Top 10 Airbnb Vacation Rentals In Johnstown, Ohio - Updated 2024

airbnb Johnstown OH
Contributing Writer
| 5 min read

Located in Licking County of Ohio, Johnstown is a small cute town, or a village if you prefer to call it that. It definitely has this ‘small-town’ America vibe and is an ideal destination to escape the daily hustle and bustle. The nearby beautiful city of New Albany might enjoy more fame due to the larger population and the wider range of entertainment options. A great festival is held each year here, when residents and tourists alike may enjoy a number of art performances and parades. Similarly, a walking race attracts also travelers who can enjoy the marvelous nature surrounding the area. Moreover, Columbus, which is the state capital of Ohio, is located also nearby Johnstown and offers great city amenities, in case you need a break from nature. One may find here numerous notable buildings, landmarks, and museums for sightseeing purposes. Your accommodation will also be unique: Most of the properties are nestled in large tracts of lush land and won’t disappoint you. Below you will find the 10 top Airbnb vacation rentals in Johnstown, Ohio, so have a look to your perfect accommodation.

We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on July 22, 2024.

1. barn turned into a home (from USD 300)

You may call it a sanctuary or a beautiful getaway; this once-upon-a-time barn, is nowadays a modern house that can accommodate up to nine guests. It’s suitable for families or large groups of friends on holiday. The house features two private bedrooms, plenty of sofas and couches in the living room, a well-equipped kitchen and four bathrooms. As guests of the property, you may enjoy an indoor fireplace, free parking space, a barbeque grill, cooking utensils and all other basic amenities. Numerous eating and drinking venues are within easy reach, and Ohio State is about 45 minutes away.

Stayed at this property?
Utica, Ohio, United States
24.84 km (15.5 mi) from Newark Earthworks
75 reviews   Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 5 Beds 9 Guests 3 Bedrooms 4 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 9

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
sleeping was as expected for them: four comfortable beds with a pull out and extra couch
spacious main room & kitchen comfortable beds many bathrooms wi-fi & big screen tv
we had lovely weather so the fans and screens let fresh country air in
the porch had two comfortable chairs that everyone took turns enjoying with a book
perfect for entertaining with a large well appointed kitchen and a great room with fire place
leslie was a perfect host and provided prompt response
the host was very helpful and responsive and we really enjoyed our stay
leslie is the perfect host and accommodated everything we needed
we couldn’t have asked for a better host
leslie is so far the best host i deal with
the location was great
the location is quiet and peaceful
the location is very quiet and peaceful
this is a wonderful house in a very quiet secluded location
this place was beautiful and interesting and cool
Read more reviews

2. Extra spacious house near Columbus (from USD 1250)

Located in Sunbury, amidst lots of greenery, you will find this huge house that has the capacity to accommodate up to 12 guests, making it ideal for family reunions or small events and corporate dinners. Amenities such as wifi, iron, TV, washer, indoor fireplace, a free parking space and a hot tub, are all provided for your convenience. The property enjoys great isolation, however, Port Columbus is only 40 minutes away.

Stayed at this property?
Sunbury, Ohio, United States
45.32 km (28.2 mi) from Newark Earthworks
71 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
Entire vacation home 10 Beds 10 Guests 5 Bedrooms 4 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 10

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the decor and furniture is all very comfortable & made everyone feel at home
the beds and linens are incredible comfortable
the living room was great for meetings
it was perfect again plenty of room lots of luxurious upgrades and he is very accommodating
very clean with lots of space
it is so clean not even a dust bunny you will not be disappointed
the house was immaculately clean and everything was easy to find
this house is absolutely beautiful and very clean
this house was better than advertised the lot is beautiful and spacious and the house is amazing
host was very helpful and conscientious
the host is considerate and easy to communicate with
the owner is very helpful and easy to communicate with
a big thank you to the awesome hosts
our host brian was responsive accommodating and respectful throughout
the location is a bit secluded but still worked perfectly for our meeting retreat
the sunbury location proved ideal for relatives attending from nearby and convenient to grocery food et
house is unreal pictures don't come close to doing it justice
it's a great private location for an extended family get-together
wonderful to have a place like this so close to columbus
Read more reviews

3. The travelers' escape

For a more intimate holiday, choose this private room in a guest suite that can sleep up to two guests. Guests may enjoy a full bathroom and a cozy bedroom, both private and separate from the main house. Bed and bath essentials, a coffee maker, free parking space, A/C, heating, wifi, and TV are all provided for your comfort. From here, you can reach, within 25 minutes, the city center of Columbus, while plenty of fine restaurants and walking trails are also nearby.

