Top 22 Airbnb Vacation Rentals In Harbour Island, Bahamas - Updated 2024

airbnb Harbour-Island Bahamas
| 7 min read

Harbour Island is a part of the Out Islands of the Bahamas, just a few miles away from Eleuthera. It is famous for its pink-sand beaches, colorful colonial-style structures, and floral display along the streets. It provides tourists and locals alike with a solemn retreat where they can watch the majestic setting of the sun or savor the beauty of the shoreline. Hotels and restaurants on this part of the Caribbean won’t disappoint you either. From resort-like accommodations to spacious and breezy homes, you will surely find one that will suit your taste. Here are some of the most amazing Airbnb vacation rentals in Harbour Island, Bahamas. Check them out below for great accommodations in your upcoming trip to the Caribbean’s finest.

We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on May 15, 2024.

1. Tucked In on Dunmore Street (from USD 495)

Tucked In is an adorable one-bedroom cottage boasts an upper deck sure to become your favorite spot for a glass of wine at sunset during your stay. A covered porch in the front of the house comes in handy for bird watching or when indulging in a cup of coffee. The interior speaks of warmth and elegance with all the wooden furnishing from the living room to the bedrooms.

Choose among the varied and plentiful seating in the lounge for your indoor leisure sessions. The two bedrooms are equally fitted with large beds and private bathrooms, one even comes with its own entrance for easy access. Wi-Fi is available if that’s one of your concerns.

Stayed at this property?
Harbour Island, Eleuthera, Bahamas
7.71 km (4.8 mi) from Glass Window Bridge
70 reviews   Wifi Available
Entire cottage 2 Beds 4 Guests 2 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 4

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the wifi worked very well
beautifully decorated and maintained rooms with fresh flowers brought in daily
tucked in is the perfect place its lovely decorated and clean
it is clean bright with a great number of decks and with a rooftop one with a view
james was a great host
our hosts were very quick and easy to reach
the location is great and the host was quick to respond
cute place in the perfect location
great location beautiful home
perfect accommodations in amazing location
a great location easy and convenient walking distance to everything great for 2 couples
i loved that i could walk everywhere from this central location
Read more reviews

2. Vibrant cottage near Pink Sand Beach (from USD 315)

The vibrant feel of this Harbour Island cottage is complemented by a sub-tropical garden to achieve a highly relaxing accommodation for four guests. Your summer getaway is bound to be extra comfortable with the two bright bedrooms in the unit; a king-size bed and bunk bed await your arrival. Note that access to the second bedroom is only through the master suite. Whip up your favorite dishes in the fully equipped kitchen and be delighted by its essential appliances and stocks.

Savor the island air on the furnished private patio or in the hammock. Before basking under the sun, check out the bathtub in one of the two bathrooms. The unit is situated in a quiet area but close enough to top destinations; Pink Sand Beach and a nearby resort are within short walking distance.

Stayed at this property?
Dunmore Town, Harbour Island, Bahamas
6.86 km (4.3 mi) from Glass Window Bridge
66 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
Entire cottage 3 Beds 4 Guests 2 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 4

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
ac is cold wifi works great and the washer/dryer were awesome to have
we prepared most of our meals using the small kitchen and enjoyed using the patio and grill
the a/c which we used at night was cool quiet and efficient
kitchen is very complete the place was very clean with plenty of towels beach chairs and umbrella
laundry beach chairs fresh water spices and plenty of towels
it's cozy quiet private clean and charming
the house is clean comfy and the location was ideal
the cottage is nice and spacious clean well-cared for and the location is great
she was very helpful with any questions we had and everything was seamless
the marina hotel concierge was helpful too
having a functioning laundry out back was very helpful
harbour island has the friendliest people you will ever meet
great spot and accommodating hosts
amazing location and simple nice house
excellent location excellent beds and linens well appointed kitchen
wonderful home in a great location on the island
definitely recommend staying here as it is a great value and great location
the location is perfect as it is immediately adjacent to ramora bay
Read more reviews

3. Quaint apartment for two guests (from USD 180)

You can experience a unique tropical life for two in this one-bedroom gem. Suitable for couples or solo travelers, this apartment is a comfy accommodation set in a peaceful area with direct access to the beach.

