Long Island, appropriately named for its size and geography, has long been home to some of New York’s most-desired holiday destinations. Many of its beaches are protected, such as Jones Beach State Park and Orient Beach State Park, and offer visitors plenty of fun activities to enjoy, such as surfing, fishing, and boating. The island is also home to cultural and historical attractions, including Long Island Maritime Museum in West Sayville and American Airpower Museum in Farmingdale. Moreover, don’t miss the celebrated annual events, such as the Jones Beach Airshow and the Shinnecock Indian Powwow.
Long Island’s affluent towns and neighborhoods are well-protected, ensuring security and privacy. If luxury and safety are part of your priorities, check out these top luxury Airbnbs in Long Island, New York.
We handpicked these listings carefully, considering (wherever possible) Superhost status, recent guest reviews, location, accommodation type, prices, availability of dates, decor, and access to luxury services and amenities. The image galleries get refreshed with the latest updates regularly. They were last updated on October 25, 2025.
1. Fireplace Farmhouse, Brookhaven (from USD 4109)
This 1815 Fireplace Farmhouse served as a trout farm and town post office before. Having been restored and modernized, you can expect comforts such as centralized air-conditioning, a hot tub, and a heated in-ground pool. You can read or play indoor games in the study and the solarium.
The property is also dog-friendly, but the host will need to approve the pets first. If allowed, your pet can enjoy amenities such as food and water bowls, a bin of toys, and a big dog bed.
Brookhaven, New York, United StatesSuperhost
Accommodates: 12
Top guest reviews
Host:
most wonderful home and hosts… highly recommendthe hosts were very helpful and responsive to our questions before our stay and during the weekendthe owners were very good with communicationchris & renee were great hosts - easy going and helpfulthe home was beautiful and chris and renee were very attentive hosts would highly recommend a stay hereLocation:
location was perfect for us and walking distance to a great restaurant/barthe location is perfect; very easy to get to bellport for a wander around the local shops and restaurantsit is very close to nyc and is incredibly peacefuldefinitely a place worth visiting againthis was such a unique and beautiful place very private with a huge backyardCleanliness:
it was sparkling clean and freshthe house itself was clean beautifully decorated spacious and had everything we neededRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
the beds were super comfortable and also appreciated all of the organic amenitiesthe beds are so comfortable the sheets and robes soft and cozywe loved the atmosphere the living rooms and the cozy fireplace in the breakfast cornerchris & reneé were so lovely soo comfortable to contact the 2 times we had qs
2. Stylish modern family home, Water Mill (from USD 2000)
White, bright interiors and posh furniture give this wonderful home a pristine and deluxe atmosphere. Take a swim in the heated gunite pool while taking turns cooking steaks and ribs on the barbecue grill. Kids can run around the backyard lawn and have fun with the cedar wood playground equipment.
The living room is designed for socializing, as there’s a dedicated media room in the lower level for watching movies or sports games. Other places in the home for relaxing and chatting include a lovely deck by the playground and a screened patio.
Water Mill, New York, United StatesAccommodates: 10
Top guest reviews
Host:
fantastic home in a great part of town and incredibly nice hostsoverall we truly enjoyed our stay and would recommend this home and their wonderful hostsbest host we have had and we use airbnb frequentlychris/brett was a fantastic hostchris was very helpful and responsiveLocation:
great location too about 10 minutes from bridgehamptonwhat a great house excellent location all the rooms were nicely furnished and had everything we neededexcellent home clean well designed in a great location close to the beachCleanliness:
property was extremely clean and absolutely stunningvery clean and there was great communication with chris throughout our staythe house was extremely clean quiet and beautifully decoratedevery room is very clean and thoughtfully decoratedit was very clean and ready for us when we got thereRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
great backyard with pool outdoor grill patio and jungle gym set for the kidsthe playground the trampoline and the pool were a huge success with our kidslot’s of rooms and a great living area and kitchen for relaxing and entertaining
3. Wonderful waterfront home, Southampton (from USD 1201)
Enjoy a scenic waterfront property with a large grassy backyard and a private dock. The house also has surrounding verdant foliage adding to the privacy and tranquility of the place. Kids can have fun in the playground while the grown-ups talk around the fire pit. The outdoor living spaces include an oversized deck and a ground-floor patio with a barbecue grill. Plus, there’s a Florida room with a ping-pong table.
