Nestled between the shores of Long Island and the gorgeous expanse of the Atlantic Ocean, enjoy a slow weekend off the beaten path on Fire Island. With less than 500 residents populating the island, you can enjoy quiet afternoons by the crashing waves, or head out and explore the towering sand dunes without the onslaught of enthusiastic tourists posing for a picture. If you are wondering about where to stay, don’t fret because there are plenty of cozy vacation rentals and cheap hotels in the area. Scroll down for a well-curated list of the best Airbnb vacation rentals on Fire Island, New York.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on April 08, 2024.
1. Boho-style cottage with a lovely deck (from USD 225)
This house rental on Fire Island is only a few steps away from the white-sand beach. The vibrant decor of the interiors is steeped in the authentic flavors of a Bohemian lifestyle.
Suitable for a family of four, this two-bedroom cottage comes equipped with comfy beds that offer a good night’s rest. A fireplace keeps the indoors snug and warm. Guests can curl up by the comforting embers on a drizzly afternoon with a book and a cup of tea. A high-speed internet connection lets you go about a smooth day of remote work if needed or video-call folks back home without lag.
A beautiful patio lets you relish yummy barbeques made on the outdoor grill under the canopy of tall trees. You can spend a tranquil afternoon in the midst of nature and drink beer on the outer deck, which is furnished with solid hardwood flooring.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
it was comfortable in mid july even without acthe place has multiple umbrellas and comfortable folding chairs that were much appreciatedthe outdoor space is tranquil and lovely and includes an outdoor showerwe keep returning to this cozy cottage nestled among mature trees with its myriad decks including a roof deckHost:
robert is an amazing hostrobert was a great hostwe love a great host and our regards to robin as wellawesomeexperience at this uniquely one of a kind beach cottagerobert is a great host and very communicativeRead more reviewsLocation:
this place is a small corner of paradise really close to a magnificent beachif you like simplicity this is the placethe location couldn't be more convenient and enjoyable and robert is an exceptionally responsive hostthe very best feature is its location and proximity to a fabulous part of the beachcharming cottage just a quick walk to the beach and conveniently located in the pines
2. Cozy cabin for two with a kitchen
Enjoy your weekend getaway on Fire Island by staying in this rustic cabin, which is a perfect choice for a pair of lovebirds. The mid-century cabin rental has a cozy interior that is equipped with air conditioning and heaters for added comfort all year round. Guests can prepare light meals in the kitchen that has a stove, oven, and microwave among other modern appliances.
The friendly host greets you and shows you around upon your arrival. The cabin also opens out onto a deck where guests can lounge on one of the furnished sunbeds with a book and work on a nice tan.
Fire Island Pines, New York, United StatesAccommodates: 2
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
also a great mattress great shower a/c private deck fridge microwave and hotplatepretty room beautiful little garden nice deckif you can get a room at under $200 it’s a great value as far as the location goesCleanliness:
clean and peaceful comfortable bedmaria housekeeper cleaned the house really goodthe room was clean quiet and privateclean comfortable and conveniently locatedthere was also something that was maybe dried blood but hopefully old foundation/makeup on one of the pillowcasesHost:
alex was very helpfulglenn is a great hostalex who host was very nice helpful and making sure that you have everything you need lovely guyhe is a very accommodating host and will make sure you get the most out of your tripa great stay the host was extremely welcoming and accommodating and even let us check in earlierRead more reviewsLocation:
the location was perfectgreat location with a cute room that was perfect for our long weekend stay in fipgreat location and exactly as described/depictedclose to town and perfect for a night or twogreat location loved our stay and would definitely recommend for anyone visiting pines for the first time
3. Iconic Pyramid House in Fire Island Pines (from USD 714)
Take your vacation to the next level by staying in this iconic holiday rental on Fire Island. Besides its stunning architectural design, this accommodation is fully furnished with everything you need to ensure a relaxing stay. It comes with three spacious and comfy bedrooms to sleep up to six guests. The wonderful interior design is coupled with stylish furnishings and nice amenities like a fully equipped kitchen, WiFi, TV, and a hot tub among many others for your comfort and convenience.
