10 Best Vrbo Vacation Rentals In Windermere Island, The Bahamas - Updated 2024

Nadine
Contributing Writer
Updated
| 4 min read

The Bahamas is such a marvelous place to go to because of the warm sandy beaches and crystal clear waters plus lush landscapes all around. The beach in Windermere Island is known as one of the most beautiful beaches, so be amazed at such glory! In this island, do not expect that there will be pubs and bars all around. Accommodations in Windermere Island in will provide you comfort and all the things you need. What you should treasure here is the sea and the view itself so choose the private accommodation that can give just the right convenience. Read on to find out the best Vrbo accommodations in Windermere Island, the Bahamas.

We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on August 21, 2024.

Why Trust Trip101?


Over 50,000 articles reviewed and published by our experienced team

Over 50 years of combined experience researching, writing and reviewing travel articles

Over 40,000 hours spent on research and fact-checking from credible sources (last year’s data)

Optimizing content from data-driven insights collected directly from users on our platform

Focus on authentic and up-to-date information by collaborating with local guides, global travelers and other industry experts

Long-standing partnerships with credible brands like Airbnb, Booking.com, Agoda, Expedia, GetYourGuide, Viator, RVShare and more

Full disclosure on any partnerships or sponsored content

Trip101’s team of writers, editors, and content managers oversees the publication of all travel content, including destination guides, accommodation recommendations, and travel tips. They have extensive experience in the travel industry and no content, written or visual, gets published without a review. Many of our team’s work has also been featured in Travel+Leisure, National Today, The Indian Express, The Telegraph (India), Robb Report, The Adventure Handbook, Tripoto, Korea Tourism Organization, and Korean Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism. Some of them are also members of professional organizations like the Society of American Travel Writers and the International Travel Writers and Photographers Alliance.

Each member of the team follows Trip101's methodology and strict editorial guidelines to ensure accuracy, authenticity, and relevance.

1. Exclusive beachfront home on pink sand (from USD 1427)

You will feel like you are in a different world by staying in this beautiful and luxurious beachfront home! The Bahamas is such a magical place and you will get an immersive experience in this home since it is directly on the pink sand beach! In here, you are surrounded by lush landscapes while hearing the gentle crash of the waves. The place has everything you need and even more! Chill at the new private dock and indulge in the beauty all around.

Stayed at this property?
Eleuthera, Eleuthera, Bahamas
15.96 km (10.0 mi) from Leon Levy Native Plant Preserve
villa 8 Guests 3 Bedrooms 5 Bathrooms

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
whatever your preference might be
The beach is very private
the bathtub-like ocean
it was almost like swimming under moonlight
you will not want to leave
Cleanliness:
The house was very clean
It was clean and well maintained
we were able to cross the road and swim in the Sound - where the water is incredibly clear and clean
Later each evening Venus rose over the ocean
The house is very private extremely well stocked (everything you could ever need is available) and incredibly clean
Host:
Miranda is exceptionally nice and very helpful
always friendly and very attentive to our needs
well taken care of and made for a great vacation
she answered all our questions and promised that we would love her home
She was in communication before and during to make sure we had all the information to make the trip as easy as possible
Location:
and it is by far the best
We snorkeled many times just north of the house
Just north of Ocean Daze we found a little private cove where we enjoyed an entire day and spotted a beautiful huge stingray right off the beach
The views from the entire house are stunning
She has access to the best resources on the island
Read more reviews

2. Refreshing and elegant retreat (from USD 574)

Situated just by the shores is this elegant and historic villa. Be delighted with the simplicity and cleanliness of the place while rejuvenating in the ocean breeze. Fun fact: Did you know that Prince Charles and Lady Diana spent their honeymoon here in 1981? Exclusivity is granted here so you have the entire space (and the shores too!) all for yourself. The place can accommodate up to ten people due to its spaciousness so bring along family or friends for a secluded and immersive Bahamas experience.