The rental welcomes with a covered porch looking out onto the beach and ocean, furnished to host a relaxing morning or afternoon unwinding with your favorite drink. Inside the air-conditioned unit, you can laze in the living room’s sofas and catch a flick on the TV with standard cable or make use of the available Wi-Fi for your browsing needs. Can’t miss out on home-cooked meals? The kitchen is an equipped space to cater to your skillful cooking. A large bed in a separate room can cradle you to sound sleep, recharging you for the batch of activities to try out the next day.

Stayed at this property?
Dunmore Town, Bahamas
6.22 km (3.9 mi) from Glass Window Bridge
120 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE RENTAL UNIT 1 Bed 2 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 2

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the wifi works great (we were working remotely and never had any issues at all)
cold ac and an extremely comfortable and spacious bed await you after a day in the sun
we had an amazing week long stay at apartment atlast
harbour island is a beautiful island and the apt is the perfect getaway
the sounds of the ocean are so soothing from the apartment
very clean and functional
everything was so clean and well kept and the beach was just a path away
the apartment was very clean and all amenities worked well
teejay was a great host
the host is more than welcoming and can you help you with anything you need
teejay was the perfect host
teejay was a great host very welcoming
on an island where hospitality is key you won’t find a more gracious host than irma
it's in a perfect location - easy to access quiet and steps from the beach
the location is the best and very quiet which we really enjoyed
close to the beach and surrounded with quiet beauty
great spot in a quiet neighborhood; feels tucked away and secluded
we loved staying at irma v’s place
Read more reviews

4. The Mill House (from USD 600)

A historic waterfront property, this five-generation family home is an ideal vacation abode for easy access to the beach. It is conveniently located near the dock so it is a great starting point for water activities in the deep sea. The cozy living room and generous balcony overlooking the bay provide a picturesque view of the beach and turquoise ocean. You can be your own chef in the kitchen and showcase all your techniques in whipping up delectable dishes.

A group of up to six is welcome in the property with its three air-conditioned bedrooms—the snug king-size and queen-size beds, as well as two single-size beds. Take advantage of the Wi-Fi to update your loved ones back home about your island adventures. Note that the property is on the second floor and only accessible by stairs.

Stayed at this property?
Dunmore Town, Harbour Island, Bahamas
7.49 km (4.7 mi) from Glass Window Bridge
46 reviews   Wifi Available
ENTIRE RENTAL UNIT 4 Beds 6 Guests 3 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 6

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
air conditioners were also great and very cold
the apartment itself is bright and airy with comfortable beds and great amenities
the unit was clean updated and extremely comfortable
it was clean centrally located and the communication was great
the apartment has been been beautifully decorated and was spotless
this place was clean well equipped and plenty comfortable for our group of 6
unbelievably clean and remodeled everyone who visited was so impress with the place
roomy comfortable upstairs unit with a nice friendly host
christina was a great host and responded with everything that we needed in a very timely manner
the place is ideally located on the island
great location right off the dock and in the heart of down town
very easy to find from the dock and close to food places
fantastic location great facilities clean
everything was excellent great location very clean
Read more reviews

5. Watercolor Cottage in Dunmore Town (from USD 500)

Spend your holiday right in the heart of Dunmore Town with a stay at Watercolor Cottage. Staying at the rental puts you close to the famous Pink San Beach, shops, restaurants, and other tourist hotspots.

The property consists of the main house that accommodates four people but an annex unit is available for an additional two guests. You can make your own homemade meals in the fully equipped kitchen and have an alfresco feast in the outdoor six-seater dining area. For cozy nights in the main house, choose between the queen-size Murphy bed and the king-size bed available in the two bedrooms. Those who’ll stay in the annex will enjoy double-size and two twin-size beds, along with an outdoor shower, and lots of seating. Don’t forget to hang out on the front porch for an extra relaxing afternoon.

Stayed at this property?
Dunmore Town, Harbour Island, Bahamas
7.84 km (4.9 mi) from Glass Window Bridge
43 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 4 Beds 6 Guests 3 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 6

Top guest reviews
jessica is a great host
jessica was a great host
jessica was very responsive and knowledgeable about the island
as a host you’d be hard pressed to find a better host than jessica
and jessica is an equally charming (and attentive) host
the location was excellent for us
jessica's place was great and centrally located to be close to everything
charming house great location and perfectly priced
we loved the location and that the house was a traditional property
it is in great location opposite the supermarket and dunmore deli
Read more reviews

6. Luxurious rental with a guest cottage (from USD 1900)

The luxury home is an exceptional and popular rental on the Sunset Harbour Estate that features a private deep-water dock for all guests. Just a few walks from the water edge is the high-end rental comfortable for 6 guests but with the property’s separate cottage, a group of 10 is also welcome.

