Key Colony Beach is home to scores of gorgeous beaches, family-friendly points of interest, and cozy rentals with scenic views. Brave the waters and enjoy some adventurous water sports here, such as snorkeling, boat riding, and kayaking. If you want to commune with the locals, you can visit Sunset Park and sing-along to some vibrant live music by the shores. For a relaxing and private swim along the coast, The Cabana Club is a top-notch luxury destination. Furthermore, this quiet municipality is brimming with aquariums and community parks that will elate kids and kids at heart. When visiting this beautiful island, we’ve put up a carefully selected list of accommodations to your liking. Most of these provide complimentary membership access to The Cabana Club. Read on for the top Airbnb vacation rentals in Key Colony Beach, Florida.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on April 12, 2024.
1. Stylish property with a screened porch (from USD 275)
In this coastal charmer, you will find beauty and comfort everywhere. The screened porch is an ideal hangout spot for catching up with friends and sunbathing. Spend quality time with your family while grilling and eating barbecue on the outdoor patio with fantastic canal views.
One of the impressive amenities of this stylish property is its fast 119 Mbps WiFi that allows you to quickly update your socials or video call your loved ones. After a long day, reward yourself with a warm and bubbly bath in the private bathroom tub.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
it had a wonderful king bed lovely patio and screened in porchwe enjoyed the tv and tv appsthe wifi was also excellent as i run 2 businesses while i'm on the road working virtuallytwo good size bedrooms each with its own bathroomawesome very clean cozy and has all the amenities you would needCleanliness:
the house was very clean upon check-in and was very easy to keep cleanfabulous place to stay super clean & comfortablehouse was super clean and in excellent conditionthe house was perfect it was clean well appointedyohan’s place is beautiful quiet and cleanHost:
the hosts were responsive and accommodating to our requeststhe hosts were great and answered questions promptlythis place was great people weren’t kidding when they said the hosts were very responsivegreat place for vacation the hosts answer all questions so quickly and are very helpfulthe owner takes great care to ensure the limited landscaping is immaculateRead more reviewsLocation:
this is a really cute placeit’s a great location toogreat location the house was comfortable safe and had a great locationloved the location super peaceful on the canalperfect location for getting anywhere in the keys
Superhost
2. Ocean-inspired condominium with a pool (from USD 498)
Everything about this rental promises a worthwhile stay. This property is tastefully decorated with ocean-inspired details, from wall artworks to pillowcases. Suitable for six, this condominium offers two bedrooms fitted with crisp cotton sheets providing a good night’s sleep.
With a well-stocked kitchen, you can easily prepare your daily meals while your kids wait on the dining sofa. If you want to watch the orange sunsets, Sunset Park is just a few steps away. The property also provides access to a heated pool, a private beach, and a backyard where you can have barbecue cookouts.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
ac worked great & the memory foam beds were comfywe enjoyed our stay but wished for a more comfortable mattressCleanliness:
very clean and newer appointmentsit was very cleankim's place was very clean and roomythe place was great and clean love iteverything was great super clean modern & comfortableHost:
one of the best host experience everkim was a wonderful hostess and very accommodatingwe had everything we needed there and more kim was incredibly responsive will all the questions we hadwhat a gem rating details: kim (host) was very helpfulkim was very responsive replying almost immediately to any inquiriesRead more reviewsLocation:
this condo was exactly as described great locationabsolutely beautiful place perfect location for a relaxing tripnice central location integrationists in a super safe neighborhood/keygreat quiet location for young familiesit's a great location for exploring other things in the area
3. A Beach Bungalow (from USD 277)
A Beach Bungalow is characterized by a unique A-frame architecture, making the place extra adorable. The property exudes a bright and airy ambiance with white-colored walls and furniture. The master bedroom with an ensuite bathroom and the charming loft can sleep up to four guests.
Outside, there is a seating area perched on the dock where you can relieve your stress by catching some fish. The complimentary access to the beach club is an excellent add-on worth noting.