Stayed at this property?

18.21 km (11.4 mi) from Leon Levy Native Plant Preserve
38 reviews   Wifi Available
House 9 Guests 5 Bedrooms 5 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 9
Minimum Nights: 1
Refund Policy :

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
but it will not be our last
The view from the balcony was absolutely breathtaking
It was not overtaxed with number of people for the size house
so you are not on top of each other
4 stars is that the property lacks beach umbrellas and enough beach chairs
Cleanliness:
The interior was lovely and modern and rooms were spacious and clean
The vacation rental was very clean
The house is clean and perfect for a large group (we had 4 couples)
we had 4 adults and many nights several guests over for dinner and drinks
I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental
Host:
Matthew Simon was awesome to work with and gave us all great tips
They were so very helpful in giving us pointers about the island and made sure our trip would be the success that it was
The property manager Bobbett was always available to us and even did grocery shopping before our arrival
then nice waves at high tide Clean beach as well
Eleuthera is laid back very casual island but is very expensive as all goods are imported
Location:
Groceries were a short drive away at the Midway Cost Cutter and restaurants within 30 minutes
The house is a "beach" house
Cars are very expensive and older
The house is set up perfectly for a beach getaway
biking walkining and exploring
Read more reviews

3. Artistic and unique island beach house (from USD 647)

What’s great about the Bahamas is how pristine the beaches are that it will excite you to indulge in water activities. However, after all the splashing fun, it would be amazing to rest in such a cozy and comfortable place. This property is at the exclusive Windermere Island right by the fantastic pink sand beach! With this proximity, you are prone to explore the fun. Another great feature about this place is the artistry all around. In addition, it comes with access to the Windermere Club, providing you a heated pool, a tennis court, a small gym, and a restaurant and bar.

Stayed at this property?

18.12 km (11.3 mi) from Leon Levy Native Plant Preserve
19 reviews   Wifi Available
House 10 Guests 4 Bedrooms 4 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 10
Minimum Nights: 5
Refund Policy :

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
(there is a TV that is hooked-up to a DVD player; we did not use it); the house has usable Wi-Fi
Bugs in two of the bedrooms were so pervasive that the kids all had to sleep in the living room
Had problems with the old oven Had problems with the showers draining (standing in 1-2" of water while taking a shower)
Our group of 10 fit nicely in the house with 8 in the main house (one master bed room; one room with two beds and one room with two bunk beds) and 2 in the guest house (i e
We travelled with three young children and were very comfortable in Savannah house
Cleanliness:
The vacation rental was very clean
The club/common pool that goes along with this house
Pool was clean and tennis courts in good order
a bed room and full bath)
I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental
Host:
The housekeeper was wonderful as well and provided us with loads of information
so your only concerns will be whether to hit the pool or the beach
My only complaints were that the house was not stocked with some essentials that would have made our lives easier:
all in all a great vacation
I was more than happy with the location
Location:
The house is perfectly located next to the club too
We got some tennis in at the club and and even paddle boarding on the sound
which is steps away from the main house and is great for people (a couple?)
The house is a 2 minute walk to a gorgeous beach
We stayed here in 2015 after seeing India Hicks at a book signing The property has not been maintained Several leaks in the kitchen Sofa's and rugs were stained Bugs throughout the home
Read more reviews

4. Elegant and vibrant beachfront estate (from USD 885)

This beautifully designed home promotes fun outdoor activities with the availability of many outdoor facilities. Here, you will feel the luxury as well as the refreshing Bahamas vibe while you relax on the comfortable seats and bask in the gorgeous panoramic view. There is also a swimming pool here so don’t hesitate to go for dip! The terrace, patio, and many other amenities are well-designed. There are four bedrooms and four-and-a-half bathrooms and the place is spacious enough to accommodate up to eight people.

Stayed at this property?