The upper-level kitchen is fully equipped, with a bright dining area with a cathedral ceiling. The lower level features a kitchenette with a cozy second living room that has a 50-inch TV with streaming.
Southampton, New York, United StatesAccommodates: 9
Top guest reviews
Host:
the host was very responsivemichael was the perfect host - answered all questions and had great recommendationswe had a great stay michael was a great host and very communicativethe view is also beautiful and very relaxing michael was an amazing host - super fast in responsesLocation:
the location is wonderfulfantastic house in great locationgreat location and outdoor spacethe location provided easy access to everywhere in the hampton’smichael's house is like heaven: quiet comfortable spaciousCleanliness:
they place was sparkling clean and very comfortablethe house was clean and just as picturedthe entire place was very cleanwe had a great vacation in michael’s house it was very clean and organizedextraordinarily clean wonderfully cozy sheets and a beautiful water viewRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
it had everything we needed and was so comfortable
4. Waterfront property with a spa-like indoor pool, Mastic Beach (from USD 4693)
Have a resort-like getaway at this property overlooking Moriches Bay. Bring your boat or jet ski and moor it on the private dock. You can also hang out on the dock for some lazy afternoon fishing. Grill meat and fish or make some gumbo using the outdoor kitchen. Take a swim whenever you desire in the heated indoor pool. It even includes water loungers by the window with a view.
If you’re not ready to turn in for the day, the kitchen has a bar area, where you can mix up some mocktails and cocktails. Moreover, you can use the media room on the third floor with a 120-inch projector screen for a family movie night.
Mastic Beach, New York, United StatesAccommodates: 8
Top guest reviews
Host:
john is a great hostjohn was a great host and made sure to have all the extrasjohn was one of the best hosts i've stayed withhe was very responsive and friendly throughout our staythe host also treats us a nice lunchLocation:
the location is also good for the nearby sightseeingsif your looking for a peaceful gate away then i highly suggest this locationwe loved staying at john’s placeperfect place for a getaway from the cityjohn's place is beyond goodCleanliness:
it was clean and comfortablesparkling clean and so much to dothe place was extra clean and perfectthe house was spotless when we arrived and the owner takes care of all of the cleaningthe house is amazingly clean and fully stocked with everything you could needRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
the a/c and wireless were perfect as wellat night we played pool in the game room and watched movies on the big screenthe beds were also more comfortable than most airbnbsthe pool was super convenient and a crowd pleaser for those with small childrenthe kitchen is wonderful to cook in and the artwork and decor is beautiful eclectic and inviting
5. Scenic bayside home with a private beach, Shirley (from USD 1184)
Take in the majestic sunrise and sunset views at this charming bayside abode. Despite the size of the house, it features well-appointed and well-decorated interiors that give it a very homey atmosphere. The fully equipped kitchen is great for preparing seafood dishes made with locally caught ingredients.
The large backyard deck presents an unimpeded view of Bellport Bay, part of Long Island’s Great South Bay. Spend your afternoons just admiring the bay’s beauty, or use it as inspiration for some amazing photos, paintings, or sketches.
