Whether you’re a history buff, a nature lover, or just looking for a place to escape the hustle and bustle of daily life, Lake Geneva is an ideal spot. The resort city nestled on the shores of Geneva Lake has been a favorite travel destination since the 19th century. In those days, affluent individuals, especially Chicagoans, would build lakefront holiday villas for themselves. Today, you can tour some of these mansions, including the Queen Ann-style summer home at Black Point Estate and Gardens. Also, learn about the history at Main Street Historic District or cruise on Geneva Lake. Big Foot Beach State Park and other beaches await as well.
You’ll also discover many luxurious homes around this place, offering private swimming pools, hot tubs, natural settings, and more to relish. Check out these best vacation rentals with private pool near Lake Geneva, Wisconsin.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) host status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and access to private pool. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on October 26, 2025.
1. Quaint property for 20 with a fishing pond
If you’re planning a memorable stay with a group of 20, this 3-bedroom rental is your best bet. It’s set on a 7.5-acre (3-hectare) lot complete with a beach, fishing pond, and more. You can fish or take advantage of the two available paddleboards and cruise the water. During winter, guests can enjoy ice skating, ice fishing, or sledding on the lake.
Back in the lodge, you can soak in the heated outdoor pool (open from mid-May to October 1) or the hot tub. And inside the colossal house, there is a movie projector (upon request), ping pong, and pool table to enjoy. This place also has a functional kitchen and laundry amenities, and it’s about a 50-minute drive from Lake Geneva.
Caledonia, Wisconsin, United States
Top guest reviews
Host:
the owner is very easy to work with as wellrobert was the most gracious host we’ve had yetrobert was so helpful and easy to communicate with before and during our stayLocation:
i highly recommend this location"the retreat was an outstanding place for a five day trip to wisconsinCleanliness:
easy check-in everything clean and great location just off the i-94 exitlarge great room clean kitchen and sleeping spaces when we finally went insideRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
large well taken care of yard and nice pool and hot tubthe game room/garage was perfect
2. Modern lodge overlooking Geneva Lake (from USD 876)
Surround yourself with verdant nature and water panoramas when you stay in this four-bedroom home overlooking Geneva Lake. It feels remote yet is within walking distance from landmarks, including Geneva Lake Museum and Lake Geneva Cruise Line. In addition, the home is beautifully styled and modern.
You’ll love its open floor plan, complete with a stone fireplace, hardwood floors, vaulted ceilings, and sweeping views of nature coming in from the windows from all directions. Visitors can also cook in the functional kitchen or enjoy outdoor cooking with the deck’s barbecue grill. For some recreation, unwind in the outdoor in-ground pool with a waterfall feature (open from May end to early September).
Lake Geneva, Wisconsin, United States
Top guest reviews
Host:
owners were incredibly attentive and helpfulthe hosts were very accommodating and communicative highly recommend staying here for a relaxing getawayRead more reviewsLocation:
this is exactly what we were looking for; peace and quiet with easy access to the town
3. Cozy wooden house for 10 in a forested property (from USD 2064)
You, and especially the kids, will love this four-bedroom wooden cabin that’s 1 mile (1.6 kilometers) from Geneva Lake. It’s thoughtfully decorated, spacious, and highlights entertainment features, including an HDTV in the sitting room with cable, a game console, and a fireplace.
Out on the yard, you’ll find an in-ground heated pool available during the summer months for a surcharge. And on a cold evening, guests can relax in the hot tub. Other perks include a barbecue grill and a well-equipped kitchen. However, Wi-Fi isn’t available because there’s no tower nearby.