17.84 km (11.1 mi) from Leon Levy Native Plant Preserve
8 reviews   Wifi Available
House 8 Guests 4 Bedrooms 5 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 8
Minimum Nights: 3
Refund Policy :

Top guest reviews
Cleanliness:
I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental
I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental
Host:
They have a pool and tennis
They loved the beach and the pool
She is a lovely lady who did so much for us
We were very well taken care of by the caretaker Bobbett
I was very happy with the location
Location:
The Club is really nice
The house is beautiful with an easy walk to the beach
Windermere island is very secluded and private which was a big plus for us
My only comment is that when looking at the ammenities when searching for a house
Rating Details:The property manager was very helpful
Read more reviews

5. Tranquil beach bungalow (from USD 194)

This place will have you surrounded by palm trees and a relaxing beach ambiance for that much-desired tranquility. Your stay here in the Bahamas would be relaxing and soothing with a cozy home like this. The best part is the exclusivity of the open grounds. Here you can enjoy the beauty of the sea during the day and admire the wonder of the stars at night! Everything you need is here for your convenience.

Stayed at this property?

10.11 km (6.3 mi) from Leon Levy Native Plant Preserve
46 reviews   Wifi Available
bungalow 4 Guests 2 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 4
Minimum Nights: 7
Refund Policy : 100% refund if you cancel at least 60 days before check-in.

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
excellent kitchen knife unbelievably sharp Beds more comfortable then our own Great internet Sherman
Thanks for the insulated coolers and lawn chairs
Wi-Fi worked reliably but some TV functions were unavailable --
It was also nice to just clean out the fridge and leave -- the cleaning service changes the bedding sweeps
If you like to escape all the Stress
Cleanliness:
Very clean and nicely decorated
The house is new clean and very nicely furnished
The beds were extremely comfortable
Host:
Sherman was a great help nice to have his SUV rental
They arranged our car rental with Sherman who is also the caretaker
We really appreciated them Nearby beach was wonderful
heard many birds & watched & photographed the many tiny lizards
the nice owner told us he had just made fresh fried snapper & sold us two
Location:
The snorkeling is safe and gentle best at low tide
It is a very very short walk away but definitely not directly on the beach
the only way is to get to Eleuthera
It's situated just about a 3 minute walk from the beautiful Ten Bay and is Central to Eleuthera which we thought was perfect for exploring the entire island One of the islands better markets
Enjoyed Da Perk Coffee Shop with free wifi
Read more reviews

6. Caribbean paradise by the sea (from USD 230)

This beautiful place is rather newly built so you can enjoy the modern amenities and design. The place features wireless internet, air conditioning, three bedrooms, and two bathrooms. It is spacious so it can accommodate up to six people. Another great attribute of this place is that it is situated just in front of the crystal clear sea! So refreshing.

Stayed at this property?
Central Eleuthera, BS
10.25 km (6.4 mi) from Leon Levy Native Plant Preserve
17 reviews  
House 3 Guests 3 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
Had a great time during our stay
The bed was soooo comfy
You do need a jeep or suv (high clearance) to get to the house because of the rocky road
if you wanted to use/fill the jugs for that
If you like Conch Salad you have to try the private food stand that is down and across the street from Buccaneers
Cleanliness:
Lovely house with almost everything you needed
Brand new beautifully decorated and the location can't be beat
It had a washer and dryer which was great
our "backyard" Can't wait to stay again soon
a few things aren't ready yet like the dishwasher but just look for the little notes
Host:
Darek was so helpful before and during our stay
Dariusz was so understanding and helpful when we had a last minute change
The caretaker and his wife were so wonderful and helpful
Looks nicer in person and so is the view
The local people are so kind and willing to help you out
Location:
We've been to other out islands but first time to Eleuthera
This house is a newer build
Centrally located accurate listing
We spotted stingray and starfish right in
We wanted to swim but had bad timing
Read more reviews

7. Fantastic private beach house (from USD 428)

The Hamilton House features a pool and tennis court plus unblocked views of the beautiful Atlantic Ocean! Unwind and settle into this lovely beach house to get to that much-desired state of relaxation. Here, guests are entitled to four bedrooms and three bathrooms. The place is spacious and it can accommodate up to eight people. With that, it would be a good idea to bring along your family or friends for an unforgettable trip to the Bahamas!