Top guest reviews
Cleanliness:
it was very clean and very well stockedclean trendy convenient and well appointedwe loved it extremely cleanthe house is very clean and it’s beautifully and tastefully decoratedtheir place is nicely cleaned and in a beau full area with tons to doHost:
jackie & joel are wonderful hostsjackie & joel we’re great hostsowners were very responsive with any questions we hadjoel and jackie were marvelous hoststhe hosts were awesome at answering our local questions as wellRead more reviewsLocation:
perfect location for everythingthe location is perfectthe location is perfectbeautiful house in an amazing locationperfect place & perfect location
4. Waterfront home with a large hammock (from USD 243)
This waterfront home sleeps four guests. It features a roofed porch where you can have casual al fresco dining. Afterward, lay on a large hammock for your siesta. You can eat your snacks and breakfast in style at the kitchen granite countertop to start your day.
Moreover, there is a pretty seawall dockage nearby if you want to witness the sunset atop the blue waters. You can also enjoy some water activities on the canal, such as fishing, kayaking, and paddling.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
there’s a huge grill plenty of dock space a super cozy hammock and just beautiful viewsthe living room and kitchen were very user friendly and spacious with beautiful views of the canalwould nice to have an indoor table but did locate a card table that worked fineCleanliness:
ther house wad clean and had a nice welcome baskethouse is very clean and stocked with all the basicsthe house was spacious and very cleanthe house looks and even smells clean the second you walked in the doorthe home was very clean and had everything we needed during our stayHost:
jorge was the perfect hostjorge is an amazing hostjorge was responsive and helpful throughout our tripjorge is super friendly and very responsivealways very responsive to questionsRead more reviewsLocation:
great location in a friendly neighborhoodhouse is close to many great restaurantsconsidering the set up and location i think the value is phenomenal for what you getwe had a great time at jorge's place the neighborhood was friendly with a grocery store and beach nearby
5. La Casa Azul (from USD 325)
La Casa Azul is embraced by a mix of white and pastel-colored walls, creating a warm and homey tone inside. This property can comfortably accommodate four. While having your meals or lounging on the sofa, you can binge-watch your favorite movies on the cable flat-screen TV.
With the gorgeous backyard pool and sun loungers, you can bask under the sun while looking over the calming canal views. Likewise, you can drink your first coffee cup on the beautifully landscaped lawn.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
i love having my morning coffee besides the poolyou have full water views from the living/kitchen area and a beautiful pool to top it offthe updated interior boat slip pool and kitchen truly make this airbnb one of a kindit was just awesome make the pool even better and bring your own floaties book this spotthe pool was perfect great location as well definitely rebooking when we returnCleanliness:
great place clean and comfyit was super clean and very cozybeautifully remodeled and very cleanother than that it just had to be clean cool and comfortablevery nice clean place would definitely recommend to anyoneRead more reviewsLocation:
really enjoyed our stay cute house nice pool and great location would stay againgreat location and amenitieswe didn’t have to go saturday to saturday like most places we got a full 10 daysyou couldn’t ask for a better location or hostall around an excellent place to stay
6. Rustic accommodation with a Tiki hut access (from USD 169)
This rustic accommodation highlights wood carvings and bamboo furniture, giving an additional charm to the place. Ideal for a small group, this property can fit four guests. For homebodies, you can stay indoors in the comforts of central air conditioning.
To maximize your stay, dine out under the shades of a tiki hut overlooking the stunning canal. If you’re lucky enough, you may even get a chance to see boats passing through. A Cabana Club membership is among the outstanding inclusions you can get with this rental.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
is the tiki hut on the water is fantastic with very comfortable furniturewould be nice to have a tv in the second bedroomCleanliness:
quiet nice and cleanvery clean in a nice quiet neighborhoodthe unit is clean and layed out very wellthe house is beautiful and cleanthe house was sparkling clean and much more spacious than anticipatedHost:
our host was available and kindhosts were super responsive hospitable and accommodatingwe got the to meet the owner she is an absolute pleasurehad a great time owner responds quicklythe owners are super organized and everything is detailed in their welcome binderRead more reviewsLocation:
great central location in a great communitywe loved the central location in the keysabsolutely great location close to everything that you would want to do in marathongorgeous neighborhood to take morning walksthe access to the private club is fantastic the location in marathon is amazing
7. Tropical-inspired condo with ocean views (from USD 450)
This studio condo takes pride in its delightful tropical interior and colorful furnishings. You can relax on the private balcony while marveling at the crystal-clear waters. Take advantage of the natural light passing through the expansive windows and finish a book on your bed or the sofa.
