Fire Island, New York, is a popular travel destination for all the beach bums out there. Replete with natural wonders, this place offers plenty of stuff to do. Did you know that it has as many as 17 car-free communities that can only be reached by ferry? Thanks to its close proximity to New York City, this quaint island offers an exciting weekend getaway option or a perfect addition to your eastside itinerary. But apart from its natural beauty, this hideaway is also rich in cultural heritage, with interesting tales from the colonial era. If you are a water baby, then you may also be able to find some shipwrecks buried deep under the sea. No pollution, plenty of good food, and fun activities to do—all good reasons for you to consider this haven for a holiday if you haven’t already! So if you are planning to visit soon and wondering where to stay on Fire Island, New York, then this article will be the perfect starting point for you!
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status. recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on February 05, 2024.
Apartment
1. Comfy stay amid peace and tranquility just two minutes from the beach
Want to get away from the hustle and bustle of New York? If the answer is yes, then what better place than this amazing retreat? Cherry Grove Studio is designed to offer complete privacy and a peaceful stay. Gain access to the beach within two minutes and walk on tranquil shores for hours. You get a private entrance, bathroom, access to fridge and microwave, AC, Wi-Fi connectivity, and lots more. This nature lover’s retreat is ideal for a couple or a small family wanting to spend some quality time together on their short vacation.
Cherry Grove, New York, United StatesSuperhost
Accommodates: 2
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
there's a ceiling fan and floor fani would suggest to rent out a bigger space that includes a full kitchen and a fantastic viewthe room was very cozy and had a wonderful deck where we could relax and enjoy the weatherthe deck is fairly large given the coziness of the roomCleanliness:
the space was clean and comfortablethe apartment was adorable it was clean comfortable and extremely privateit's very clean and offered even more than i would expect (beach towels chairs)the room we stayed in was clean and had everything we needed for a long weekendvery clean tranquil very spacious for a studio apartment host and neighbor were extremely nice and helpfulHost:
alexandre was a great hostalexandre was a most gracious hostvery accommodating and a kind hostalexandre was an amazing hostalexandre was a very welcoming and charming hostRead more reviewsLocation:
the location was greatthe location is perfectalexandre’s place was perfectly locatedbauhaus is perfectly located if you want to be close to cherry groves nightlifebeautiful cozy studio close to the bay and the beach in easy walking distance to everything in cherry grove
Cottages
2. A home away from home for a big family or a large group of friends (from USD 732)
If you are traveling to Fire Island with a bunch of friends, then this cottage will be right up your alley. With three well-maintained bedrooms and two bathrooms, it can house up to 10 guests. The cottage comes equipped with a flat-screen TV and an eat-in kitchen that opens up to a large backyard. BBQ in the open or simply enjoy the cool sea breeze on the patio. You can also rent bikes from the property and go exploring in the area.
Ocean Bay Park, New York, United StatesAccommodates: 10
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
we loved the outdoor space and how you could see the bay from the cute breakfast nookCleanliness:
the house was clean and was exactly as describedeverything was clean and it was perfect for our needsthe house was very cute and cleanhouse was spotless exactly how listed and had great outside area for grilling and relaxingHost:
host was very kind and helpfulpeter and lydia were amazing hosts and had quick responses for any questions we hadpete and lydia are wonderful hostseverything was so convenient they had 4 bikes which was very helpful for us in exploring the islandRead more reviewsLocation:
the location was perfectperfect beach house close to the beach restaurants and barsexcellent location extremely close to the ferry :) would love to rent againclean great location great space for a family we enjoyed it so very much
3. A charming house for a perfect beach vacation (from USD 750)
With three spacious bedrooms and charming décor, this house is everything you need for a peaceful holiday. Three fully equipped bedrooms fitted with queen-size beds, a ceiling fan, two twin beds, and Wi-Fi will ensure you have everything you need. A big plus? There is no TV or AC, so you basically spend more quality time outdoors. What’s more? The property also offers bikes, beach gear, a gas grill, and even a kayak for your use!
Fire Island, New York, United StatesAccommodates: 6
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
it feels lived in and comfortableHost:
our host made us feel very welcomethe house was great and the owner was very responsiveowner super easy to deal with and very accommodatingjane was an excellent host so responsive and helpful and we would love to come backRead more reviewsLocation:
perfect location and comfortablealso the location was amazingamazing location 30 seconds from the beach very close to the ferry and grocery storegreat house - close to beach and still close to the dock restaurant and grocery store) but this place is well equipped
Houses
4. Your exclusive house right on the beach
Fire Island is a popular tourist destination that pulls a lot of people from the cities. However, if you want to spend some time away from the crowd, then this beach house is the ideal choice. This comfortable cottage is bright, sunny, and airy, giving you splendid views of the ocean. Equipped with four bedrooms, it can accommodate up to eight guests. This well-stocked property provides everything you need, with an added bonus of peace and tranquility! Do note that the hosts allow only midweek booking—that is, from Monday evening to Friday afternoon.
Fire Island, New York, United States
5. Stay in a handcrafted home right on Atlantique Beach (from USD 679)
This simple yet clean and comfortable beach house has been crafted to perfection by Marcel Breuer, an apprentice to the famous architect Carl Stein. This lodging is perched right above Atlantique Beach, so you get not only sprawling views of the ocean but also complete privacy. This modest structure has been tastefully designed to offer comfort. It can accommodate up to six guests in its three bedrooms, and it is equipped with a huge deck, a screened dining area, high-speed Wi-Fi, a washer and dryer, beach toys, and lots more.
