Nothing says “tropical vacation” quite like a trip to the Bahamas; with clear, turquoise waters, white sandy shores and warm temperatures year round, it’s not hard to see why. Green Turtle Cay is a barrier island of the Bahamas and offers its visitors a plethora of options when it comes to things to do. Enjoy a day of snorkeling, boating, and swimming and be sure to check out the Albert Lowe Museum while on the island. While the island is small, being only about 3 miles long (4.8 km), there are plenty of options when it comes to lodging choices. For the best selection, be sure to check out the best Vrbo accommodations on Green Turtle Cay, the Bahamas.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on March 13, 2023.
1. Spacious home overlooking the bay (from USD 450)
For a spacious vacation rental in Green Turtle Cay, you need not look any further than this comfortable home. Inside, you’ll find room for up to six guests to stay at a time, all while being only a short walk away from both Coco Bay and Ocean Beach. The house also comes equipped with a large, well-equipped kitchen, ample living space and a screened-in porch with plenty of room at the table to sit. During your stay, be sure to venture to the roof deck, where you can see the beautiful waters of the bay by day and a sky full of stars by night.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
it's worth the climb because the view is gorgeous - Turn one wayThe downstairs level has 2 nice bedrooms wTurtle Dreams has everything you need if you are going to cook at home - the kitchen is well appointed with appliances kitchenware and a nice dining room tableWe were all pleased with the WiFi to use our apps and stream movies in the eveningThe house was incredible and so comfortable for all five of usCleanliness:
The house was beautiful clean and very comfortablethe the ocean path (just as close)It is beautifully decorated and landscapedThe island and the people were so warm and invitingWe found the house to be clean and comfortable with most everything we could ask forHost:
Even so we managed to snorkel out to the reefs where we saw beautiful corals Because we had heard that some people find the water slightly chillythe owner was very helpfuloffers many more choices for mealsWe could not have been happier with the accommodationsMary Lowe is an absolute darling and made us feel totally at home and got us all set up - wonderful galRead more reviewsLocation:
Located at the quieter north end of GTC a 15 minute golf cart ride from the main and only settlement on the islandlocal restaurants & beautiful beachesThe home is located within a short distance to Coco BayIt is a five minute walk either waybut that was never a problem
2. Large house with direct water access (from USD 600)
Vacationing in Green Turtle Cay is no hardship, and this fantastic rental home will make you never want to leave! The house sleeps up to six guests and sits right at the water’s edge, even featuring a private dock for guests’ use. At the head of the private dock, you’ll find several chairs and a plunge pool, both of which make for great places to watch as the sun sets in the evening. Inside the house, you’ll find a fully equipped kitchen, laundry facilities, and two full bathrooms.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the Wi-Fi worked greatI have ran out of room to leave a longer reviewThe kitchen is fully stocked for cooking or grilling your fresh catch and the screened in porch gives you some of the best views of the Sea of Abaco that you will find anywhereThere was enough space for all without anyone crowding one another and WiFiThe view was absolutely stunningCleanliness:
it was clear that they were very concerned both before and after thatThe house was clean and in perfect condition Would come back againeverything we had asked for prior to arrivalHost:
(they have family friendly trips as well)The owner is very accommodating and responsive in communicationVery nice house with exceptional viewsBrad was very responsive to any questions we had and Margaret the caretaker was available whenever neededextremely responsive and informative Magaret and Ken property caretakers were very helpfulRead more reviewsLocation:
Perfect house in the best location on GTCis at a different location every nightwhich are just around the corner from the houseand we loved every minute of itEverything on the island was accessible within 10 minutes from the house Entertainment around the island
3. Bluff-side rental with amazing views (from USD 352)
With beautiful ocean views readily available, this rental home is not to be missed. The interior of the home has a wonderfully modern feel to it, with three bedrooms and three bathrooms ready to host up to seven guests at a time. Spend your evenings on the spacious outdoor deck, or wander down to the private dock where you can enjoy a glorious sunset over the blue waters. The rental is next door to the Bluff House Beach Hotel, where you grab a bite to eat at one of the restaurants or grab a cocktail from the bar.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
The kitchen is well stocked with the essentials to cook at the housethe air conditioning works greatThe slip gets a little shallowEverything you see in the add is a describedOne of our best vacations yet house is as beautiful as the pictures showHost:
Clean good ac unitsEverything about the listing was accurate and the help and attention given by the caretakers Jennie and Jason was more than anyone could ask for We will most certainly rentwho for 6 weeks continued to assist us whenever we needed themThe caretaker answered all of our questions when we arrived and stayed in contact all week answering questions and making sure everything went smoothly Wonderful experience/C amazing views and was supplied with all the necessities and luxuries anyone would want This vacation homeRead more reviewsLocation:
The house sits roughly 800 ft uphill from the dock slipYou could dock a mid 30's cc in there no problemIn a Great Location on the islandIt's very convenient to the Bluff House where we kept our boatWe loved the location and how close it was to Bluff House
