10 Best Airbnb Vacation Rentals In Buffalo, Wyoming - Updated 2023

Trina Joy Cassey
Trina Joy Cassey 

Buffalo is a charming city in Johnson County, Wyoming. It is nestled in the foothill of the majestic Big Horn Mountains, giving the city a breathtaking backdrop. Wyoming is known for its main street, which is dotted with historic buildings. Its old-country charm is attractive to tourists, and the pace of life is slower in this side of the country, compared to the big highly urbanized cities, makes it an ideal place to unwind and relax. Some of the most visited attractions in this city include Mountain Plains Heritage Park, Red Gulch Dinosaur Tracksite, and the fascinating Jim Gatchell Memorial Museum. Planning to explore the beautiful county of Johnson anytime soon? Here is a list of the best Airbnb vacation rentals in Buffalo, Wyoming. Browse below.

1. Refurbished 1894 historic hotel suite (from USD 119)

Excited for an upcoming holiday in Wyoming? Why not complete all your travel plans and book this refurbished historic hotel suite, located in downtown Wyoming. Its excellent location is perfect for tourists who plan to indulge in the city’s offerings, from shops to eateries to must-visit landmarks. This apartment can sleep up to four guests, and houses one bedroom and a private bathroom. More so, it is equipped with a kitchen, a dining space, and a living room with a TV. WiFi is also accessible in the house for added entertainment. In the garden, there’s a grill that you can use if you want to have a little barbecue party.

Converted Historic1894 Hotel, Western Coyote Suite
Buffalo, Wyoming, United States
111 reviews Superhost  Wifi Available
Entire serviced apartment 2 Beds 4 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 4

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
our rooms at the old capitol hotel were great wonderful old structure being lovingly restored
we especially enjoyed the comfortable bed spacious layout and washer/dryer
everything was great and we loved having a kitchen stocked with sugar salt and pepper towels etc
very comfortable space fun to be in old hotel
very clean and spacious
spotless and charming
it was clean clean clean
western charm in a clean comfortable place
very nice and clean apartment
she’s a wonderful host
cynthia was a generous host who responded promptly and gave us great recommendations for dinner
cynthia was super friendly easy to contact quick to respond and just a wonderful host
cynthia is a great host responding very swiftly to our emails
the host had very good and made it easy to stay
great location in historic downtown
great location and nice lodging located downtown and very spacious
a must stay location in an amazing town
great location in the downtown of adorable buffalo
great value and wonderful location
Read more reviews

2. Century-old haven with cosmopolitan vibe and superb city views (from USD 117)

This cozy loft is located on the main street in downtown Wyoming. It is conveniently located close to shops, eateries, and popular historic buildings in the area. This sweet little haven is a 100-year-old place that can accommodate up to 6 guests. It is built with expansive windows, where guests can see the views from inside. More so, it has everything you need, and more. It houses two beds, an air mattress, comfy couch seating, a complete kitchen, a dining area, and a clean bathroom with essentials.

The Court Haus on Main Street
Buffalo, Wyoming, United States
200 reviews Superhost  Wifi Available
Entire loft 3 Beds 6 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 6

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
comfortable private old world and new world charm combined
the kitchen was well-stocked the beds comfy and the views charming
also nice views of main st from the big windows in the living room area
there is a steep flight of stairs to climb but room is bright with windows that open
very comfortable murphy bed unlike most
sparkling clean place
it was clean and spacious
everything is clean and well appointed
everything was clean well stocked and beautiful
the condo was exceptionally clean with very nice extra touches ample towels soaps etc
tyler was an excellent host
tyler was a great host
tyler is a great host
tyler was a great host highly recommend
hosts were so thoughtful and accommodating
beautiful spot close to restaurants and downtown shopping
the location is awesome located downtown
beautiful apartment in a very cute location
it’s a great location
right in town close to restaurants and a great location to set out to explore the national forest
Read more reviews