Fire Island, New York, United StatesAccommodates: 6
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
it's not big but the views of the ocean from all the rooms make it totally worth itCleanliness:
everything's clean and well-maintainedit was clean and simply stylishit's beautiful clean and very charmingthe house was clean and well-appointed (inclgreat place clean neat private and excellent communication from the hostHost:
the host was incredibly helpful and accommodatingeveryone wins marc was a wonderful hostand the host was very helpful and responsivethe host was very responsive to any questions we may have had as wellmarc was a wonderful host and could not have been more helpfulRead more reviewsLocation:
the location is amazing — right on the beach on a walkwaygreat house great location beautiful view and right on the beachmarc is great this house and location is great and i would 100% recommend anyone to stay heremarc's place was perfect
6. A retro house with an award-winning design just seconds away from the beach (from USD 407)
This ‘60s retro-themed house is right on the beach, offering clean and spacious rooms. With a maximum guest capacity of 10, it is ideal for an intimate family gathering or a group of friends vacationing together on Fire Island. This property features an open-roofed porch, an outdoor BBQ, hardwood floors, plenty of natural light, and close proximity to all the areas of interest—you are basically getting the best of both worlds. The vintage feel of this house and quirky décor is a perfect way to feel away from home without leaving your comforts behind.
Bay Shore, New York, United StatesAccommodates: 10
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the deck off the kitchen is the bestthe real treat for all you beach bums is the outdoor showerplenty of space and comfortable rooms several of which have acthe house was exactly what we were looking for--comfortable and casual with all the necessary amenities at handthe indoor kitchen space was great complete with a wood burning stove full kitchen and two bathroomsCleanliness:
very clean spacious and well stockedthe rooms were clean and the beds were comfortablehouse was clean simply beachy and retrothe house was very clean and comfortable and fit the bill for a great beach houseit was spacious clean and a stones throw from both the bay and the beachHost:
wally was a great hostwally was attentive and nicewally was an amazing hostwally was an amazing hosthost made us feel welcomeRead more reviewsLocation:
charming and unique house equally close to beach and towngreat place close to the beachsuch a great location and very walkable to the beachgreat house spacious close to the beachclose to everything most importantly the beautiful beach
7. A newly constructed house close to Ocean Bay
This five-bedroom house is an ideal holiday spot for families and friends. It can sleep up to 13 guests and is an easy three-minute walk from the beach. The outside deck has an outdoor shower, a BBQ grill, beach chairs, and awesome views that will make your holiday relaxing as well as unforgettable.
Ocean Beach, New York, United States
8. A fun-filled beach house on Ocean Beach
This Fire Island vacation home is perfect for you if you are looking for something laid-back. It is perfect for large groups, bachelor parties, and large families. It can sleep up to 10 guests and features four fully equipped bedrooms right on Ocean Beach. Offering various perks, from a spacious outdoor deck to a satellite TV, the host leaves no stone unturned to ensure your comfort. The property has all the latest amenities and basic facilities for guests to use.
Ocean Beach, New York, United StatesTop guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
10 single beds great for groupsHost:
host is extremely helpful and responsivebenjamin was an excellent hostben was a great host and responded to me quicklygreat place to stay ben is extremely helpful and quick with responseshost ben was very responsive to messagesRead more reviewsLocation:
great central location to bars and beachit's perfectly located aside from the fire house across the streetthis house was great for a big group perfect location to everything in town and to the beachvery close to the nightlife and better restaurants and shopswe absolutely loved this place it was prime location and such a lovely space for large groups
9. The perfect house for a fun weekend getaway
This is the only house on the beach block of Fair Harbor on Fire Island. When you book this property, you will not only enjoy privacy but also gain access to all the amenities that the hosts provide. The spacious house can sleep eight guests in its four bedrooms. It also features an upstairs deck as well as windows on all sides. This affordable vacation home is a close walking distance from grocery stores, restaurants, and the beach.
Fair Harbor, Fire Island, New York, United States
10. An airy and spacious four-bedroom house on Atlantique Beach
If you want views to die for, absolute comfort, and close proximity to the beach, then this house scores a perfect 10! This modern accommodation has been carefully designed to transport you to another world when you are on vacation. Just a 15-minute walk from the ferry, this holiday home is what you need for your next getaway to Fire Island. The hosts provide all the necessary facilities and amenities for the guests’ comfort, including a fully equipped kitchen.
Bay Shore, New York, United StatesTop guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
really nice very relaxing well-appointed (beach equipment kitchen etcto be able see the water from the living room was truly amazingCleanliness:
dani's beach house is beautiful open very clean and airyhouse is clean and has a fresh reno feel - and is brilliantly locateddanni's house was very clean and in a gorgeous location with beautiful ocean views and great cross breezesHost:
danni was a great host very responsive but not intrusivedanni was an excellent hostdanni was very accommodating and very responsive if we had any questions about the location or the stayRead more reviewsLocation:
perfect location in a great communitywe loved the locationamazing location and great house for all agesdanni's place is beautiful i love location of the house and danni was a great hosthis house is fantastic beautiful location directly on the beach
Life is a beach at Fire Island, New York
This 32-mile barrier island is a part of Fire Island National Seashore. With the Atlantic Ocean to the south and Great South Bay to the north, this place is perfect for beach lovers. Walk around in nature, explore the waters, or simply relax on the sandy shores. Fire Island allows you to choose the pace of your holiday and spend your time the way you like!
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data
Create an account to bookmark our articles, like local expert tips, receive great stories in your inbox, and follow writers and topics that you love.
Log in with Google ×