You’ll enjoy a three-bedroom and bathroom accommodation in the luxurious main home and the additional two bedrooms and bathrooms in the equally gorgeous guest cottage. If you love entertaining, the ample social space in the open-plan kitchen, dining, and lounge areas make for an excellent spot. Delight the panoramic view of the bayside through the large windows and dip in the wrap-around pool for a refreshing break from the heat of the beach. This property is an ideal vantage point for a spectacular sunset during the golden hour.

Stayed at this property?
Harbour Island, Bahamas
6.89 km (4.3 mi) from Glass Window Bridge
15 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 3 Beds 10 Guests 5 Bedrooms 5 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 10

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the house was very spacious and the pool was heated to the perfect temperature
very clean and great quiet location
can’t thank lawrence and staff enough for our stay at this stunning property on harbour island
Read more reviews

7. Tropical retreat with a private pool (from USD 1000)

Spending a summer vacation at Harbour Island with the whole family and some friends? Let this four-bedroom holiday retreat host your big crew getaway. The property comfortably sleeps 16 guests in its sizeable, well-kept indoor and outdoor spaces.

In the tastefully decorated living, dining, and kitchen areas, everyone will find it easy to navigate the modern amenities. Enjoy the benefits of the flat-screen TV, fully-equipped and contemporary kitchen, and four bathrooms when indoors. You’ll have pampering nights in the range of beds available in the four bedrooms, from single-size to double-size mattresses. Have an intimate yet exciting outdoor experience in the property’s sparkling pool surrounded by luscious greenery. There is also an alfresco living area and grill to host all your barbecue and leisure activities. Wi-Fi is available throughout the property to always keep you online.

Stayed at this property?
Harbor Island, Harbour Island, Bahamas
6.72 km (4.2 mi) from Glass Window Bridge
25 reviews   Wifi Available
Entire townhouse 5 Beds 16 Guests 4 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 16

Top guest reviews
great pool and beautiful clean space would stay again
the place was clean and as advertised which made getting situated a breeze
wonderful clean townhouse especially if you have a lot of people
it was gorgeously decorated and super clean
darico and the staff were amazing
from start to finish darico and gina were wonderful hosts
darico & team were uber responsive and helpful with making our stay as relaxing and seamless as possible
great house and great location
great experience great location
this is my favorite island and the house was a perfect and convenient location
for the money it’s a great place on harbour island
Read more reviews

8. Modern and luxurious haven (from USD 5000)

This beachfront property is a secluded haven nestled in the northern part of the island. The house speaks of a highly convenient and comfortable vacation with its modern furnishings and amenities. With a large wrap-around deck and private beach access, the gorgeous coastlines of Harbour Island are yours to enjoy all day. Four bedrooms equipped with king-size and single-size beds provide a relaxing ambiance after ceasing from the ocean waves.

Its open layout interiors consist of living space with large sofas and flat-screen TV, six-seater modern dining table, and fully renovated chef’s kitchen with new appliances. Electrical power is secure as there is an independent power generator on standby. Should you wish to have an opulent and stress-free vacation in this property, avail of the host’s extravagant services such as private aircraft transports, jet skis, boats, chef, and even babysitting.

Stayed at this property?
Harbor Island, Harbour Island, Bahamas
8.38 km (5.3 mi) from Glass Window Bridge
28 reviews   Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 5 Beds 11 Guests 5 Bedrooms 5 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 11

Top guest reviews
the house is well equipped and clean
natasha was amazing and very helpful and a lovely lady came into clean everyday
the host is superb and went out of his way to meet our every need
location and beach are amazing host is very responsive and super helpful the entire staff was wonderful and kind
beautiful comfortable easy and a wonderful host to boot
everyone was extremely friendly helpful and kind thank you again hopefully will be back someday soon
communication with natasha and her staff was excellent
amazing location right on the world’s most beautiful beach
second time this year great location and beautiful house for our family and friends
beautiful place with a perfect location can’t wait to go back
Read more reviews

9. Beautiful beach house with amazing views and pool (from USD 1600)

Welcome to this beautiful spacious house for 10 persons, which is strategically set only a few steps from the popular Pink Sands Beach. Located in one of the best areas of Harbour Island, the accommodation features a swimming pool and a lovely lounge area on its rooftop. The homey accommodation is loaded with all the amenities required for a relaxed stay. These include a TV with cable channels, dryer, and beach essentials. Its lounge is an ideal place to watch the sunrise or view the waves of the ocean. Stay here for a few days and unwind yourself thoroughly.

