
Entire guesthouse 2 Beds 3 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 3

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
an easy walk to breakfast or coffee
jen's place is as described very comfortable/modern and clean
everything was very clean
awesome place cute clean cottage with modern touches
quiet and very clean
the cottage is clean and cozy
the house itself is clean stocked with everything you need and stylish
the host was responsive and very helpful
jen was an amazing host
jen is a great host
jen is a great host and super helpful
jen is a most thoughtful host
great location right near town
great location in the heart of southampton
good location close to the main street
súper well stocked kitchen; great location
wonderful location on a quiet road
Read more reviews

9. Cozy studio with air conditioning (from USD 173)

This cozy condo can comfortably sleep up to two guests, making it ideal for couples looking for budget-friendly options. It features a private bathroom with bathing essentials such as towels and soap for the guests’ convenience. If you are looking for entertainment, this rental comes with a TV and free WiFi, so you can easily stream your favorite shows. During your stay, you can have access to the spacious backyard with comfortable seating.

Stayed at this property?
Freeport, New York, United States
62.23 km (38.7 mi) from Smith Point County Park
303 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 1 Bed 2 Guests 0 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 2

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
super cozy with modern vibes netflix & easy access is huge plus
pullout bed is not comfortable but the rest of the space is perfect
small but well designed room with a great bath
would have liked a better bed but otherwise worth the stay here
very clean fun and modern
jason’s place was clean and stylish
space is very clean modern and comfortable for two
tiny place but its very clean and the shower is amazing
clean comfortable & easy to access
jason is a great host
the host is very nice and responsive
he was kind enough to pick me up some snacks from the store on his way back home
host was professional & is great with communication
great host place is fun and interesting
nice location in residential area
place is in a perfect location
good place in a great neighborhood
a cozy modern studio in a great location
close to local fun things food etc
Read more reviews

10. Cute, red cottage getaway (from USD 150)

One of the most charming Long Island vacation home rentals, this Airbnb resembles a fairytale abode that is sure to impress you. Simply decorated and bright, you can just relax and unwind while you’re on the sofa, or pull it out into a sleeper that can sleep an extra guest easily. How about saving some money by grabbing some groceries and cooking in the well-appointed kitchen? When you want to fall asleep, you can choose between any of the two bedrooms that come with a queen-size bed each: the roomy and comfortable master bedroom or the smaller yet cheery second bedroom.

Stayed at this property?
Huntington, Northport, New York, United States
46.04 km (28.7 mi) from Smith Point County Park
293 reviews   Wifi Available
Entire cottage 2 Beds 6 Guests 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 6

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the cottage is quaint and comfortable
while very simple it has:- great high-speed wifi- large screen tv with netflix prime video cable etc
the cottage is private quiet and comfortable
nice kitchen comfortable sitting room and a work table and wifi
if you’re a big ice cream fan be sure to check out burgerology downtown
we found this house very clean comfortable and quiet
nice cottage clean and cozy
this place is exactly as advertised: a clean cute cosy cottage
clean private and rick is very responsive and hospitable
sweet private serene and sparkling clean red cottage gem
host helpful and available for questions
rick was a very responsive host
rick is an amazing host
richard the host was very friendly and helpful
richard was a very nice host
very cute and a great location
the location was good
the location is great- very central to huntington and/or greenlawn
we loved the location since it was so close to family
location was central and we could easily navigate
Read more reviews

11. Colourful, contemporary beachside home (from 215 USD)

Feel right at home while you’re relaxing in this bright and comfortable Airbnb vacation rental, and the sofa in the living room can be pulled out into a plush sleeper that can sleep 1-2 people with ease. If you want to whip up a meal, you can definitely do so in the well-appointed and modern kitchen. And when you want to catch up on some well-deserved sleep, you can retreat into the vibrant and cosy bedroom. After a long day out, you could wash up in the pristine bathroom. Or even hang out in the hammock while enjoying the peace and quiet of the private side yard.

Cozy Modern Beach House

Address: Long Beach, New York, United States (see map)

Price: from 215 USD

Number of Guests: 4

Stayed at this property?

12. Charming and lively home (from USD 250)

The kitchen of this Airbnb home comes stock with plenty of modern appliances and is also stocked with tons of ingredients like fresh eggs, making it the perfect space to stay in and cook for the night. Retire to the welcoming bedroom of this vacation rental which comes with some closet space to put your belongings away neatly, or just sleep tight in the large and plush bed. Bright and well-equipped, you can clean yourself up after a long day out. Whether it be rain or shine, you can relax and unwind on the covered front porch while admiring the view of the well-maintained garden. Within the gardens, there’s a small sitting area where you can sit and enjoy the warmth of the sun.

