Shipshewana is the perfect escape for those who want to experience the quiet charm of an Indiana town and discover the simplicity of Amish culture. Your first stop must be Shipshewana Auction and Flea Market, a seasonal market selling everything, from crafts to food. To experience the local Amish culture, you can book a meal and an immersive tour of the Hoosier Banquets or other locations around the Amish country. Another interesting attraction is Heritage Ridge Creamery, which displays the cheese-making process and allows visitors to taste delectable varieties of cheese and other Amish specialty foods.
The best way to experience Shipshewana’s unique culture is by staying at a local vacation rental. Read on to find a list of the top Airbnb vacation rentals in Shipshewana, Indiana!
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on October 29, 2025.
1. Sophisticated home with a private back garden (from USD 483)
This beautiful home is centrally located and fitted with exquisite furnishings and amenities. With central air-conditioning and heating, you will be comfortable no matter the season. The television equipped with streaming services will keep you entertained, while the WiFi and dedicated workspace will help you stay productive. The home also features a private back garden with furniture and a fire pit allowing you to enjoy indoor-outdoor living with your whole group.
Shipshewana, Indiana, United States
501 meters (0.4 ft) from Shipshewana Flea Market (May-Sept)Superhost
Accommodates: 12
Top guest reviews
Host:
joanna was helpful and immediately responsive to our questionsLocation:
amazing locations literally right in the middle of everythingclose to the shopping and just a special placeshops and restaurants are close by within easy walking distancegreat location for what we need it for close to food and the mec centerwe absolutely loved the locationCleanliness:
everything was clean and as describedvery clean and well keptfantastic lovely clean and comfortablei would recommend very clean and beds are comfortablebeds were comfortable and all linens were cleanRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
the inside of the house looks just like the pictures and the beds were so comfya bathroom down there would be fantastic
2. Davis Street in Shipshewana (from USD 257)
This comfortable home is conveniently located close to Shipshewana’s Auction and Flea Market, shops, and restaurants. You will have access to a television and WiFi for indoor entertainment, as well as a garden where you can relax. Start your day off right by enjoying the breakfast provided at this accommodation and use the fully equipped kitchen to cook the rest of your meals. Biking enthusiasts would love to follow the trail nearby.
Shipshewana, Indiana, United States
209 meters (0.2 ft) from Shipshewana Flea Market (May-Sept)Accommodates: 4
Top guest reviews
Host:
michelle is a great hostthis house and host is by far the best i have ever experiencedgreat host that looks out for your needs and communicates very wellgreat host and great locationamazing house and host can’t wait to come back again next yearLocation:
perfect location if you are going downtown or to the market walking distance to bothgreat location to walk to blue gate and the downtown shopscouldn't be any close to area attractionsit is a very close and easy walk otherwisemichele's place is a quaint house in a great locationRead more reviewsCleanliness:
always clean and so handyeverything was very cleanit's clean and cozythis place was clean and comfortablequiet and clean neighborhood
3. The Oasis (from USD 372)
This fully furnished house features a spacious living room, a large deck, and a backyard where you can enjoy quality time with your co-travelers. The home provides all bedroom and laundry essentials, as well as free parking for guests for a seamless stay. The kitchen possesses everything a home chef desires, along with lots of storage space. A barbecue grill is also provided for cookouts. For the entertainment of all guests, books for both adults and kids are available here.
Shipshewana, Indiana, United States
361 meters (0.3 ft) from Shipshewana Flea Market (May-Sept)Accommodates: 8
Top guest reviews
Host:
the host was wonderful to work with and efficient in communicationswe loved our stay darlene is a great host and lovely homegood communication with the ownerthis property is perfect and darlene is a wonderful hostLocation:
the location is perfectthe location of the house is perfect for local sight seeingwe loved the location the check-in and the accommodationseasy distance from shops in shipshewanaeasy walk to town and to the auction/flea marketCleanliness:
everything very cleanit was a clean and well kept househouse was very cleangreat place to stay clean and comfortablethis extremely clean house was very comfortably furnishedRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
the furniture was extremely comfortable especially the bedsthere was tons of beds and space that was really helpfulchildren loved the bunk beds and toy train setthere were nice touches like small tables in the bedrooms to put our things onbeds were very comfortable ample space for a lot of people
4. Beautiful cottage with Wi-Fi (from USD 480)
This centrally located apartment provides easy access to Shipshewa’s downtown area, lovely paved walking and biking paths, and the local flea market. You can cook delicious meals in the well-equipped kitchen and watch your favorite movies on the TV. The home has central air-conditioning and heating to ensure comfort in any weather. Moreover, there’s reliable WiFi to keep you well-connected to the outside world. For your laundry needs, there is a laundromat nearby.