If you want to spend the day out in the waters, the beach is right at your doorstep. For your convenience, beach towels and bed linens are at your disposal. Four guests can occupy this cheerful unit.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
it was a great room with a beautiful viewgorgeous views from the room wonderful locationthe room and location were fantastic kim’s communication and helpfulness was awesome and appreciatedCleanliness:
the space was clean and amazing as advertisedamazing condo the unit was very clean as describedthe condo was very clean and exactly as describedgreat stay beach is beautiful clean and well appointedthe beds were comfortable and the condo was very cleanHost:
kim was very responsive and a wonderful hostkim was a great host who provided a ton of information about the local areakim was super communicative with us during our arrival and departurekim was very helpful and responsive and was a great host i highly recommend this placekim was great host and very responsive the local restaurants that were recommended were also deliciousRead more reviewsLocation:
great location right by beachgreat location right on the waterbeautiful location and very quiet stayi am glad we chose this location in the keys it was a perfect relaxing vacationquiet complex which we loved
8. Spacious villa for five (from USD 179)
This spacious open-concept villa is an ideal home away from home for five guests and pets. Whether you opt to dine inside or outside the house, the property provides you with everything you need for your home-cooked meal preparation.
If you want to try Florida’s local cuisine, multiple restaurants are within the immediate vicinity. Stroll around the area and allow your skin to be kissed by the sea breeze. Additionally, you get complimentary access to Cabana Club here.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
beds are comfortable and the house accommodated 5 adults with everything we neededCleanliness:
place was very clean and had every cooking/kitchen utensils we neededRead more reviewsLocation:
great location fun and safe neighborhoodvery tranquile and location is great for family and fishingit’s in an excellent location near so many restaurants and activitiesfantastic location quiet area cabana club was an excellent perk
9. Cozy rental with a beautifully landscaped backyard
This cozy rental has a beautifully landscaped backyard for a secluded nature retreat. On lazy mornings, you can breathe in the fresh air on the outdoor seating area with a provided awning to avoid overexposure to the sun’s heat. If your kids tag along, they can safely play in the fully fenced backyard.
With two bedrooms, this property can host up to six guests. Upon booking, you are entitled to a Cabana Club membership with unlimited access to a private heated pool and spa services.
Key Colony Beach, Florida, United StatesAccommodates: 6
Top guest reviews
Cleanliness:
very clean and cozythe place was very clean and nicely appointedthe house is nice and cleangreat unit well stocked in cooking utensils and very cleaneverything thing you would need to cook and clean was there tooHost:
we were so impressed with this sweet home and gracious hostkatia is a wonderful host she was quick to respond to any issue or questioncheck in was seamless and excellent communication with hostwe loved the proximity to the beach and loved how kid friendly the home wasRead more reviewsLocation:
cute little place great locationloved this location as wellwe loved the location in marathonthe neighborhood is amazing with a park right across the streetlocation is superb house is as advertised
10. Why Knot House
Why Knot House is ideally situated near many top attractions. You can go for a family picnic at Sunset Beach and drink some cold cocktails at Havana Jack’s. Make the most out of your stay and enjoy the Cabana Club access this rental provides.
For your accommodation, you get to have great outdoor spaces for relaxation and sightseeing. A walk-on dock is also available to easily hop on your boats. Share the fun with four more travel companions and your pets!
Key Colony Beach, Florida, United StatesAccommodates: 5
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the beds were extremely comfortableCleanliness:
clean nice on the canalbeach club was nice and cleanthe house was beautiful and so cleanthe beach was small but clean with turquoise waterskelly's place checks all the boxes; location coziness cleanliness pet friendly etcHost:
kelly was an amazing hostshe was a great hostlaundry was extremely helpful for all of our beach daysvery clean and host is very responsive to make sure all needs are metRead more reviewsLocation:
the location is wonderfullocation of this property was perfect for usbeautiful home and a great locationwonderful get away spot in a prime location gotta go to the farmers market on tuesdaysthe house was in a great location right on the water
Capture moments through photographs
Known as the “Gem of the Florida Keys,” this unspoiled paradise features breathtaking natural scenery to make your holiday exceptionally rewarding. Catch the romantic sunsets and don’t forget to capture the moments through photographs. Choose an accommodation that suits your needs best from the top Airbnb vacation rentals in Key Colony Beach, Florida.
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data
Create an account to