Top 10 Airbnb Vacation Rentals In Suffolk County, New York - Updated 2024

Andrea Mae
Andrea Mae 
Updated
| 4 min read

Nestled in the easternmost portion of Long Island, Suffolk County is surrounded by vast waters such as the Atlantic Ocean, Long Island Sound, and large bays. If you are looking to enjoy a summer getaway, consider going to Suffolk County. It has many enjoyable things to offer such as museums, local parks, art galleries, mansion tours, and outdoor activities on the beach. The place also has plenty of historic buildings, ethnic eateries, and quaint downtowns. There are a variety of ways to explore the county. No matter who you are with, there can always be fun things to experience here. Check out the top Airbnb vacation rentals in Suffolk County, New York, where you can have a relaxing stay after a long day of exploration.

We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on February 07, 2024.

1. Gorgeous treehouse with an outdoor deck

This amazing upstairs loft is nestled in Brookhaven, which can accommodate four guests. The house is above a barn, so you can bask in the gorgeous view of the fields and woodlands on its spacious outdoor deck. You can even get a glimpse of beautiful animals such as deer and wild turkeys from time to time. Despite being close to nature, you can stay connected with high-speed internet. It is also near must-visit destinations in the county such as Bellport Village, Smith Point County Park, and Carmans River.

Stayed at this property?
Brookhaven, New York, United States
58 reviews   Wifi Available
Entire guesthouse 2 Beds 4 Guests 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 4

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the bed was comfortable and the deck was extra special
the deck is gorgeous and large with an awesome grill and room for friends or family
everything in the house like ac stove bathroom
the kitchen has everything we need for cooking and the deck and the huge backyard
very relaxing has all the comforts of home and a well stocked kitchen
Cleanliness:
it was spotless and very welcoming
the whole house is nice and clean
it's very clean and fully equipped
immaculately clean and user friendly full-size kitchen with well stocked dinnerware
the flat is very clean and had lots of light
Host:
the host is also very helpful
bret was a great host
bret is an amazing host
bret is a great host
host was responsive flexible and offered great recommendations for things in town
Location:
great quiet place close to anything you need
beautiful apartment in a peaceful but convenient location
location is close to the cutest one stop light town i’ve seen
beautiful space in secluded location
the treehouse is a lovely location with a wonderful cozy-yet-airy feel
Read more reviews

2. Secluded retreat with spacious deck (from USD 198)

Are you a nature lover searching for a quiet getaway in the county? This secluded retreat located in Middle Island might be perfect for you. With its spacious interior, it can house up to four guests. You can wake up to the glorious view of Pine Lake and relax in the hammock on lazy afternoons. Previous guests also loved the spacious deck, en suite balcony, and front patio. Outdoor recreations are within reach as it is near several parks, beaches, wineries, restaurants, and more.

Stayed at this property?
Middle Island, New York, United States
89 reviews   Wifi Available
Entire cabin 2 Beds 4 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 4

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the bed is very comfy and the balcony is a nice touch
comfortable and well designed space with lots of notes about how to operate things
the kitchen was stock with useful essentials and coffee there were useful signs everywhere (light switches etc)
the space was clean and there were clear directions posted for the wifi sofa bed etc
this charming and cozy cabin is such a jem
Cleanliness:
this cabin is a gem we had such a pleasant stay in this sparkling clean charming lakefront property
home was very clean and exactly as pictured
cute little cabin the inside was sparkly clean
it was clean cozy and the hosts were super responsive
Host:
the hosts were great with communication and provided top-notch hospitality
debra was a wonderful host and we look forward to returning once the weather gets warm
debra and irving incredibly responsive
this place was great the hosts were friendly and professional and the space was cozy
Location:
great location on the lake
calm quiet location very peaceful area
the area is beautiful you can walk or run in the morning near the lake
if you have kids check out the county fair amusement park that's about ten minutes away
cozy for one or two people and would be a great place to stay in the summer time
Read more reviews

3. Spacious apartment with private entrance (from USD 85)

You can have this vast apartment all to yourself when you visit the county. With its spacious living room and dining area, you can enjoy a comfortable stay. Its stylish bedroom can sleep up to two guests. Even if the house is adjoined to the host’s house, you can have a separate private entrance. The rental is also near shopping centers such as Macy’s, Walmart, and Shoprite. There are gyms, fast food restaurants, and hospitals nearby as well.

Stayed at this property?
Centereach, New York, United States
287 reviews   Wifi Available
ENTIRE RENTAL UNIT 1 Bed 2 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 2

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
great place a bit hot but the ac and fans help out alot with that
the apartment was clean and both rooms have window a/c units and ceiling fans
very comfortable to work in during the day and to relax in the evenings
Cleanliness:
clean and spacious retreat
super clean convenient and private
very clean spacious and quiet
space was clean and as described
great space very clean and organized
Host:
the host was pleasant
great place wonderful host awesome price
abida was a great host
abida herself was a most gracious host
great place & nice host easy check in and out
Location:
great location on the island
great place to stay close to everything
great place excellent value & great location
very good place for the price
nice quiet place to cozy in and get away
Read more reviews

4. Lovely country home with fenced backyard (from USD 232)

Do you plan to spend your summer getaway with your family and furry friends? This lovely country-themed home might be a great choice for you. It has spacious rooms and full baths that can accommodate six guests. Your pets will love the fenced backyard, and there are also dog parks nearby. Within walking distance are Smith Point Bridge and Atlantic Ocean Beach, where you can enjoy some sea views and fun water activities. You can also enjoy viewing sunsets on the patio with Bellport Bay as your background.

