Top 11 Airbnb Vacation Rentals In Bellport, New York - Updated 2024

Diah
Diah 
Updated
| 4 min read

As the small East Coast village in Suffolk County, Bellport is another village for your weekend getaway on the South Shore of Long Island. Located in between Manhattan and the Hamptons, Bellport promotes a good old-fashioned relaxation atmosphere with its colonial feel and beautiful sunrise and sunset by the beach. Considering its perfect location, Bellport can be your choice for a more friendly budget accommodation but still within arms-length reach from the Hamptons. The quaint destination plays host to plenty of colorful specialty shops, delectable restaurants, and, most especially, the premier showcase of local talents in the Gateway Playhouse. It’s also home to several enchanting vacation rentals that are certainly worth staying. From cozy bed and breakfast to cute home rentals, Bellport, New York, has it all! So, keep scrolling for a list of our top Airbnb vacation rentals in Bellport, New York!

We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on February 02, 2024.

1. Cheery seasonal rental with two bedrooms (from USD 250)

Able to comfortably accommodate small and mid-sized families, this cheery Bellport rental is an idyllic vacation home to come to in the shining summer heat. The surrounding neighborhood is quiet and peaceful, ensuring your time here is healing. However, plenty of exciting local attractions, including the Bellport Marina and Gateway Playhouse, are within reach.

Inside the cozy rental are two bedrooms, one of which has identical twin beds. You can expect standard self-catering amenities here, from the opulent kitchen to the in-unit laundry facilities. Additionally, its backyard features a swimming pool and an outdoor shower, setting the scene for endless summer fun. Dogs are also welcome on the property, although do make sure to keep them away from the pool.

Stayed at this property?
Bellport, New York, United States
8.66 km (5.4 mi) from Brookhaven Ecology Site
50 reviews   Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 4 Beds 4 Guests 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 4

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
this is a small cottage home with lovely furnishings and very comfortable
the patio / pool area is stunning
we appreciated the kitchen fully equipped as we enjoy cooking when we travel
back yard and pool is adorable
the house was very comfortable and had the most beautiful back yard
Cleanliness:
it was clean and bright
the house is clean and comfortable
jean francois home is lovely it is clean and very cozy
very clean and with useful instructions we appreciated a lot
the house was sparkly clean very well kept and very comfortable
Host:
nice simple home and very communicative and accommodating host
jf is a wonderful attentive host
a lovely and quiet neighborhood and a very kind and responsive host
jean is a great host and goes above and beyond for his guests
he is a great host and communicator 5 star’s all the way
Location:
the location is great
the location is perfect near the beach and close to town
just a beautiful location
the location is wonderful close to town center and all local attractions
we could not have asked for a better house and location for our vacation
Read more reviews

2. Bellport House (from USD 500)

This 1940s renovated home has interiors featuring contemporary decors and furnishings with a modern twist. Savor the experience of peaceful luxury with several of its indoor and outdoor spaces, including a sitting lounge with a seasonal wood-powered fireplace, a screened patio, and a quaint pool in the backyard.

Furthermore, the kitchen keeps several vintage items, as evident in the stove-top oven, amongst all the up-to-date appliances. The same can be said for much of the house, as familiar comforts such as WiFi and TV are within your reach. With such a convenient location, you’ll have easy access to all the fun things to do in Bellport, New York, such as strolling by the beach and exploring the marina.

Stayed at this property?
Bellport, New York, United States
8.85 km (5.5 mi) from Brookhaven Ecology Site
32 reviews   Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 4 Beds 8 Guests 4 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 8

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the plunge pool was fantastic for a dip on those hot july days
the place was just as cozy and beautifully decorated as the photos make it seem
the kitchen is equipped for a chef and we loved creating meals and memories here
beautiful pool and back yard
Cleanliness:
georges place was great very clean and excellent design
the house is beautifully decorated very clean and comfortable
it was impeccably clean and a bottle of wine awaited us
Host:
george was a great host and always answered any questions promptly
finally george is a great host
george was a gracious and hospitable host
excellent stay the host was very responsive and has the cutest house
george was always available to respond to any questions or requests he was a delightful and accommodating host
Location:
location is great
we really enjoyed our stay the location was super convenient and a quick walk to the village
a great getaway from the city with everything you need within walking distance
gorgeous space in an amazing location
george was great to work with great location just minutes/blocks from water and downtown area
Read more reviews

3. The Walkway studio apartment

The Walkway studio apartment is located on the second floor of a house in Town of Brookhaven. The apartment has a private entrance, private bathroom, and it comes with a fully equipped kitchen too. Other facilities such as WiFi connection, AC, and TV are also available in the apartment. Within walking distance, you will reach the main street where you will find shops and eateries, the Great South Bay, ferries to Fire Island, and The Gateway theatre.