Shipshewana, Indiana, United States
765 meters (0.5 ft) from Shipshewana Flea Market (May-Sept)Accommodates: 8
Top guest reviews
Location:
the location was ideal -- two blocks from the main shopping area of townthe location was superb within walking distance to blue gate restaurant and the mallwhat a lovely place and the location is fantastici would definitely stay at this location againperfect location and size for our getawayCleanliness:
clean comfortable spaciousthe rooms were spotlessly clean and invitingthe whole house was very clean when we arrivedthe house was spotless and so comfortablewas very clean quiet and convenient to townRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
the wifi was useful and the tv was easy to usevery relaxing weekend cozy home with plenty of room for our family to play cards games watch movies etcjessica left a basket of travel fliers for local attractions in the living roomfresh flowers from the garden wonderful white towels a cozy living room all made our trip enjoyablegreat family home with large rooms and plenty of space and comfort
5. Charming dairy farm home with free parking (from USD 131)
Located on a working dairy farm, this guesthouse has authentic farmhouse decor and a fully working kitchen featuring modern appliances. While staying here, you can go on tours of the dairy farm or explore the surrounding Amish neighborhoods. Menno-Hof is also nearby if you wish to learn more about the Amish culture. The parking spot has space for up to four vehicles, so feel free to bring your cars along.
Moreover, guests will have access to a gym to stay fit during their stay.
Shipshewana, Indiana, United States
865 meters (0.6 ft) from Shipshewana Flea Market (May-Sept)Accommodates: 7
Top guest reviews
Host:
thank you to our gracious hoststhe hosts were friendly and kindhosts are wonderful and available for questions and assistancethe host and hostess were amazing peoplethe hosts are very hospitable and welcomingLocation:
we loved how close it was to townwe loved the farm tour and being so close to all the animalsthere isnt a tv but the location is very quiet and relaxingit’s quiet cute and on a dairy farmit’s really a great place to get away and experience the country lifeCleanliness:
clean relaxing and beautiful farm getawaywell kept clean quiet & comfortablethe house is clean and nicely decorated with antiquesvery nice clean and child friendlythis ome is well decorated and very cleanRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
the beds are comfortable and the provided coffee and snacks were appreciated
6. Welcoming home with a firepit and grill (from USD 301)
Escape to this bright and lovely home close to downtown Shipshewana for a comfortable stay. This property comes with an open-plan kitchen, living, and dining area flooded with natural light. The contemporary kitchen appliances and equipment will help you whip up tasty meals. Guests will enjoy access to two bicycles, which can be used to go around the neighborhood. There is a sizeable patio, too, with a grill and a fire pit perfect for fun evenings under the stars.
Shipshewana, Indiana, United States
2.04 km (1.3 mi) from Shipshewana Flea Market (May-Sept)Accommodates: 4
Top guest reviews
Location:
very close to area attractions and good places to eatreally was the perfect place to stay beautifully decorated comfortable and perfect locationa beautiful home and great location to the shipshewana areai would highly recommend bennie's place to all travelersfantastic place will absolutely stay there again when in the areaCleanliness:
beautifully decorated clean and cozy we loved our staybeautiful home immaculately clean and very nicely decorated well stocked kitchen with everything we might needwe thoroughly enjoyed our stay here everything was very clean and such a cozy houseRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
comfortable bed and bathrooms
7. Davis House Inn (from USD 151)
Experience true relaxation as you unplug from the digital world at this rental, which comes without WiFi or a TV. You can spend your time lounging on the shared patio and in the garden or taking walks around the local surroundings. Restaurants are also nearby if you wish to try some local delicacies. Though this accommodation does not have a kitchen, you will enjoy access to a microwave, coffee maker, and mini-fridge for your basic needs.
Shipshewana, Indiana, United States
533 meters (0.4 ft) from Shipshewana Flea Market (May-Sept)Accommodates: 6
Top guest reviews
Location:
the location was super cool in the middle of townRead more reviewsCleanliness:
the space is clean and comfortable
8. Songbird Haven 2 at Miriam's Bed n Breakfast (from USD 125)
This rental is cozy a room in a charming bed and breakfast accommodation located close to shops and restaurants. There’s even a bike trail nearby for active guests to explore. You will have access to a shared bathroom with a hot water supply. To unwind, head to the front porch or the backyard with a fire pit.
Breakfast will be provided to you by the host, and for your other meals, you can make use of the well-equipped kitchen available.
Shipshewana, Indiana, United States
1.89 km (1.2 mi) from Shipshewana Flea Market (May-Sept)Accommodates: 3
Top guest reviews
Host:
great host comfortable bed nice and clean and a good breakfast definitely recommend staying at miriam’s placeRead more reviewsLocation:
miriam's place was perfect for our overnight stay
Slow down in Shipshewana
Pleasantly different from conventional tourist destinations, Shipshewana is a peaceful town where you can spend some quiet time with yourself or loved ones. Choose a rental from the list above and enjoy a refreshing stay at this lovely location, while learning about the Amish way of living!
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data