Stayed at this property?
Dunmore Town, Harbour Island, Bahamas
7.63 km (4.8 mi) from Glass Window Bridge
55 reviews   Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 7 Beds 12 Guests 4 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 12

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
very spacious comfortable beds on and on
friendly neighbors very clean and responsive management
his staff is very responsive and helpful
gina and darico were very friendly and helpful
darico was very responsive to any issues
dario and gina were very responsive and helpful
darico and gina are superb hosts; book with confidence you won’t be disappointed
house is in a great location
the house is ideally located in a very quiet area close to town with outstanding beach access
a beautiful lookout point from the widow’s walk
great place to stay house is amazing and in a great location 5/5 stars
a great house in a spectacular location with excellent service and amenities
Read more reviews

10. Cozy townhouse for big groups (from USD 225)

If you’re looking for a lively neighborhood for your stay in Harbour Island, this is the perfect property. It is located on Dunmore Street and Love Lane which is occasionally a venue of fun, community events. Get to know the locals and see what Harbor has in store by exploring the beaches, specialty shops, club, and the town center. You can rent a golf cart to take you around the islands or go walking on some days. The house is equipped with everything you need for a convenient stay: a fully-equipped kitchen, a washer/dryer, a living area, and bedrooms with closets and a full bath.

Stayed at this property?
Dunmore Town, Harbour Island, Bahamas
7.69 km (4.8 mi) from Glass Window Bridge
83 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
Entire townhouse 2 Beds 6 Guests 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 6

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
positive things to note are comfy beds reliable wi-fi and a quick walk to bahamas coffee roasters
everything with the place was clean check in was easy communication was quick and helpful
very cute and clean and easy to get to from the water taxi
great stay very communicative and flexible host clean home easy check-in and check-out and central location
the owner is really nice and patient
lorette was a wonderful host who replied to our questions very quickly
lorette was a great host
very nice place host is real nice
lorette's place is lovely and she is an amazing host
great location and very central
great place perfectly equipped and very well located
awesome place central to everything
such a perfect location in harbour island
great location - it was only a 15 minute walk to pink sands beach
Read more reviews

11. Ideal getaway for solo travelers (from USD 375)

If you’re looking for a relaxing getaway as a solo traveler, this house is a must-try. It comes with a cool, island design with hues of white, blue, and green all over the interior. Enjoy a view of the garden from your own balcony and feel the breeze of summer days and nights. You can also catch some birds singing in the morning or go star-watching at night. The house has one bedroom and a private bathroom, a kitchen, and a spacious living area. “It’s a quiet, comfortable, resting place,” to borrow the words of one of this property’s satisfied guests.

Stayed at this property?
Dunmore Town, Harbour Island, Bahamas
7.52 km (4.7 mi) from Glass Window Bridge
15 reviews   Wifi Available
ENTIRE RENTAL UNIT 1 Bed 2 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 2

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
there is also good wifi
our stay at rositas apartment was great everything looked exactly as shown on the photos beautiful and clean
rosita was helpful with the golf cart rental which is a necessity on the island
rosita was a fantastic host (even bringing us fresh fruit in the morning )
they were such lovely women so friendly helpful and caring
rosita and mrs thelma are very friendly and helpful we enjoy our stay very much
the location is great everything is just around the corner on this small island
Read more reviews

12. Two-bedroom apartment (from USD 300)

This is a perfect home for couples or solo adventurers who love to listen to the sound of waves or have a peaceful stroll along the beach. This two-bedroom apartment features two large bedrooms, a comfy living room, and a private deck where you can feel, see, and savor the beauty of your surroundings. Add to your experience the beautiful plants and trees in the yard which you do not always get to enjoy if you’re from the city. Guests love the bonus beach chairs and umbrellas that you can rent out! All in all, a fantastic home in a fantastic location.

