7 Best Airbnb Vacation Rentals Near Keuka Lake, New York, USA - Updated 2022

airbnb keuka lake

Keuka Lake is one of the 11 lakes in New York, jointly referred to as the Finger Lakes. It is a glacial lake with pristine waters covering 47.5 square kilometers (18.1 square miles). Fishing for trout, bass, and yellow perch makes this lake a favorite amongst fishermen, and fishing guides are available to show you great fishing spots. Keuka Lake is also popular for swimming amongst other watersport activities. Aside from the lake, the area has numerous vineyards offering hiking trails and wine tastings. Discover the charms of Keuka Lake while staying in one of the various accommodation options along its shores. Read on to know more about the best Airbnb vacation rentals near Keuka Lake, New York.

1. Idyllic waterfront log cabin (from USD 1266)

Take a break from the hustles and bustles of everyday life and unwind in this dreamy log cabin featuring a cathedral ceiling and an A-frame window opening up to panoramic views of the lake and woods. With 5 bedrooms and 3 baths, it comfortably sleeps 15. When at the house, you can relax on the wrap-around porch as you take in the beautiful scenery and listen to the burbling waterfalls. Keuka Lake is just a short walk down the driveway where you can enjoy swimming, kayaking, or fishing from the large dock. Be immersed in the serenity that this home, surrounded by nature at its finest, offers.

Wooded Lakeview Cabin with Spacious Lakefront
Penn Yan, New York, United States
129 reviews Superhost  Wifi Available
Entire cabin 7 Beds 15 Guests 5 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 15

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
this is a very beautiful and comfortable house with great views to the lake and trees
excellent cabin - spacious cozy and wonderful views
the house was clean and had everything we needed for our stay
absolutely lovely in every way on point communication couldn’t have been more inviting or clean
the host was very responsive whenever we had questions
tony is a great host
the hosts were very quick to respond and made sure our entire stay was enjoyable
our hosts were extremely prompt and attentive to our questions from the very beginning which was most appreciated
tony was prompt to reply to our emails and very helpful with any questions we had
it is very close to great wineries
the house is beautiful and is in a great location for visiting the finger lakes region
loved the cabin and location
house is in great location and porch is wonderful
the house is beautiful and a great location
Read more reviews

2. Rustic lakefront rental for eight (from USD 399)

Relax and unwind in this rustic home that opens up to gorgeous views of Keuka Lake. It comes equipped with four bedrooms, two-and-a-half baths, a living room with a flat-screen television, free Wi-Fi, a laptop-friendly workspace, and a fully equipped kitchen. The dock and deck have ample seating space for you to enjoy the beautiful views of the lake. Your furry friend is more than welcome at no additional cost, and the surrounding wooded area is perfect for walking your dog. Enjoy the convenience of free parking on the premises.

Romantic cottage on beautiful Keuka Lake w/views
4 reviews  Wifi Available
Entire cabin 6 Beds 8 Guests 4 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 8

Top guest reviews
perfect location on the water and near wonderful attractions the finger lakes has to offer
it was not what we expected but we made the best of the location and dock
Read more reviews

3. Gorgeous newly renovated waterfront cabin (from USD 500)

Have a great time staying in this three-bedroom cabin that comfortably accommodates six guests. It features a living room where you can relax as you watch television or admire the lake’s stunning views. The newly renovated state-of-the-art kitchen has everything you need to whip up a hearty meal. You have the option of indoor dining on the kitchen table that seats six or outdoor dining on the deck. The deck also has a cozy lounge area and gas grill. In the evening, gather around the fire pit and stargaze as you roast marshmallows. Steps down the deck lead to the lake.

Gorgeous Newly Renovated Waterfront Cabin
32 reviews Superhost  Wifi Available
Entire cabin 4 Beds 6 Guests 3 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 6

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
great views of lake from huge deck kitchen and living room
amenities were spot on beds were super comfortable
everything in this space from coffee mug to bedding to decor was beautiful to look at
the interior remodel belongs on hgtv we were extremely comfortable
the room with the twin beds was perfect for our girls
the place is beautiful and clean
amazing cottage clean spacious beautiful
the house was sparkling clean and well equipped with everything we needed
beautiful spot felt very clean and maintained thank you
clean beautifully decorated great location with ease to trails and restaurants
loretta was very kind
lynda and loretta were fabulous hosts who went out of their way to make the stay memorable
beautiful house and wonderful lakeside location hosts were very thoughtful and left a welcome basket along with local tips
lynda’s place is the perfect location
very relaxing place to spend vacation
beautiful place right on the water our family including our lab loved our time here
great place for a family of 4-6
Read more reviews

4. Quaint and rustic space for two (from USD 99)

When looking for a place that will take you back to simpler times, this cabin in the woods is just what you need. The wood-built interior, combined with simplicity, is perfect for unwinding. The surrounding trees give you all the privacy you may need. Amenities include two single beds, an indoor fireplace to warm up those cold nights, a dining table that seats four, and a half bath. Hunters will especially love hunting in the woods. You can spend your day hiking the numerous nearby trails as you appreciate nature, and at the end of the day, retire to your private getaway.