Shirley, New York, United StatesAccommodates: 6
Top guest reviews
Host:
they always provided super quick and helpful responsesthe hosts are courteous and very attentivethe absolute best space to escape life amazing hosts amazing space amazing memoriesthe hosts are very responsive responsible and had great recommendations on local activities and food choicesthis place is really just exceptional with excellent hostsLocation:
it is the perfect location for a relaxing getawayperfect location by the state park beach and a very peaceful backyardwe had a wonderful staycation visit at this locationlocation is perfect especially with the marina 2 minutes away for crabbingbeautiful house in great location meticulously maintained house with large deck right at a private beachCleanliness:
very clean and nicely decoratedit’s clean and well maintainedsteve and dory's place was amazing clean cozy and beautifulthe house was clean and comfortablesteve and dorry's place was very stylish clean and cozyRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
the house has good amenities with a firepit barbecue and fully stocked kitcheneach bedroom was so comfortable and has a roomy closet to keep your belongings in order
6. Impressive Airbnb rental near downtown, East Hampton (from USD 2634)
This rental offers a luxurious stay with the convenience of being close to the town’s best shops and restaurants. Keep yourselves warm by lighting up the classic stonework fireplaces all over the home. Sit in the backyard and sip some coffee or tea while admiring the hydrangea blooms. You can also swim during a warm sunny day or get a tan on the sun loungers.
There’s a workout room on the lower level, so you won’t need to hunt for a gym in town if you need to do cardio and calisthenics. Moreover, you can even access a lounge space with a pool table.
East Hampton, New York, United StatesAccommodates: 6
Top guest reviews
Host:
michelle was a wonderful host - incredibly responsivemichelle was an amazing host who was very responsive and super helpfulabsolutely beautiful home with very hospitable hoststerrific house and michelle is a great hostmichelle and robert were most responsive when we had questionsLocation:
the location is perfectthe location is greatcentrally located and a short walk to great restaurants shopping and spasabsolutely amazing location in a beautiful homeperfect house with a perfect locationCleanliness:
clean your home or sell it if you can’t afford to clean it properlythe house itself is beautifully furnished and decorated everything is impeccably clean and the housekeeper very friendlylisting description was accurate and house was very well kept and cleanthe house is spotless and perfectly located for those traveling via train or jitney from manhattanRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
kitchen is fully equipped for those that enjoy cookingthe outdoor seating area is also very comfortable and features an outdoor fireplace
7. Posh and artsy loft apartment, Brooklyn (from USD 529)
Have a pleasurable stay in this apartment located in one of New York City’s most famous neighborhoods. You’ll have many great stalls, restaurants, and shops within reach.
The apartment has a lovely minimalist design, presenting clean and uncluttered spaces. Because of this, it can fit a full kitchen with a stovetop oven and a roomy dining area. For sleeping, the bedrooms have queen-size beds, although those who prefer a view might choose to spend their night in the loft bedroom. Guests will also have access to a sunny rooftop area to hang out and socialize.
Brooklyn, New York, United StatesAccommodates: 4
Top guest reviews
Host:
great place and the host is very nicethe host made himself available when needed which was perfecthost is friendly and his turn-around reply is fastavigor was one of the greatest hosts i ever hadavigdor was a amazing host and i will definitely be back againLocation:
love the location and apartmentlocation and neighborhood is goodeverything you can possibly need for entertainment is within walking distancegood location and very friendly and welcoming hoststhis is a great flexible minimalistic rental in a quiet brooklyn locationCleanliness:
very clean and comfortableclean loft and quick with communicationclean modern feel and cozythe loft was great clean and really luxuriousi love this place it's clean and really modernRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
cute small apartment with good outdoor space and great views of the citythe layout of the apartment is very unique and looks exactly like the photos
8. Bright and elegant designer home, Southampton (from USD 5392)
Make this home your family getaway while visiting the state of New York. Bedrooms come equipped with queen-size and king-size beds. Apart from comfort amenities such as air-conditioning and Wi-Fi, this home has a heated swimming pool. There’s even a sauna room where you can relax and detox after a hard day of excursions or a hard night of partying. Though the home is a short drive away from many restaurants, it’s equipped with a fully furnished kitchen.