Stayed at this property?
Dunmore Town, Bahamas
6.12 km (3.9 mi) from Glass Window Bridge
72 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE RENTAL UNIT 2 Beds 4 Guests 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 4

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the second bedroom has a king-sized bed a larger closet and is also a nice big room
for breakfast/lunch we liked arthur’s bakery and dunmore deli
we sat on the balcony and listened to the ocean waves very comfortable for two couples
adorable place a little oasis lots of space very comfortable for our family of 4
beautiful spacious rooms a great deck a stone's through from the ocean
the space is clean and comfortable
the apartment was very clean and had everything we needed
the apartment was sparking clean and sunny the veranda overlooks a beautiful garden
the apartment is spacious clean and has everything you need jean is super helpful and friendly
the host was very helpful with getting there and lining up a golf cart for our trip
teejay is a fantastic host
the apartment is great and tj is a fantastic host
jean was a wonderful host we hope to return someday
teejay offered helpful recommendations for restaurants on the island
great place and great location
the location is great and very quiet
loved our secluded location at the end of a nice neighborhood
just a short walk to the beautiful beach and a golf cart ride to town
we loved staying at teejay's place apartment atlast
Read more reviews

13. Value-for-money property (from USD 1500)

Offering four large bedrooms, four beds, and four baths, this huge property in Dunmore town is a perfect getaway for big groups of up to eight persons. It has a great ambience and a private yard with an outdoor pool. The neighborhood is generally peaceful and charming, providing a good setting for your much-needed quality time with friends and loved ones. It is just two blocks away from shopping centers, nightlife, the dock, and superb restaurants. It’s one of those luxury homes that you would want to try at least once in your lifetime!

Stayed at this property?
Dunmore Town, Harbour Island, Bahamas
7.62 km (4.8 mi) from Glass Window Bridge
11 reviews   Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 4 Beds 8 Guests 4 Bedrooms 4 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 8

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
wonderful pool and outdoor living space
the house is very clean and the maid (carol) came daily
the hatch is centrally located and the owners couldn’t have been more friendly and helpful
Read more reviews

14. Monochromatic bungalow beside the Cove Resort (from USD 345)

Located in Gregory Town, a quiet area surrounded by gorgeous and uninhibited beaches where this lovely villa resides. Best for guests of four, like small families or groups of friends, the home boasts all-white interiors with a ton of light radiating through the windows. It’s an open-space home with a functional living room and kitchen area, with a connected sun deck and patio area for relaxing afternoons with a view of the ocean. The house has two bedrooms and two bathrooms with bohemian touches of tile work, along with complimentary shower essentials for guests’ use. Other amenities include wifi access, laundry facilities, free street parking, and a private entrance.

Stayed at this property?
Gregory Town, North Eleuthera, Bahamas
4.07 km (2.6 mi) from Glass Window Bridge
185 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
Entire bungalow 2 Beds 4 Guests 2 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 4

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
beds were comfortable and a/c was nice
it's a fantastic apartment very tasteful interior and the view from the sundeck is just breathtaking
the couches were comfortable lounge on and the outdoor furniture as well
the living room kitchen and eating nook all add wonderful views of the crystal clear caribbean sea
all of the amenities you need centrally located gorgeous and comfortable accommodations
very clean and very comfortable
kathy’s place was simple clean and comfortable
the house was great very clean and had everything we needed
the house is extremely comfortable clean and scenic
clean and beautiful just like the pictures show
very responsive property manager to resolve problems and answer questions
kathy was a great host and was very helpful in answering all of our questions
the owner was great with info and advise for island must do's
friendly and very helpful
kathy is a wonderful host and very easy to reach
perfect central location on the island
it's perfectly located to explore north and central eleuthera
great location right on the water
perfect location beautiful spot incredible vacation
the cove being so close is a great plus
Read more reviews

15. Charming frame house close to Surfer's Beach

Travelers making their way to Eleuthera should consider setting up base in this charming frame house close to one of the most popular destinations in the Bahamas, Surfer’s Beach. The two-story house has stunning views of the island just a nine-minute walk to the ride up on Surfer’s Beach, it’s a great place to experience the local life, while still having everything you could need when on vacation. There’s hot water, a functional bathroom, air conditioning in the bedrooms, as well as a full kitchen for families who would rather cook their meals indoors throughout the trip. Guests also have access to the sun deck with patio furniture where they can enjoy sunbathing or just simply having a cup of coffee early in the morning The property is close Surfer’s Manor restaurants, and also lends guests surfing or hiking equipment for those keen on experiencing more nature nearby.