Rustic Ridge
Penn Yan, New York, United States
109 reviews
Entire cabin 3 Beds 4 Guests 0 Bedrooms 0 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 4

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
heads up - portable chargers are your friend
the cabin itself is beautiful and has comfortable beds
it was quite and comfortable and cozy with wood burning stove
absolutely beautiful and clean cabin
super nice area in the woods very clean
this was a great place to stay it was clean simple and very peaceful
the cabin itself was spacious & clean
seth was an incredible and accommodating host making sure everything was perfect
very responsive and reliable host
seth was a great host and was very accommodating with everything we asked of him
awesome stay beautiful place and the host was very hands-off but gracious and ready to respond
even means to make coffee seth was super responsive and accommodating
really pleased to find this place and will definitely be returning
great spot to get away from the noise and enjoy the quiet
such a great place spend at least a few days to really settle in
great cozy place to stay
the property is beautiful with trails to walk and plenty to see
Read more reviews

5. Cozy cabin for a peaceful getaway (from USD 150)

Escape to this cozy cabin nestled in a red pine forest that offers its guests a quiet spot to rejuvenate. With one bedroom with a queen bed and a loft with two double beds, it comfortably sleeps six. From the moment you step in through the main door, you will be left in awe by the high ceiling and beautiful stone fireplace in the living area. Outdoors is a hammock, firepit, and picnic table. Stay here and explore the nearby hiking and cross-country skiing trails, wineries, Keuka Lake State Park, and restaurants.

Cabaña privada aislada escondida en Red Pines junto al lago Keuka
165 reviews  Wifi Available
cabin 6 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 6
Minimum Nights: 2
Refund Policy : 100% refund if you cancel at least 30 days before check-in.

Top guest reviews
great experience clean private and enjoyable
cozy and immaculately clean
property was clean
host was very welcoming
the cabin is beautiful and the owner was very quick to reply with any questions i had
pet friendly although we did not bring our dogs they were welcome
the owner was great about communicating but everything was organized so it wasn't really necessary
wonderful location in the middle of the lake
such a wonderful location for a week away from relativity
we loved out stay at grouse cabin it was the perfect location in the woods near vineyards
15 minutes from a decent sized town beautiful property with no close neighbors
beautiful secluded cabin but close to a lot of places to go see
Read more reviews

6. Picturesque log cabin overlooking Keuka Lake (from USD 218)

Make yourself at home in this cabin perched above a hill, offering stunning views of Keuka Lake. Admire the beautiful wood-built interior, cathedral ceiling, and many windows with spectacular views that give its interior a warm and cozy vibe. Put your culinary skills to practice in the well-equipped kitchen with granite countertops and a kitchen bar. This cabin also features a living area, two bedrooms, one bathroom, table games in the basement, a large deck with plenty of seats, and a firepit perfect for stargazing. The fenced-in area in the yard gives your pet space to run around.

Una hermosa, totalmente amueblado cabaña de madera con vistas a lago Keuka
239 reviews  Wifi Available
cabin 8 Guests 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 8
Minimum Nights: 2
Refund Policy : 100% refund if you cancel at least 30 days before check-in.

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
lovely new outdoor dining table and the grill worked perfectly
game room down stairs is a nice touch
it was clean and comfortable
extremely clean and super easy to check in
the property is so clean and had everything we needed
the interior is also very beautiful clean and serene
the sunrises were amazing the property was so very clean with such tasteful decor
owners were very easy to communicate with and quick with responses
communicating with the owners is very easy
"a beautiful place" is exactly what we got everything about our stay here was pretty close to perfect
if you are looking for peace and relaxation then you have found the right place
Read more reviews

7. Secluded cabin with a beautiful swimming pond

Located on 10 acres (4 hectares) of well-manicured grounds is this gorgeous two-bedroom, single-bath cabin that’s ideal for a small family. Guests can spend time watching television in the living room with a warm glow emanating from the indoor fireplace. Kids will love the variety of books and toys available. The well-appointed kitchen has everything you need to prepare your meals. You can sit in the gazebo as you read a book or roast S’mores on the firepit while appreciating the beauty of nature, or enjoy a refreshing dip in the beautiful swimming pond. This home offers easy access to wineries, hiking trails, and Keuka Lake State Park.

Cabin on the Bluff
Keuka Park, New York, United States
81 reviews
Entire cabin 5 Beds 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

A slice of heaven by the lake

Combine staying in a cozy home near Keuka Lake with numerous hiking trails and wineries nearby, and you have the perfect spot for a relaxing getaway. Have a pleasant time staying in one of these Airbnb vacation rentals near Keuka Lake, New York.

Disclosure: Trip101 selects the listings in our articles independently. Some of the listings in this article contain affiliate links.

Get Trip101 in your inbox

Unsubscribe in one click. See our privacy policy for more information on how we use your data

Herine is from Nairobi, the capital city of Kenya. As a travel enthusiast, she always takes interest in learning about and visiting new places. She has traveled to many places within the country,...Read more

 Want to contribute as a Local Expert?
Explore Keuka Lake State Park
Good things are meant to be shared!