Where To Stay In Montauk, New York - Updated 2024

Hotels

1. Haven Montauk (from USD 110)

1/5 places to stay in montauk | haven montauk

2/5 haven montauk

3/5 haven montauk

4/5 haven montauk

5/5

Show all photos

This luxurious hotel is conveniently located just 600 meters (1968.50 feet) from Gin Beach and offers bike rentals for beach exploration. Select rooms provide picturesque views, with some overlooking the beach and others facing Lake Montauk.

Complimentary parking is available on the hotel premises for your convenience. If relaxation is on your agenda, take a few leisurely laps in the outdoor swimming pool. Inside your room, you’ll find essential amenities including a television, refrigerator, and clothes rack to ensure a comfortable stay. The outdoor fireplace, garden, and picnic area create a serene atmosphere where you can unwind and enjoy quality time with your pet.

2. Montauk Manor (from USD 142)

1/5 places to stay in montauk | montauk manor

2/5 montauk manor

3/5 montauk manor

4/5 montauk manor

5/5

Show all photos

The views, on-site amenities, and the ambiance exuded by Montauk Manor make it an inviting abode for every visitor in Montauk, New York. The facility has spacious gardens with beautifully manicured lawns and park benches ideal for relaxing evenings. The rooms are uniquely decorated, and each features a cable TV, a full kitchen, and a private bathroom equipped with free toiletries. Guests at the Manor will also have access to indoor and outdoor pools, free WiFi, multiple tennis courts, and a spa and wellness center. For those who would love to indulge in some outdoor activities, horse riding and fishing would be very appropriate, though Kirk Beach and Montauk Museum are also in proximity, being just 2.9 km(1.8 miles) and 10.1 km(6.28 miles) away, respectively.

3. The Montauk Beach House (from USD 329)

1/5 places to stay in montauk | the montauk beach house

2/5 the montauk beach house

3/5 the montauk beach house

4/5 the montauk beach house

5/5

Show all photos

The Montauk Beach House is located just off Route 27 and it promises guests a wonderful stay with the presence of an outdoor pool, free WiFi, a snack bar, café, and a gift shop. All the rooms in this beach house feature a flat-screen TV, air conditioning, and private bathrooms equipped with free toiletries. For guests interested in exploring nearby attractions, Hither Hills State Park is only 9.3 km (5.78 miles) away, while Camp Hero State Park is just 7 km (4.35 miles) away.

4. The Montauk Soundview (from USD 230)

1/5 places to stay in montauk | the montauk soundview

2/5 the montauk soundview

3/5 the montauk soundview

4/5 the montauk soundview

5/5

Show all photos

If you are looking for a celebrity-like treatment during your stay in New York, then you have every reason to consider The Montauk Soundview. The hotel boasts of world-class beachfront accommodation with a variety of facilities and amenities that will make your stay a very pleasant one. All the rooms are air-conditioned and each is fitted with a flat-screen TV, a private bathroom, and a hairdryer. Some of the shared facilities you will find on site include free WiFi, an outdoor swimming pool, and a sun terrace. On the available nearby attractions, you will be delighted to learn that the hotel is only 3.6 km (2.24miles) from Montauk Downs State Park and 5 km (3.1 miles) from both Shadmoor State Park and Fort Pond Bay Park.

5. The Surf Lodge (from USD 332)

1/5 the surf lodge

2/5 the surf lodge

3/5 the surf lodge

4/5 the surf lodge

5/5

Show all photos

There are many highlights at The Surf Lodge but the most captivating ones include the whitewashed walls, the private balconies, the sun-bleached floors, the lazy hammocks, and the artwork done by various surfers and surf enthusiasts who made it home at some point in the past. The rooms in this lodge are spacious and each has a private bathroom where you will find a shower and free toiletries. There is an on-site restaurant where contemporary meals are served for both lunch and dinner. On proximity to attractions and other amenities, Kirk Park Beach is just 1.7 km (1.05 miles) away, while Montauk Downs States Park is only 2.1 km (1.3 miles) away. The Montauk Train Station and Long Island MacArthur Airport are 0.65 km (0.40 miles) and 108 km (67 miles) away from the hotel, respectively.

