Kelleys Island, Ohio, the largest of Ohio’s Lake Erie Islands, is a nature and bird lover’s paradise. The island’s rocky shorelines, sandy state park beach, lush forests, popular winery and brewery, historic homes, and friendly hospitality make it the perfect destination for a relaxing getaway. Rent a golf cart or bicycle to explore the world’s largest glacial scoring and discover Native American petroglyphs carved into a limestone boulder. Hike miles of trails at the state park, charter a fishing boat to catch perch or walleye, and enjoy the island’s downtown with clothing and gift stores, miniature golf, karaoke, restaurants, and live entertainment. For those looking to bring their furry friends along, Kelleys Island offers a variety of pet-friendly rentals including cozy cottages, spacious homes, and even waterfront properties, making it the perfect destination for pet-loving vacationers. Check out our list of the best pet-friendly rentals in Kelleys Island, Ohio.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) host status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and pet-friendly rules and regulations. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on March 23, 2024.
1. Cedar Cottage (from USD 325)
Experience the natural beauty of Kelleys Island at Cedar Cottage, a charming three-bedroom vacation retreat that welcomes you and your furry friend. Boasting ample amenities and a warm, casually sophisticated decor, this cottage offers an open living space and is surrounded by mature cedar trees and a large private yard, perfect for your pet to play and enjoy. Note that the host charges a 100 USD fee for each pet you bring along.
Conveniently located on a quiet wooded road, it’s just a short bike ride to downtown or the beach.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
nice and quiet cell phone reception and wi-fi sometimes non-existentthe yard and deck were great spaces that we thoroughly enjoyed and inside was nice and cozythe cottage air conditioners worked great the place is clean and well-maintained and everyone had their own bedonly one bathroom but we did okCleanliness:
very clean amd nicevery clean and comfortablevery clean and furnished nicelythe unit was clean and cozyoverall everything was neat & cleanHost:
owner was very easy to communicate withowner is very good at answering any questions you have in a prompt mannerthe owner was very responsive and wonderful to work withowner was also very responsive and easy to work withRead more reviewsLocation:
good location close to townnice location not to far from town but yes far enough away to enjoy the quietnessvery peaceful and quite location and an easy bike ride to either the town or the beachit was quiet and relaxing yet close enough to the attractionswe would love to come back again ( don’t forget cash for the transfer station
2. Memory Manor (from USD 256)
Memory Manor is a spacious, comfortable vacation home in a quiet neighborhood on Kelleys Island, Ohio. Only 1 mile (1.61 kilometers) from the town center and just a few blocks from the lake, it offers the perfect balance of privacy and convenience.
The home features three bedrooms, two full bathrooms, central air conditioning, city water, and a fully equipped kitchen. The living room is spacious and offers satellite TV for your entertainment. You can also enjoy the outdoors with a deck and gas grill, or gather around the fire ring in the front yard. The property also welcomes one well-trained dog for an additional fee of 100 USD.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
a nice yard and adequate kitchen was perfect for usbeds were very comfortable and slept greatCleanliness:
it was clean and comfortablehouse was clean and well appointedit is a very clean and comfortable homesuch a great little spot everything was clean and well cared forgreat host clean and well kept property would definitely book with joel againHost:
he was a gracious hostjoel was a great hostjoel was a very helpful and knowledgeable hostjoel was awesome host who answered all my questions before and during our stayfriendly and made sure you had everything you need for your stayRead more reviewsLocation:
cute house quiet and peaceful locationlocation was fantastic - close enough to everything while still feeling secludedgreat quiet location for a stay on kelly’s islandpeaceful and relaxing stay in a cute cottage on a quiet inner side street yet still close to everythingthe house is in a great location for exploring kelley’s island and comfortable for relaxing in
Superhost
3. The Cedar Chalet (from USD 175)
The Cedar Chalet is a spacious vacation rental home on Kelley’s Island, Ohio, with three bedrooms, three bathrooms, a large living room with a cathedral ceiling and balcony, a large first-floor deck, and a backyard fire ring. The kitchen is fully equipped and there’s a washer and dryer.
Pets are welcome and the outdoor spaces are great for them to explore with their owners. Renters should be responsible for their pets and any damages caused. Limited grocery shopping is available on the island, but there are several restaurants open during the summer season.
Top guest reviews
Host:
we definitely hope to return jerold was a great hostRead more reviewsLocation:
you’ll love the location of the cedar chaletwe had a great stay at this locationpleasant home in a quiet locationgood location lots of room host provided a number of bikes for traveling about the islandgreat place to stay we always enjoy our time on the island
4. Stunning getaway near the beach (from USD 414)
This Kelleys Island getaway is the perfect vacation home for families or groups of friends. The four-bedroom home is located on the peaceful east side of the island. The home features a gourmet kitchen with an island, a large private lot, and a bright living space.
Renters have the option to rent golf carts on the island to explore the island’s attractions such as restaurants, the beach, hiking trails, and state parks. The rental allows just one dog and does not have a cat-friendly policy.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
it was fantastic the kids all had comfortable beds (no one on a pullout or futon)Cleanliness:
clean and quiet house to stay inthe house was clean and exactly as advertisedthe bedrooms were clean and comfortableit was clean and beautiful with lots of extrasvery attractive clean home with plenty of space for a familyHost:
the home was beautiful and bob was a great host we are definitely planning to come back next yeargreat place to stay owner easy to communicate withhouse was well stocked and bob was a great hostbob was responsive and helpfulRead more reviewsLocation:
the house is well stocked and the location is quiet and peacefulkelley's island is a relaxed location with beautiful homes and just enough activities
5. Casa Del Sol (from USD 450)
Casa Del Sol is a luxurious vacation home situated on private land with a stunning lake view. The rental sleeps up to 18 people and features a family room with a TV and DVD player, a fully equipped kitchen, and a three-level deck with a Tiki bar, a barbecue grill, and a patio set.
Spend evenings roasting marshmallows, sitting on Adirondack chairs, and enjoying conversation among family and friends. Pets are welcome, however, the host only allows one small dog.
Top guest reviews
Amenities & Room:
the back deck was so comfortable having a lovely view of the lakethe kitchen had all of the necessary cookware the house was huge and the back deck was fantasticCleanliness:
house was very clean when we arrivedit was clean and seemed well cared forthe suite was clean and comfortable with a private bathroomthe inside at first glance was clean but then started to notice many things were not cleanthe house was very clean and there was a lot of space to spread out inside and outdoorsHost:
the owners were very responsive to our needs and concernsowner was very responsive during this processthe owners were very responsive after we got in and settledour family truly enjoyed our stay at this home and the owner/manager couldn't have been more accommodating and graciousoverall very pleased with this property and our communications with the ownerRead more reviewsLocation:
loved the location and solitudewe could easily walk or ride bikes to towneverything functioned well and location was great especially for childrenwe enjoyed this roomy and comfy house in it's quiet locationlocation is great on the island and our four generations had a great stay
Escape to Kelleys Island for a dreamy pet-friendly vacation
Explore the island’s natural beauty with your furry friend by your side and come home to a comfortable rental that feels like home. Enjoy outdoor spaces, gourmet kitchens, cozy chalets, and luxurious properties all with pet-friendly amenities.
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data
Create an account to