4. Stunning newly built home (from USD 399)
Built with comfort and relaxation in mind, this house makes for a fantastic home base during your stay in Green Turtle Cay. The inside features two bedrooms and two bathrooms to accommodate up to six total guests in addition to a spacious open concept living room, dining room, and kitchen area. Head up to the rooftop deck and treat yourself to an outstanding view of the waters and island around you or relax in the screened-in en-suite porch of the master bedroom.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
The kitchen is fully stockedwe chose the upper Master Bedroom with that beautiful view of the sunrise each morningthe bedding is comfortable and the outdoor spaces are perfect for dining quiet time or enjoying the gorgeous 360 degree viewsit's own ) GORGEOUS 360 view from the upper deck on the top floor like nothing else we've seen on the islandThe 360 view from the top deck is absolutely stunningCleanliness:
it is very clean and beautifully decoratedBoth bedrooms were beautifully decorated - as was the entire house-We loved how clean and nice everything was in the house and the lovely beach houseFully functional and well stocked kitchen bathrooms washer and dryer facilitiesShe had propane brought over right away when it was outHost:
Questions were always answered promptly - She could not have been more helpful even checking in throughout the week to make sure our needs were met Now for the houseThe caretaker Rachel met us at the ferry dock and helped with our luggageThe owner set up our golf cart taxi with Omri to ferry and grocery shop and her caretaker met us upon arrival and they were both very accommodatingher renters have also taken care as wellspices utensils beach bags and moreRead more reviewsLocation:
Domino Dreams is the perfect house in a great locationand it's just a 1min ride to the public dockDomino Dreams was in such a great location in the middle of the island to get around everywhereConveniently located with Green Turtle Club and Bluff House in one direction and the settlement of New Plymouth in the other directionthe rental is within a block of it and has a panoramic view of the island from the crow's nest
5. Luxurious home amid lush greenery (from USD 500)
There is nothing lacking within his spectacular vacation rental, as you’ll find out as soon as you step foot inside. Perfect for a large party of travelers, this house can accommodate up for 10 guests at a time with a total of 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms. The living room and outside deck provide guests with plenty of seating in which to relax while the well-equipped kitchen allows you to do any cooking you’d like. Outside, you’ll find a path down to the blue waters of Bita Bay Beach, and a large, in-ground pool in the backyard.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the screened in porch has amazing view and the pool was perfect we spent hours in the poolthe home is well appointed with all the amenities necessary for a comfortable staybananaquit has a great kitchen with plenty of room for all 15 of us to have a mealbedrooms were generously sized and the beds were incredibly comfortable to sleep inthe pool was fantasticCleanliness:
the house was spotlessly cleanluxurious clean loved the three bathrooms great sound system comfy beds and open kitchen/lounge area plus screened porchbeautiful home and pool fully stocked house clean and centrally locatedHost:
the owners and the property manager are great to work withmanagement company super helpful on arrival and throughout our staythe owners where very kind and considerate as we had to schedule our vacation twice in 2011Read more reviewsLocation:
great location on the island and less than a minute to walk to bita bay for snorkelingthe location of the home is perfectly situated in the middle of the islandthe beautiful beach good for swimming and snorkeling is just a two minute walkit was a great location and an excellent houseit is hard to beat green turtle for a low-key and relaxin' place
6. Cozy bungalow in downtown area (from USD 252)
Stay in the heart of town in this remodeled rental for a great time in Green Turtle Cay. The use of a golf cart is included in your stay, make use of it by taking it around town or down to the beach! Inside the rental, you’ll find accommodations for up to four people in two bedrooms with a single bathroom. Just outside your front door, you’ll find dockage for boats, which is an obvious upside if you happen to be a boat user.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
We were also able to use the WIFI and cable TV provided to our satisfactionThe home is just wonderful with a living room in front filled with windows and great lightso the air conditioning was on and it worked fineair conditioning and cooking utensilsso the fact that it is included in the rental is a blessingCleanliness:
The house was clean and cozyyou become part of the island life and the peopleThe house was perfect for 2 adults and was nicely furnishedHost:
Greeting us at the dock & helping us unload our boatgave us both hugs and said "welcome hometheir hospitality is always first classhow friendly all the GTC people areThey showed us the necessities of the house and got us our golf cart ( very helpful)Read more reviewsLocation:
Really enjoyed the convenience of the locationWe found the location was perfect for a first visit to New Plymouth within easy walking distance to restaurants and the small grocery stores in townhowever you can pretty much walk to any of the shops and restaurants in New Plymouth within minutestook a 5 minute taxi ride to the Green Turtle Ferry and a 10 minute ferry ride to the islandI rented a 21' center console from Sunset Marine which was less than a mile away and tied it right up at the Cap'n Sam's dock
Relaxation in the Bahamas awaits you
Surround yourself with a quiet beauty when visiting Green Turtle Cay and get away from your everyday life for a while. Be sure and stay in one of these excellent vacation rentals, where you’re guaranteed to be relaxed for the entirety of your trip.
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data
Create an account to