Stayed at this property?
Gregory Town, Eleuthera, Bahamas
10.1 km (6.3 mi) from Glass Window Bridge
88 reviews  
Entire cottage 2 Beds 1 Bedroom 1 Bathrooms
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the a-frame is beautiful as cable and wifi and a magnificent ocean view from its deck
the house was cozy and had a nice outside deck
a cozy and clean house with beautiful view from balcony
cozy place with everything we needed for an enjoyable stay
a wonderful and much needed storm came through and a frame was cozy and dry
the house was clean and comfortable and communication prompt
it's a quaint and very clean place
very clean and high standard of equipment
it's very clean and you can see all the stars at night
clean attractive cottage with a decent kitchen and a homey bedroom
owner is very nice
wonderful hosts with great recommendations
owner ron is a great guy
tom and liz are great hosts
tom and liz are fantastic knowledgeable and gracious hosts
the location is perfect
quiet and cute house
neat place close to surf
great location to be based out of
really cute house which is in a great location to explore northern eleuthera and go to harbour island
Read more reviews

16. Spacious three-bedroom home

Six guests can comfortably make this property a true hideaway. It has a tropical garden, a covered terrace, and access to a private dock. The Hideaway is one of the six luxury properties developed into what is now a community called the Sunset Harbour Estate. You will find the place secured, peaceful, and refreshing with the surrounding landscape and the functional design of the houses. This particular property has two floors. The lower floor is dedicated for the three spacious rooms, while the second floor houses the kitchen and the living area. There’s a laundry room and a big storage space for your belongings. All windows and doors are hurricane-proof.

Stayed at this property?
Dunmore Town, Harbour Island, NA, Bahamas
7.53 km (4.7 mi) from Glass Window Bridge
49 reviews  
Entire house 4 Beds 3 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
we enjoyed the plunge pool and the deck and gazebo area
great outdoor sitting areas throughout the property comfortable furniture including the beds
the house is ten times more beautiful than the photos and the beds were very comfortable
heated pool with waterfall and gazebo i highly recommend hideaway
the private pool and cabana felt like a tropical oasis
clean homely clean towels everyday beds changed during the week
wonderful house beautifully decorated and clean
the hideaway was in a perfect location very clean and nicely decorated
the three bedroom home is very welcoming and clean
everything was clean and any issues we had were quickly addressed and taken care of
catherine is a great owner/host
catherine was a great host
catherine was a fantastic host
harrison thomasa and catherine were quick with responses and helpful
catherine was prompt with her responses and very helpful
great location: just 5-10 minutes anywhere on the island
beautiful house in a fabulous location highly recomended
it’s beautiful and the location is amazing so easy to get anywhere on the island
location was perfect just far enough from the active center of town
the hideaway was a dream rental perfect location great communication and a beautiful house highly recommended
Read more reviews

17. Bright home overlooking harbour sunset

You can never go wrong with a house that gives you the view of Harbour’s sunset every day, right from your own porch. This, plus a spacious and clean house will be your second home in the Bahamas if you choose this property. It has all the amenities you need: a TV, Wifi, fans or a/c, a private bathtub/shower, and two large bedrooms that can accommodate up to five guests. The shared living room has enough space to accommodate your group, and the kitchen spaces are equipped with cooking supplies and utensils. When you step outside, you’ll find a refreshing yard. A golf cart rental is recommended if you would like to go experience the island and sea views that are way beyond ordinary.

Stayed at this property?

7.5 km (4.7 mi) from Glass Window Bridge
14 reviews  
Private room 4 Beds 7 Guests

18. Two-storey cottage

This property is not hard to miss with its brightly colored structure. It’s light pink all over, which is not a surprise because it is just five minutes away from the famous Pink Sand Beach. It is a two-story cottage with two bedrooms, four beds, and two ensuite bathrooms. Owned by a Harbour-Island-raised host named Ann, this simple yet inviting home is well kept, clean, and organized. You will love staying in the patio in the morning and end your day on that exact spot. The quiet neighborhood adorned with palm trees, plus the cozy house and the adventures that await you in the nearby paradise will give you a real taste of island living.

Stayed at this property?

8.25 km (5.2 mi) from Glass Window Bridge
8 reviews  
Entire cabin 4 Beds 5 Guests

19. Refreshing home near Lone Tree Beach

Not too fancy but refreshing. This new apartment provides an island vibe accommodation with its spacious porch where you can view the sunset, and where you can feel the breeze of the beaches nearby - the Lone Tree beach and the Pink Sand Beach. This cozy little home houses a living space, a kitchen area, a master bedroom, and a shared modern bathroom. It is perfect for travelers on the go, couples, or a small group of friends.