Stayed at this property?
Bellport, New York, United States
9.04 km (5.7 mi) from Brookhaven Ecology Site
56 reviews  
Entire apartment 2 Beds 0 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
we had a very comfortable stay
nick has notes here and there to help out—couch to bed conversion tv etc
Cleanliness:
everything was clean and uncluttered
everything is clean and organized
everything was clean and as described
clean and felt like our own
clean thoughtful touches and comfortable bed
Host:
nick & judy were great hosts
nick and his wife were such wonderful hosts too
nick is a wonderful host who truly tries to make his guests feel at home
great host and wonderful space
we appreciated the water and snacks provided by the host
Location:
location was perfect very close to town
it’s located within easy walking distance to belport restaurants and shopping
perfect location in bellport
super close to the downtown village and a short distance to the water
the studio is walking distance from great restaurants and cute shops
Read more reviews

Nearby Airbnb vacation rentals

4. Two-bedroom cottage rental (from USD 155)

Although there are many hotels near Shriley, this two-bedroom cottage is perfect for those looking for countryside holiday with a modern touch. The hardwood floors and the house itself are amazing, but with a modern touch from its newly renovated kitchen that included new stainless steel appliances. It’s perfect for families with kids! WiFi connection, AC, and TV are available in the property. There are two bicycles available for you if you want to explore the village, Smith Point beach is just 10 minutes’ bike ride or 2 minutes’ drive by car. Tangler Outlets, Farms, waterpark, Hampton Bays, Montauk Point, and Long Island wineries are just a short drive away.

Stayed at this property?
Shirley, New York, United States
14.19 km (8.9 mi) from Brookhaven Ecology Site
272 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 3 Beds 4 Guests 3 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 4

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
comfortable place with many amenities
this little cottage is adorable and has all the amenities for a comfortable stay
nice kitchen with washer/dryer
after reading the reviews i knew that our group would be comfortable
the bedrooms are comfortable and ac works great
Cleanliness:
the space was clean and cozy
the house was clean and comfortable
plenty of clean towels paper goods and kitchen items
the place was fantastic and very clean
the house was very clean and had everything you need
Host:
excellent home and host
diana was a great host responding quickly to questions
diana is a great host
host diana was friendly and responsive
diana is a host who provides quick responses great advice and is flexible
Location:
mama lisa’s is a very nice italian eatery close by
cute little place in a great neighborhood
the location was great as well everything you needed was close to the house
it was close to my family and friends and very close to the beach
beautiful spacious house in a lovely location
Read more reviews

5. Shores retreat (from USD 157)

Enjoy a retreat from the hustle and bustle of the big city in this beautiful one-bedroom antique house. WiFi connection, TV, AC, and a fully equipped kitchen with stainless steel appliances are available on the property. The Airbnb rental also comes with a spacious deck with a barbecue facility and outdoor dining area where you can enjoy dinner as well as a flagstone patio with a fire pit for late night bonfire talk.

The most interesting part is that the property is next to the woods and has a direct access to the creek. There are canoes available in the property that you can use to explore the creek during your stay.

Stayed at this property?
Patchogue, New York, United States
6.54 km (4.1 mi) from Brookhaven Ecology Site
264 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
Entire guest suite 2 Beds 3 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 3

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the accommodation was great and included private sitting room with sofa large screen tv and fireplace
the bed is extremely comfortable the breakfasts were yummy- what more could you ask for?
everything was very nice quality from the mattress we slept on to the towels in the bathroom
there is a very comfortable private living room space to relax and unwind in
cozy suite with a perfect mattress and an easy distance to great restaurants
Cleanliness:
the place was immaculately clean with soft towels and comfortable bed
titus keeps the suite clean and stocked with all the essentials including really nice towels
everything was clean and well thought out
it was clean and the bed was really comfortable
it was clean comfortable and well maintained
Host:
titus is a great host
titus is an amazing host
and titus and mary elisabeth are lovely hosts
the accommodation is sumptuous and the hosts are delightful
titus is the best host you can dream of
Location:
the creekside location is particularly nice
this is an excellent location at a wonderful price
a perfect getaway that is conveniently close to patchogue's bustling main street
close to the big city but quite a refreshing retreat
fantastic location delightful hosts and delicious homemade breakfast every morning
Read more reviews

6. Cottage with seashells (from USD 89)

This guest cottage offers one bedroom for two people with its own yard and a barbecue facility. The kitchen comes with a microwave, toaster, coffee pot, and a full-size refrigerator. WiFi connection and AC are available also in the property. Within six to seven blocks, you will reach the Great South Bay shoreline.