Stayed at this property?

18.37 km (11.5 mi) from Leon Levy Native Plant Preserve
16 reviews  
House 8 Guests 4 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
Did you want to cook onsite?
The house is spacious and comfortable (the kitchen is to have a makeover)
You can take the pool chairs to the beach -
The clubhouse is an added bonus for dinners out--
The air conditioner in the living area could not keep the house cool
Cleanliness:
and I felt like we were centrally located
I was very dissatisfied with the condition of the vacation rental
The miles of perfectly pink beaches were exquisite especially since for most of our trip
highly recommend Alva's cocktail list and the service can't be beat
and you don't need action and pool parties in your holiday
Host:
and she cooks an amazing meal
You must visit Julian and his wife at nearby Fishbones-for drinks late night fireside chats and eats
So we rented beach chairs and extra kayaks
Bobbett is always available for any of your questions or needs Thanks for another great family vacation
The home is nicely furnished and had lots of books games snorkels and fins
Location:
Check out the Midway Cost Cutter
Eleuthera and Hamilton House are unparalleled in island charm raw beauty and imagination
But it's also a great location if you are the type of person who wants to explore the island (which we did)
In Governors Harbor breakfast at "The Buckaneer" is legendary-
:Hamilton House's location is beautiful but the house could really use some maintenance
Read more reviews

8. Gorgeous property at the beautiful Windermere Beach (from USD 700)

Tagged as one of the most beautiful beaches, Windermere Beach is the ultimate spot for a tropical getaway at the Bahamas! This gorgeous house will surely provide you that experience. This lovely place can accommodate up to eight guests. Take advantage of the scenic views of the ocean and beyond. Your hearts will be filled because of how lovely the place is in terms of design and amenities. Everything you need is already here. There is even a pool at to enjoy!

Stayed at this property?
Savannah Sound, Eleuthera, BS
17.99 km (11.2 mi) from Leon Levy Native Plant Preserve
22 reviews  
House 8 Guests 4 Bedrooms 4 Bathrooms
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
The kitchen has everything you need
To top it all off
roomy house with fully equipped kitchen large open center room with great views and a large deck joining the room to relax on I particularly liked the separate bedroom wings for privacy
The large sliding doors on all sides of the main room open wide on 3 sides plus the front doors as well
It's a long swim to snorkel the off-shore coral
Cleanliness:
All basic bed and bath supplies and plumbing were available and working-
and she kept the house fresh and clean and put fresh flowers in every room
Winnie and Jeff are there to clean and take care of property
so Surfsong is best for people who enjoy preparing and sharing meals together
Host:
electrical water all available and working as expected-
The locals are amazing everyone knows everyone and are so friendly
so the breeze blows through the whole home
I give SurfSong my highest recommendation for any group that wants a beautiful peaceful getaway
We had a wonderful time and the home is very accommodating to all needs
Location:
we found time to get our daily dose of tennis and visit some of the local restaurants and bars
This can easily be solved by repositioning the wireless router-
there is very little in the way of tourist infrastructure
It take a bit of driving to get to the nearest store or restaurant
The island is very peaceful and the beaches on March break are very uncrowded
Read more reviews

9. Chic and clean condo at Windermere beach (from USD 357)

Enjoy the panoramic ocean views from this chic condo unit! Everything needed for a convenient and comfortable stay is already here, so all you have to do is to sit back and relax with the amazing views of the famous Windermere Beach. The private accommodation features two bedrooms, two bathrooms, television, fast internet, appliances, and other essentials. From here, you have easy access to the beach for some fun.

Stayed at this property?