Stayed at this property?
Shirley, New York, United States
122 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 5 Beds 6 Guests 3 Bedrooms 2 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 6

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the ac works well and the wifi is great as well
the signla for wifi was perfect but the network didnt worked
the house was spacious and comfortable with everything we needed to both work and relax
the kitchen appliances made cooking several delicious meals a delight
Cleanliness:
the house was very clean really appreciated the hotel style towels
this place is beautiful clean and comfortable
house was very clean
all rooms are clean and tastefully decorated
clean bright and everything as described
Host:
zbigniew was quick to answer any questions we had and helpful with suggestions
the hosts are very welcoming and quick to respond
the home owners are very kind and get back to you very quickly with any questions or concerns
host responded very quickly and very helpful if needed anything
zyggi and vicky are great hosts and have great communication
Location:
great location - close to beach and food
location was great away from most city traffic
it’s very close with a walking distance to a nice beach
nice house in close proximity to smith point
this is a beautiful home located very close to a wonderful beach
Read more reviews

5. Unique apartment with a vintage tub (from USD 123)

Nestled in the cul-de-sac of Sag Harbor Village, this apartment with artistic interiors can be a delight for people who are not fans of congested streets. It is spacious enough to accommodate up to four people. Previous guests loved the vintage clawfoot tub and the private garden. You can also bring your pets with you as it has a shaded and fenced dog run where they can enjoy playing. The host also offers free bikes, surfboards, and a four-person canoe, so you can visit nearby beaches and enjoy fun water activities.

Stayed at this property?
Sag Harbor, New York, United States
169 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE RENTAL UNIT 2 Beds 4 Guests 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 4

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
fridge was well stocked with all sorts of snacks ac and wifi are great
common area: the ceiling fan is wobbly when on “high
kitchenette is well stocked with breakfast essentials and healthy snacks
had a great night sleep - quiet surroundings and extremely cozy bed
very quiet and a very comfortable setting
Cleanliness:
the space was also incredibly clean and cozy
place was great very clean and comfortable
if this place really got a proper cleaning these items would've been clean
everything was also very clean and overall had a great stay
the space is clean comfortable and really the perfect getaway
Host:
brian was great host and gave great advice about the area
he is attentive and caring
bryan was a wonderful host who enhanced my stay in sag harbor tremendously
he is a friendly and considerate host
he is a polite and kind host
Location:
the location is fantastic
great location with everything you need
great location and very comfortable bed
great location: quiet street very close to water and town
location was better than we expected
Read more reviews

6. Picturesque accommodation with private beach (from USD 225)

Are you looking for a place where you can get away from it all but still enjoy modern conveniences? Situated in the peaceful neighborhood of Aquebogue is this gorgeous accommodation that is great for two guests. You can have free access to the bay and garden area, where you can spend some quiet time. The private beach is also great for people who want to enjoy swimming and other outdoor activities without being swamped by a large crowd. With its close proximity to Manhattan, you can explore more than 50 wineries. It is also close to The Hamptons and North Folk villages. Note that each guest has to pay taxes and resort fees per night worth 15 USD.

Stayed at this property?
Aquebogue, New York, United States
98 reviews   Wifi Available
Room in hotel 1 Bed 2 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 2

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the rooms doors open up to a beautiful social area with enough space to follow social distancing guidelines
location was great amazing views from the room
Cleanliness:
very clean and well kept room
great value and nice and clean beds were comfortable and the whole place was well kept
very clean the space is very stylish and exactly what is on the pictures
the hotel really clean and stylish really good location
great amenities in the clean modern space
Host:
ali & erin on the 'front desk' are top notch - efficient and attentive
this place is awesome the staff is great it’s pretty secluded and can’t really be overcrowded
staff was awesome and accommodating the hotel is really cute and well decorated
room was spotless staff was friendly and helpful
Location:
beautiful hotel in a serene location
the backyard area is so cute and the location was quiet and beautiful
perfect place for a quick trip away from nyc
great place to getaway from the city
great place to stay for a couple
Read more reviews

7. Comfortable home with beach-themed den (from USD 312)

Located near Hampton and Fire Island National Seashore, this comfortable home can spoil you with beautiful scenery. The spacious accommodation can house up to six guests. You can also love its beach-themed den that can give you the fresh, summer vibes, complete with a fireplace and a spacious lounge area. There are several interesting activities to try nearby such as kayaking in Carmans River, hiking in Wertheim National Wildlife Refuge, and visiting William Floyd Estate.