Stayed at this property?
Mastic Beach, New York, United States
15.2 km (9.5 mi) from Brookhaven Ecology Site
153 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 1 Bed 2 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 2

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the cottage was comfortable and charmingly decorated
the cottage was setup comfortably with a little kitchenette a bed bathroom and a few tables
it was comfortable and safe at the cottage
the cottage was cute and cozy
our only complaint was some ants in the kitchen area but theresa took care of this right away
Cleanliness:
eclectic clean cottage in quiet neighborhood
everything was clean and the bed was confortable
house was clean and welcoming
the place is very clean cozy and private
the cottage is clean comfortable and well-decorated
Host:
the host was very respectful and communicative
theresa is the perfect host
theresa is a great host
theresa was a fantastic host
theresa was an excellent host
Location:
this is a cute and comfortable place
location was awesome only 5 minute drive to fire island beach
mastic beach is also close to other nice places like hamptons bays and southampton
nice neighborhood very quiet
close to the beach and the motif fit the atmosphere
Read more reviews

7. Delightful Bellport Village beach home

This two-storey house at the Bellport village offers three bedrooms and two bathrooms that can accommodate up to eight people. WiFi connection, AC, TV, and a fully equipped kitchen are available in the property. The property also has a swimming pool for you to enjoy on summer days and a spacious outdoor deck with barbecue facility to enjoy dinner on summer nights. Within walking distance, you will reach local shops, restaurants, and ferries to Fire Island.

Stayed at this property?

8.84 km (5.5 mi) from Brookhaven Ecology Site
4 reviews  
Entire house 4 Beds 8 Guests

8. Smith Point home

Spend your relaxing holiday in style by staying in this elegant Smith Point home which is walking distance from Smith Point beach. The accommodation offers four bedrooms and two bathrooms, and it can accommodate up to eight people. The basic amenities such as a fully equipped kitchen, TV, AC, an indoor fireplace, and WiFi connection are available on the property. There is also a swimming pool with spacious space for everyone to enjoy the summer, a hot tub that can accommodate up to six people, and a barbecue facility for you to enjoy during your stay. Within walking distance, you will reach Fire Island ferries and the beaches. It’s a holiday in style to the last touch!

Stayed at this property?
Shirley, New York, United States
14.55 km (9.1 mi) from Brookhaven Ecology Site
311 reviews  
Entire house 4 Beds 4 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
huge lawn with firepit and lovely pool
very nice house with big upper patio desk over looking the pool and huge backyard
the backyard is spectacular and we’d welcome a trip when we could take advantage of the pool
the pool was closed but the hot tub was very relaxing after a long day
the pool and hot tub are awesome
Cleanliness:
very clean and beautiful place
so clean and spacious
carlo was great with communication the house is as described and very clean
hot tub is clean and well placed
carlo's place is amazing clean and super chic
Host:
very helpful and service minded
carlo the host is great
great host and a great place
carlo was a great host from start to finish
carlo is a great host who was readily available
Location:
good value and location
however the location allows for easy travel around the island
great house very relaxing and great location close to the beach
beautiful modern beach house situated so close to smith point beach
my family had a wonderful summer holiday at carlo’s place
Read more reviews

9. Charming cape, close to the ocean

This beautiful two-storey house is located in a charming yet quiet neighbourhood in Bellport. Within walking distance, you will reach the beach. The house has four bedrooms and two bathrooms, and it can accommodate up to five people. It comes with AC, TV, WiFi connection, and a fully equipped kitchen for you to use during your stay. There is a small backyard where you can find a sitting area to enjoy the summer day.