Lake Geneva, Wisconsin, United StatesSuperhost
Accommodates: 10
Top guest reviews
Host:
thank you for being a wonderful host debbiedebbie is a great hostdebbie was an amazing hostshe was very kind and hospitable to our groupthe host was helpful communicative gracious and easy to deal withLocation:
great location a quick ride from downtownthe location is perfectthe pool was perfect and location is amazinggreat location- close to downtown lake geneva and minutes away from the lakeit was in a great location close to downtown lake genevaCleanliness:
very clean and cozyit was clean and nicely decoratedthe house was very clean and as expecteddebbie’s place was awesome it was very clean her communication was always very fastplenty of clean linens towels and blankets for large groupsRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
the patio table was lovelyawesome comfy new leather furniture in tv roomthe heated pool was the perfect touch will definitely be coming here againa lovely private property with a fabulous poolall the beds were very comfortable and the lower level tv area was also so comfortable
4. h-century home on a large forested lot (from USD 398)
This rental sits on a 77-acre (31.2-hectare) forested lot, 20 minutes by car from Delavan Lake and Geneva Lake. Great for outdoor lovers, guests can access miles of on-site hiking trails. Plus, there are ponds where you can fish upon request. And did we mention that it’s a 10-minute walk from Lulu Lake State Natural Area?
The partly refurbished home dates back to 1954. It highlights a spacious living room outfitted with large windows overlooking the outdoors and an HDTV. Outside, you can take advantage of the fire pit, hot tub, and heated pool. This home also includes a kitchen, a ping pong table, and Wi-Fi.
Eagle, Wisconsin, United States
Top guest reviews
Host:
the owners were so accommodating and friendlywe loved the house daniel was very welcoming & helpful with all the details needed for the houseLocation:
amazing place and wonderful locationwe love the location that it's not too far from our home but feels hundreds of miles awayCleanliness:
the house was clean and had everything we neededthe home was clean and had everything we neededRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
everyone loved the views from the family roomthe pool and hot tub were delightful and the entire space was just so thoughtfully and artistically designedthe pool and hot tub worked great and we loved the screen porch
5. Handcrafted pet-friendly home amidst nature
Feel at home while being surrounded by nature in this four-bedroom handcrafted home. It’s nestled in a 10.5-acre (4.2-hectare) wooded lot, about 45 minutes by car from Lake Geneva and 3 miles (4.8 kilometers) from shops and eateries. On the property, you can hike the three woody paths and connect with nature.
Furthermore, the inside is cozy and well equipped. After a long day outdoors, you can swim in the small indoor heated pool and pamper yourself in the sauna. It also opens to a large deck, where guests can unwind with a good book. This accommodation has cable TV, a kitchen, and a firepit as well. Pets are welcome too.
Milton, Wisconsin, United StatesAccommodates: 8
Top guest reviews
Host:
host was great and communicated wellLocation:
close to stores but secluded enough for a nice quiet getawaythis spot was the perfect location for a small getaway with friendsthis place was the perfect thanksgiving get away for the entire familyi’m sure this place is even more beautiful in the summer or warmer weatherwow this place is one of the most unique airbnbs i’ve ever stayed atCleanliness:
comfortable and cleanit was extremely clean and well stocked with the necessitiesit was quiet and secluded and very cleanabsolutely beautiful home very clean and the sauna was such a treatan artful and peaceful retreat super clean and well-cared forRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
the pool was honestly perfect for our 7 and 2 year oldthe deck is awesome after relaxing in the pool and saunajust as fantastic the second time around sub zero temperatures outside didn't keep us from being warm and cozythe sauna was a great addition for the adults and my toddler had a blast with the poolcomfortable and quiet bedrooms
6. Updated home on a quiet cul-de-sac (from USD 510)
Enjoy a comfortable, tranquil getaway with your family in this three-bedroom house set on a dead end. Surrounded by nature, the property also boasts a fenced yard where you can dip in the heated pool or relax on the patios or outdoor lounge area.
The interior is artsy and comfy. Guests can watch TV in the sitting room with a fireplace or test their skills in the fully stocked kitchen. The updated rental also includes Wi-Fi, laundry amenities, and two garages. What’s more, it’s just an hour’s drive from Lake Geneva.