3. Two-bedroom vintage apartment in a historic hotel (from USD 149)

Full of character, charming, and cozy are some words to define this lovely converted 1894 hotel apartment. It is delightfully situated on the main street in downtown Wyoming, which makes it ideal for tourists who like sightseeing and trying out local eateries. Once you enter the unit, you’ll see some modern renovations done to the place, but some of its stunning vintage furnishings are still in there. In terms of amenities, this Airbnb vacation rental features two comfortable bedrooms, a bathroom, a spacious kitchen with cookware and utensils, and a dining area. In the morning, you can have a picnic in the garden while enjoying the pleasant atmosphere.

Converted 1894 Historic Hotel, The Western Buffalo
Buffalo, Wyoming, United States
96 reviews Superhost  Wifi Available
Entire rental unit 4 Beds 6 Guests 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 6

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the beds were comfortable and the air conditioner was just what we needed after a hot day
the space was comfortable for our family
our stay was very comfortable good amenities great location and owner suggestions were very helpful
sofa couch not very comfortable but the bedrooms are and is very clean
very comfortable one night stay
everything was very clean and comfortable
rooms were clean and well organized
the place was really clean
smallish bathroom but very clean
it was quiet and sparkling clean
host is super nice
cynthia was an awesome host and everything was smooth
cynthia was pleasant and very accommodating
the host made it easy to check in late and responded quickly to inquiries
comfortable beds great value and very friendly helpful hosts
great location in town
great location in the center of a cute town
it’s a great location right in the middle of downtown buffalo
location was great to walk through town and the drive to museums was very easy
great place in a charming location
Read more reviews

4. Superb apartment suite with nice city views (from USD 149)

This interesting Airbnb vacation rental is nestled in a fascinating 1894 historic hotel. It has vintage furnishings with modern details, rustic accents, and a lovely old-town atmosphere that will surely make you feel right at home. It has one bedroom and one private bathroom, making it ideal for a couple on a holiday or a small group of friends. The kitchen has everything you need to prepare your meals for the day, and the dining area is located just in front of the living space. Also, this unit has a washer and dryer for your convenience. On top of these, the views from the windows are breathtaking.

Converted 1894 Historic Hotel, Antelope Suite
Buffalo, Wyoming, United States
79 reviews Superhost  Wifi Available
Entire serviced apartment 4 Beds 6 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 6

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the tall windows wood floors dramatic drapery super high ceilings gave the room old world charm
the place was great–plenty of space and very comfortable and right next door to many shops and restaurants
buffalo was quite and the space was comfortable
we had a comfortable two-night stay in the apartment
comfortable and good size space for a family with kids
clean and had an interesting history which gave it character
everything was super clean and we had plenty of room
the suite was clean and comfortable old-style hotel
the apartment was clean and gave us a real western feel
clean and bed very comfortable thanks cynthia see you next time
cynthia was a gracious host and a delight to work with
cynthia was a great host greeted us when we arrived and very friendly :)
easy to get to ans check in nice touches by the host
first off cynthia was very responsive to all my inquiries pre-trip of which there were many
host communicated well and accepted our reservation quickly loved the location and the suite
location was great- right downtown
easy walk to shopping and attractions
location is great for walking through the city
the location in downtown buffalo was perfect for walking to restaurants and the nearby bars
such a cute apartment it was an easy walk to shopping and restaurants
Read more reviews

5. Luxurious private ranch house (from USD 275)

If you are very much into privacy, comfort, and upscale amenities that will give you a bang for your buck, you might want to check out this private ranch house. Its vast surroundings provide stunning nature views and a serene environment that will make your holiday an unforgettable one. As for amenities, this tastefully furnished abode has four cozy bedrooms, two bathrooms, a bright and airy living room, a modern kitchen with state-of-the-art appliances, a huge dining space, and a laundry area. High-speed internet is accessible throughout the property, as well.