Southampton, New York, United StatesAccommodates: 8
Top guest reviews
Host:
mary ann was a lovely hostshe was so responsive and helpful throughout our staymary ann was a gracious host and very kindmary ann was a wonderful host and so easy to communicate withshe was an excellent host and greeted us very warmlyLocation:
the house is in a great locationlots of privacy and perfect location for restaurants the beach and storesbeautiful artfully decorated home in the perfect location closeby all the southampton shops restaurants and cooper’s beachit's a great place for groups since the bedrooms are in different wings allowing for privacy if neededCleanliness:
house is spacious clean and thoughtfully decoratedthe house was spotless and so comfortable - we couldn’t have asked for a better experienceadditionally the home was beautiful clean and well keptRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
pool is heated and great for day/nightthe heated pool spa and sauna were the bestthe beds and linens were super comfortablethat said the home is very comfortablethe chickens laid some eggs during our visit and we cooked them for breakfast haha
9. The Hidden Retreat, Port Jefferson (from USD 1541)
The Hidden Retreat offers a picturesque hideaway that will inspire your artistic and creative notions. This home is secluded enough while providing modern comforts at the same time. It is even converted from a fisherman’s cottage built in 1920.
Have a picnic on the deck patio while warmed by the outdoor fireplace. Snuggle in the living room and stream a movie on the motorized projector. You can also take amazing pictures of the lush surroundings and show them on social media.
Port Jefferson, New York, United StatesAccommodates: 6
Top guest reviews
Host:
the owner was responsive when we had questionsshe was also quick and responsive to all my questionsthe most gracious host and wonderful experienceemma and adam were great hosts and very communicative throughout our stayemma is a great hostLocation:
good places to eat near bybeautiful house in an excellent location we needed a central location to see family and work for a weekoverall this was a good find conveniently close (like 10 walking distance) to port jefferson ferrysuper cozy and quiet cottage located in port jeffersona very nice and well maintained house within walking distance of shops and restaurantsCleanliness:
it is quaint and clean and beautifully decoratedthe house is very clean and fully equippedthe place is adorable spotless and very tastefully decoratedit is beautifully decorated and sparkling cleanthe house is absolutely stunning clean cozy beautifully decorated and stocked with everything we needed during our tripRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
quiet space and extremely comfortablewifi supported all of my calls even outsidethe kitchen was well equipped as promised and the grill was an added touchloved the coffee at locals breakfast at toast and lunch at tigerlillysthe kitchen was fully equipped and the grill was very easy to use
10. Delightful European-style rental, Queens (from USD 633)
Long Island is dotted with posh seaside homes and offers homey abodes in quiet suburbs. You can check out this Airbnb rental with enough sleeping and living spaces for a large family. It has amenities, including a game room basement for movie or poker nights. The basement also has a ping-pong table and a foosball table for something more active.
The chef’s kitchen is fully equipped, so prepare your favorite recipes and have an al fresco feast on the backyard patio. Additionally, there’s a separate man cave den for the guys to hang out in and enjoy their drinks and sports games.
Queens, New York, United StatesAccommodates: 10
Top guest reviews
Host:
peter was a great hostthe host was great and responded quicklypeter is an awesome hostthe host was very attentive making even more enjoyable to stay therethe hosts are very helpful and accommodating readily available to answer any questions we hadLocation:
location: the airbnb was perfectly locatedgreat neighborhood with stores and metro station within walking distancegreat location super close to grocery stores restaurants and barsgreat restaurants and stores in walking distanceperfect location and quiet neighborhoodCleanliness:
the beds were clean and comfortablethe rooms were very clean and niceamazing stay super clean luxurious and comfortableclean spacious with an excellent backyardthe house is very spacious and cleanRead more reviewsAmenities & Room:
ac worked great in all rooms which was important because it was blistering hot outsidebeautiful home with plenty of room to spread outthe beds were very comfortable and the rooms were super nice
Indulge yourself with a grand holiday in Long Island
Long Island is perfect for all sorts of vacations. Whether you prefer a relaxing retreat to rest and recover, or an itinerary of non-stop partying, you’ll find something you’re looking for in this stunning place. While here, you should pamper yourself with a lavish stay at these top luxury Airbnbs in Long Island, New York.
History
Get Trip101 in your inbox
Unsubscribe in one click. See our Privacy Policy for more information on how we use your data