This amazing property is bordered by the ocean and a national park, which means you’ll have easy access to the natural beauty around you. The outdoor heated pool is a great spot to unwind with your family or friends.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the house is beautiful & tranquil while also being incredibly welcoming & cozythere’s also a fantastic kitchen to cook and bake in (in particular great knives )beds were comfortable water pressure was awesome towels galore and that heated pool was perfectthere is everything you'll need from the kitchen being fully stocked to wonderful towels and even robesCleanliness:
we liked it that way our dog loved the beach which was clean and expansivethe house is very unique and cleanHost:
host was super nice and helpfulglenn is an awesome hostglenn was a wonderful hostglenn is the most gracious hostglenn is the perfect hostRead more reviewsLocation:
great location in an incredible placegreat pool and location - really close to the beachamazing vibe and perfect locationbeautiful beautiful home and locationgreat place to be quiet and enjoy watching birds and deer roaming through the dunes
4. Modern cottage near Fire Island Pines (from 600 USD)
Situated a 10-minute walk away from the harbour, don’t fret if you can’t find the address on the map! This Airbnb vacation rental tucked away on a private path leading away from the busy Tuna Walk will allow you to experience a true home away from home in the secluded stillness of the woods. Spend a relaxing afternoon by the picnic benches with some homemade snacks, or hide in the comforts of your fully air-conditioned home with your favourite Netflix show playing in the background.
Modern Cottage
Address: Near Fire Island Pines (see map)
Price: from 600 USD
Number of Guests: 6
5. Beach house near Cherry Grove (from USD 775)
If you’re planning a family staycation this summer, consider Cindy’s Airbnb in Cherry Grove on Fire Island. Equipped with children-friendly facilities, the huge outdoor pool is a hit with the little ones every year! You can even expect to catch a glimpse of a shy deer grazing by the front porch, though feeding is not allowed. Head back indoors and feel the refreshing blast of the AC cool you down after a day of exploring - if you are beat, be sure to take a nap on the sofa bed to replenish your energy!
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the kitchen is a delight to cook in fully stocked with a massive center islandHost:
host was very responsive and nicethe owners and other tenants were absolutely wonderfulcindy and carol were the perfect hosts: warm easy-going approachable and so thoughtful and considerate of our comfortRead more reviewsLocation:
good space in an amazing location
6. Psychedelic apartment in Ocean Bay Park (from 500 USD)
With enough room for a large family of seven, this airy Airbnb apartment is often basked in the refreshing musk of ocean waves - perfect for beach enthusiasts! Spend some quality time with your loved ones by the wrap-around deck comfortably sheltered with umbrella shades, or go on a mini-marathon around the sandy shores with the bikes provided. After a long day, tuck yourselves into bed with the array of sleeping accommodations available. Whether it is the bunk beds or the queen-sized sleepers, the cushy pillows will have you dreaming in no time!
Psychedelic Apartment
Address: Ocean Bay Park (see map)
Price: from 500 USD
Number of Guests: 7
7. Zen retreat near Fire Island Pines (from USD 157)
Slow down your pace here in Glenn’s serene Airbnb cottage for a crowd of three. Furnished with colourful works of art, take some time to admire the vintage collection of wall art from the host’s personal collection. Spend slow afternoons in the shaded lounge area with a book in hand, or indulge in an afternoon siesta on the cosy single beds provided. Not featured in the photos are the outdoor shower spaces that are great for washing off the sand from the beach, as well as shared bathrooms in the house.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
my room was comfortable clean and air conditionedi would definitely try to get a room with a private bathroom as sharing can get crowdedCleanliness:
clean comfortable and convenient space- would recommendshared bathroom was cleanstylish clean rooms and and amazing hostHost:
really stylish shared space with welcoming hostsglenn was a great host with quick responseshe was swift in responding to all our questions and very helpfulglenn was a great hostour host was attnetitive and coukd not uave asked for better hospitalityRead more reviewsLocation:
location is great - near everythingthe house is ideally located and just a short walk to the beachthe location is also excellent very close to the port and beachwould definitely consider going back the location is perfectthe location was amazing just a few minutes from the pier
8. Minimalist apartment in the Davis Park neighbourhood (from 545 USD)
Live in contemporary comfort here on Tsia’s vacation rental for six people. The large windows and high skylights convey a sense of extended space together with functional yet minimalist furniture. Stocked up with all your beach necessities, you don’t have to worry about bringing extra towels or beach chairs because Tsia has it all prepared for you! Head out to the deck for a whiff of fresh morning air, as you watch the rising sun slowly illuminate your temporary Airbnb home.