4 bedroom/2 bath Private Guest Ranch House
22 reviews Superhost  Wifi Available
Entire home 6 Beds 10 Guests 4 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 10

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
““loved the quiet location comfortable furniture and beds
the house is incredibly spacious (huge living room and bedrooms) and the furniture is high-quality and very comfortable
and the water is safe for showering and tooth brushing
the house is clean and tastefully decorated
it was clean and had so many complimentary bath soaps etc
the house is sparkling clean well stocked and spacious
her place is very clean and the house is in a beautiful location
kim was a great host
the host was incredible very helpful and accommodating
kim was highly responsive and her directions were spot on
kim is awesome - timely responses very attentive and friendly
the house is great and you can not ask for a better host than kim
the location was great
location is amazing but it is a little way from town
this beautiful quiet secluded farmhouse is located on a working ranch to the east of buffalo
the house has plenty of room and is a great place to stay
Read more reviews

6. Cosmopolitan home with upscale amenities (from USD 200)

Enjoy the comfort, convenience, and privacy of your own accommodation, contrary to the crowded hotels. This stunning Airbnb vacation rental is modern, and it has a home away from home ambiance that helps guests relax after a long day outside. It boasts visually refreshing white walls, rustic accents, and expensive furniture. The kitchen is a paradise for culinary enthusiasts as it is complete with state-of-the-art appliances, including granite countertops and quality dishes. It also has a nice coffee bar. There are three bedrooms that you can share with the rest of your company. The living space has a flat-screen TV and cloud-like couch seating. For campers, there’s a parking space outside that can fit small trailers.

Hollyhock House on Fort
Buffalo, Wyoming, United States
28 reviews Superhost  Wifi Available
Entire home 4 Beds 6 Guests 3 Bedrooms 1 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 6

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the beds were comfortable and the linens delightful
such a quaint and comfortable place
wonderful place to stay very clean and very responsive
nice place- very clean-if you need anything just ask jen and she’ll make sure it there
it was great to have parking so close to the door
really comfortable cottage right near the main street with restaurants and cafes
Read more reviews

7. Rustic mountain cabin (from USD 105)

Make the most of your Buffalo holiday and experience a countryside lifestyle when you book this lovely rustic mountain cabin - or cabins, if you are with a large group of friends. Each cabin can accommodate up to four guests. They have two queen-size beds, a kitchenette, a dinette, and a private bathroom with a bathtub. Bathroom essentials are provided, such as towels and toiletries. The city’s most-visited parks are a short drive away, including the Black Hills and Yellowstone.

Rustic cabins with modern amenities Double Queen
49 reviews Superhost  Wifi Available
Room in hotel 2 Beds 4 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 4

Top guest reviews
the place was clean and had everything i needed
great little cabin in a great location
this is a really charming place in a convenient location in buffalo
wonderful place close to downtown and very clean
Read more reviews

8. Fully furnished home minutes away from the historic buildings (from USD 150)

If you are looking for a spacious, budget-friendly, and comfortable accommodation that can fit a medium-size group of guests, this charming home might pique your interest. It is fully furnished and has a homey atmosphere that will help you relax. Also, its location provides you quick access to local attractions and must-try restaurants, and it is a short walk away from the historic buildings of Buffalo. Two bedrooms and a clean bathroom with basic essentials are housed in this abode. More so, it is equipped with a kitchen, a dining space, a comfy living room, and a driveway for your service vehicle.

