Top 5 Historic Hotels In Cape May, New Jersey - Updated 2024

Nicole
Nicole 
Updated
| 2 min read

Situated on the southern edge of New Jersey, Cape May is a gorgeous coastal city and a fantastic tourist destination in Cape May Peninsula. It is famed for its family-friendly beaches and the vibrant Beach Avenue, a popular oceanfront walking and jogging route. In addition to stunning natural wonders, this resort destination mesmerizes guests with its charming Victorian architecture. One of the best examples is Emlen Physick Estate, which houses exhibits that revolve around life in 1879. Moreover, Cape May offers historic hotels, perfect for history and culture buffs. To give you an idea about unique accommodation in this lovely city, browse through this list of top historic hotels in Cape May, New Jersey.

We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) properties with historic significance, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on March 01, 2024.

1. The Queen Victoria (from USD 183)

Are you the type of tourist who likes staying in characterful hotels? If so, The Queen Victoria is the perfect Cape May vacation home for you. This award-winning hotel opened its doors to the public in 1881, featuring Victorian architecture. At present, it exudes an old-world charm, noticeable in its Pinterest-worthy rooms, wood-framed fireplaces, and picture-perfect porches.

Originally a bed and breakfast, this hotel serves a hearty buffet-style breakfast and English-style afternoon teas.

Stayed at this property?

The Queen Victoria

Address: 102 Ocean Street , Cape May, Cape May (NJ), United States, NJ 08204
21.15 km (13.2 mi) from Cape May County Park & Zoo

2. Inn of Cape May

Inn Cape May New Jersey
Source: Photo by Wikimedia Commons user Paul Lowry used under CC BY 2.0

What was a former four-story Victorian boarding house in 1894 is now a Colonial hotel with an added swimming pool for guests’ enjoyment. With the beach steps from the property, the best of both worlds can be enjoyed by guests. Besides cozy rooms with old-world charm and modern conveniences, it offers lovely on-site dining that serves contemporary American fare. While savoring delicious meals, you can also relish picturesque sea views from the in-house Aleathea’s Restaurant.

Inn of Cape May

Address: 7 Ocean Street, Cape May, New Jersey

Star Rating: 3 Star

Travelers Review: Very Good 4.3(from 248 reviews)

Book Now

Stayed at this property?

3. Hotel Macomber (from USD 401)

Located within walking distance from Cape May Historic District, Hotel Macomber is a shingle-style hotel that offers a tourist-friendly location. With the beach for a neighbor, you can expect breathtaking sea views and easy access to watersports.

This 1916 hotel has survived the test of time and has undergone renovations to fit it in the modern world. Rooms feature New England-style interiors, canopy beds, and a cool and airy atmosphere. Feel free to check out the award-winning Union Park Restaurant on site. Explore the area the old-school way and take advantage of the bike rentals.

Stayed at this property?

Hotel Macomber

Address: 727 Beach Avenue, Cape May, Cape May (NJ), United States, NJ 08204
21.1 km (13.2 mi) from Cape May County Park & Zoo

4. The Chalfonte

The Chalfonte
Source: Photo by Wikimedia Commons user WhisperToMe used under CC0

If you are a fan of Pinterest-worthy accommodations you can show off on your socials, the aesthetics of The Chalfonte will surely excite you. Billed as the city’s oldest original hotel, this 19th-century retreat boasts a posh Victorian design. With pastel walls, hardwood flooring, and chandelier lighting, every corner of this hotel is picture-perfect. You can book suites with a whirlpool tub for added delight. WiFi is accessible throughout the property.

With the on-site Magnolia Room Restaurant and The King Edward Bar, you need not go far for delicious food and fine drinks.

The Chalfonte

Address: 301 Howard St, Cape May, NJ 08204, United States

Price: 120 USD onwards

Star Rating: 2 Star

Travelers Review: Very Good 4.3(from 263 reviews)

Book Now

Stayed at this property?

5. Congress Hall (from USD 160)

If you wish to live the life of the rich and famous on your Cape May holiday, Congress Hall is the perfect vacation home for you. This hotel spoils guests with four-star luxuries, starting with stunning rooms with a Smart TV, WiFi, and a minibar. An outdoor pool, a gym, and an American restaurant are at your disposal throughout your stay.

There’s more to Congress Hall than meets the eye. Besides upscale facilities, it boasts rich history kept in its walls for more than 200 years. Congress Hall was formerly known as The Big House (and informally The Summer White House). It only got renamed when the owner, Thomas H. Hughes, got elected in congress. It is also acknowledged as America’s first seaside resort.

Stayed at this property?

Congress Hall

Wifi Available Wheelchair accessible

Address: 200 Congress Place
21.43 km (13.4 mi) from Cape May County Park & Zoo

Parking Restaurant Meeting/banquet facilities Bar 24-HOUR FRONT DESK Fitness centre Terrace Non-smoking rooms

Earn OneKeyCash for every dollar spent on eligible hotels, vacation rentals, flights, car rentals, and more when you book across our family of brands.

Fall in love with Cape May

Cape May is a picture-perfect city adorned with gorgeous beaches and stunning Victorian abodes. It is a fantastic getaway destination for all types of vacationers, especially families and couples on a romantic getaway. History and culture enthusiasts will also have an unforgettable time in this beautiful city. Complete your vacation plans by booking the perfect accommodation for you.

Stayed at this property?
Any must-sees we missed? Tell us about them in the comments section or write a post here to help out fellow travelers!
Disclosure: Trip101 selects the listings in our articles independently. Some of the listings in this article contain affiliate links.

History


Get Trip101 in your inbox

Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data

Nicole, a writer and traveler, also identifies herself as a free spirit with a wild heart. She is dedicated to telling authentic stories in a relatable manner. Nicole also enjoys exploring new,...Read more

 Want to contribute as a Local Expert?
Explore Cape May - Wildwood
Looking for accommodation?
x
Good things are meant to be shared!
Back to top
Visited any of these places? Click this button to activate our "Add a Tip" feature to share your experience.