Minimalist Apartment
Address: Davis Park Neighbourhood (see map)
Price: from 545 USD
Number of Guests: 6
9. Designer pool house near Fire Island Pines (from USD 260)
If you’re not too fond of shared spaces, Alan offers an isolated Airbnb vacation rental off the coast for a small family of four. Upon entering your new house, you will be greeted by the gentle aroma of fresh fruits laid out for you in the kitchen. Head to the garden (not pictured above), where flourishing herbs such as rosemary and oregano are free for your use. When the weather gets unbearably hot, dunk yourselves into the huge outdoor swimming pool or hide from the heat wave in your fully air-conditioned rooms.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the heated pool and jacuzzi are great amenitiesfresh herbs grow by the pool including oregano and rosemarybonus for having air conditioning as homes on the island without it often smell mildewyi've done fire island shares in the past but having our own apartment was really nicethe bedroom was elegant and comfortableCleanliness:
the place was clean and very nicely appointedthe one-bedroom poolhouse is clean spacious well-stockedperfect choice at the pines the pool house is clean near the pier and the hosts are very friendlyHost:
alan was a great hostwe had a great time everything was just as promised alan was a great hostRead more reviewsLocation:
beautiful place and great locationwe'll definitely look to alan and 281 shady walk for our next stay in the pines
10. Beautiful vacation home near Kismet (from 550 USD)
If you have a furry friend who looks extra sad when the family goes on vacation, look no further as we have the perfect pet-friendly Airbnb rental for your next holiday! Your pets can roam freely by the seaside or relax comfortably with you on the gazebo of this vacation rental, situated a short 3-minute walk from the sandy shores. When you find your stomachs growling, head back home and start up the outdoor BBQ grill for a delicious al fresco dinner, or head back into your living room and sprawl out on the sofabed whilst catching up on your favourite shows!
Beautiful Vacation Home
Address: Near Kismet (see map)
Price: from 550 USD
Number of Guests: 6
11. Boho beach house near Fair Harbor (from USD 150)
The Airbnb vacation rental, located right beside the post office in Fair Harbor, it is perfect for bringing your kid out for a refreshing ice cream treat on sweltering summer afternoons or scavenging for snappy hermit crabs by the bay. All of these activities are located not more than a 10-minute walk away at your new home! Decked out in boho themes, the oaken lounge chairs draped with snow white sheets are reminiscent of a lovely day out at the beach. Whenever you feel sleepy, retreat back to your rooms for a short snooze - the couch can also be unfolded into a comfortable sleeper.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
very comfy beds and ac made the room perfectCleanliness:
clean house and comfortable bedsHost:
mitch was a great hostcontacted us before the trip and sent helpful informationmitch is a great host full of knowledge and enthusiasm about fair harbor and fire island in generalmitch is an excellent host and clearly loves introducing people to the magic of summers on fire islandwe just loved our time on fire island and mitch was a wonderful and very welcoming hostRead more reviewsLocation:
also worth noting the excellent location right next to the ferry dock market playground and restaurantwe very much enjoyed our stay the location is perfect and mitch was a wonderful hostits the perfect place to let kids be kids and for parents to get some much-needed relaxation
12. Bayview property in Fire Island (from USD 390)
It’s an architectural marvel worth your time and exploration near Fire Island. Fit for up to ten guests, this estate allows you to bring along family or friends for the journey, where three individual bedrooms and four beds, plus two private baths, await to comfortably accommodate you. You’ll find yourself right along the water at Mastic Beach, the perfect excuse to introduce your toes to sandy shores. Enjoy the sun over the water on a daily basis, from windows that offer sweeping views of nearby natural landscapes. When you’re not lounging on the wrap-around deck, you’ll be able to enjoy all of the many amenities on the premises, including a well-equipped kitchen, wireless Internet access site-wide, laundry provisions, free onsite parking, and even an indoor fireplace! There’s even a local train station nearby, allowing for public transportation to deliver you to your destination of choice near Fire Island.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
there is no air conditioning but with the breeze from the water it kept the house very coolquiet neighborhood beautiful views quick drive to fire island beach comfortable family friendly homethe location is stunning with a beautiful view of the bay from the master bedroom and kitchenthe kitchen was well stocked and it was great having access to the two kayaksalthough no a/c in the house it stays nice and cool from the ocean breezeCleanliness:
the house was very clean when we arrivedeverything in the house was very clean when we arrivedoverall clean great house that worked great for our needsthe house is spacious and cleanthe house was neat and clean upon arrival and well supplied with kitchen and living essentialsHost:
the hosts were responsive to questions and/or requestshosts were very accommodating and responsive to questionseoin was a great host and was quick to respond to any questions we hadeoin is also pet friendlyeoin was extremely responsive and helpful throughout the processRead more reviewsLocation:
the location was beautiful quiet and right on the baygreat place to get away from the citygreat place to get away to and just relaxthis house is in an incredibly beautiful location and was comfortable for 8 of us for a weekendnice place right by the water
13. Woody beach house near Fire Island Pines
Follow the sound of ships at the harbour and you will soon find yourself at Cheryl’s lovely Airbnb beach house for two. Enjoy a romantic escapade with your partner within the fully enclosed apartment walls, or chill out by the private outdoor pool with a glass of martini in hand. Pit your cooking skills to the test by inventing a new dish in the fully-equipped kitchen - the bartop counter makes for a great place for wine and dine!