Stayed at this property?
Shirley, New York, United States
131 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE HOME 3 Beds 6 Guests 2 Bedrooms 1 Bathrooms

Accommodates: 6

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
beds were super comfortable and the ac worked excellent
the breakfast nook is amazing
the beds were very comfortable and the 2 bathrooms was a huge plus
the breakfast nook was our favorite to have breakfast in the mornings
the place was well maintained with comfortable large beds and a
Cleanliness:
beautiful clean home with plenty of space
the house is very clean and welcoming nicholas place has great communication
great communication clear instructions and a clean and comfortable space to stay for a weekend
great and clean space highly recommended
very spacious and clean
Host:
owners very responsive and attentive
they were very responsive and attentive
nick is a good host very quick at responding
nicholas was a great host
house was everything i expected the host was very nice and helpful
Location:
nice place to stay near beach
i especially loved the location
the location was safe and a nice community
it was very nice and spacious; convenient location
i loved the location and just overall had a great getaway to go see a friend
Read more reviews

8. Private studio with a dedicated workspace (from USD 105)

This private studio apartment might be the perfect vacation rental for you. It is located in the serene and historic town of Stony Brook. With its rustic interior and wonderful amenities, you can have the peaceful vacation you have always wanted. It is roomy enough for two guests. With its cute front porch and backyard, you can enjoy a lovely view while sipping coffee. It is also near tourist destinations such as Suffolk County Courts, The Hamptons, Greenport, and Montauk.

Stayed at this property?
Stony Brook, New York, United States
124 reviews   Superhost Wifi Available
ENTIRE RENTAL UNIT 1 Bed 2 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 2

Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
had many thoughtful touches such as bathroom essentials tea coffee electric tea kettle and keurig
the bathroom was good and it was great to have coffee
they were alot of amenities that made it feel comfortable and practical i couldn’t really ask for more
the bed was super comfortable and warm
the apartment couldn’t have been more perfect for my stay
Cleanliness:
the place was so clean and so stylish
vatt's place is super clean and comfortable
the place was super clean and we felt very comfortable staying there
highly recommended this sparkling clean gem of an apartment
the area is spacious clean and well decorated
Host:
thank you for being a great host vatt
vatt is a fantastic host
vatt is such a wonderful host everything was perfect for my stay
if there is one super host
vatt was very responsive to our needs
Location:
very nice and cute place love it a lot
great location in stony brook vatt is friendly and great to work with
many conveniences very cute private spacious studio in a nice quiet neighborhood
great place for a city get away
vatt’s place is really great
Read more reviews

9. Rustic loft with an indoor pool

This rustic loft is located right off the railroad tracks. It has a laid-back atmosphere that can let you relax during your stay. This is a good spot to unwind, and two people can enjoy the whole space. With its private outdoor area where you can have some barbecue parties and an indoor pool, you can enjoy a fun bonding time with your companions. The rental also has a full-size refrigerator where you can store your groceries and more.

Stayed at this property?
3 reviews   Wifi Available
Tiny home 1 Bed 2 Guests 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 2

Top guest reviews
Host:
great location and pool very nice owner w/ good communication
loretta is super hospitable and a terrific host
Read more reviews

10. Charming studio with backyard deck

If you are looking for a compact house with modern amenities, check out this charming studio in Shirley. This one-bedroom apartment is spacious enough for two guests. Previous guests recommend this charming space because it is well-kept and is squeaky clean. With its lovely backyard deck and chairs, you can spend some time watching the sunset or have a romantic dinner. It is also near many shopping centers, restaurants, and beaches.

Stayed at this property?
Shirley, New York, United States
7 reviews   Wifi Available
ENTIRE RENTAL UNIT 1 Bed 2 Guests 1 Bedroom 1 Bathroom

Accommodates: 2

Top guest reviews
Cleanliness:
wonderful space clean & cozy
Host:
great host highly recommend
as always colleen was a great host
another great stay at colleen’s she is a wonderful host and always available
the host is very nice friendly helpful and responsive for any needs or issues
Location:
colleen's place is compact but has everything one needs to be comfortable
Read more reviews

Discover the rich history of Suffolk County

As you walk around the county, you can discover many historic buildings built in the 1700s. The rich history of Suffolk County is what makes it unique from other places in New York. Discover stories of rebellion, industrialization, and the preservation of its historical sites when you visit the county. Book one of the top Airbnb vacation rentals in Suffolk County, New York, for a relaxing holiday.

Stayed at this property?
Any must-sees we missed? Tell us about them in the comments section or write a post here to help out fellow travelers!
Disclosure: Trip101 selects the listings in our articles independently. Some of the listings in this article contain affiliate links.

History


Get Trip101 in your inbox

Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data

Andrea, a freelance content writer based in the Philippines, is both a teacher by profession and a passionate writer. Her travels, primarily with family and occasionally with friends, have left her...Read more

 Want to contribute as a Local Expert?
Explore Suffolk
x
Good things are meant to be shared!
Back to top
Visited any of these places? Click this button to activate our "Add a Tip" feature to share your experience.