Stayed at this property?
Granville, Ohio, United States
15.42 km (9.6 mi) from Newark Earthworks
64 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
Private room in residential home 1 Bed 2 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 2

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the bedroom has a lovely view nice comfortable bed linens and tv
a comfy bed and hot shower along with amenities like the fridge microwave keurig and nice scented candle
with a private space off the garage it was like having a little studio apartment all to ourselves
very comfy bed great shower appreciated having the microwave refrigerator and coffee maker
it was a quiet neighborhood check-in was a breeze and the bed was extremely comfortable
it is clean and very comfortable
a very clean and quiet place to stay
a very clean relaxing and quiet place to stay
we found it clean comfortable convenient and private
very clean and the extra towels soap coffee etc
the hosts were available and helpful
thoughtful communicative host
joshua was helpful as we accidentally locked ourselves out and quickly provided a solution
joshua was vary welcoming informative and kind
:) host is an excellent communicator which made our last minute stay very easy
perfect location for visiting denison
perfect location for us
great location for our purposes
the location was close to town and in a nice neighborhood
josh and michelle’s place was in a great location; near denison university
Read more reviews

4. New Albany Cape Cod home

Ideal for family or corporate trips, this entire house may easily sleep up to five guests and features three bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, a fully-equipped kitchen, a private patio and an extra spacious room. Among the amenities provided here, guests may enjoy wifi, TV, washer, indoor fireplace, A/C, game console and children’s books, as well as free parking space. The house is conveniently located 20 minutes from downtown New Albany and is nearby the highway.

Stayed at this property?
New Albany, Ohio, United States
32.32 km (20.1 mi) from Newark Earthworks
68 reviews  
Entire house 3 Beds 4 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms
Top guest reviews
the house was roomy and very clean
house was spacious and clean
the house was very well put together and clean
very clean house in a great location
tim was a great host
tim is a great host
tim was also very responsive to any questions that we had
tim was a great host with quick response and very accommodating for our needs
tim is a wonderful host very responsive
very good location with 2 min access to the freeway system
it is in a great location near shopping and restaurants with great access right near the highway
easy access to freeway close to cute little restaurants and grocery store
loved the neighborhood close to columbus and shopping
a perfect location for visiting either owu or denison
Read more reviews

5. Lovely, spacious mansion

You may well call it a villa since this large estate can comfortably accommodate up to 15 guests and offers great luxury. The house features four bedrooms and many more couches, a fine gourmet kitchen and seven bathrooms. As guests of the villa, you may also use the indoor pool, sauna room, hot tub, a 10-seat theatre and great workout facilities. All basic amenities you may think of do exist here, together with numerous family features and free parking space. Within easy reach, you will find the John Glenn airport and downtown Columbus.

Stayed at this property?
New Albany, Ohio, United States
32.85 km (20.5 mi) from Newark Earthworks
8 reviews  
Entire villa 2 Beds 4 Bedrooms 7 Bathrooms
Top guest reviews
excellent host and the home is amazing
he was always available and the home is beautiful milroy is a wonderful host
Read more reviews

6. Stylish, French-style loft

This stylish loft with a French countryside touch may sleep up to four guests and features one bedroom, common spaces, one full bathroom and a well-equipped kitchen. The place offers all basic amenities, as well as free parking space, a barbeque grill and a unique seven acres (28,000sq m) of lovely grounds. Ideal for nature lovers, a 36-acre (145,000sq m) nature reserve is adjoined to the property, while the Columbus airport is just a 30-minute drive away.

Stayed at this property?
Granville, Ohio, United States
11.82 km (7.4 mi) from Newark Earthworks
106 reviews  
Entire guesthouse 3 Beds 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
nice tv wifi device charging etc
great apartment had wonderful amenities and decor
the property is lovely and the views from the apartment are wonderful
wow kathy and doug's guest apartment is fabulous
four of us stayed in the space and were very comfortable
just as advertised - clean and comfortable
sparkling clean with luxurious touches
sparkling clean just so adorable
fun clean and cozy space
everything was clean and the bed is comfortable
host is very responsive with questions or concerns
hosts were very helpful
a great space with gracious hosts
many thanks to the host and hostess
kathy and doug were extremely kind and thoughtful responding quickly to any of our questions
the location is super convenient to denison university
excellent location in a very private setting
exceptional accommodations close to granville perfect for a visit to denison university
great location minutes from town
very nice place and location to denison and granville
Read more reviews

7. Quaint condominium near Port Columbus

A home away from home is ready to welcome its guests in a quaint and peaceful condo community in New Albany. Up to two guests can comfortably fit here and they will have full access to the kitchen, the living room, the master bedroom and the bathroom. Cooking utensils, TV, iron, heating, A/C, free parking space and a laptop-friendly workspace are just a few of the numerous amenities provided here. The unit is conveniently located 15 minutes from Port Columbus, 20 minutes from downtown Columbus and nearby are plenty of dining and shopping areas.