Superhost
Accommodates: 2
14. Seaside cottage in Fair Harbor
Looking for a romantic retreat this summer vacation? Book a stay at Jenn and Daniel’s Airbnb, where you get to enjoy each other’s company in peace. Your private room is furnished with all the basic necessities, and you get access to all the other shared areas such as the outdoor tub and the outdoor patio. For those who can barely even start a fire, fret not, for the hosts will prepare your lunch and dinner for you. Feel free to even request for morning tea and it will be delivered to your room - all for no charge, only asking for hospitality in return!
Fire Island, New York, United StatesAccommodates: 6
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
also the outdoor shower roof deck bed and hot tub were awesomeCleanliness:
the room was comfortable and clean and the food was deliciousjennifer and daniel keep a beautiful and clean home and define what it means to be hostsHost:
amazing place hosted by wonderful peopledaniel & jennifer are extremely generous hostsgreat hosts great room awesome hot tub delicious foodi had a fabulous time jennifer and daniel are wonderful hoststhey have a great laid back attitude while still being very attentive to usRead more reviewsLocation:
this place is an ideal weekend getawaythe location of the house is perfect close to the ferry beach and bay (and supermarket)the food was incredible the company was fun and interesting and the location was so simple to findthis was a great place to stay for a few relaxing days on the island
15. Simple, comfortable beach house
Relax in a comfortable environment when it comes to this Airbnb vacation rental near Fire Island, an estate that allows you to keep more money in your wallet than you ever thought possible. It’s a dome house, easily identifiable from the street and featuring rare architecture inside of the property itself. You’ll be able to join five other privileged travelers in this rental, a location that offers you access to six individual beds across three bedrooms, plus a private bath. The estate is also temperature-controlled, so you can set an ideal atmosphere during your time in the region. You’re located in the private Corneille Estates, close to all of the local landmarks you’re looking to discover!
Ocean Beach, New York, United StatesTop guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
would have liked better kitchen amenities but worth it for the location beach supplies and deckewa's house was exactly as pictured and very comfortable for 2 families of 3 (3 kids and 3 adults)Cleanliness:
the place was cleanthere were soft clean towels for us to use on the beach and for bathingthe house is very original and feels spacious even it's not so bigeverything was clean and inside is so bright and sunny and ewa was great about instructions directions etcHost:
very helpful property managerewa was a great hostewa was a great and responsive host who answered all of our questions in a timely mannerewa was responsive and accommodating in our requestsewa was a great host providing us with lots of information and responding quickly to any questionsRead more reviewsLocation:
so cute and close to everythinggreat location - short walk to the beachthe dome is a unique place in a great location near downtown ocean beacheww was helpful and responsive great value in a great locationthe house was very fun and it's a quick walk to a gorgeous beach
Don't burn out before the end of your trip!
Travelling from place to place can get difficult - make sure to keep your batteries fully charged by finding a comfortable Airbnb vacation rental to spend your free time in. With this wide selection of family-friendly accommodations, you’ll be fully refreshed for a new day of adventuring ahead!
Frequently asked questions about Airbnb vacation rentals on Fire Island
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data
Create an account to