6. Beachcomber at Montauk (from USD 250)

1/5 beachcomber at montauk

2/5 beachcomber at montauk

3/5 beachcomber at montauk

4/5 beachcomber at montauk

5/5

Show all photos

Beachcomber is located directly across from the beach, with the Montauk Village being just 0.8km (0.49miles) away. The hotel boasts of an outdoor pool, a sauna, and tennis courts as some of the shared amenities. The rooms are neatly organized and each features WiFi, a cable TV, a sofa bed, an en suite bathroom, and a terrace with ocean views. Nearby attractions include Montauk Downs State Park which is only 10 minutes away by car and Hither Hills State Park that is about 8 km (4.97 miles) away.

Resorts

7. Beach Plum Resort (from USD 208)

1/5 beach plum resort

2/5 beach plum resort

3/5 beach plum resort

4/5 beach plum resort

5/5

Show all photos

Each room at this beach resort is thoughtfully equipped with modern amenities, including a television, refrigerator, coffee maker, and air-conditioner, ensuring your comfort and a homey atmosphere. Additionally, it features a private beach area and a charming garden. For those seeking relaxation and recreation, the hotel offers both a seasonal pool and an outdoor heated pool, perfect for taking a refreshing swim and unwinding.

Situated just 400 meters (1312.34 feet) from Kirk Park Beach, you can enjoy leisurely walks and bask in the breathtaking sunrise each morning. Nearby attractions include Theodore Roosevelt County Park, a mere 6 kilometers (3.73 miles) away, and Montauk Point State Park, located 10 kilometers (6.21 miles) from the resort.

8. Hero Beach Club (from USD 225)

1/5 hero beach club

2/5 hero beach club

3/5 hero beach club

4/5 hero beach club

5/5

Show all photos

The air-conditioned rooms at Hero Beach Club feature charming boho-themed interiors and captivating aesthetic lighting. The resort is conveniently located just 100 meters (328.08 feet) from Kirk Park Beach and a mere 9 kilometers (5.59 miles) from Montauk Point State Park. For those seeking relaxation, the beach club offers a spa and sauna, providing the perfect opportunity to rejuvenate and unwind after a busy week.

You can look forward to a variety of entertainment options at the resort, including movie nights, live music, and evening entertainment. In your room, you’ll find board games, puzzles, and a television for indoor amusement. And when the night sky is clear, don’t miss the chance to gather around the outdoor fireplace, where you can bask in the warmth beneath a canopy of stars.

9. Royal Atlantic Beach Resort (from USD 144)

1/5 royal atlantic beach resort

2/5 royal atlantic beach resort

3/5 royal atlantic beach resort

4/5 royal atlantic beach resort

5/5

Show all photos

At Royal Atlantic Beach Resort, guests can take advantage of a bar and complimentary parking, as well as a private beach area with comfortable beach chairs for sunbathing and achieving that perfect tan. For a delightful breakfast experience, head to the on-site restaurant, Atlantikos, and if you’re in the mood for some indoor fun, there’s a game room with table tennis and video games. Plus, you can unwind in the resort’s swimming pool after a long day of activities.

You can whip up your own tasty snacks in the kitchenette, and then savor them while sitting in the picnic area and gazing at the waves rolling in. In your room, you’ll find a television, complimentary WiFi, and a wardrobe for your convenience.

Notable nearby attractions include the Second House Museum, a mere 850 meters (2788.71 feet) away, and Theodore Roosevelt County Park, located 4.9 kilometers (3.04 miles) from the hotel.