Western Main Street Cottage, City approved
Buffalo, Wyoming, United States
52 reviews Superhost  Wifi Available
Entire home 4 Beds 7 Guests 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 7

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
enjoyed the outside table and chairs
clean quiet strong recommend
the house is very clean and neatly organized
cynthias place was very comfortable clean and homey atmosphere
it is clean bright and fresh without losing its old house charms
the house is very clean with oak floors and two bedrooms that will sleep 5
cynthia is the best host
she was very laid back and kind to us thank you cynthia
communication between the host and ourselves was great
***host comes in for light house keeping and brings pastries great place
cute little house in a very walkable location to town
great location and nice yard
location was good close to shops and really easy to get to
excellent location in buffalo close to the bighorn mountains huge city pool and downtown
location couldn’t have been better
Read more reviews

9. Quaint cottage with three bedrooms and a spacious backyard

This quaint cottage is a superb accommodation that will make you enjoy the old-town lifestyle during your holiday in Wyoming. Its rustic interiors and laid-back decorations complement well with its airy atmosphere. After a long day outdoors, relax in this beautiful cottage, and unwind in the living room while enjoying the warmth from the fireplace. Three bedrooms are housed in this Airbnb, which makes it ideal for a medium-size group or family. Also, the property has a bathroom with a bathtub, a complete kitchen and a wooden dining area. You’ll love basking in the warmth of the sun in the spacious backyard every morning.

Buffalo cottage
Buffalo, Wyoming, United States
30 reviews Superhost  Wifi Available
Entire cottage 3 Beds 4 Guests 3 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 4

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
mike's place is very comfortable and has an amazing view of the mountains
peaceful quiet spot with a great view of the mountains you can see from the front room
this is a very clean little house
this was a clean and comfortable place to stay
the cleanliness and comforts of home were fantastic
the house was very clean and had lovely quilts to enhance the bedding
it is an older home that has updates so expect some charm but it is super clean
mike is a great host and has great advice for places to visit in buffalo
excellent place for value and the host is excellent in response time
mike was a very responsive host and communicated during our stay to make sure we were happy
this home in buffalo was very comfortable and mike is very hospitable and helpful
great location and accommodating host
it is also within walking distance of the free public swimming pool
good location but very rusticsmells like old campfire inside
great place to stay in
it is just a few blocks from the charming main street
Read more reviews

10. Affordable accommodation in Mansion House Motel

Situated in downtown Buffalo, this fantastic family-run motel is cozy and comfortable. Go on a sightseeing tour, indulge in a shopping spree or a gastronomic escapade, and then come home to a comfy nest that will shelter you. This motel features four rooms and a clean private bathroom. The decorations and amenities are mostly brand new, and guests can pick which of the four uniquely designed rooms catch their interest. Also, the rooms have a dining area and a TV. All of these rooms have access to a private patio, where guests can relax and enjoy the views.

Mansion House Motel - Room w/Two Queen Beds
Buffalo, Wyoming, United States
74 reviews Superhost  Wifi Available
Room in hotel 2 Beds 4 Guests 0 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 4

Top guest reviews
very clean and comfortable quiet room
adorable clean little retro motel
super easy check in clean space great value
clean and comfortable motel checking in was a breeze with the access code
we loved this place lara was a great communicator and the rooms were charming and clean
hosts were communicative and helpful highly recommend
this location is super close to the heart of buffalo so it's really walkable
mansion house inn was a great place to stay in buffalo while we needed to work remotely
Read more reviews

Make your Buffalo vacation an unforgettable one

Buffalo is a breathtaking city in Wyoming, with stunning views of the majestic Big Horn Mountains as its backdrop. It has an old country charm that tourists are fond of. The city is known for its downtown, where historic buildings are everywhere, together with superb local shops and excellent restaurants. If you are planning to visit Buffalo anytime soon, use this list of the best Airbnb vacation rentals available in the city as your guide in choosing the most ideal accommodation for you and your company.

Disclosure: Trip101 selects the listings in our articles independently. Some of the listings in this article contain affiliate links.

Get Trip101 in your inbox

Unsubscribe in one click. See our privacy policy for more information on how we use your data

Trina is a preschool teacher, a working mom of a four-year-old girl, and a happy wife of an analyst programmer who loves to sing, cook, write and travel. She believes that travel is one of the best...Read more

 Want to contribute as a Local Expert?
Explore Buffalo
Good things are meant to be shared!