A getaway in Eleuthera is pure bliss and soaking up the sun on a pristine white sand beach or swimming with the wild pigs over ancient coral reefs are two things that you shouldn’t miss. Another great way to enjoy this Bahamian tropical island is to stay at one of these places, listed on Vrbo. Which ones? Well, keep reading and find out about the best Vrbo accommodations in Eleuthera, Bahamas.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on March 13, 2023.
1. Comfy home with a resort-like experience (from USD 363)
The fresh Caribbean ocean breeze awaits you in this three-bedroom home. It is less than five miles (eight kilometers) from Gaulding Cay Beach, Surfers Beach, and Hatchet Bay Cave.
Boasting an open-plan design with a New York loft feel, the rental provides a resort-like experience and a soothing atmosphere that’ll help you relax. The kitchen has concrete countertops, a Smeg cooktop, a convection oven, and a refrigerator for your cooking needs. The master and queen bedrooms are both equipped with French doors that lead to a deck with beautiful ocean views. Complimentary snorkel sets and beach towels are also provided.
2. An idyllic yellow beach cottage on a white sand beach (from USD 495)
Perfect your beach getaway with this sunny wooden house in Spanish Wells. Spanish Wells is a community located on the island of St. George’s Cay, just 500 meters (1640.4 feet) off the northern tip of Eleuthera Island. It boasts a spacious deck overlooking the blue ocean – party goers can enjoy their happy moments with the barbecue facilities.
There are also two hammocks, shade umbrellas, and cozy sun loungers for your leisure, all provided by the owner. Eateries and grocery stores are within walking distance.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the house has everything needed for a comfortable stayCleanliness:
fantastic stay with super-responsive wonderful hosts at a nicely decorated very clean modern housevery clean and location is perfectthe house was clean spacious and met all of our needs for our time on the islandHost:
great hosts for overall perfect stayowners were great and very responsivetara and jody are fantastic hostsjody and tara are wonderful hosts that make you feel like family right from the startthe property and house are well maintained and the inclusion of the golf cart is so helpfulRead more reviewsLocation:
it’s location is what dreams are made ofspanish wells itself is a quiet friendly and safe community
3. Coral cove beach cottage (from USD 347)
For those who plan on catching some lobsters or doing some bottom fishing, be sure to secure your spot at this coral cove beach cottage, nestled in Spanish Wells, a community located on the island of St. George’s Cay, just 500 meters (1640.4 feet) off the northern tip of Eleuthera Island.
It’s accessible to some public spaces, such as churches, restaurants, and bars and it has a tropical-themed bedroom, accommodating up to four people. There is an outdoor grill on the beach for your evening barbecue party.
Top guest reviews
Cleanliness:
coral cove was it it was clean and perfect for usHost:
tyson and april are the most wonderful and helpful host you could ask fortyson and april were incredibly responsive and wonderful hostsapril and tyson are amazing hosts and respond to any questions right awayeveryone was so helpful and friendly and i can't wait to go back soonthe locals are very friendly and i would have pleasant conversations in the eveningRead more reviewsLocation:
great location by the sandbrthe location of coral cove is breathtakingawesome location and perfect place for a long weekend
4. Western View Cottage (from USD 350)
Western View Cottage is only a one minute walk from a beautiful, white sand beach – this place is totally recommended for beach fanatics. There are three bedrooms (one with a king-sized bed and two others with a twin-sized bed and bunk beds). Cable TVs and complimentary WiFi are available and the green backyard is great for picnicking.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
we enjoyed breakfast and coffee in the backyard every morningCleanliness:
the house was clean and comfortablenice clean place to stay for a familythe house was well appointed and cleanHost:
great owners who were very attentive and informativethe owners are the most friendly approachable people around they will gladly help you out with anythingthe island has zero crime everyone is so friendly and willing to helpthe owners are very friendly and so helpful they only live footsteps awaythe newbolds were extremely helpful in every aspectRead more reviewsLocation:
the neighborhood was quiet and peaceful and the house was only a 2 minute walk to the beachwe could not of asked for a better place to stay
5. A nice cottage with breathtaking views of the sunset (from USD 575)
Looking for a rental where you can savor a sunset view? If so, this fascinating cottage with a spacious deck facing the sea in Spanish Wells is the right place. The house features colonial island architecture and the master bedroom upstairs has a stylish balcony, ideal for your late afternoon moments with some tea and a sunset.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
however the interior is spacious comfortable clean and inviting i can't imagine better accommodations on the islandCleanliness:
the house is comfortable and cleanhouse was steps from the beach well appointed and cleanHost:
you will love the ownersjody and tara are great hosts and their house is immaculatethe owners were very hospitable and the house was lovely with a big and spacious kitchenwow i can’t say enough wonderful things about this home and it’s ownersRead more reviewsLocation:
summer sunset is the perfect vacation home in an idyllic locationgreat location and super nice place jody and tara are so hospitableperfect place to unplug & relax
6. Island Cliff Shores (from 420 USD)
Are you looking for an unusual rental? This small house set on a 50 foot (15.2 meter) cliff with a scenic view of the Caribbean Sea, will make for an impressive stay – and the edge of the world is just before you. In addition to the extraordinary location, enjoy your sleep in the queen-sized bed. Other amenities like a full kitchen, bathroom, and a washer are also included. Pets are also allowed.
Island Cliff Shores
Price: from 420 USD
Number of Guests: 9
7. A peaceful cottage close to the ocean (from 175 USD)
To experience a tranquil atmosphere in an island retreat, the lovely settlement of James Cisten, in central Eleuthera, shouldn’t be missed. A mere 10-minute drive from the Governor’s Airport, this newly built home accommodates up to three people and has a wide number of amenities. It’s less than three minutes to the ocean and pets are considered.
A peaceful cottage close to the ocean
Price: from 175 USD
Number of Guests: 3
8. Harbor style living - Sleeping on the dock of the bay! (from 99 USD)
Baie-Front is another stunning location where you can experience history meeting beach life. This captivating harborside house is loaded with handpainted art. To feel the fresh breeze from the ocean and enjoy the home’s magnificent setting in the bay, unwind in a seat on the balcony. To satisfy your appetite, the nearby open-air restaurant, serving an abundance of delicious seafood, mustn’t be ignored.
Harbor style living - Sleeping on the dock of the bay!
Price: from 99 USD
Number of Guests: 3
9. Big bang for your buck at Pineapple Blues (from 80 USD)
Are you traveling on a budget in Eleuthera? Then don’t miss this tropical cottage in Rainbow Bay, priced at under 100 USD. It features a snug master bedroom with a queen-sized bed for your convenience. If you want to savor the golden sunset, the deck is the spot. Feeling hungry at night? Grab some delectable pizza at the nearby Rainbow Bay Restaurant.
Big bang for your buck at Pineapple Blues
Price: from 80 USD
Number of Guests: 3
Enjoy paradise in Eleuthera!
Eleuthera doesn’t only feature awe-inspiring nature and fun attractions, this pearl of the Bahamas also holds plenty of breathtaking accommodations, where you can truly experience the atmosphere of paradise.
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data
Create an account to