15.97 km (10.0 mi) from Leon Levy Native Plant Preserve
5 reviews  
condo 4 Guests 2 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
We did not eat out preferring to cook but car was essential for getting to condo and trips to grocery store
But main draw is the beach which goes on for six miles and is perfect for walking sitting and swimming and is right outside the condo One does need a rental car
Cleanliness:
Beautifully decorated and fully appointed the interior is lovely
Host:
Very well equipped bright
very clean condo opening on to spectacular almost empty beach with clean warm water
Location:
We loved this quiet quiet island and quiet space
-this was not a problem but should be arranged at the airport- for grocery shopping and eating out
courts right behind condo in very good shape
But it's the easy access to the Sandy pink beach that make this lovely space heavenly
We only used local grocery store which was limited but fine for our needs
Read more reviews

10. Cute cabin by the sea (from USD 225)

cute cabin by the sea
Source: www.vrbo.com

If you love snorkeling and cliff diving, you will surely love this exclusive space. Literally just a few steps away from the glorious waters of the Bahamas, this cute cabin is on the cliffs of Little Bay. It is a quiet cove so when you stay here, you will have the entire place exclusively! The place truly caters for adventurers, since it also offers facilities like a diving board for some fun water activities. Dip into the Caribbean waters and swim to your heart’s desire with this cute cabin being just nearby the sea.

Stayed at this property?
Savannah Sound, Eleuthera, BS
13.97 km (8.7 mi) from Leon Levy Native Plant Preserve
50 reviews  
cottage 6 Guests 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
The highlight is the waterfront deck and the excellent diving board
It has plenty of towels two outdoor showers comfy beds
specialty items and wonderful produce
The full wall of screened windows facing the Caribbean and the full vernandah open up the wonderful view of the coral reefs in Little Bay
There is a great farm/bakery stand down the road that has everything you need for food - fresh veggies
Cleanliness:
The house is clean and the beds are comfortable
The domestic equipment to clean the house is a catastrohpe - don't use the hoover
The house had everything we needed and more
we plan on returning and look forward to doing so
Host:
We made this vacation about reconnecting with each other and
our gracious owner of the house and Doyle the caretaker to be most helpful in providing both information directions and local culture
We made the trek to Lighthouse Beach (Southern most point of Eluethera)
What is most evident about Eleuthera and its people is that it is safe and friendly and so very hospitable
For anything more extravagant Governors Harbour is just north and can offer varying types of stores
Location:
it's a once in a lifetime leap
quiet and easy access to lots of great beaches and great snorkeling
There is a small grocery just 5 minutes south from house on Queens Highway called Cost Cutter which is handy
Enjoyed great lunches and dinners at Tippy's and at the Buccaneer Club in Governors Harbour
and there are a couple neat gift shops and Take aways to stop and eat Glass Window Bridge
Read more reviews

Tranquility and peace at the beautiful Bahamas

The natural beauty of the place is enough for people to desire spending a well-earned vacation. Other than just going for a swim, so many water activities can be done such as cliff diving and snorkeling! With places as magical as the Vrbo accommodations listed above, you will certainly book yourself an adventure in Windermere Island, the Bahamas that you will treasure for life.

Any must-sees we missed? Tell us about them in the comments section or write a post here to help out fellow travelers!
Disclosure: Trip101 selects the listings in our articles independently. Some of the listings in this article contain affiliate links.

History


Get Trip101 in your inbox

Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data

Nadine has a passion for film photography, entrepreneurship, and the performing arts. She loves meeting friendly people, trying exotic cuisines, and exploring new places authentically. Her life...Read more

 Want to contribute as a Local Expert?
Explore Eleuthera
x
Good things are meant to be shared!
Back to top
Visited any of these places? Click this button to activate our "Add a Tip" feature to share your experience.
all inclusive resorts exuma bahamas

Top 4 All-Inclusive Resorts In Exuma, Bahamas - Updated 2024