10. The Surf Club Resort (from USD 599)

1/5 the surf club resort

2/5 the surf club resort

3/5 the surf club resort

4/5 the surf club resort

5/5

Show all photos

The Surf Club Resort is located on an 8.5-acre (34.39 ha) and has an incredible private beach that measures 550 feet (167.64 metres). The rooms in the resort are spacious and each is equipped with elegant wooden furniture. Cable TV, large seating area, and a sofa bed are also available in all the rooms. For guests’ fun and entertainment, there is a pool, tennis courts, and steam rooms. On convenience to nearby amenities and attractions, it is pleasing to know that Hither Woods is only five minutes away by car, while Suffolk County Parkland is just 6.4 km (3.79 miles) away.

11. Ocean Surf Resort (from USD 128)

1/5 ocean surf resort

2/5 ocean surf resort

3/5 ocean surf resort

4/5 ocean surf resort

5/5

Show all photos

Ocean Surf Resort is only 0.3 km (0.18 miles) from Kirk Park Beach. The resort has a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, free WiFi, non-smoking rooms, barbecue facilities, and concierge services. The rooms are spacious enough and equipped with air conditioning, a microwave, a coffee machine, a flat-screen TV, a hairdryer, a bath, and a work desk. Also, each room has a private bathroom where guests will find a shower with free toiletries. Nearby attractions to this resort are Fort Pond Bay Park and the Second House Museum which are 2.4 km (1.49 miles) and 0.6 km (0.37 miles) away from the resort, respectively.

12. Montauk Blue Hotel (from USD 298)

1/5 montauk blue hotel

2/5 montauk blue hotel

3/5 montauk blue hotel

4/5 montauk blue hotel

5/5

Show all photos

Montauk Blue Hotel is adjacent to the Main Town Beach and one of its main highlights is an indoor pool and a large sun deck with very nice ocean views. All the guest rooms have free WiFi, a microwave, a refrigerator, cable TV, and a large seating area with a sofa bed. Both the Montauk Airport and Montauk Downs are less than 9 km (5.59 miles) away, while the Montauk Lighthouse & Museum is just seven minutes away by car.

13. Gurney’s Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa (from USD 310)

1/5 gurney’s montauk resort & seawater spa

2/5 gurney’s montauk resort & seawater spa

3/5 gurney’s montauk resort & seawater spa

4/5 gurney’s montauk resort & seawater spa

5/5

Show all photos

Gurney’s Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa offers year-round accommodation just a few meters from the beach. All the rooms of this resort have an ocean view and feature a flat-screen cable TV, a CD player, iPod docking station, and a private bathroom with free toiletries and hairdryer. Guests also have access to a 24-hour, full-service spa where they can enjoy a variety of healing treatments, a sauna, and an ocean-fed seawater swimming pool. Nearby amenities include Hither Hills State Park and Montauk Downs State Golf Course which are 3.7 km (2.3 miles) and 6.9 km (4.29 miles) away from the resort, respectively.

14. The Ocean Resort Inn (from USD 120)

1/5 the ocean resort inn

2/5 the ocean resort inn

3/5 the ocean resort inn

4/5 the ocean resort inn

5/5

Show all photos

The Ocean Resort Inn is just a few steps from the Atlantic Ocean and about 8 km (5 miles) away from the Montauk Harbor. All the rooms in this inn feature a flat-screen cable TV, a microwave, a fridge, coffee- and tea-making facilities, and private bathrooms with a hairdryer and free toiletries. Some of the shared amenities guests will have access to include a heated saltwater swimming pool, free WiFi, beach chairs, beach towels, bicycles, and beach umbrellas. For guests who would wish to indulge in outdoor activities, the Montauk Downs State Park is five minutes away by car where guests can enjoy games such as swimming in an Olympic-size pool, as well as playing tennis and golf.

Enjoy the great accommodation options in Montauk, New York

Hopefully, the above options will adequately answer your questions on where to stay in Montauk, New York. You now have the freedom to choose whether you want to go for a hotel or a resort, based on the kind of accommodation experience as well as the amenities you would like to access during your stay.