Stayed at this property?

34.41 km (21.4 mi) from Newark Earthworks
74 reviews  
Condominium 1 Bed 2 Guests

8. Private room in Alexandria

If you are on a tight budget and are looking for an inexpensive but cozy place then choose this private room that can sleep up to two guests. Guests are welcome to use the kitchen and a shared bathroom, as well as the washer and dryer if needed. All basic amenities are provided, along with free parking space and bed and bath essentials. Since the property is located in the heart of Alexandria village, a good number of city amenities are all at your fingertips. Easily reach various coffee shops, bars, and even art studios, while the airport is just 20 minutes away.

Stayed at this property?

16.35 km (10.2 mi) from Newark Earthworks
15 reviews  
Private room 1 Bed 2 Guests

9. Peaceful retreat

Up to four guests may be accommodated in this charming country retreat which is situated on a huge land of woods and farmland. Guests will have their private room, but they can have access to the kitchen, the dining room, a big common area and a deck and porch. All basic amenities, along with great family features and free parking space are all provided for your comfort. A yoga class is also possible, while plenty of bike trails are found nearby. New Albany is just 16km (10 miles) away and similarly, Columbus Airport is only half an hour away.

Stayed at this property?
Alexandria, Ohio, United States
16.7 km (10.4 mi) from Newark Earthworks
5 reviews  
Private room in house 2 Beds 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathrooms

10. White cottage farm guesthouse (from USD 126)

An ideal place for couples, solo travelers or even families is this beautiful cottage that can sleep up to four guests. The entire house features two bedrooms and two bathrooms, as well as a kitchen, wifi, free parking space, room essentials, A/C, heating and a laptop-friendly workspace. Smoking or pets are not allowed on the property. The house is conveniently located near downtown Granville and enjoys a very relaxing lush surrounding area.

Stayed at this property?
Granville, Ohio, United States
12.6 km (7.9 mi) from Newark Earthworks
162 reviews   Wifi Available
Entire guesthouse 2 Beds 4 Guests 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 4

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
nice new amenities for those wishing to use the kitchen space
alice’s cottage in granville is a well updated comfortable space that felt like home
adorable cottage updated bathroom comfy bed great views responsive host what more do you need? would highly recommend
the cottage is literally amazing beautiful bathroom kitchen and living area
this space is a study in how best to convert a former outbuilding into a stylish and comfortable cottage
very clean and very comfortable bedding
it was very clean
everything was very clean stylish and comfortable
everything was extremely clean and comfortable
the house is very clean and beautiful
the owners are gracious and welcoming inviting us to walk the paths behind the lawn
fantastic place and wonderful hosts
adorable converted barn on owner’s property
the hosts were very responsive and easy to communicate with
alice was a responsive host and we had everything we needed
very cute and cozy place
alice's place is ideal for a small family
wonderful location great for a quiet and cozy getaway
alice's place was so cute and chic
if you like privacy and quiet this is the ideal location for you
Read more reviews

For nature lovers

The majority of the accommodation options you can have in Johnstown, Ohio, include a magnificent landscape to calm your anxious mind. However, civilization is only a few steps away, so you can’t possibly run out of entertainment options in this destination.

Any must-sees we missed? Tell us about them in the comments section or write a post here to help out fellow travelers!
Disclosure: Trip101 selects the listings in our articles independently. Some of the listings in this article contain affiliate links.


Get Trip101 in your inbox

Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data

Meet Villy, a perpetual explorer with an insatiable curiosity for the world and an unwavering eagerness to learn. Growing up in Greece, Villy embarked on a journey to transcend her comfort zone....Read more

 Want to contribute as a Local Expert?
Explore Johnstown
Good things are meant to be shared!
Back to top
Visited any of these places? Click this button to activate our "Add a Tip" feature to share your experience.
safe neighborhoods in columbus ohio

Top 7 Safe Neighborhoods In Columbus, Ohio - Updated 2024