Sussex, Wisconsin, United StatesAccommodates: 6
Top guest reviews
Host:
the owners were also greatjames all the way through answers all questions quickly and is a wonderful hostjames was a great host and was readily available if anything was neededthe owners communicate pretty well toonice neighborhood good communication with hostLocation:
it was great to have stores so close to make it convenientthe location was perfect also in that it was a calm quiet location yet near needed amenitieswe loved the pool and the convenience of have a store close byCleanliness:
the house was super clean and everything was very spelled out before hand and after arrivalthe house was clean and in a nice quiet neighborhoodthe house itself was super clean and very nicely updatedthe pool was clean with lots of toys for the kidsthe house was so clean updated private and funRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
the pool area is beautiful with outdoor furniture and lovely landscapingnice heated pool and lots of pool toysthe beds were super comfortableour kids loved the heated poolwater in the pool was heated and clear
7. Top-end mansion for 12
Experience top-end luxury in this mansion located in Waukesha County, about a 50-minute drive from Lake Geneva. Oriented for 12 guests, this place comes with a spacious exterior highlighting a fireplace, a heated swimming pool with fountains, a hot tub, and lounge areas.
Further, the interior is colossal and features beautiful decorations, including wall art and an artistic fireplace. Guests can recline in the great room and play video games or enjoy the ping pong and pool tables. And did we mention the theater room for movie nights?
Accommodates: 12
Minimum Nights: 1
Refund Policy : 100% refund if you cancel at least 30 days before check-in.
Top guest reviews
Host:
the host was extremely classy polite and very flexibleRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
the pool was huge and the covered bar area was perfect
8. Historic second-floor condo
Dating back to the 1900s, this historic property was constructed as the carriage house for Loramoor Estate. The rental is set on the second level and boasts a mix of modern and vintage touches to make your solo or romantic stay delightful.
The newly renovated accommodation comes with a functional kitchen, a colorful sitting area with a flat-screen TV, and WiFi. Additionally, you can use the outdoor pool throughout the summer months.
Accommodates: 2
Top guest reviews
Host:
hospitable hosts and very easy and fast check in and outLocation:
great condo and good locationgreat place and a great location to downtown lake genevagreat apartment for a couple’s get away in quiet surroundings and yet a short drive to lake genevawe also enjoyed the pool and the short walk to the public lake pathit was so calm and peaceful there but only a quick 8-10 minute drive to downtown lake genevaRead more reviewsCleanliness:
wonderful quiet clean comfortable place to staythe pool was also very cleanthe unit was tastefully updated clean and comfortablevery clean and comfortable with all the needed amenities
9. Cozy home in a private wooded lot
Privacy and upscale comfort await you in this 7-bedroom accommodation located in Walworth County, about 10 minutes by car from Lake Geneva. Nestled amidst soaring trees, it’s just a stroll away from Rice and Whitewater lakes. While on the property, you can picnic in the private yard or take a dip in the seasonal outdoor pool.
Additionally, the home is newly remodeled, enormous, and boasts modern features. You’ll find a sitting room with a fireplace and a fully stocked kitchen. Plus, you can enjoy playing poker and pool.
Accommodates: 6
Minimum Nights: 2
Refund Policy : 100% refund if you cancel at least 60 days before check-in.
Top guest reviews
Host:
the owner was great she response to any question or concenrs very quicklyit was a peaceful friendly stayLocation:
great house for couples with a under 1 minute walk to rice lakeCleanliness:
very clean and privatethe house was roomy clean and comfortable and the grounds were really niceRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
the master bedroom lights had to be on in order to use the ceiling fanthere was plenty of family space and the kitchen was great
Enjoy a memorable getaway in Lake Geneva
These best vacation rentals with a private pool near Lake Geneva, Wisconsin, are well-appointed. They’re situated in private, natural settings and boast modern features, including kitchens, hot tubs, and more to make your vacation memorable.
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data