Stayed at this property?
Sayville, New York, United States
19.01 km (11.9 mi) from Smith Point County Park
22 reviews   Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 1 Bed 2 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 2

Top guest reviews
everything was clean and in order when we arrived
her house is clean and neat
it was convenient quiet clean and very relaxing
her home is clean lovely and quaint
tina is a fantastic host
tina was such a wonderful host
tina was the perfect host she was very communicative and accommodating to us throughout - truly lovely
tina's home is the perfect place tina was very helpful from the very beginning
tina is friendly responsive and helpful
close to the train near the stores and in a lovely lane
the location in sayville is great
location is perfect for walking to town and the train is very close
minutes of walking distances away from great local restaurants and bars
great place to stay and get away from the city
Read more reviews

13. Cottage perfect for a beach getaway

You’re welcome to relax in the well-decorated living room of this Airbnb cottage, or pull it out into a sleeper that can sleep one guest perfectly. Cook yourself a delicious meal in the kitchen before tucking into it while it’s still warm at the snug dining area of this vacation rental. Feel free to lounge on the bed in the master bedroom while watching your TV, or just tuck yourself in and sleep comfortably. The second bedroom comes with storage space for you to put your belongings away, and you can catch up on some restful sleep. Grill up a delicious feast or just let yourself loose in the large and well-maintained yard.

Stayed at this property?
Shirley, New York, United States
2.53 km (1.6 mi) from Smith Point County Park
96 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
Entire cottage 3 Beds 5 Guests 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 5

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the house was fully equipped well equipped kitchen and stocked pantry
the bathroom was stocked like the kitchen with plenty of shampoos and soaps
sherrys place was amazing everything you would need she had cozy and a lovely backyard
beautiful clean and large house
the house was immaculately clean and decorated perfectly
house was beautiful clean and better than advertised would definitely recommend
my family and i appreciated the extra towels comfy beds and how clean the cottage was
sherry made it super easy coordinating arrival and the place was very clean
sherry was an amazing host
sherry was a great host and made us feel very welcome
great host was extremely accessible and communicative
sherry was a great host and went out of her way to make us feel welcome
shirley greeted us and could not have been more accommodating or sweet
the house was cute and had a pretty good location
the location is great right by a bay beach and minutes by driving from smith point beach
we enjoyed the location it was easy to access the hamptons and riverhead area
great place to stay near the beach - sherry was very helpful and friendly
so kind the location is also great
Read more reviews

14. Secluded and rustic cottage

Leave all your troubles at the door, and just relax in the living room. Throw some logs into the fireplace and keep warm, and you can also pull the sofa out into a sleeper that can sleep 1-2 people comfortably. Despite looking rustic, it comes fully furnished so you can go about cooking and dining well in this cute kitchen. When you want to fall asleep, you can head up to the loft bedroom which features a plush, queen-size bed. Go about your daily business in the spacious and well-equipped bathroom. When you want to enjoy a walk, you can stroll through the large and well-maintained gardens of this best Airbnb on Long Island while enjoying the sights and sounds.

Stayed at this property?
East Patchogue, New York, United States
9.71 km (6.1 mi) from Smith Point County Park
210 reviews  
Entire guesthouse 2 Beds 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

15. Tranquil apartment near the beach

This cabin rental in Long Island, New York is in close proximity with the beach. It can easily sleep up to three guests, featuring a queen bed and a sofa bed. You can enjoy access to high-speed WiFi while you are here, so feel free to post your photos on social media. The TV offers Netflix and Roku access for entertainment.

If you prefer the outdoors, you can enjoy several activities nearby, such as hiking and tennis. With barbecue facilities available, you can enjoy an intimate celebration with your loved ones while you admire the stunning views of the sunset.

Stayed at this property?
Shoreham, New York, United States
25.42 km (15.8 mi) from Smith Point County Park
11 reviews  
Entire apartment 2 Beds 0 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the apartment is so beautiful and so much more spacious than it appears in the photos
place was all new and clean maria was welcoming and helpful
very clean with a variety of amenities
maria was a great host and was super responsive and communicative throughout the days leading up to my trip
this air bnb was very cozy and inviting the host was easy to get in touch with
great location - literally right next to the beach
the neighborhood is very quiet and peaceful
the location is steps from the beach and is very calm and peaceful
stayed at maria's place for a quick friends get away
super gracious hosts and a beautiful place to stay right next to the beach highly recommend
Read more reviews

Luxuriate in style on Long Island

For people who want to vacation in the state of New York, yet want to get away from all the hustle and bustle of the larger cities, Long Island is truly the perfect getaway spot! Whether you’re searching for private rooms in charming houses or beachfront vacation rentals on Long Island, Airbnb has plenty of options for you. So, check out these Airbnb vacation rentals and set out exploring the different counties that interest you by embarking on the best weekend trips from Long Island. Whatever you choose to do, the attractions and romantic places of this charming region will surely enchant you.

Frequently asked questions about the top Airbnb vacation rentals in Long Island, New York

Any must-sees we missed? Tell us about them in the comments section or write a post here to help out fellow travelers!
Disclosure: Trip101 selects the listings in our articles independently. Some of the listings in this article contain affiliate links.


Get Trip101 in your inbox

Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data

Eunice, an introvert who finds solace in the pages of a book while snug in her bed, transforms into an eager adventurer at the mere mention of travel. Despite her usual penchant for solitude, the...Read more

 Want to contribute as a Local Expert?
Explore Long Island
Good things are meant to be shared!
Back to top
Visited any of these places? Click this button to activate our "Add a Tip" feature to share your experience.