Stayed at this property?
Dunmore Town, Harbour Island, Bahamas
8.33 km (5.2 mi) from Glass Window Bridge
36 reviews  
Private room in apartment 1 Bed 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

20. Chatterbox - classic Bahamian house with modern amenities

Chatterbox is conveniently situated centrally in Dunmore Town and is only five minutes from the beach by one of the golf carts. It is a short walk from a grocery store, shop and multiple eateries and cafes. Ideal for six persons, the house offers a complete home from home experience. Use the patio to enjoy gorgeous views of the sunset and enjoy the cool and refreshing island breeze during your stay. Amenities such as a dryer, TV with cable channels, beach essentials, and air conditioning are offered to the guests.

Stayed at this property?
Dunmore Town, Harbour Island, Bahamas
7.89 km (4.9 mi) from Glass Window Bridge
19 reviews  
Entire house 5 Beds 3 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
we loved being able to walk over to arthur’s for breakfast and coffee
also neka and clint who help manage the house we’re so kind and welcoming and helpful
eartha the housekeeper was extremely serviceminded and kind
everything was perfect the house location vibe
wonderful house great hospitality good location beautiful island
Read more reviews

21. Colonial-style home

Located in the lovely and historic Dunmore town, this property is an eye-candy with its sophisticated look and interiors. The pictures tell that this home is adorned with colonial touches and structural design, perfect for those who are looking for a unique and Instagram-worthy home in the Bahamas. You can easily access the beach with a golf cart and explore the nearby shops and restaurants. There are three bedrooms, four beds, and an outdoor pool that kids will surely enjoy if you’re traveling as a family.

Stayed at this property?
Dunmore Town, Harbour Island, Bahamas
7.87 km (4.9 mi) from Glass Window Bridge
20 reviews  
Entire house 4 Beds 3 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms
Top guest reviews
trish was the most wonderful host attentive and very informative responding almost immediately to all our questions
trish and her staff were very responsive to all our needs
the jewelbox is one of a kind
trish was very helpful with suggestions too
great house and location harbour island is a beautiful place
we had an amazing time on the island and really enjoyed staying at this place
beautifully appointed and perfect location trish the host communication is prompt and thoughtful
Read more reviews

22. Lovely house for special events

Stay close to nature all throughout your visit to Harbour Island by renting this fabulous hilltop home at King Country. The panoramic view of the ocean and harbor is simply breathtaking! With its great location and classic interiors, the house offers a perfect retreat for small and big groups. You will find must-see spots easily accessible and the beach is just a five-minute walk away, as well as the town proper. The beds are comfortable and the whole house, though a bit old in structure, is very well-maintained and looks fresh!

Stayed at this property?
Dunmore Town, Harbour Island, Bahamas
7.51 km (4.7 mi) from Glass Window Bridge
18 reviews  
Entire house 2 Beds 2 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
wifi worked perfectly
while admittedly during the summer months i wish there was a pool available we made it work
the beds are also very comfortable ; ) we would recommend kimberly’s place
kimberly is a great host and very quick to answer any questions you may have
the housekeeper was friendly and we had everything what we needed
loved the central location on the island
the house location was perfect close to the beach and close to all our favorite restaurants
it was a very cute place near the beach and everything was nerby located
loved the location of this cottage
the beautiful pink sand beach is only a 5 minute walk away
Read more reviews

Island living at its finest

The houses on Harbour Island reflect island living at its finest. Hospitable hosts, spacious porches and bedrooms, quirky interiors, the trees and the sunset accessible from your home. All these plus the natural wonder that is Harbour Island is truly a magical treat for all travelers. Book one of these rentals and you’ll understand exactly what I mean.

Any must-sees we missed? Tell us about them in the comments section or write a post here to help out fellow travelers!
Disclosure: Trip101 selects the listings in our articles independently. Some of the listings in this article contain affiliate links.


Get Trip101 in your inbox

Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data

Carmela Ann Santos is a freelance writer and a licensed teacher from the Philippines. Her top destinations would include any place with a clear view of cloud formations and peaceful waters. She...Read more

 Want to contribute as a Local Expert?
Explore Harbour Island
Good things are meant to be shared!
Back to top
Visited any of these places? Click this button to activate our "Add a Tip" feature to share your experience.