Stayed at this property?
Shirley, New York, United States
14.41 km (9.0 mi) from Brookhaven Ecology Site
327 reviews   Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 5 Beds 6 Guests 4 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 6

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
sleeps 6 and great kitchen space for communal dinners
the space was large and comfortable
it has plenty of room for family fun both inside and outside
Cleanliness:
amazing communication easy check-in/check out and very clean house
sparkling clean home at a great price
inside was clean and just lovely
house was very clean and had all the essentials we needed
it was a clean house with everything you would need for a nice stay
Host:
carmen was a wonderful host
carmen was a wonderful host
carmen is a wonderful host
carmen is amazing host
carmen was a great host
Location:
great location for the beach
great location and beautiful house
great location- so close to the beach
lovely house in a nice location on long island
great location so close to the water without water front pricing
Read more reviews

10. Perfect beach getaway

Who needs Hampton if you can stay in a lovely house next to the white sandy beach? This three-bedroom house can accommodate up to six people and it’s perfect for a small family group holiday! The property has everything you need from TV, WiFi connection, a fully equipped kitchen and a barbecue facility. Within 5 minutes’ walk, you will reach the bay and within 10 minutes drive, you will reach Smith Point Beach.

Stayed at this property?
Mastic Beach, New York, United States
16.46 km (10.3 mi) from Brookhaven Ecology Site
95 reviews   Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 3 Beds 6 Guests 3 Bedrooms 1 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 6

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the photos accurately depict the house which was very quiet and comfortable
great screened in room to sit out at night
we had a great time the house is super comfortable and very complete
the beds and linens were super cozy
the house is very comfortable and had everything we needed
Cleanliness:
house clean and charming
antoinette’s place was clean and extremely cozy
spacious tidy clean and “koselig”
the house was very clean when we arrived and had all the linen and towels we needed
we had a great stay at antoinette's it was immaculately clean with a well appointed kitchen
Host:
she is an excellent host
very accommodating and checking in to make sure we were comfortable
antionette was a wonderful host and was very responsive to all our needs
antoinette was a great host
antoinette was a very good host
Location:
wonderful house close to good local shopping and the beach
the location is great for a visit to the hamptons or a beach closer by
super close to smith point beaches and easy access to all major freeways
we strongly recommend this location
great stay with my family quiet location
Read more reviews

11. Beach bungalow

Take a break from the hustle and bustle of the big city by staying in this self-contained cozy beach bungalow with two bedrooms. A simple kitchen with stove, WiFi connection, and a barbecue facility are available on the property. The property also provides some family amenities if you are travelling with toddlers. There are two beach cruiser bikes that you can use to explore the Mastic beach area all the way to Smith Point beach.

Stayed at this property?
Mastic Beach, New York, United States
15.44 km (9.6 mi) from Brookhaven Ecology Site
119 reviews  
Entire cottage 2 Beds 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the wi-fi worked great
the furniture is comfortable and gives the little house a special touch
copy of wifi code) would have been nice
the bungalow is nicely set up and offers a bit more (living)room than you may expect from the pictures
the home and surrounding yard/patio were comfortable and fully functional and the house was beautifully decorated
Cleanliness:
place was neat clean and tidy
clean very comfortable beds
house was quite clean
the place is very clean inside and comfortable
it was charming and sparkling clean
Host:
pat was a great host
very responsive and attentive host
pat was a thoughtful and attentive host
pat is a wonderful and communicative host
pat was a great host and communicated very easily
Location:
good 'midpoint' location for li
the location was great very short drive to the beach and lots of things in the area
excellent location perfect size for my family of 4
great price great location great cottage
the cabin is very nice quiet and close to the beach
Read more reviews

Who needs Hampton if we have Bellport?

Bellport might not be as famous and high-end as its neighbour, Hampton. But you are still able to enjoy summertime on one of the most beautiful beaches in Long Island, overlooking the sunset. Have a relaxing time in many of Bellport’s scenic hotels and Airbnb rentals, even when the night is over. Your accommodation will give you the best comfort that you can get on your weekend getaway at Bellport.

Looking for a similar location near the Hamptons? The area is packed with several cozy hotels and Airbnb vacation rentals in Bohemia, Mastic Beach, and more, all of which are worth checking out!

Frequently asked questions about the Airbnb vacation rentals in Bellport


Any must-sees we missed? Tell us about them in the comments section or write a post here to help out fellow travelers!
Disclosure: Trip101 selects the listings in our articles independently. Some of the listings in this article contain affiliate links.

History


Get Trip101 in your inbox

Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data

Rany is an Indonesian woman with an insatiable love for global exploration. Having set foot on four continents and visited 17 countries, her wanderlust continues to grow. Alongside her adventures,...Read more

 Want to contribute as a Local Expert?
Explore Bellport
x
Good things are meant to be shared!
Back to top
Visited any of these places? Click this button to activate our "Add a Tip" feature to share your experience.